Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end 20 year friendship over this?

291 replies

BirdieStar · 16/07/2023 16:20

Been I’d say best friends with G for 20 years. We are v close and do a lot together. We’ve recently just last year travelled across America together and I’d considered her family.

So a few months ago G started seeing someone for the first time and I was delighted for her. She had always shied away from relationships. However he’s turned out to be not so good, no job, does drugs, doesn’t see his child, ex-offender and refuses to meet her family or friends so we’ve never met.

This person has become her whole world and she adores him but it’s sort of taken over her life and made her a shitty friend. She keeps missing prearranged and expensive plans we’d made at last minute with some very serious excuses only for me to find out she was actually dossing at her boyfriends house. (She’s said previously he sits on games most the day and she just watches- we are 40!)

So, for example, we’d had a afternoon tea booked for a few weeks after her birthday- I paid the deposit and train tickets as part of her gift, she said she’d like to do this and said she wanted to go- talks excited really happy until the day before when she went quite cold and started saying she had to take her mum to hospital urgently. I completely understood, I rearranged the plans, lost the train money but that’s life. Only to find out by accident through her weeks later that she was actually at her boyfriends that weekend at a concert and mum was never sick. I confronted her for lying, she got upset and we moved on from it- although I was annoyed.

The same thing happened with the rescheduled date- big drama involving her now having to work and her manager saying so (the day before we were suppose to go again) to again find out that she was at her boyfriends house waiting in for a package for him.

Then comes this weekend, it’s my 40th birthday bbq. Friend is coming and really excited- messaging the day before saying that she’s going to be bringing certain things and what time train she’s getting in, she’d asked me if she could pay for the cake as part of my present and I said I’d pick her up at the station. The day comes and nobody has heard from her- we are all worried when the time the train is suppose to be getting in comes and she isn’t there, calling round, trying to get her to answer- only for her to respond 5 hours later saying she and her BF went out, got too drunk and she’d only just woken up and charged her phone. I’d messaged her BF on Facebook to check if she was ok and with him, and when he saw it later on he just replied “lol”. She’s known it was my birthday bbq for weeks.

I spent my whole birthday morning trying to get hold of her, feeling worried something had happened to find out that she had just overslept- and we had to quickly run out and get another cake too!

When I finally spoke to her, she said a half sorry but her apology was mainly about how awful she felt herself hungover.

Im feeling just so sad today, it’s like my friend has had a personality transplant since meeting this person. I’m happy for her, but I’ve never behaved this way myself when I got into a relationship.

Im really feeling like I should say enough is enough and end the friendship, but I’m heartbroken a little and trying to rationalise that before she met this person she wouldn’t have been like this in the last 19 years! She’s never been this person- it’s horrid.

but should I end the friendship and distance myself?

OP posts:
nofluffsgiven · 18/07/2023 17:39

I would ring her and tell her how you feel and tell her you will be taking a step back from the friendship. Tell her you are concerned at her erratic behaviour and it seems off and not her usual character. Ask her if she is in an abusive relationship? If she says no, tell her you won’t be making any more immediate plans with her because you don’t want to waste your time, but you will be there when she comes to her senses or if she needs help or to talk. Then stop arranging things. Maybe send her a text every now and again and ask her if she’s ok, but the end of the day she has to decide for herself to end her relationship and it’s likely that she’s still too loved up to see sense at the moment.

PennySc · 18/07/2023 13:38

She's in an abusive relationship. The abuser is trying to isolate her that's why she's missing the planned meetings with her friends. He either manipulates her by pretending sad/ill/lonely/etc or outright threatens her. So she will need a good friend now more than ever. I have been married to a narcissistic psychopath for over 10 years. They absolutely love ruining your plans, you personality, your life.

tattygrl · 18/07/2023 12:30

You might try contacting Womens Aid for advice on how to respond when it seems a friend is in a coercive relationship. The more I think about it, the odder it is to suddenly block all your friends (of 20 years) without so much as a word.

BirdieStar · 18/07/2023 12:23

Hi all, sorry last night I think I just felt angry and upset. I did phone the police for advice afternoon and they’ve said I can go in and speak to someone but ultimately it would be up to my friend to disclose that this abusive relationship was happening and if she doesn’t there isn’t much that they can do.

I just think the worrying things are the change in personality, the exchanges of money etc.

OP posts:
winnieanddaisy · 18/07/2023 12:18

Do you not wonder that her boyfriend has coercive control over her and she has to make excuses to stop him being angry with her . She might not even realise that it is happening.

tattygrl · 18/07/2023 10:21

I agree with those saying these are signs of a controlling, abusive relationship. The crux of it for me is that this is extremely out of character and unprecedented. This doesn't mean that it's now your responsibility to sort it out and put your own feelings aside - not at all! But I think worth bearing in mind when you make your decision about how to proceed. I would do as others have suggested and distance yourself, but leave the door open. She may get to a point where she really needs a friend, and it sounds like for 20 years she has been a good friend to you. Once again though I must reiterate, I'm not placing any responsibility or obligation on you. Your feelings matter and it must be heartbreaking to be ditched like this. It seems so out of character though that I do believe there's something going on.

MrsGtotheMax · 18/07/2023 09:54

Sadly, I think you need to distance yourself from your friend but be ready to be there when the fallout comes. If you have been friends for 20 years you know the person that she is but it sounds like this guy has really done a number on her. She's fallen hook line and sinker and only she can come to the realisation that he's bad news.
Take a step back, say that you think you need some space from the friendship and that you'll be there for her when she see's the light.
Hugs for you x

Toomuchtrouble4me · 18/07/2023 09:38

MayThe4th · 16/07/2023 16:29

I would have ended the friendship when she got together with an ex con who didn’t see his kids.

Would you? Really? How odd. If it didn’t change her in any way you would end a 20yr friendship because you didn’t like the sound of her bf that you’d never met? You sound like a good pair!

Jumpmom1 · 18/07/2023 09:32

I would distance yourself but keep an eye on her from a distance. He sounds like he’s probably controlling. Staying in for a package screams this to me. So while I would definitely cool the relationship I would probably keep up a distant conversation so she feels like she has someone to turn to when this ‘ inevitably’ goes pear shaped.

FlipFlop1987 · 18/07/2023 09:09

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 23:32

You keep making this about you. The bit about how much you've done for her.

Its blatantly not ahout you. Only you can decide how you handle this but you need to try and think outside your own perspective.

Of course it’s about the OP, they’re asking if they are being unreasonable and for advice. They can only tell the story from their perspective. If the friend wants advice then she posts her own thread 🤷🏻‍♀️

Staygoldponyboystaygold · 18/07/2023 08:32

I would be concerned that she is in a controlling relationship.

AngelDelight1234 · 18/07/2023 08:23

Agree with frankiefirstyear. I was in a abusive relationship and this has all the hallmarks, thankfully my parents and friends helped me escape and those old friends are still with me fifteen years after I left him. So grateful to them that they stuck around.

WideEyedStirrer · 18/07/2023 08:21

I am always surprised by friendship posts on MN. In my experience, friendships wax and wane over the years. The idea of formally 'dumping' a friend or "ending the friendship" is completely alien to me. If a friend starts acting in a way that is odd or unpleasant, what most normal people do is a) wonder if there's a reason; and b) take a step back. The friendship might re-emerge, and it might not - but it seems totally unnecessary to me to end a friendship in the way you might end a romantic relationship.

OP, you are also making it all about you. It isn't about you. Your friend has 'blocked' you, so there's nothing you can do at the moment and you just need to get on with your life. But given that she is behaving in a manner unusual for her, I really wouldn't make it worse by dumping her.

AngelDelight1234 · 18/07/2023 08:18

Agree with Emotionalsupportviper. This is totally out of character. I think that she had been desperate to be in a relationship for a long time and is literally blinded by it and this man. If you think of her as family don’t cut her out, she has behaved badly but she needs you now more than ever, she just doesn’t see it right now. See it as a madness and not a rejection of you. Hopefully she will find herself and you all again.

Takeitonthechin · 18/07/2023 08:14

Right - stop this, stop arranging things, stop contact and let her have her relationship, she will either sink or swim with him.

By the time she comes to her senses, you will have either moved on or she will have realised how stupid she's been.

frankiefirstyear · 18/07/2023 08:11

I've not read all the comments but it sounds to me (having been there myself) that the bf is controlling. At first she may have felt swept up by his 'love' but he may use that to control her, possibly without her realising, to not disappointing him - the waiting in for a package for him is a massive red flag for me as it means he's distancing her from her friends AND knows where she is all day.
I wasn't as taken in as your friend seems to be but I still alienated almost all of my friends and family, it was about a year before I realised that all that was left in the relationship was fear. He was vile to me 90% of the time unless we were having sex, then afterwards he'd be vile about that too.
It was awful and some of my friends seemed to want to 'teach me a lesson' when I'd finally gotten up the courage to LTB, then just didn't want to know. I had become a shell of my former self and it took months of therapy to get me back to even slightly as I was before.
Luckily I had a couple of friends and my family who were still there and gave me the support to regain my identity, but the fear remains for me as I unfortunately had a child with this man - a child is ultimate control for these vile me - so I live with the fear daily. But thanks to those who did stick around and my partner now, I'm back to my old self.
I know it's bitterly disappointing to have your friend change so much and let you down, maybe it's non of the above, but if it is then soon enough she's going to need a good friend to support her on her terms to dig herself out of the hole so many decent women (and men) have fallen down. If I were you, I'd be there for her then, and I'd be available for her now too, she may not realise or want to admit what's going on; hopefully she will realise before it's too late.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/07/2023 07:43

BirdieStar · 17/07/2023 23:12

For those asking this is only her second relationship and first “proper” adult one the first one was when we were teens.

she does struggle with self image and confidence and has always portrayed a “I love travelling, don’t have time/care for relationships” persona so we were happy for her at first as she seemed to be really happy but now it’s obviously turned sour…for us. I did once mention about how I thought she could do better but she quickly shut me down and said I was mean so I never mentioned it again.

Our other friends say she will regret it one day but perhaps she won’t, I guess now we just need to keep shun.

stay in touch keep the door to her open , and meanwhile make your important plans with someone else

If you can, do this as @Mrsgreen100 suggests.- but it wouldn't be unreasonable of you to just walk away.

It is indeed a very, very sad state of affairs, but please try to remember - people who have few or no early relationships are very emotionally vulnerable. They don't get "innoculated" by the experience of early passion and disappointment and "true love" as teenagers, and when it hits them it hits them HARD.

I know that you and other friends are hurt - understandably so - but she's emotionally a young teenager in the first throes of sexual passion. I also agree with others that she is likely to be being coercively controlled in some way. but the depth of her feeling is such that she isn't yet aware of it.

This relationship may all end in tears - if so, try to be kind. I doubt that you will ever be able to trust her so much again, but if she is left (figuratively or literally) battered and bruised she will need a friend, even if you don't allow yourself to become close again.

MaryWelly · 18/07/2023 07:09

BirdieStar · 16/07/2023 16:29

Yep! I have no doubts that she would probably be straight back if the relationship ended but I’d not let her back in.

Take a step back now but be there for her if she needs it. This guy doesn't sound nice and is isolating her. 20years is a long time!

Oceanus · 18/07/2023 06:56

What a sad turn of events, yet not shocking.

user1492757084 · 18/07/2023 06:45

You don't need to end the friendship but the friendship has taken a bad turn and a battering due to the bad boyfriend.
She is not reliable. That you can not deny.
You can not expect much from her until she sees the BF's vices herself.
Hopefully she will escape to see sense and when the boyfriend, drink and drugs are no longer a factor she might re-emerge and reconnect.

malificent7 · 18/07/2023 06:08

I wouldn't end the friendship. He is an ex criminal⁷...he sounds dangerous. I have suffered from coercive control and it's not something you can push back on easily.

newhaircut · 18/07/2023 06:04

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 23:32

You keep making this about you. The bit about how much you've done for her.

Its blatantly not ahout you. Only you can decide how you handle this but you need to try and think outside your own perspective.

And just what do you suggest OP do if this woman has blocked her and is refusing to answer texts or calls?! OP cannot force this woman to leave her boyfriend can she? neither can she force her to keep in contact. All she can do is respect her wish not to be in contact and protect herself from further hurt.

I dont know why people are acting as if the OP has any power over this situation- she doesnt. If friend has blocked her and wont accept her messages then there is nothing she can do about it fgs.

Pawpatrolsucks · 18/07/2023 06:00

It does sound like he is isolating her. I wouldn’t cut contact, but I wouldn’t make plans with her. Let her know you care about her, and are always there if she needs you. Then leave her to it. Eventually she will call and you can help her escape.

In the meantime spend time with other friends, if she was your closest friend move on in that sense, but your friend may need you down the road.

MayThe4th · 18/07/2023 05:44

WildUnchartedWaters · 17/07/2023 23:32

You keep making this about you. The bit about how much you've done for her.

Its blatantly not ahout you. Only you can decide how you handle this but you need to try and think outside your own perspective.

Of course it’s about the OP. Friendship is a two way street. How many posts do we see on here from people saying that they’re fed up of always being the one who makes contact, always the one the friend turns to when they want something, and they’re told to step back from the friendship.

This woman has relied on the OP and friends for significant parts of her life. I mean giving someone the deposit for a house isn’t just a small thing it’s significantly life-changing, and now when someone has come into her life she’s blocked her friends.

Ignoring is one thing, blocking someone altogether sends a very definite message.

And I disagree re her being controlled. Maybe she is, but she had choices.

Yes, some people get involved with someone who they believe is lovely, who appears lovely on the outside and as the relationship progresses they find out that the person is an abusive arsehole.

But knowingly choosing to get involved with someone with a criminal record who has done time for his crimes is a choice. And she chose that.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 18/07/2023 03:40

She’s 40 but behaving like a flaky 17 year old. I would be quietly just stepping back. She doesn’t seem to care about anyone else.