Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my 2 y/o watch so much iPad?

133 replies

MelroseGrainger · 16/07/2023 17:47

I’m expecting some flames…and I will listen to it. I know it’s not great. But I’m also curious if people have non-judgemental views about iPad use?

Our DD is nearly 2.5 and watches A LOT of iPad every day. Hours of it. It’s the go-to for her otherwise very present and engaging and loving and affectionate father.

But, here’s the thing…I think she’s actually pretty advanced in language and numeracy. She can name all but 3 or 4 letters of the alphabet (which we haven’t actively taught her). She knows how to count actual objects, up to about 5 or 6 (we’ve taught her this mostly. But it’s been reinforced by YouTube videos). She knows how to say three colours in Spanish (we’ve not taught her this)

She can also now independently type in the first two or three letters of something specific she’s looking for, and choose the correct auto-suggested word from the search list.

She gets lots of other activities and time outside, lots of mummy and daddy time and crafts etc. So we’re not awful parents. I don’t think!

But interested to hear if we’re still rotting her brain and social abilities, or if she’s getting the pay off from so much learning (and evident enjoyment)

runs and ducks for cover

OP posts:
Growlybear83 · 17/07/2023 20:32

Your daughter would learn a lot more from you and/or your husband sitting down and playing with her toys with her. I can't imagine letting a very young child watch a tablet for any length of time.

user12345678213 · 17/07/2023 20:12

You are my best friend from a few years ago, i wouldn't let my DD nr a digital device, she allowed full access.

Fast fwd into teenage years, her DD is really struggling, CAMPHS self harming and mine isn't, into sport, exercise, music, hiking, language, yes had a few fails but nothing beyond the pale.

I ve no evidence it made the difference (nor do i particularly care, i'm sure plenty more is in play) but my friend bitterly regrets her choices, she feels it distorted her DD development.

TizerorFizz · 17/07/2023 20:05

You will find a brand new world of learning without a tablet. I look forward to your post in years to come that she’s Oxbridge bound.

Flittingaboutagain · 17/07/2023 19:58

FlowersInTheSky · 16/07/2023 17:59

This is absolutely unacceptable. Why would you allow this? Because it keeps her quieter so you have an easier life?

I have a 2.5 year old too. There’s no way I would even dream of letting her have a tablet yet, let alone use it for hours every day.

I feel the same way. Can't believe this.

MelroseGrainger · 17/07/2023 19:56

AmITooOldToDoThis · 17/07/2023 12:52

She shouldn’t be having unfettered access to YouTube. Even the kids version has porn and scary videos get through the filters. My 12 year old isn’t routinely allowed on YouTube and I’m a pretty permissive parent!

I’m pretty certain the kids YouTube doesn’t have porn! 🤣 Can’t even find porn on the normal version!
I think that’s a bit scaremongery TBH…
And anyway, I have lots of parental controls and pre-approved blocked content on the version she uses.

OP posts:
MelroseGrainger · 17/07/2023 19:52

TizerorFizz · 17/07/2023 12:43

@MelroseGrainger She might not have tantrums yet, but I’ve seen it in older DC who won’t stop gaming. I do think it replaces learning when over used. Can she hold a pencil? Turn the page of a book? Build something? Understand instructions and follow them? Engage in a conversation? Ask questions? How do you know she is doing this as well as other dc? Does she have siblings? My DC are old enough never to have had a tablet. DD1 was certainly ahead. Other dc were reading before they went to school. Definitely ahead. None had tablets. So intelligence is not helped by tablets snd you are right to reduce the time spent on it. Maybe just use it for fun. For 30 mins every so often.

I know I sound like “one of those” mums when I say: she is honestly incredibly advanced in absolutely all of those things. Way more than the other toddler her age that I know.

But actually, that’s probably why we’ve been a bit lax and indulged her with the iPad too much. Because we’re already so confident about her abilities. But that doesn’t mean much if she’s going to be affected in other ways.

You’ll all be pleased to know that it’s only Day 1 of the new regime and she’s only had the iPad for about 25 minutes on total today. She didn’t bat an eyelid!

That’s despite us all being sick as dogs and barely functioning properly.

So I think we can all stop worrying now. Thanks for everyone’s input!

OP posts:
MerryMarigold · 17/07/2023 14:08

I work in a preschool and you can tell the ones who have a lot of ipad time. They struggle to listen to normal human beings who are not brightly coloured or talking in weird voices or singing. They struggle to focus on most adult led activities, especially listening on the carpet. They struggle to be self directed (have their own ideas, explore, create), they are often either adult dependent for ideas to play or they will play the same things over and over again.

Not sure how it affects brain development but 2 things stand out. 1. The addiction (iPads give off reward). If your brain gets used to that, where will it go later in life? 2. The ability to focus and maintain attention on 'normal' environments. I'll bet you my bottom dollar you will be seeking an ADHD diagnosis when she hits Y1.

Not to be critical because I used TV a fair amount when mine were young (lucky for me, we missed the iPad). Now I'm trained in early years, I wish I'd encouraged my kids more in self directed imaginative play. If you need a babysitter, I think a film particularly if it's not too cartoony is better than constant ipad interaction/ brightness. My kids used to love dinosaur 'documentaries' (from around 2!).

AmITooOldToDoThis · 17/07/2023 12:56

VAST. Sorry.

AmITooOldToDoThis · 17/07/2023 12:52

Can also lead to VEST - it’s similar to ADHD but caused by environment rather than being born with it.

AmITooOldToDoThis · 17/07/2023 12:52

She shouldn’t be having unfettered access to YouTube. Even the kids version has porn and scary videos get through the filters. My 12 year old isn’t routinely allowed on YouTube and I’m a pretty permissive parent!

NorthWestThree · 17/07/2023 12:48

Using screens like this is addictive and damaging for a very young brain. There's no real arguments for having hours of iPad time but plenty of arguments against. We are raising a generation of screen addicted children who have disordered social and communication skills and this is very, very apparent in the education system right now.

TizerorFizz · 17/07/2023 12:43

@MelroseGrainger She might not have tantrums yet, but I’ve seen it in older DC who won’t stop gaming. I do think it replaces learning when over used. Can she hold a pencil? Turn the page of a book? Build something? Understand instructions and follow them? Engage in a conversation? Ask questions? How do you know she is doing this as well as other dc? Does she have siblings? My DC are old enough never to have had a tablet. DD1 was certainly ahead. Other dc were reading before they went to school. Definitely ahead. None had tablets. So intelligence is not helped by tablets snd you are right to reduce the time spent on it. Maybe just use it for fun. For 30 mins every so often.

MelroseGrainger · 17/07/2023 12:35

dabdab · 16/07/2023 21:28

Early years educator here - totally agree with Brk's response - it is noticeable which children come into school with to much screen time. Levels of attention, social interaction and often language have been affected.

Thanks, that’s useful confirmation. Her social skills and language are definitely not affected (yet). She’s brilliant in both those areas. But attention span is a concern for me in the future.

OP posts:
MelroseGrainger · 17/07/2023 12:33

goodkidsmaadhouse · 17/07/2023 09:33

Sure your kid may learn the alphabet/numbers faster, but that isn’t important at this age, what you want is healthy brain growth and emotional development and hours of screentime is not going to give that.

Thus comment early on has nailed it. I find it so depressing when parents of toddlers tell me how ‘advanced’ their screen time has made them but they have almost no emotional literacy, under developed gross and fine motor skills, etc.

Anyway. OP good for you taking the comments on board and responding to everyone so politely. I will just say as someone with slightly older DC and who works with kids you wouldn’t believe the amount of behavioural problems that basically come back to screen time in later primary (no experience of teens yet so I can’t comment on that! Whole other ball game I suspect!) I really, really think you’re doing the right thing nipping it in the bud now and your later self will thank you for it.

Yes, I think we (her father and I) have been making an excuse for it by saying to ourselves “but look how much she’s learning!”

I need to confront the fact that it doesn’t matter about learning those things at this age, and it’s no substitute for the damage it might be doing.

luckily, my partner agrees fully and already today we’ve made big changes. Just letting you all know that before this descends into LTB territory!

OP posts:
MelroseGrainger · 17/07/2023 12:29

TizerorFizz · 17/07/2023 09:00

Screens and tv are used as baby sitting. There’s little evidence young children arrive at school better ready to learn having used an iPad or screens. Language is sometimes behind and definitely concentration. Plus being able to hold a pencil and fine and gross motor skills. It’s amazing to think people now believe screen time replaces a varied diet of learning pre school. Never mind the tantrums when the screen is removed.

Yes, the attention span thing is a concern of mine. So I’m going to strongly limit her use from.

But it’s certainly never been used to replace learning of any kind. It happens in tandem with learning, and creative play, family time etc etc. And she never has a tantrum when it’s removed. She turns it off when she’s told to.

OP posts:
MisschiefMaker · 17/07/2023 11:24

One other thing, if your DC has the capacity to learn the colours from TV they also have the capacity learn them through books. My 22 month old knows her colours and can count to 10, which she picked up through books. Tv is never necessary for education, even if it is educational.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 17/07/2023 09:33

Sure your kid may learn the alphabet/numbers faster, but that isn’t important at this age, what you want is healthy brain growth and emotional development and hours of screentime is not going to give that.

Thus comment early on has nailed it. I find it so depressing when parents of toddlers tell me how ‘advanced’ their screen time has made them but they have almost no emotional literacy, under developed gross and fine motor skills, etc.

Anyway. OP good for you taking the comments on board and responding to everyone so politely. I will just say as someone with slightly older DC and who works with kids you wouldn’t believe the amount of behavioural problems that basically come back to screen time in later primary (no experience of teens yet so I can’t comment on that! Whole other ball game I suspect!) I really, really think you’re doing the right thing nipping it in the bud now and your later self will thank you for it.

TizerorFizz · 17/07/2023 09:00

Screens and tv are used as baby sitting. There’s little evidence young children arrive at school better ready to learn having used an iPad or screens. Language is sometimes behind and definitely concentration. Plus being able to hold a pencil and fine and gross motor skills. It’s amazing to think people now believe screen time replaces a varied diet of learning pre school. Never mind the tantrums when the screen is removed.

DeeLasVegas · 16/07/2023 22:00

So what does the father do all day while you DC is on the iPad?

Helihelicopter · 16/07/2023 21:55

I’d agree with you that this sounds like too much screen time. I think some is probably fine, but I’d worry about the impact on attention and behaviour if the iPad is being used for hours each day.

We’ve never had a TV at home and don’t use a tablet regularly, so it’s been kind of no screens by default for our toddler (26 months), rather than an active choice. He’s also able to count and sing the alphabet song, so I don’t think screen time is needed to encourage learning. We are thinking we might get a TV at some point in the future so he isn’t at odds with his peers.

dabdab · 16/07/2023 21:32

'too' much

LSSG · 16/07/2023 21:30

peachesandsweets · 16/07/2023 19:04

I'm watching this with interest. My DD is two and exactly as you've described yours. Seems very advanced - for example, she knows 12 colours - whereas google says a two year old would know one or two. I'm sure that's mainly from the YouTube videos of colours!

She watches about 30 mins in the morning and then over the day around 15-20 mins a few times.

I know it's too much but we are also struggling to cut back.

There are you tube videos of colours? 🤦‍♀️ And sorry but who counts/googles how many colours their child knows, at any age?

dabdab · 16/07/2023 21:28

Early years educator here - totally agree with Brk's response - it is noticeable which children come into school with to much screen time. Levels of attention, social interaction and often language have been affected.

VisionsOfSplendour · 16/07/2023 21:28

Missingmyusername · 16/07/2023 21:20

Well actually she does know- there was no nursery/school during covid. No outside influence. They wouldn’t have taught to that level at his age in any case, even if he had been going.

But by the same token you have no idea the two weren’t connected, do you.

Being gifted isn't a result of watching ipads it's something a child is born as

Do you think that pre ipads there werent children ahead of their peers when they started school?

Why would watching number blocks (I assume from the name that's something match's based) make a child top class whatever that means in English?

Missingmyusername · 16/07/2023 21:20

VisionsOfSplendour · 16/07/2023 21:07

You have no way of knowing if those two things are connected

Well actually she does know- there was no nursery/school during covid. No outside influence. They wouldn’t have taught to that level at his age in any case, even if he had been going.

But by the same token you have no idea the two weren’t connected, do you.