Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my husband’s debt my problem?

87 replies

SebHH · 15/07/2023 20:18

My husband and I pay most of our salaries into a joint account to cover joint expenses. We do this in proportion to our earnings so that we are each left with the same amount in our personal accounts to spend as we wish. Some years ago I realised my husband had built up a debt, around 30K, just accrued through spending more than he had, nothing huge but small overspends which added up over time. Around that time I inherited some money and we paid the debt off; maybe it wasn’t made explicit but my assumption was that it wouldn’t build up again. Over time though it did and, because of the interest he was paying, we again paid some of it off from joint savings and his sister gave him the money for the rest- the agreement was that he’d pay back both his sister and the money used from our savings over a couple of years (without any interest to pay). At the time I wanted some assurance that he would tell me if he we’re getting into debt again but he felt this to be unreasonable/intrusive; he sees any debt as an overspend of his personal account and therefore as his debt/his problem to sort out (nothing to do with me) whereas I can’t help but think that it must impact on me in some way/that although we have this division of joint and personal expenditure really that’s a bit artificial and it’s really all part of a shared pot

AIBU to want to know the detail of his finances because it’s his personal money/his debt to sort out or AINBU because really our money is shared/his financial position will impact on me?

OP posts:
SebHH · 15/07/2023 21:00

I shan’t bail him out again- he knows this which is why he maintains that the problem, should it recur, is his to manage… though I take some of the (really helpful) points about the impact on me… thanks all for all your comments

OP posts:
LIZS · 15/07/2023 20:54

He needs to learn to spend within his budget. You are effectively picking up his slack and he is not adjusting his attitude because you and family bail him out.

Densol57 · 15/07/2023 20:52

I wouldnt want to be married to an unreliable man like this

fuchiaknickers · 15/07/2023 20:48

Of course it is your business. If he gets into unmanageable debt and the bailiffs come knocking, it's your home as much as his.
If you didn’t pay it off, what would he have done? It would have grown and grown. Left to get serious you may even have to sell your house. You are a married couple and considered to have joint assets. It is very much your problem, and he is a very unreasonable ass.

SebHH · 15/07/2023 20:41

Nothing in particular- he’s less anxious about debt than I am and more spendthrift- it will have been a number of small overspends over years that gradually built into a sizeable debt…

OP posts:
Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 15/07/2023 20:41

If he was paying it off without yours or anyone else’s help then I’d say no.

but seeing as it’s been paid off from your inheritance, join saving and his sister I’d say it’s very much your concern as it’s affecting you. He clearly can’t be trusted to keep an eye on what he’s spending and then expects others to bail him out. I don’t know how he can say it’s nothing to do with anyone else?

Daffidale · 15/07/2023 20:39

It may impact your credit rating, will def impact ability to get a mortgage / rate you’re offered. Even on that basis it is your business

BUT… you’ve bailed him out TWICE. You have literally spent your own money to pay off his debts. Once from your inheritance. Once from joint savings (half of which is yours). He can’t have it both ways. Either it’s his debt so his business, so he shouldn’t be using a dime of your money to pay it off. OR it’s a joint issue that affects you both and you’ve every right to know what he’s getting you both in to

with how your finances are structured, and his pattern of getting into debt, I think he should be paying you back for the inheritance pay off as well as him repaying the joint savings.

SebHH · 15/07/2023 20:38

I think that’s his point- that it’s his personal debt/his problem to sort out and that he would do that himself, independently of me, should it build up again… so not my concern!

OP posts:
FOJN · 15/07/2023 20:30

It would be his debt and his problem if he was paying it off from his own money but he's not, he's been bailed out twice.

He's being unreasonable for accruing more debt after it was paid off and for claiming it doesn't affect you. You have subsidised his personal spending from inheritance and joint savings so of course it affects you.

If he wants his personal spending to remain private then he needs to live within his means.

Hoppinggreen · 15/07/2023 20:23

Of course it’s your concern, you’ve paid it off for him for a start!
Also it impacts both of you in terms of what mortgage you could get, what disposable income you have etc

euff · 15/07/2023 20:22

I've no answer to your actual question but I would be quite angry in your shoes. That's a lot of debt to get into especially if you are managing on the same personal spends without incurring debt. Did he have any reason?

FedUpWithEverything123 · 15/07/2023 20:20

He is an ass and of course it is your concern.