Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need an antidote after the "What is going on with British kids?" was one of the nastiest ones on here for ages

81 replies

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 15:07

The "What is going on with British kids?" thread is full (thank god). I read the whole thing which I know was silly when it was pissing me off but there we are.

It was full of a lot of judgemental posts about families who (gasp) don't eat at the table which somehow morphed into a pretty shocking discussion on families with ND children.

So please can we have a thread of lovely stories about kids and families being nice to others? An antidote, a bit of positivity.

I'll start, there's a little girl in my dd's class who is blind and in a wheelchair (she can crawl a bit). At the last all class birthday party a group of the kids helped her into the bouncy castle slide thing, they'd learned to tap the floor so she knew where to go, they helped her climb up and slide down and made sure she was included in all the games (pass the parcel / musical statues etc.) It was so lovely to see how they made sure she wasn't left out. My heart grew a little bit ❤️.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 15/07/2023 16:13

I didn't read that thread, but I always have a bit of a smirk when I see the threads about how much better behaved French kids are. I used to live in an area where we got lots of tourist, including French school parties. Those groups were generally considered to be the most rude and badly behaved groups of the lot. And when the local police did a crackdown on shoplifting, let's say they found a certain demographic was in predominance down at the police station.

At work (café) we had a grandad come in a couple of weeks ago with his two small grandchildren, the older is under assessment for autism, and they're both living with him due to neglect from their parents.
He bought them a drink each and a cookie, and they were so sweet about it. They thanked their grandad, the people that served them, the people on the seats next to them... Then they whispered together and each put half their cookie into a napkin and said they wanted to save it for "nanna" who was at work.
The older one got a bit stressed and sat under the table, so I sat on the floor and chatted to him. At the end he said "thank you for letting me sit on the floor".
If they come in again I've saved a couple of colouring books for them.

Grandad was clearly a bit overwhelmed at finding himself looking after two little ones, but was doing a fantastic job with them both. He'd only had them a few weeks at this point, and was having to sort out schools, doctors and all sorts of things that hadn't been sorted out for them.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 15/07/2023 16:10

We went camping the other week and I found my DS10 and his friends giving an impromptu football training session to some random younger boys. My son also insists on carrying my shopping bags even though I'm stronger than him.

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 16:04

I tend to hide the "Aren't British people Awful!" threads. Ignorance is bliss. 🙂

aintnothinbutagstring · 15/07/2023 16:03

Well my kids are nice - they can sit at a table well enough. My Dd14 goes out to eat in restaurants with her friends plenty so it seems they can all use a knife and fork - I'm sure they all have their phones out though! I work in an SEN school too and they're all great too - a genuine pleasure to work with.

WeetabixTowels · 15/07/2023 16:03

My mum lives in France. I like visiting her and the local scenery is stunning but I really struggle with the rudeness of the people in her local area. Queue pushing, staring at anyone disabled or ND, enormous amounts of hostility towards the British etc, terrible inconsiderate driving. It puts me off going.

CrustyWingshield · 15/07/2023 16:00

I didn't get that thread. My first trip to France at the age of 11 with the school resulted in loads of French kids breaking into our accommodation and stealing our stuff. Not sure what people were talking about there with well mannered French kids.

I think we are more accepting of differences here and maybe have the ability to critically think beyond social norms when a child is ND and understand their view point. Although our governments and local governments don't seem to get this judging by the state of SEND services.

Why are all these people gawking at other groups of people when they are socialising? That's just weird. The last thing I would do is stare at an ND child and tut at their behaviour. You just look like a bit of a dick if you do surely?

Anyway, my story is I was struggling getting a buggy onto a train. The only people who offered to help me were teenagers. That says it all really.

Theunamedcat · 15/07/2023 15:54

When ds was younger someone was discussing how French children have better manners than British and complained about the ipad culture in the UK etc etc he (ds) loudly asked (hearing issues he wasn't TRYING to be rude) if French children really were given alcohol at the dinner table for some reason the original speaker thought he was insinuating that French children were quiet little drunks that's why they behaved and slept well he tried to tell him this wasn't correct then ds said my auntie is French the man wandered off quite fast after that 😂 (ds doesn't think French children are drunks btw he was four and trying to contribute to a conversation he was clueless about)

lljkk · 15/07/2023 15:51

Not only were my kids much happier in high school (than primary), but there are several local stories about the dorky unpopular clever but not sporty boys of primary school... becoming THE most popular kids at secondary. Also: "By year 9 or 10 we all just get along and accept each other," said DD.

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 15/07/2023 15:51

Oh and I’ve lived in 4 different European countries and contrary to the belief of many on here, they have badly behaved children too.

Nanny0gg · 15/07/2023 15:49

EverybodyLTB · 15/07/2023 15:40

Yes yes to sports day, some really heart warming love and care for one another at my son’s primary. A little boy who I’ve noticed on a school trip recently is very nervy and subdued, English is his second language and he’s the smallest in the class, only joined in y4 so maybe not quite as comfortable with the others - the whole year group chanted his name in the last race and his whole face lit up. He went from nervous wreck before they started to beaming from ear to ear. Me and the mum next to me were choked up watching, it was beautiful.

There were kids tying each other’s laces, helping up when they’d fallen over, sharing out their snacks, tying each other’s hair back. Just warm and kind all over.

I'm glad I wasn't at my middle DGD's sports day

She loathes PE and anything sporty and the last race was round the field.

She was going to give up halfway (last as always) and everyone, inc parents and staff, cheered her on till she finished.

I'd have howled

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 15/07/2023 15:49

My DC are lovely. My youngest is severely autistic and non verbal, but he’s still lovely. He may not be able to sit nicely at a table in a restaurant but thankfully that doesn’t define his worth as a person.
My 9 year old’s class did an exercise last week where they all had to write a compliment about every member of the class, and they brought their results home. DD had lovely comments telling her how smart, kind and helpful she is. Two of the boys in the class had written that she’s ‘beautiful’, which made me smile as I thought 9 year old boys were too cool for that sort of thing!

lljkk · 15/07/2023 15:47

2 of my DS's did cadets. Big groups of kids who enthusiastically want self-discipline and team work & encourage the highest standards in each other, totally believing in honour, responsibility, sensible pragmatism, unselfishness. It astounds me all the hard work the adult volunteers do to make the cadet activities happen: Oh that's right, that's because the adults enjoy it. Because the kids are great !!

The kids sit thru long Remembrance day ceremonies in cold boring churches. That takes a special type of self-sacrificing idealism, I dare say.

Nanny0gg · 15/07/2023 15:45

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 15:34

Some lovely stories I love the one about the kids helping the upset little girl into the classroom.

@TheBig4O I agree primary school seems to be a much more lovely place than it was in the 90s hurrah for that!

Sadly that may not be the case when they move up to secondary, unless they're very lucky...Angry

Allmyghosts · 15/07/2023 15:42

My kids are delightful despite us being (shock horror) very poor, we don't eat at the table or own a frigging board game. They have a well developed sense of fairness, care about their friends and are very polite. There are some horrors on this estate tho, case in point the little fuckers that keep breaking my windows.

x2boys · 15/07/2023 15:42

Yeah but this is mums net and Britain is the worst for everything even kids🙄
I.can only couch for my own teen ,who is a,lovely,funny ,caring lad who makes me very proud
And his friends all.seem nice too.

lljkk · 15/07/2023 15:42

I'm always impressed at how huggy & emotionally open the youngsters are. I was telling DS this last night. Just more open and at peace with their emotions & their bodies, very emotionally supportive to each other, too.

Not that we were complete cowbags in my youf, but I don't think we were as brave about showing our vulnerabilities.

Also DD is so direct & honest with people. Her mates take it well & it's a rare friendship she can't salvage even if tense feelings arose earlier.

EverybodyLTB · 15/07/2023 15:40

Yes yes to sports day, some really heart warming love and care for one another at my son’s primary. A little boy who I’ve noticed on a school trip recently is very nervy and subdued, English is his second language and he’s the smallest in the class, only joined in y4 so maybe not quite as comfortable with the others - the whole year group chanted his name in the last race and his whole face lit up. He went from nervous wreck before they started to beaming from ear to ear. Me and the mum next to me were choked up watching, it was beautiful.

There were kids tying each other’s laces, helping up when they’d fallen over, sharing out their snacks, tying each other’s hair back. Just warm and kind all over.

WeetabixTowels · 15/07/2023 15:38

Yes the teens in my town are lovely. They do hang around the park because there’s nowhere else to go but if little kids come in they’ll move to the field but not before engaging the kids in a polite chat. I never see them smoke, vape or do weed and malt of the runners round here are teens! I feel teens get such a bloody bad rap.

kayserah · 15/07/2023 15:38

Oh thank goodness I didn’t read more
than a few posts on that thread.

At Easter time my daughter age 6 participated in an egg decorating competition. Hers was really good and all of her friends loved it and said they thought it was the best. She tried really hard to make her model look good.

She wasn’t picked as the winner but her teacher pulled me up at the end of the day to say how impressed she was with her attitude. Daughter approached the teacher and said she was really happy her classmate had won because he looked really happy and proud

Bovrilla · 15/07/2023 15:37

Used to teach secondary. I promise you, 95% of them are genuinely lovely kids who are caring, kind and considerate.

The 5% who aren't have been there since time immemorial, with poor parenting, etc etc.

But yes, most kids are indeed awesome and far more tolerant and lovely than kids were when I was small.

Spendonsend · 15/07/2023 15:35

There are several teens in my road. Every single one does voluntary work and not for the DofE - just because.

WeetabixTowels · 15/07/2023 15:34

I agree it was a weird thread, there’s some real simpering that goes on about European countries on MN and I have no idea why as I don’t see anything better WRT children elsewhere.

I have to say I’ve never been on holiday and seen ‘embarrassing British children’ as others claim. I’ve seen adults with tattoos day drinking but I’m not a classist arsehole do I don’t pearl clutch at this. I think compared to a lot of other couple tires Brits are very polite, considerate, helpful and non-judgmental.

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 15:34

Some lovely stories I love the one about the kids helping the upset little girl into the classroom.

@TheBig4O I agree primary school seems to be a much more lovely place than it was in the 90s hurrah for that!

OP posts:
monpetitlapin · 15/07/2023 15:34

YANBU OP. There were a lot of people fetishising foreign children through very rose tinted glasses on that other thread.

I have one that's not as awe-inspiring as the OP. My toddler was crying and her older brother gave her his favourite toy car to help her feel better.

TheBig4O · 15/07/2023 15:32

Ds6 is ND and currently waiting for referral. His school have been amazing. He gets social stories to help him manage changes at school, a box of fidget toys to calm him down after a meltdown, extra support during tests, and I recently learned his teacher was giving up half her lunch break to take him down to the canteen and then bring his lunch back to the classroom because the canteen was too loud for him (I've switched him to packed lunch now). In dds class there is a boy that comes to school in pink socks and sparkly jacket, kids that stim, children that have meltdowns for various reasons, and children from chaotic homes. All are given extra support and accepted for who they are without any of the bullying or teasing that would have happened in my day. This a bog standard primary in a deprived area.

I don't expect my children to sit quietly through a 3 course meal because they are fucking children. They want to run and play and explore, not sit like mini adults nodding politely for hours. My son has meltdowns in public and no one stares at us. I'm very grateful we live in a country that offers support for families with ND children.