Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end 20 year friendship over this?

291 replies

BirdieStar · 16/07/2023 16:20

Been I’d say best friends with G for 20 years. We are v close and do a lot together. We’ve recently just last year travelled across America together and I’d considered her family.

So a few months ago G started seeing someone for the first time and I was delighted for her. She had always shied away from relationships. However he’s turned out to be not so good, no job, does drugs, doesn’t see his child, ex-offender and refuses to meet her family or friends so we’ve never met.

This person has become her whole world and she adores him but it’s sort of taken over her life and made her a shitty friend. She keeps missing prearranged and expensive plans we’d made at last minute with some very serious excuses only for me to find out she was actually dossing at her boyfriends house. (She’s said previously he sits on games most the day and she just watches- we are 40!)

So, for example, we’d had a afternoon tea booked for a few weeks after her birthday- I paid the deposit and train tickets as part of her gift, she said she’d like to do this and said she wanted to go- talks excited really happy until the day before when she went quite cold and started saying she had to take her mum to hospital urgently. I completely understood, I rearranged the plans, lost the train money but that’s life. Only to find out by accident through her weeks later that she was actually at her boyfriends that weekend at a concert and mum was never sick. I confronted her for lying, she got upset and we moved on from it- although I was annoyed.

The same thing happened with the rescheduled date- big drama involving her now having to work and her manager saying so (the day before we were suppose to go again) to again find out that she was at her boyfriends house waiting in for a package for him.

Then comes this weekend, it’s my 40th birthday bbq. Friend is coming and really excited- messaging the day before saying that she’s going to be bringing certain things and what time train she’s getting in, she’d asked me if she could pay for the cake as part of my present and I said I’d pick her up at the station. The day comes and nobody has heard from her- we are all worried when the time the train is suppose to be getting in comes and she isn’t there, calling round, trying to get her to answer- only for her to respond 5 hours later saying she and her BF went out, got too drunk and she’d only just woken up and charged her phone. I’d messaged her BF on Facebook to check if she was ok and with him, and when he saw it later on he just replied “lol”. She’s known it was my birthday bbq for weeks.

I spent my whole birthday morning trying to get hold of her, feeling worried something had happened to find out that she had just overslept- and we had to quickly run out and get another cake too!

When I finally spoke to her, she said a half sorry but her apology was mainly about how awful she felt herself hungover.

Im feeling just so sad today, it’s like my friend has had a personality transplant since meeting this person. I’m happy for her, but I’ve never behaved this way myself when I got into a relationship.

Im really feeling like I should say enough is enough and end the friendship, but I’m heartbroken a little and trying to rationalise that before she met this person she wouldn’t have been like this in the last 19 years! She’s never been this person- it’s horrid.

but should I end the friendship and distance myself?

OP posts:
doorstopper123 · 17/07/2023 20:54

Yes, i’d be letting that friendship slide and i fear for her future but she’s 40 and can make her own mistakes

Poppinjay · 17/07/2023 20:54

Threenow · 17/07/2023 20:42

Ditch her! She won't change while she is with him, but even if she sees the light and leaves him I would be steering clear - she's old enough to know better.

This attitude is why people end up feeling unable to leave coercive controlling and abusive relationships.

My daughter was in a relationship like this and started to behave very out of character. She was plenty old enough to understand that she was hurting me while also being completely under his spell, miserable, torn apart inside and unable to escape. It was only the fact that I continued to support her in whatever way I could that enabled her to leave.

OP, please educate yourself on coercive control before you decide to throw away your friendship and abandon your friend to a potential lifetime of abuse and misery.

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 20:52

Threenow · 17/07/2023 20:42

Ditch her! She won't change while she is with him, but even if she sees the light and leaves him I would be steering clear - she's old enough to know better.

Wow

Katey83 · 17/07/2023 20:48

i agree with posters who say this has all the hallmarks of the early stages of an abusive relationship. I think distance yourself but be aware she may not be in a good place. Sending her a message like ‘I’m really
concerned you’ve changed and I’ve found your behaviour over our recent plans inconsiderate and upsetting. I’m hoping things are ok with you, and always here if they are not - but I am not willing to be let down again. Give me a call anytime you feel ready, but as I said please don’t let me down again.’ Might set your own boundaries while not isolating her completely as abusers tend to do (he will know exactly what coercing her to miss these occasions means for your friendship).

DustyOwl · 17/07/2023 20:47

MumLass · 17/07/2023 20:22

I’m in the YABU camp, you have known this friend for 20 years. She’s behaving out of character. The BF does drugs, won’t meet her friends or family, seems to be leading her down a dangerous path. Instead of getting angry at her, have you told her you are worried? What do her family think? This has red flags waving all over it. From what you say she doesn’t have much experience of relationships.
I get that it’s annoying she’s letting you down and costing you money. I’d stop with the expensive plans, or anything in which you are depending on her. I wouldn’t cut her off though. It sounds like you are her lifelong best friend. Make sure she knows the door to you is open. Arrange to meet for coffee occasionally. One day she might turn up and tell you she needs help.

I totally agree. He’s not met any friends or family, she is cutting herself off. She might genuinely be excited to be seeing you but he guilt trips her into staying in with him. She brushes it off as she is protecting him. Yes this can happen this fast.
Only you know what she was like before but if this is a massive change in personality I would be seriously concerned about her. I would keep the lines of communications open and also keep an eye on her from afar.

Threenow · 17/07/2023 20:42

Ditch her! She won't change while she is with him, but even if she sees the light and leaves him I would be steering clear - she's old enough to know better.

Chevybaby · 17/07/2023 20:39

UpUpUpU · 16/07/2023 16:39

I’d be keeping a close eye on her. She may be in an abusive or coercive relationship

this!

op keep your distance if you have to but if you were as close as you say you were keep the door open, he might force her into a really dark place and she might need to reach out to you further down the line. I know this because I’ve been almost identical situation as you describe. I was so hurt and angry and really cut her off only to find out her boyfriend was a horrendous abuser who systematically isolated her from her friends and family so he could have better control of her.

Libelula21 · 17/07/2023 20:37

MumLass · 17/07/2023 20:22

I’m in the YABU camp, you have known this friend for 20 years. She’s behaving out of character. The BF does drugs, won’t meet her friends or family, seems to be leading her down a dangerous path. Instead of getting angry at her, have you told her you are worried? What do her family think? This has red flags waving all over it. From what you say she doesn’t have much experience of relationships.
I get that it’s annoying she’s letting you down and costing you money. I’d stop with the expensive plans, or anything in which you are depending on her. I wouldn’t cut her off though. It sounds like you are her lifelong best friend. Make sure she knows the door to you is open. Arrange to meet for coffee occasionally. One day she might turn up and tell you she needs help.

This is a better response than mine!

42wordsfordrizzle · 17/07/2023 20:34

As others have said, please don't drop her- it really sounds like she's in a coecivrly controlling relationship, if not an abusive one. She needs to know that you're there for her and will be when she, hopefully, realises, how damaging this relationship is for her.

I'm sure others have given more practical advice about how you can support her, but I was shocked by the number of pps who think you should cut her off, and refuse to accept any apology from her.

friedalmond · 17/07/2023 20:27

You say he takes drugs? My gut is telling me that she is too. I just hope, for everyone's sake, that they're not addictive drugs.

pineapplecrushed · 17/07/2023 20:25

Yes.
If she ever realises she is better off without him, you can be there for her, in the future, but she is treating you like shit.

MarchingOnTogether · 17/07/2023 20:24

I wouldn't drop her completely, hopefully one day she will realise she's made a mistake with this man and she may need her friends to support her through the breakup.
But definitely distance yourself a bit. Don't make plans, don't book things or pay in advance for anything. Stay in touch even if it's just messaging now and again, if she wants to meet up have her come to you or somewhere you're going anyway so you're not putting yourself out just to be let down.

I had a good friend who dropped all her friends for an awful man. He threatened me when I tried to help when he was being awful.to her and after that she completely ghosted me and a couple of other mutual friends. I heard on the grapevine she's still with him and desperately unhappy but she's got herself trapped and there's nothing we can do. Even though her behaviour was totally shitty towards us, me and our mutual friends would have preferred to keep some communication with her so that we could help her leave him when she was ready but there really is nothing we can do now

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 20:24

Agree with the above two.

QueenMaize · 17/07/2023 20:23

OP - I would be looking out for warning signs of abuse. These are all red flags. It may well be that she has just chosen a man over her friendship with you. But she may also be being abused - coercive control, financial, physical, sexual, any form and she may not even know it herself.

If she is enthusiastic and contributing to conversations and dropping out last minute it may be that she’s being abused and using any excuse or no contact to avoid the truth coming to light, because it can feel shameful and embarrassing admitting that.

Before ditching her, please consider this and throw some support at her, face to face, away from him, throw a line to her and try, then at least you may rest easy in knowing that you’ve done all you can. Well that’s what I’d do anyway.

MumLass · 17/07/2023 20:22

I’m in the YABU camp, you have known this friend for 20 years. She’s behaving out of character. The BF does drugs, won’t meet her friends or family, seems to be leading her down a dangerous path. Instead of getting angry at her, have you told her you are worried? What do her family think? This has red flags waving all over it. From what you say she doesn’t have much experience of relationships.
I get that it’s annoying she’s letting you down and costing you money. I’d stop with the expensive plans, or anything in which you are depending on her. I wouldn’t cut her off though. It sounds like you are her lifelong best friend. Make sure she knows the door to you is open. Arrange to meet for coffee occasionally. One day she might turn up and tell you she needs help.

BadNomad · 17/07/2023 20:16

She's only been going out with this guy for a couple of months. It isn't a relationship. She's ditched her friend because she's excited to finally have a boyfriend. It's what teenage girls do, not 40-year-old adults.

Libelula21 · 17/07/2023 20:16

I haven’t read the whole thread, only the OP’s posts but I find it weird that someone who shies away from relationships and hardly ever goes out with anyone would choose such a downbeat.

A horrible way to treat the OP. I’m wondering whether there was always some kind of power imbalance in the friendship (projecting my own experiences there though)… or indeed if the new boyfriend is controlling.

Nothinglikeachild · 17/07/2023 20:15

This is typical behavior of someone in an abusive relationship which if I may add, she’s not enjoying. She either hasn’t realized it, she feels trapped or somehow thinks if she tries a little harder and concentrates on him, it will get better. She actually needs you to look out for her. Please leave the door open for her. She would likely come back.

MsRosley · 17/07/2023 20:15

I'd have ditched her at the afternoon tea stunt. Ain't nobody got time for that shit.

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 20:13

TheLadyofShalott1 · 17/07/2023 20:09

Well you haven't posted for over a day now @BirdieStar so I presume you have left your thread. However, on the vague chance that you are still reading these comments, I want to say that I am disappointed by your last post. You have been very close to your friend for 20 years and yet seem willing to dump her when she has got herself into a very bad situation. Isn't it on occassions like this that friends show just how good they really are, or whether they were only ever fair weather friends.

She needs you now more than any other time OP, so I think that you should be doing as many others have suggested, and let her know that you can't support her at the moment as she obviously won't accept any advice or help, but that if she does ever need you, you will of course be there for her.

This

Hopper123 · 17/07/2023 20:13

It sounds like she may be in a coercive/controlling relationship especially as it is so out of character. He won't meet her family or friends so therefore when there are plans she can't go because he won't perhaps? She's due to meet you and have a nice time woth other people so he coercively convinces her she needs to stay in and sign for his package? People in a secure/safe relationship could say no! Is it a way of separating her from the people who can protect her maybe? It's rubbish and she is absolutely being a rubbish friend but maybe distance yourself from her with the proviso that the door is open for reconciliation should she ever need your support in leaving him? I think there are a lot of red flags for her relationship with this man and as a friend I would actually be very concerned for her safety alongside my own feelings of frustration and hurt.

I lost a best friend of many years about 10 years ago in a similar way except instead of a narcissistic boyfriend it was another friend who was jealous of our friendship who caused the issues. I had to walk away but I understand the hurt it causes.

Could you have a conversation with her to tell her how hurt you are, that it's not like her and also to flat out ask her if she feels safe with him (if you are able to have a private conversation without him there of course)

IveHadItUpToHere · 17/07/2023 20:12

When you're in a bad relationship with an unreliable person - that's when you need your friends more. Abusive men go out of their way to isolate women from their support networks.
By all means change the parameters of your friendship with her but I wouldn't end a 20 year friendship because my friend was in a bad relationship.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 17/07/2023 20:09

Well you haven't posted for over a day now @BirdieStar so I presume you have left your thread. However, on the vague chance that you are still reading these comments, I want to say that I am disappointed by your last post. You have been very close to your friend for 20 years and yet seem willing to dump her when she has got herself into a very bad situation. Isn't it on occassions like this that friends show just how good they really are, or whether they were only ever fair weather friends.

She needs you now more than any other time OP, so I think that you should be doing as many others have suggested, and let her know that you can't support her at the moment as she obviously won't accept any advice or help, but that if she does ever need you, you will of course be there for her.

Oceanus · 17/07/2023 20:05

Oceanus · 17/07/2023 19:48

I have a friend who was in an abusive relationship shortly before I met her. I couldn't believe it when she told me. She dumped her friends and was treated like crap, even in front of strangers at the pub. His friends became hers.
Even his friends told her to get out but she said she was blind and she can't expalin what made her go on like that. I met her when she was 20 and she was already a strong and smart woman already. Her parents weren't wonderful (no abuse there), she had a dominant personality and she wasn't a yes person. My friend's the reason I'd keep the door open in your shoes OP. If your gut's telling you something's wrong with this guy, listen to it.

Her parents WERE/ARE wonderful! Goodness me, her mum's lovely!

WideEyedStirrer · 17/07/2023 20:05

FrugalKisses · 16/07/2023 16:53

I’d be worried about her tbh. What’s going on there?

YANBU to be pissed off, disappointed, sad, hurt and confused by the horrible change in behaviour.

However I’d keep the door open if she does leave him. It seems odd that she’s suddenly behaving in a way that is alienating everyone around her and causing her to become ever more isolated in this sad existence. It doesn’t sound like he has much of a life of his own.

Some people can be very manipulative and if this is really out of character having known her for 20 years, I’d be concerned for her whilst also doing whatever you need to do for yourself.

Spot on.