Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my 2 y/o watch so much iPad?

133 replies

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 17:47

I’m expecting some flames…and I will listen to it. I know it’s not great. But I’m also curious if people have non-judgemental views about iPad use?

Our DD is nearly 2.5 and watches A LOT of iPad every day. Hours of it. It’s the go-to for her otherwise very present and engaging and loving and affectionate father.

But, here’s the thing…I think she’s actually pretty advanced in language and numeracy. She can name all but 3 or 4 letters of the alphabet (which we haven’t actively taught her). She knows how to count actual objects, up to about 5 or 6 (we’ve taught her this mostly. But it’s been reinforced by YouTube videos). She knows how to say three colours in Spanish (we’ve not taught her this)

She can also now independently type in the first two or three letters of something specific she’s looking for, and choose the correct auto-suggested word from the search list.

She gets lots of other activities and time outside, lots of mummy and daddy time and crafts etc. So we’re not awful parents. I don’t think!

But interested to hear if we’re still rotting her brain and social abilities, or if she’s getting the pay off from so much learning (and evident enjoyment)

runs and ducks for cover

OP posts:
pinkunicorns54 · 16/07/2023 21:14

I have a 2.5 year old and they get a maximum of 1hr per day.
I know this time of day (before bed) isn't recommended but I refuse to put the TV on before 5pm - because if I do, there is an almighty tantrum when I turn it off!

They have a tablet that my parents have bought them. This stays at my parents house (unless we are going on a long drive which they may need a little help being distracted!) if I bring it home, I'm sure I will pay the price!

But TV is also DH's default!

VisionsOfSplendour · 16/07/2023 21:07

Missingmyusername · 16/07/2023 20:43

I think it depends what they watch. My friends little boy watched a lot of pad, but it was number blocks.

He’s gifted in maths, very bright and top class for English.

If they’re watching crap, the kids who play with slime, talking back to parents etc - not so much.

You have no way of knowing if those two things are connected

Atnilpoe · 16/07/2023 21:04

@Fairislefandango

i think 2 year olds shouldn’t have access to screens at all! My rule was no screens before 3. And only bits and bobs of TV after that. My 8 year old is only allowed 2 x 30 mins on Minecraft on the iPad over the weekend, and never during the week. My 5 year is allowed the same, although rarely asks for it. A bit extreme of me perhaps, but they certainly don’t lose out educationally. Let’s face it, tech is so easy to access, no one is missing out by not playing on an iPad at 2.

if I were you, I would “lose” the iPad so your DH can’t just hand it over.

Maireas · 16/07/2023 20:56

Yes, it reduces the ability to focus.

Fairislefandango · 16/07/2023 20:54

I think it depends what they watch. My friends little boy watched a lot of pad, but it was number blocks.

I don't think it entirely does depend what they watch. It's not just about the content, it's about the format. As a previous poster said, kids who are used to getting everything through (often highly gamified) apps and programmes often find it hard to concentrate on anything else. Imo that is part of the problem with the Covid cohorts in schools. A worrying number of kids find ot hard to sit through a lesson in a classroom.

Missingmyusername · 16/07/2023 20:43

I think it depends what they watch. My friends little boy watched a lot of pad, but it was number blocks.

He’s gifted in maths, very bright and top class for English.

If they’re watching crap, the kids who play with slime, talking back to parents etc - not so much.

Fairislefandango · 16/07/2023 20:42

Which book did you read? I'd be interested in reading that myself.

It's called Stolen Focus and it's by Johann Hari.

Yes, I can see them all reaching for the smelling salts because they don’t let Ptolemy have an iPad even though he’s 20.

Except that nobody on this thread has even said that a 2 year-old shouldn't have access to screens at all. But don't let the truth get in the way of a snide comment, eh?

Maireas · 16/07/2023 20:42

I think the iPad is more individual and immersive. The tv you watch together and interact more plus the parent has total control.

ColourfulHairbands · 16/07/2023 20:42

Toottooot · 16/07/2023 20:41

Fa rattled your cage min?

No clue what this means but there’s absolutely no need to reference my thread on someone else’s. Quite pathetic really but that’s Mumsnet for you

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 20:41

VestaTilley · 16/07/2023 20:36

YABU. It’s lazy parenting. It’s really not good for their developing brains.

Use proper TV, fine, but still not as much as you are, but the flashing images and constant gratification/dopamine hit of an iPad is not good for her.

Serious question - why is TV ok to you but not iPad?

OP posts:
Toottooot · 16/07/2023 20:41

ColourfulHairbands · 16/07/2023 20:39

LOL get a life will you

Fa rattled your cage min?

ColourfulHairbands · 16/07/2023 20:39

Toottooot · 16/07/2023 18:38

Just dinna feed her nik naks and you’ll be arite.

LOL get a life will you

VestaTilley · 16/07/2023 20:36

YABU. It’s lazy parenting. It’s really not good for their developing brains.

Use proper TV, fine, but still not as much as you are, but the flashing images and constant gratification/dopamine hit of an iPad is not good for her.

chillipopcorn1 · 16/07/2023 20:33

I would echo previous poster from an educational viewpoint. I'm a primary school teacher and we see a huge issue with children who have hours of screen time a day. It's not with their educational ability (they often have good knowledge and are as intelligent as other children) but with the fact that they are so used to being spoon fed high entertainment content that they can't manage to work independently in class. Having a teacher teach them and then consolidating that learning is too boring in contrast to what they do in their leisure time. In my experience they either disengage ('it's boring' 'I don't want to' and refusal) or act up and are disruptive. It's heartbreaking and by the time they're in school it's very hard to change patterns of leisure time and screen time expectations at home. Plus parents are super touchy and feel judged.

WeetabixTowels · 16/07/2023 20:02

Freepo · 16/07/2023 17:48

It really is a mistake asking this on here, people are irrational and sanctimonious about it

Yes, I can see them all reaching for the smelling salts because they don’t let Ptolemy have an iPad even though he’s 20.

But in the real world this is fine, not everything is made to make children into dummies and there’s some great educational shows and apps out there!

ZickZack · 16/07/2023 20:01

Not judging, op. My 3 year old has TV but I have to admit, when he has too much, his behaviour is awful so we limit it.
There are studies that show too much screen time can be damaging and should not replace human / carer interaction with the child. So I do think while some iPad time is fine, hours of it at 2.5 is not.

Abouttimemum · 16/07/2023 19:59

I generally don’t have an issue with limited screen time when watching and playing the right things, but they shouldn’t be on it every day, and definitely not for hours on end. DS is probably on his a couple of times a week, and usually for a half hour car journey or the like.

my caveat to this is letting him watch unlimited screens on our what ended up being 13 hour flight to Florida recently. But I knew he’d not be looking at any screens for a fortnight and I’m all for not making things difficult for myself!

QueenBitch666 · 16/07/2023 19:59

Fairislefandango · 16/07/2023 19:10

@Fairislefandango - a very good point - why more and more schools are banning phones.

I've just read a book about it and it's made me ditch social media. I need to ditch MN too tbh - I find it more addictive than FB and Instagram together.

Obviously a 2yo isn't on social media, but apps and websites use exactly the same psychological tricks to draw people in and keep them clicking. It's worth remembering- if you're not paying a subscription to the content you're accessing, that's because you (or your attention, or your child's attention) are the product that's being sold. Their money is coming from giving companies access to your attention and to knowledge about your clicking habits.

Which book did you read? I'd be interested in reading that myself

Maireas · 16/07/2023 19:49

Good luck OP - especially with DH (although I suspect there's something there for another thread...)

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 19:47

Ok, thanks all. Some useful hard truths here (and some quite frankly rude and definitely not useful reactions. That’s the internet for you…my next habit to break!)

I didn’t have any idea about the effect on sight, that was an eye opener (sorry). I had assumed about attention span but had chosen to shrug it off really. But horrifying to think it will affect her school life later on if it becomes too ingrained.

In all honesty, I personally have a problem with screens and phones. Which is why I think I know I need to nip this in the bud with her, an am
looking for ammunition. My attention span is awful, my reliance on my phone is awful, my need to have it with me everywhere is awful. I hate myself for it.

Making changes for us all, starting tomorrow.

Wish me luck with the DH, who will see it as a personal attack on his parenting, and me being my usual bossy know-it-all self!

OP posts:
TizerorFizz · 16/07/2023 19:46

There’s very good reasons why it’s too long. Mine learnt colours from books and interaction with me. They learnt about words and sounds. They enjoyed describing pictures and characters. They developed empathy and gross and fine motor skills by playing with toys. Screen time was zero for mine. There’s a lot to be learnt by doing a lot away from a screen. Games and reading for example. Imaginative play. Lots.

ginoclocksomewhere · 16/07/2023 19:37

Yes. It's clinically proven to cause short sightedness in extremes. Kids (especially toddlers!) should not spend more than 40mins on a screen without a 10min break, and should be max 2hrs per day.

Maireas · 16/07/2023 19:29

I know your little one isn't using social media, OP, but it's the habitual use of a device which can become problematic. You are right to think about it and curtail usage.

Maireas · 16/07/2023 19:26

@Fairislefandango - some staff were very much against the complete ban on phones at school, thinking break and lunchtimes would be ok. However, the Head showed us all the recent research on phone usage, social media and developing brains. There is strong evidence to seriously limit usage for children. Compelling evidence about the impact on mental health, particularly girls. Lots of research. Some of it quite eye opening.

sweepleall · 16/07/2023 19:20

A few thoughts:

I really like the Vooks app - it's basically like slower paced stories told to video, much more chilled than YouTube kids

Yoto player or Tonie box might be worth a look too

I think it affects some children much more than others - I gave one who is just more addicted to screens than the other who has always been able to take or leave it

I think an hour or so over the course of a day is fine, several hours is different

Swipe left for the next trending thread