Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop breastfeeding newborn ?

62 replies

Onedownonetogooo · 16/07/2023 11:31

I want to start by saying I know all babies are different .

I was unable to fed dc (18 months ) I was devastated . However I realize I was able to let DH feed him , we could go out unplanned as I just took a bottle and my MIL was able to take DC out for the afternoon as she had a bottle . DC1 seemed very contented.

Dc2 is two weeks old and I can feed her ( yay!) but she seems to feed constantly. Very 30 mins . If she isn’t feeding she is mostly crying and won’t be settled . DH / MIL can’t settle her . So I take her and feed her .

Getting out of the house seems almost impossible as the she is always being fed . We have been out 3 times straight after a feed and she has slept around 45 mins then woken up crying so we have had to power walk home so she can feed. This is hard as I don’t want to be at home with an 18 month old and newborn . I would love to be walking and getting toddler out. I’m scared I’ll be stuck inside as i need to be in to feed ( not sure how I’d feed out with toddler !)

Also DH is now pretty much doing bath and bed times with toddler as I’m always feeding. I’m Scared I’ll lose my bond with toddler ( he is now always shouting for daddy !)

The baby has wet and soiled nappies and midwife said she is a good weight ( so appears to be feeding well ) it is just so so different from DS1. Im worried that Brest milk isn’t satisfying her .

I also feel alone in parenting baby as DH can’t really help with baba.

Please help me ?
AIBU to consider giving up breastfeeding???

Baby is only two weeks old and I’m sure I’m exhausted .

Everyone told me bf was magical and I was devastated when I couldn’t bf ds1 but in retrospect it was far easier . Or is it just this time my baby is different to dc1?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gladreel · 16/07/2023 18:16

...Okay then. I'll leave you to do that. Have fun, I guess.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 18:12

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 18:00

You're very welcome, I hope any further official training will also be beneficial. 🙂

Aw bless. I will pass your wisdom onto my colleagues. 😁

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 18:00

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 17:49

You just quoted my job.

and all of the above use the unicef questions that I just posted the link to.

A breastfeeding baby who is never settled after a feed and feeds 48 times in 24 hours is a concern.

As I said, I would be asking more questions to be making a fuller assessment.

Thanks for the training though 😉

You're very welcome, I hope any further official training will also be beneficial. 🙂

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 17:57

Mummy08m · 16/07/2023 17:38

I'm so glad to read this @Gladreel because I was despairing for breastfeeding in this country if that pp was giving official advice...! So glad to hear most advice-givers are giving more sensible advice

Definitely, in my experience anyway! I guess there will be health visitors and even the odd breastfeeding supporter who will give incorrect advice, but thankfully I was correctly advised that it was completely normal! Hopefully anyone getting similar incorrect advice seek further opinions and quickly be reassured.

The first few weeks are so intense, feels like it'll go on forever!

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 17:52

Dc2 is two weeks old and I can feed her ( yay!) but she seems to feed constantly. Very 30 mins . If she isn’t feeding she is mostly crying and won’t be settled

Please note. The OP did not mention cluster feeding.
She didn't say it was in the evening or afternoon.
She said it was constant. She described her as unsettled.

That would be a concern for any breastfeeding professional and would need further assessment.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 17:49

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 17:13

Your opinion is contrary to that of the breastfeeding consultants, supporters and health visitors (one of whom was also a BF consultant) who helped me.
It's worrying if you're questioning mothers over a 2 week old cluster feeding in the way OP describes. A quick Google shows that NHS advice and UNICEF, who you link, disagree with what you've said.

You just quoted my job.

and all of the above use the unicef questions that I just posted the link to.

A breastfeeding baby who is never settled after a feed and feeds 48 times in 24 hours is a concern.

As I said, I would be asking more questions to be making a fuller assessment.

Thanks for the training though 😉

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 16/07/2023 17:38

Bloody do it OP. There is so much more to motherhood than breastfeeding. A happy mum for a start! I combi fed both of mine too so that's where that view is coming from. You have a toddler to run round after and they need to get out and about. Good luck with it all, you are doing amazing 💐

Mummy08m · 16/07/2023 17:38

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 17:13

Your opinion is contrary to that of the breastfeeding consultants, supporters and health visitors (one of whom was also a BF consultant) who helped me.
It's worrying if you're questioning mothers over a 2 week old cluster feeding in the way OP describes. A quick Google shows that NHS advice and UNICEF, who you link, disagree with what you've said.

I'm so glad to read this @Gladreel because I was despairing for breastfeeding in this country if that pp was giving official advice...! So glad to hear most advice-givers are giving more sensible advice

Icecreamsundayz · 16/07/2023 17:36

Doing 2 weeks is an achievement in itself. If you want to stop, stop. If you wanted to keep going you could combi feed or express some bottles to let you do things with toddler but I know this is a whole extra job in itself. I’m planning to express and combi feed instead of breast feeding for this reason but I know the extra sterilising will be just something else to do

MadKittenWoman · 16/07/2023 17:31

Just breastfeed wherever you happen to be! Much more convenient than bottles. Also, in a couple of weeks you can start expressing so DH and DM can help out and give you a break.

Gladreel · 16/07/2023 17:13

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 16:39

This is literally part of my profession.

Please see unicef link.

A satisfied baby should be content after feeds (unless it's cluster feeding of course!) and feed around 8 times in 24 hours.

Not 48 times in 24 hours.

If I was visiting a mother I'd be asking her a lot more questions to figure out how to help and what the issue is.

I wouldn't be telling her it's totally normal.

It isn't, baby isn't satisfied and there will be a reason for that.

Hopefully she has good weight gain and got good output OP.

Please call your HV (or MW if you haven't been discharged yet).
Best of luck.

Your opinion is contrary to that of the breastfeeding consultants, supporters and health visitors (one of whom was also a BF consultant) who helped me.
It's worrying if you're questioning mothers over a 2 week old cluster feeding in the way OP describes. A quick Google shows that NHS advice and UNICEF, who you link, disagree with what you've said.

moodypromises · 16/07/2023 17:12

@ADHDDDDDDDBOOM if this is reaaaaalllyyy true then I was used as a human dummy then. Both my kids fed every 45 minutes until 9 months.

Healthy babies that looked 1.5 at 10 months . Doctors told me to stop feeding but what can you do when the baby is crying for breast milk!

This is what has put me off bf my next baby coming soon.

So what's the solution? Dummies? And I'm not being snarky I'm generally asking for advice because if I can get a breastfed baby to feed every few hours I'll happily breastfeed the next one!

Everydayimhuffling · 16/07/2023 17:08

Rather than a t-shirt, I found a button up shirt plus a poncho over or vest underneath we the best for breastfeeding. You can unbutton a little and the rest of you is still covered. It was hard with a toddler, but it gets easier as you get more confident and they start to figure it out and get themselves into the right position.

I could never feed in a carrier, but lots of people can.

gogomoto · 16/07/2023 16:58

Newborns feed a lot, by about 6 weeks breastfeeding comes into its own because you don't need any equipment, it's free ... you can still give occasional bottles if you are going out by the way, don't be a martyr to it.

headcheffer · 16/07/2023 16:57

thecatinthetwat · 16/07/2023 11:35

this sounds like normal early days of bf. I’d maybe consider trying a little longer, but it’s up to you. Bf gets easier over time. You also have a different baby this time plus you have a toddler so it will be very different.

Yep

Mummy08m · 16/07/2023 16:56

Omg the first line in your link says 8 times or more in 24 hours which completely contradicts your point that more often is unhealthy...!!

Mummy08m · 16/07/2023 16:55

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 16:39

This is literally part of my profession.

Please see unicef link.

A satisfied baby should be content after feeds (unless it's cluster feeding of course!) and feed around 8 times in 24 hours.

Not 48 times in 24 hours.

If I was visiting a mother I'd be asking her a lot more questions to figure out how to help and what the issue is.

I wouldn't be telling her it's totally normal.

It isn't, baby isn't satisfied and there will be a reason for that.

Hopefully she has good weight gain and got good output OP.

Please call your HV (or MW if you haven't been discharged yet).
Best of luck.

Perhaps a baby "should" be feeding 8 times in 24 hours - but I have never come across a breastfed baby who didn't want it much, much more often! That seems insanely infrequent for a newborn and I notice you say "except cluster feeding"...! That's kind of the definition of cluster feeding isn't it? So you're saying that babies feed infrequently except when they are feeding frequently.

It is advice like this that has led to huge proportions of UK mums quitting early. Practically no mums make it to 12m breastfeeding in this country let alone 2y as WHO recommends.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 16/07/2023 16:39

Mummy08m · 16/07/2023 13:31

On the contrary I'd say this sounds like a really typical baby before 1 month. Mine was the same and has always hit the milestones and been median weight/length

This is literally part of my profession.

Please see unicef link.

A satisfied baby should be content after feeds (unless it's cluster feeding of course!) and feed around 8 times in 24 hours.

Not 48 times in 24 hours.

If I was visiting a mother I'd be asking her a lot more questions to figure out how to help and what the issue is.

I wouldn't be telling her it's totally normal.

It isn't, baby isn't satisfied and there will be a reason for that.

Hopefully she has good weight gain and got good output OP.

Please call your HV (or MW if you haven't been discharged yet).
Best of luck.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 16/07/2023 15:08

As hard as it is it all sounds really normal.

I always say breastfeeding is much harder for the first couple of months, but then after that it’s much easier. No making up and heating up bottles and no sterilising. You just have to get through the tough bit.

You’re doing well, it sounds like you want to try and stick at it, but just do whatever is right for you and your family.

thecapitalsunited · 16/07/2023 14:58

If you like to wear dresses Stylish Mum have a lot of breastfeeding friendly dresses.

A two week old on the boob constantly sounds very normal. They will be building up your supply and it will settle down over the next 6 weeks or so. That said, if you aren’t happy then you could try combi or just straight formula feeding. Breastfeeding really isn’t the be all and end all - a lot of people forget that there’s a mum on the end of the boob who deserves to feel happy too.

WoolyMammoth55 · 16/07/2023 14:52

Hi OP, you've had loads of great advice!

I just want to chime in to mention 'option c', which is combi feeding. Not EBF, not going to 100% bottle, but mixing and matching. It's worked brilliantly for me with DS2.

I started 'topping up' the breastfeeding with formula feeds when he was 10 days old (and HVs had concerns about his weight gain). I just breastfed as much as I could, ask much as he wanted, and if he seemed grumpy or unsatisfied I made up a bottle and offered that. Sometimes he refused but often he chugged it down!

He is still on a mix of boob and bottle (now sippy cups, obviously) at 2 and a half years old!

Having BFing available as an option for an extended time has been great - for example when he's got a tummy bug and the formula/cows milk upsets his tummy, the magial breast milk doesn't, so he stays hydrated.

It's also great for comfort e.g. if he gets a bump and is doing big crying, he'd bat a bottle of formula away but be keen for boob, and comforted by it.

The flip side is that if I've had enough of the endless 'boob as dummy' routine, and just want him to fill him up and stop him grizzling, I can chug a bottle of formula down him and he gets all full and sleepy and I get a break!

And if I'm away from him then can delegate a bottle to DH - like you I had an older DC so needed some time 'off' from the newborn to keep them comforted and feeling loved. Having DH feeding the occasional bottle to the baby really helped with this too.

FWIW I used Hipp organic formula which has probiotics in, and his poops stayed the yellow, "breastfed" colour, and he never struggled to switch from BF to formula or had reflux or anything.

Wish you all the best whatever you decide, and congrats on your bubba.

RidingMyBike · 16/07/2023 14:40

BFing in the first few weeks is utter hell. They basically feed non-stop and it's almost impossible to do anything else. There's a growth spurt at three weeks which is a horror show for non-stop feeding, but then it does start to improve.

You could try doing combi? I did 50/50 BF/FF in the end and found it was far more convenient for us - meant DH could take her, we took it in turns to do bedtime etc?

MargaretThursday · 16/07/2023 14:37

It depends on the baby as to how much they feed.

Dd1 did huge feeds. So even at 2 weeks old we had a sort of routine.
8am (breakfast), 10am (sleep), 12:00 (lunch) 2:00pm (sleep) 6:00pm (dinner) 8:00pm (bedtime) 2am (snack).
At 6 weeks she dropped the 2am feed. Each feed would be 10-20 minutes on each side.
Dd2 was much more as you describe. She went for quick snack, and then move on, but then wanted another about 45 minutes later. The only time she went down for a length of time was about 6am-11/12noon. She's 19yo and still doesn't like breakfast, and prefers snacking to a full meal!
Ds was more similar to dd1, although was an early bird, which she never was (he still is, even though he's more than half way through his teens!)

It depends on you as to whether you're willing to continue. I don't know whether I'd have continued with dd2 if she'd have been my first because it was so exhausting. But I don't think it would have been that much better if I'd gone for bottle feeds. I suspect it would have been similar timing, but with the added frustration of throwing away feeds only 25% used and then having to make another up shortly afterwards.
You can have someone else feeding, which is the advantage, but that would only have been weekends and evenings/night.
But it's also a disadvantage at times Wink I got very good at giving dh a list of things that had to be done while I fed.

What I did with dd1, was when I was feeding dd2, then it was story time. So she'd bring me a book to read and we'd read together while I fed dd2. So she'd often be the one saying "does dd2 want milk?" when she wanted a story.

annlee3817 · 16/07/2023 14:31

They do cluster feed a lot in the beginning and also will be very fussy in the evenings (witching hour... Or witching three hours) I exclusively breastfed my first, but this time I combi fed giving her bottles of expressed milk and later formula, which worked out better for us. You need to do what's right for you, but what you've described is perfectly normal, and the fact that you have weight gain and wet nappies shows you are giving her what she needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread