Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need an antidote after the "What is going on with British kids?" was one of the nastiest ones on here for ages

81 replies

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 15:07

The "What is going on with British kids?" thread is full (thank god). I read the whole thing which I know was silly when it was pissing me off but there we are.

It was full of a lot of judgemental posts about families who (gasp) don't eat at the table which somehow morphed into a pretty shocking discussion on families with ND children.

So please can we have a thread of lovely stories about kids and families being nice to others? An antidote, a bit of positivity.

I'll start, there's a little girl in my dd's class who is blind and in a wheelchair (she can crawl a bit). At the last all class birthday party a group of the kids helped her into the bouncy castle slide thing, they'd learned to tap the floor so she knew where to go, they helped her climb up and slide down and made sure she was included in all the games (pass the parcel / musical statues etc.) It was so lovely to see how they made sure she wasn't left out. My heart grew a little bit ❤️.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MargaretThursday · 16/07/2023 13:32

@toddlermom99

Very cute!

If you haven't come across it before, can I suggest you look at LimbPower :: Home Your ds will probably be a little young now-I think the events start at age 5yo, but they do a lot of sports events for amputees. It's worth making contact now if you think it's something you'll be interested in as they do do younger events occasionally.
My daughter was born missing her arm, and has loved their events. They make the children feel special, give them lots of opportunities (she especially loves wheelchair basketball) and provide fantastic role models in the amputee community.

LimbPower :: Home

https://www.limbpower.com/

MargosMangos · 16/07/2023 10:39

What a heartwarming thead @Poolnoodlepoodle

toddlermom99 · 16/07/2023 10:35

My little boy sadly had his leg amputated last year, it was very traumatic and for a while he has been terrified of hospitals. He is 3 tomorrow. A couple of weeks ago we had to go to the eye hospital and it was still a bit daunting to him as it's still a hospital! But there was a little girl, around 6/7 years old, sat there crying. My little boy put his fears aside and he went over to the little girl and said "it's okay little girl. you don't need to be scared. they won't hurt you. it's okay" and then proceeded to give her a kiss on the arm 🥹

I knew then he was mirroring everything I'd been saying to him over the last year or so, it made me feel so proud that he has such empathy at a young age, especially given the trauma he has experienced in his little life.

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 22:44

Saschka · 15/07/2023 22:39

Our French exchange was always a wildly popular trip because the boys would always come back with ninja throwing stars and porn. Not available (or legal) in the UK, widely available and apparently on sale to 13 year olds in France 🤷‍♀️

When we visited the lycée the teacher and kids lit up cigarettes in the classroom at the end of each lesson. (80s) I still remember finding it hilarious that a visiting French boy lit up a cigarette in the corridor of my stuffy girls' school. 😀We at least used to hide behind the bike sheds or in the toilets!

Saschka · 15/07/2023 22:39

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 17:07

My school did a French exchange. We took the students shopping one day and they were showing us all the stuff they'd shoplifted. 😀Maybe they are only well behaved when their parents are watching!

Our French exchange was always a wildly popular trip because the boys would always come back with ninja throwing stars and porn. Not available (or legal) in the UK, widely available and apparently on sale to 13 year olds in France 🤷‍♀️

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 15/07/2023 22:28

I'm a brownie leader and DD is a brownie. Don't want to say too much but we have a girl who is selective mute and the other girls are so amazing with her. They treat her the same as them and talk away to her and include her even though she doesn't speak but she is starting to acknowledge them and she is a clever little girl you can see. She takes it all in.

3WildOnes · 15/07/2023 21:58

YouJustDoYou · 15/07/2023 17:27

It's interesting.

In my home country we don't force any ND children to go out etc anywhere that's too much for them - restaurants etc - it's for them, but also, it's for the sake of other people.In general, it's pleasant to eat out, kids are well behaved BECAUSE people undertsnad not to put stress on their ND kids, forcing them to go out etc for the sake of the parents wanting to eat out. ND kids are kept at home, or other safe spaces, where they feel safest and happiest. I find it odd in the west where parents force ND kids out to cafes and restuarants etc. Why do that to them?

My ND child has always loved going out to cafes and restraunts and asks to go. Occasionally when he was younger he would get overwhelmed and have a melt down.

GloomySkies · 15/07/2023 21:22

On more than one occasion, when the DC were small, I left my car sitting on the drive with the doors wide open. It was always a teenager from the (poor reputation) local comp who rang the doorbell to let me know.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 15/07/2023 21:20

We are out of the push chair days now, but I very often found it was groups of teenagers opening shop doors for me, or telling their friends to make room for us to get past. Definitely not conforming to the stereotypes.

I genuinely think that a lot of the kids who were labelled as bad or naughty when I was in school were neurodivergent and either overwhelmed or lacking impulse control. Things seem to be heading in a much more inclusive direction now. My eldest always came out to eat and behaved impeccably. My youngest can't cope with crowds, queues or waiting and we very rarely eat out now. I guess by the other thread standards I am only half a shit parent!

RedRobyn2021 · 15/07/2023 21:16

I didn't read the entire thread just the beginning, my cousin lives in France and her DD has autism, from what I've been told they are incredibly backwards over there with how they treat children with ND.

WeetabixTowels · 15/07/2023 21:00

Honeychickpea · 15/07/2023 20:33

If you're not classist why mention the tattoo? It was certainly a dog whistle.

Because it’s what other people class as being embarrassing judging by many comments I’ve heard including those on MN.

But you knew that, you just fancied being obtuse

Honeychickpea · 15/07/2023 20:33

WeetabixTowels · 15/07/2023 15:34

I agree it was a weird thread, there’s some real simpering that goes on about European countries on MN and I have no idea why as I don’t see anything better WRT children elsewhere.

I have to say I’ve never been on holiday and seen ‘embarrassing British children’ as others claim. I’ve seen adults with tattoos day drinking but I’m not a classist arsehole do I don’t pearl clutch at this. I think compared to a lot of other couple tires Brits are very polite, considerate, helpful and non-judgmental.

If you're not classist why mention the tattoo? It was certainly a dog whistle.

Ostryga · 15/07/2023 20:30

British kids are fab. My daughter is so shy and really takes a long time to warm up to people. Her group of friends at school are so kind with her - they never leave her alone if she’s uncomfortable and will hold her hand if she’s feeling nervous. At sports day when she was worried about not being good her group came over and cheered her on. Her little face! I had to really bite my cheek to not cry so I didn’t embarrass her.

Lovely, lovely children.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 20:13

PlacidPenelope · 15/07/2023 19:50

haven't you noticed that the MC think everything European is 'better'? Especially France. It's bizarre.

The MN default is that absolutely everything is better in Europe and that the UK is some kind of backward shit hole. Those who say this have clearly never actually lived or worked in any part of Europe and probably holiday in Europe in very particular enclaves which they never venture out of so have no interaction with the people of the country they are in bar those who serve them.

I've lived in France, have lots of friends who live there and my DH is Belgian so I spend lots of time in France. Some things are great, some are awful. The people who fawn the most over Europe are usually those who don't really know much about it other than a holiday there! Apparently the kids are all perfect and the women are all thin and chic. Trust me, definitely not true. 😆

Quite, I agree with you having experienced life in many European countries. Some things are better some are much, much worse. Those on MN who believe the UK is a terrible, racist country and think European countries are a utopia of tolerance with no racism are utterly deluded.

Pretty much

Hoppinggreen · 15/07/2023 20:12

I have a 14 year old boy and him and his friends are on the surface always taking the p out of each other and behaving generally like you might expect a bunch of 14 year olds to. I thought they were all just a bit daft to be honest
One of them recently had a party and one of the other Mums is actually a teacher at their school (I didn’t know that). She told me that they are known as a really lovely kind and inclusive group and if someone is new or struggling with friendships they send them in the direction of that group and they just get happily absorbed.
It was one of the nicest things I could have heard about my son

x2boys · 15/07/2023 20:09

Loobydoobies · 15/07/2023 19:38

One thing that struck me when I was pregnant was the number of much-maligned teenage boys who either gave up their seat, or asked others to. Teenage boys in London have a bad reputation at times, but they were so polite and helpful.

Teenage boys on mumsnet have a terrible reputation
I can only speak from my own experience of having teenage boys ( my youngest is severely disabled so not typical,) but my sixteen year old is lovely, polite and and a pleasure to be around mainly all.though he did complain to.his Dad I was forcing him.to.eat his veg😂
And my two nephews now aged 21 and 19 are nice lads, too.

Ozgirl75 · 15/07/2023 20:07

At my sons’ school in Australia, the first few years are pretty small. There’s a boy who is autistic, very smart but at sports he just daydreams away, strolls etc. Anyway, when he was in year 2 I believe, I went to watch their school “cross country” (a run around the school finishing up on the main oval). This boy was miles last, jogging around, waving at the parents etc, and completely unprompted, the other boys in his year made an arch with their hands at the finish line for him to run through. It was so downright lovely to see 7 year old kids behaving so nicely.
My boys are older now - my 10 year old always has tiny children adoring him and he always says hello, high fives them, smiles etc because he knows it makes them happy.
My older boy isn’t “sweet” but he’s feisty and I’ve noticed he’ll always quietly look out for younger kids if they’re being picked on and he’ll happily weigh in and tell other kids off in such a calm and diffusing manner that just de escalates things so effectively.

PlacidPenelope · 15/07/2023 19:50

haven't you noticed that the MC think everything European is 'better'? Especially France. It's bizarre.

The MN default is that absolutely everything is better in Europe and that the UK is some kind of backward shit hole. Those who say this have clearly never actually lived or worked in any part of Europe and probably holiday in Europe in very particular enclaves which they never venture out of so have no interaction with the people of the country they are in bar those who serve them.

I've lived in France, have lots of friends who live there and my DH is Belgian so I spend lots of time in France. Some things are great, some are awful. The people who fawn the most over Europe are usually those who don't really know much about it other than a holiday there! Apparently the kids are all perfect and the women are all thin and chic. Trust me, definitely not true. 😆

Quite, I agree with you having experienced life in many European countries. Some things are better some are much, much worse. Those on MN who believe the UK is a terrible, racist country and think European countries are a utopia of tolerance with no racism are utterly deluded.

Loobydoobies · 15/07/2023 19:38

One thing that struck me when I was pregnant was the number of much-maligned teenage boys who either gave up their seat, or asked others to. Teenage boys in London have a bad reputation at times, but they were so polite and helpful.

saraclara · 15/07/2023 19:33

Yes, let's not go from bashing British children to bashing French ones.

We spent every summer on a French campsite from when my eldest was five until she and her sister were in their early twenties. They made friends from all over, and when they were little they were pretty much adopted by French teens.
All got along wonderfully and they made friends for life.

There are lovely kids from every country and culture. We might all parent them slightly differently, and cultures might very a little. But demonizing another nationality to defend our own, is being as bad as those at the start of the other thread.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 15/07/2023 19:18

I got on the late train yesterday and a bunch of late-teens got on too. They'd clearly been drinking, they were a little loud, all was fine. Because they were loud I realised they were on the wrong train, because they'd missed the last one to go to their town. No biggie.

At one point, one of them caught my eye and apologised for being loud. No bother, I said, but I couldn't help overhearing you were on the wrong train, are you OK for getting home? Yep, all was fine they'd sorted a lift.

I got up to go at my stop and then they asked me if I was OK to get home and was someone picking me up. And as I went past one of them said, we just need more people like that lady in the world, people who are kind to the teens instead of shouting at them.

They were actually the best.

nobodysdaughternow · 15/07/2023 19:14

I love kids, They make me smile and are far superior to most of the adults I know.

My kids have a range of disabilities and screens have been a lifeline.

I only ever hear what a joy they are to teach and I am so proud to be their Mum.

My most disabled child will never live independently but he makes us laugh every day.

I have not once been embarrassed of my kids or ashamed at the way dh and I parent. I have done good.

Conversely, my parents raised four kids who made French kids look riotous. We were well behaved because their parenting was based on physical and emotional abuse.

wholivesondrurylane · 15/07/2023 19:09

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 18:50

Just to be clear the other thread pissed me off ALOT. I didn't mean this to be a French children bashing thread.

I really just wanted some positive stories after all the negative ones.

There are some gorgeous ones on this thread thank you so much to everyone who has contributed ❤️.

We went to France for May half term. My youngest was crying after hurting himself. A bunch of slightly older French kids took him under their wings, and gave up their game to play with him, even offered some of their "gouter".

I didn't recognise any of the nasty behaviour I read on the other thread from my (limited) experience travelling in France, being an au-pair there and working with French colleagues.

Poolnoodlepoodle · 15/07/2023 19:06

Fernticket · 15/07/2023 18:11

Thank you for starting this thread OP. The stories shared on here have been really uplifting and heartwarming

Oh I'm glad it's cheered me up too. The lovely stories about teens especially I'm always low key worried about when my dd becomes a teen it's nice to hear the can be so lovely 🥰

OP posts:
Appin · 15/07/2023 18:50

My son was filling out a questionnaire for a dyspraxia assessment. He's 14. One of the questions was about how good he is at following adult instructions. I was in the room, but only observing.

He told the assessor that he is very good at following instructions, and that this is really important to him, as he wants to maintain the respect of his teachers.

He's such a lovely boy 😍