Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find most Brits bemusingly obedient?

238 replies

Torven · 15/07/2023 14:24

Most, not all!

But most would queue themselves into an early grave if a perceived (not even actual) authority figure ordered them to.

Why do they obey the "you must scan your receipt before exiting the self service area" rule in supermarkets? No you don't, Sainsbury's isn't going to hold you hostage in a castle dungeon until you comply.

Another thread on here about "requiring evidence" if your kid is sick so they're "allowed" to be off school? All these folk scrabbling about taking photos of thermometers oh I HOPE THE HEAD THINKS THIS IS ENOUGH 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭. Tell the head to feck right off.

Most rules can just be ignored and if enough people ignore the stupid ones they'll disappear. You're making it worse for everyone by going along with them.

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 20:35

Nèin!

twinklystar23 · 15/07/2023 20:34

So OP are you are parent? Have you actually told a teacher etc "to feck right off?" Do you consider what sort of role model that would make you? There are systems in schools that parents can appeal against, and process can be followed, for what parents might disagree with. You would hopefully balance your wish to go on holiday against your child's educational attainment. Verbal abuse is not tolerated and it cod potentially mean your child could be excluded for your behaviour. Can you understand that you might need to consider your child (and the fact they may be potentially happy at a particular school) before your own needs to not follow rules? Equally, you could consider home education or private education if affordable. So there would be options open to you, I. Not suggesting anything is perfect but at least in principle that is how a civilised society operates.

OhwhyOY · 15/07/2023 20:20

I agree excessive obedience is bad and testing the rules is worthwhile in some cases - but cases where the rules are excessive or harmful. Queuing is an example of where it should be followed I think because by not doing so you're harming others who have been waiting patiently. Who are we to decide we should get to go first? Letting someone with mobility issues or something go ahead, fine, but it should be the choice of those ahead in the queue to allow the person. I'd hope most people would have enough manners to follow this approach.

Also re Sainsburys barriers surely rather than climbing over you just stop shopping there and tell them why. Reduced customers will be much more effective than barrier hopping...

ForeverFriendsAndPierrot · 15/07/2023 20:09

So funny how this thread has backfired on the OP!

Catusrusty · 15/07/2023 18:50

Torven · 15/07/2023 14:55

Haha yes but a sensible person would just blink at you and ignore you. What are you going to do? You'll still be waiting to scan your receipt by the time they've left the shop 😀

No only a very rude an entitled person who thinks they are more deserving would try and ignore a queue.

I'm with you demoniccavemagnet I'm happy to call out queue jumpers. Never had one not back down when confronted.

Societal rules are there for the benefit of everyone. Without them there would be anarchy and people like the OP with their I'm all right jack attitude would happily trample all over everyone else.

You see it more and more, checking in at Heathrow recently and I watched a person walk past the barriered queue and join right at the front by squeezing in through a gap. They were spotted by the check in staff and loudly and unceremoniously ejected.

Frankly whilst Britain may have its faults, people having manners is not one of them. Sadly though the OP (clearly on a wind up) hasn't noticed, people are observing British social norms less and less. It's not unusual to have journeys on public transport interrupted by drunk boorish people, or people who haven't worked out that they should be using headphones.

Oh this might be news to you OP, in Germany Sunday is classed as a quiet day. Goodness how obedient German people must be to adhere to such a thing! Why don't they just all start making a noise? I shall tell you why, because it is for the benefit of everyone.

Perhaps you'll be starting a thread about Germans next? Probably not eh?

Why don't you take your xenophobic stereotypes and toddle off elsewhere dear?

BertieBotts · 15/07/2023 18:30

I still stick to my observation that Brits are not particularly obedient or rule-loving as such, but we HATE to draw attention to ourselves, as a rule. (Obviously individuals can be an exception!)

So a lot of what OP is citing as "obedience" is actually just avoiding standing out.

If following a rule will result in not standing out, then people will generally be obedient. If breaking the expected rule will bring unwanted attention to the person, then people are even more likely to stick to it. This is probably why the two things look the same, because the British "don't gain unwanted attention" culture is used in the enforcement of rules - this is possibly why we have so much CCTV compared with other places, because the CCTV is a silent indicator of "someone might come and call you out for this later".

If people will not notice or care, then people will be perfectly happy to break rules (or not) based on what suits them at the time. Such as, for example, crossing the road against a red light if it's safe to do so, parking illegally, dropping litter when nobody is looking, calling in sick to work when not actually sick, bringing your own sweets into the cinema, whatever.

It would be interesting to see how British people respond when there is a stated rule that would cause this to be broken, ie, the rule is to alert a staff member in XYZ situation, but it's possible to just ignore this and not notify anybody, and nobody is likely to come and find them later and ask why they did not do this.

I bet the majority of British people would slink away and pretend they were never in the situation in the first place or pretend that they had not noticed, in order to avoid having to attract unwanted attention, rather than follow the rule.

You can see this illustrated quite clearly in the example of somebody being disappointed when they have bought a train ticket but neither station they used had barriers and no conductor was on the train. This disappointment would simply never occur to a German, German trains have no barriers and there are very rarely ticket checks on normal public transport like trams/buses. The vast majority of people buy a ticket every single journey and do not consider it a waste if it does not get checked. I have probably been checked around 1-2% of the journeys I have made on local public transport in Germany.

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 18:28

Prestat · 15/07/2023 18:23

Societies that don’t queue are so stressful and inefficient.

I'd agree there tbh. I need an oul queue. But with 'soundness', like, if someone asked to go ahead for whatever reason and i wasn't in a particular rush, i'd say of course, go ahead. Bit without the manners bit, i'd be all sharp elbows 😂

Prestat · 15/07/2023 18:27

Prestat · 15/07/2023 18:23

Societies that don’t queue are so stressful and inefficient.

To clarify not generally but where queuing would be an option.

Prestat · 15/07/2023 18:23

Societies that don’t queue are so stressful and inefficient.

phoenixrosehere · 15/07/2023 18:19

MCOut · 15/07/2023 16:53

Black woman here, call me paranoid but I always print my receipt just to be safe. I couldn’t even imagine being brazen enough to hop the barrier and then PURPOSELY bring it to the security guard’s attention 😂

@LadyKenya I’m actually dying that being obedient is a slur that warrants cries of racism. On Mumsnet… where persistent covert racism is dismissed. It’s funny, but it’s not funny.

Black woman here, call me paranoid but I always print my receipt just to be safe.

Right. Stop at the doors if the alarm goes off, show my receipt to a shop worker at M&S with the Scan, Bag, and Pay, have bags of only a certain size, keeping items that don’t come with a receipt in a backpack fully zipped up and not reaching for anything inside until I’ve gotten a good distance away from the shop and then bagging my items accordingly.

StefanosHill · 15/07/2023 18:14

I have often seen people step aside for those more in need anyway. I do and so do many others

Probably not the op though. She’s probably pushing everyone to get to front. Pesky people.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2023 18:12

Queuing isn't necessarily fair - first person there isn't necessarily most deserving

Maybe they're not, but I'm not sure how a general melee when (for example) a bus arrives helps the less deserving either - especially if they're disabled and get shoved

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 18:08

may have been trigger happy there. If so, i apologise.

Here's my apology. It's upthread.

Davros · 15/07/2023 18:06

Funnily enough, the person I referred to was Russian

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 18:05

Davros · 15/07/2023 18:03

Tell the OP, not me

You stuck your beak in, i apologised if the person felt i was rude. So stick your beak out again.

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 18:03

And saying people not from the UK is nuts altogether. Ring China or Russia.

Davros · 15/07/2023 18:03

Tell the OP, not me

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:58

Davros · 15/07/2023 17:53

Chickenkeev the OP is characterising people from the UK a certain way so I'm just confirming her belief that people not from the UK don't follow rules.
Otherwise DFOD

Well thanks for the DFOD! But what i'm saying / what i think is that people can't just be shoved into a box that way! It's beyond simplistic where the UK has a such a rich mix of cultures. And tbh i think OP was being somewhat disingenuous with that comment if i'm being honest.

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:54

Davros · 15/07/2023 17:34

Posting from my hospital bed, let me tell you that the Rule Breaker in the next bed for the first two days was a PITA, not a rebel. And she was not from the UK

I may have been trigger happy there. If so, i apologise.

Davros · 15/07/2023 17:53

Chickenkeev the OP is characterising people from the UK a certain way so I'm just confirming her belief that people not from the UK don't follow rules.
Otherwise DFOD

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:52

Fairyliz · 15/07/2023 17:38

Oh right we will let them off them.

Well, compassion and treatment would be a start.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 15/07/2023 17:49

No I don't think so. Queuing maybe but I think you'll find people in most countries don't just push to the front of an obvious queue unless they are rude AF. I think the amount of get togethers during lockdown shits on your theory to be honest.

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:47

Davros · 15/07/2023 17:34

Posting from my hospital bed, let me tell you that the Rule Breaker in the next bed for the first two days was a PITA, not a rebel. And she was not from the UK

And why, exactly, does it matter if she was from the UK? Are you happy not to be treated by a medical professional bacause you're not from their country? People experience all sorts of hardships randomly, any time. When you were in your hospital bed, i'd bet my life many of those caring for you are foreign. I assume you didn't refuse treatment?

Fairyliz · 15/07/2023 17:38

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:35

There is an actual MH condition associated with shoplifting ffs.

Oh right we will let them off them.

Chickenkeev · 15/07/2023 17:35

Fairyliz · 15/07/2023 17:28

Generally people who shoplift are greedy or drug addicts.

There is an actual MH condition associated with shoplifting ffs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread