Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did I fat shame her?

333 replies

melonspritz · 15/07/2023 14:05

Just posting to ask for some perspective

I’ve been accused of fat shaming someone but I honestly don’t think I did

im currently looking for a full loan for one of my horses (a 15hh Connemara). She was our showjumping horse but we are moving up to something bigger so was looking for a full loan home for her to do some general riding club things. She’s a great pony, bombproof and has taken us up the levels so we owe her a lot. I left an advert in the local tack shop and was contacted fairly quickly by a lot of people and had to weed through people that were unsuitable. I was contacted by someone who was looking for a mother daughter loan share for her and her young adult daughter. She was previously a very experienced rider but had taken some time out and was now back and riding at a riding school and her daughter had been riding for a while too. They were looking for something to hack, do small jumps and spoil with cuddles and attention etc. all sounded perfect. I sent them all the details about the horse and offered for them to come out and have a lesson on her to try her out. I double checked before this and asked specifically if there were anything else I should know that may make them unsuitable for her (by this I meant that they weren’t happy with the price or were actually more novicey than they were making out) and they said no she was exactly what they wanted and they were riding horses like her at the riding school

they came out and they were far,far too big for her. I knew as soon as I saw them the mum that she was too big, and I wasn’t certain about her daughter so had to awkwardly mention it and ask what weight she was as I will not go over the weight rules for my horse. Her daughter was way over it too. I had to politely and very awkwardly explain that it wasn’t suitable and I was really sorry. They went absolutely wild, saying I had fat shamed them and that I was a nasty cow and had made her daughter cry and I should have let them try her. They were furious and I had to ask them to leave the yard. I then received a string of abusive angry messages and voice notes which I’ve completely ignored but I feel really hurt and upset by it all. Then to top it off they went onto Facebook and absolutely tore into me for fat shaming them and being nasty. They’re still bloody messaging me today going wild about it all because apparently I discriminated against them because of their size and I fat shamed them

I’m not going to mention weights or numbers so as not to cause any offense but they were absolutely way over what was ok for my horse and ultimately she’s my priority. I wasn’t offensive as far as I can see but I had to be honest and I tried to be polite about it

I suppose I should have checked their weight before I came out but they said they were experienced riders so I assumed they would know they were far too big for a 15hh Connie. And they said they were riding similar horses at the riding school, I’ve since found out they’ve been riding Clydesdales and large cobs.

there’s nothing else really I can do other than move on and ignore it but it’s still incredibly hurtful to be slagged off on social media. I’ve just taken some time out to ignore it but it’s still really upset me and they’re still bloody messaging me calling me a nasty bitch and saying I fat shamed them. I don’t know how else I should have handled it though. Am I going crazy or did I do nothing wrong?!

AIBU?

OP posts:
doingthehokeykokey · 15/07/2023 15:28

Ignore. People can be weird. Body dysmorphia is real. You are a responsible owner. Good for you OP.

DonttouchthatLarry · 15/07/2023 15:23

You did nothing wrong. I would mention it in the ad though - I've seen plenty that say things like 'suitable for teen or lightweight adult'. Or Just be blunt and put a maximum weight. You had a lucky escape there, they would have been nightmares even if lighter.

JudgeAnderson · 15/07/2023 15:18

Good for you OP.
Where I'm from there's a bit of a pony trekking industry and they have an upper weight limit of 90kg, over 14 stone, for animals that are largely very small and slight and I absolutely hate seeing the poor things overloaded with some beefy tourist Sad

Brbreeze · 15/07/2023 15:18

Definitely not unreasonable.

I've never advertised a loan with a specified weight limit except for kids ponies. For a 15hh to be honest I probably would have unless they had sent me photos/videos of them riding - which people tend to do without me even asking!

Lesson learned for the future, advertise the limit because you can't trust people to know theirs.

CoraPirbright · 15/07/2023 15:18

These horrors must be far, far less experienced than they claim as otherwise they would have had a good idea from your 15hh description that this was not going to be a suitable match. I would spread the word around the local stables/owners etc about them just as a warning. I like the comment upthread about ‘so you want me to allow you to injure an animal so that your feelings are not hurt?’!! So sorry this is happening to you but you do sound like a brilliant owner.

tenbob · 15/07/2023 15:16

SweatingSwampbeast · 15/07/2023 14:41

I mean obviously the weight of tack has to be factored in. But going by the old rule of one stone per hand, the max weight limit would be rather more than say 10 stone.

Completely agree that it's your horse and your rules though!

The most widely accepted rule is now 20% of the horse’s weight. It’s been adopted by BD for this year for all competitions

I would guess a 15hh connie would be around 400kg

Which means once you allow for tack, that’s a rider of 11.5 stone and not much more

WheresSummerGoneTo · 15/07/2023 15:16

Lots of sports require weight compliance, riding is one of them. You did the right thing OP in protecting your horse, I don’t let anyone ride my horses if they’re on the heavier side and I don’t care who I offend by refusing, the welfare of my horses come first. They’re clearly not experienced enough to realise horses have weight limits. If they’re that inexperienced you’ve had a lucky escape.

TheFireflies · 15/07/2023 15:15

You are not at all unreasonable. They are.
horse welfare first, always. And I speak as someone who has gained weight and currently don’t ride at all because of this.

Papernotplastic · 15/07/2023 15:14

If they don’t even have that level of basic knowledge they have no business riding.

MargaretThursday · 15/07/2023 15:12

I don't ride and never have had anything to do with horses, but it's kind of obvious that they will have a weight limit. Anything you put weight on will have some weight limit-even bridges do 🤣

So I suspect to anyone who knows anything about horses, what they're actually doing is saying "we don't know anything about horses, and aren't willing to learnt, don't let us use your horse". So they're shooting themselves in the foot if they're hoping to share a horse.

Jongleterre · 15/07/2023 15:12

I don't agree with the term 'shaming' that seems to be used by the terminally offended.

If you're fat, you're fat and there's no point Pusey footing around it.

In this instance their weight was completely relevant in their suitability for riding your horse.

I would have told the pair of 'GoLightly's' what you said and probably recommend they they lose weight in the interests of health and safety for them and any horses they want to ride.

wholivesondrurylane · 15/07/2023 15:11

If someone is booked into a martial art competition, but doesn't make weight on the day, is it fat shaming to tell them "no, sorry"?
Of course not.

You did nothing wrong.

It was a lucky escape for your horse, imagine having to put up with these temperamental nutcases? How do you think they would treat him after the way they are treating you?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 15/07/2023 15:11

Nobody thinks you're unreasonable, OP, not a one.

Weight is a definite deal-breaker in this instance. Think of it like a fairground rides. Those have height and/or weight limits for a reason. This is an even better reason.

I would put max weight limits in at the start of the conversation, very matter of fact, that way everybody knows where they stand and you need have no further conversation about it.

Partiallypickled · 15/07/2023 15:09

You often see 20% of a horses weight (including tack) for a heavier breed. 15% for a lighter breed. I don’t think just looking at a person is a guide to weight. Much fairer if you say what the maximum weight.

DarkDarkNight · 15/07/2023 15:09

It’s not nice for them and I’m sure a sensitive subject, but you did what was right for the horse. It’s not fair to have someone far too heavy on the horse.

It either just hadn’t occurred to them or they hoped you wouldn’t be aware, or would be too scared to tell them. Maybe they haven’t questioned why they were on cob types or heavy horses, and just assumed it would be ok. Ignore them, you have done the right thing.

InSpainTheRain · 15/07/2023 15:08

They weighed too much for your horse - statement of fact not fat shaming. However I think you should indicate suitable max weight when you advertise.

CrotchetyQuaver · 15/07/2023 15:04

Apparently at great Yorkshire shoe a couple of days ago, someone wasn't allowed in the ring because she was deemed too heavy for her pony...
I would just post a link to one of the guidelines/calculations on the maximum weight a horse should carry.

A PP is correct that they fat shamed themselves by posting their tale of woe on FB. Silly cows

pinklama · 15/07/2023 15:02

No, you did not fat shame them. You said they were too heavy (same but different). Horses have a weight limit depending on their breed, size and age. Some people just don't cope well with a reality check because it means they don't get their own way. But deep down, they know they are too heavy (not fat). If they don't then they are not the experienced horse people they claim to be.

Just add it to the loan advert, no riders over xyz stone etc.

RobertaFirmino · 15/07/2023 15:02

I know nothing about horses. You cannot argue with science though and it will cause problems for an object to bear more mass than it is capable of bearing. That's not fat shaming, it's physics.

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 15/07/2023 15:01

You're far nicer than me. I'd have responded on social media if they were publicly slandering you and very factually said why you had turned down their offer for your horse.

buckingmad · 15/07/2023 15:00

I’ve got a 14.2 connie and absolutely no way would I go over the weight limit. From how thy described themselves to you I would also have assumed they were aware of any weight limits. Weight aside, they’d have likely been too big to distribute weight evenly in the saddle and connies often don’t have a lot of back length to play with so if they had bought the pony it’d have ended up with back issues likely.

Block them and move on. Add height/weight restrictions to your initial convo with future buyers.

Fighterofthenightman1 · 15/07/2023 14:59

You did nothing wrong and it's a blessing that these idiots won't be loaning your horse

Sallyh87 · 15/07/2023 14:59

There hurt feelings are not as important as the health and comfort of the animal! The fact they weren’t aware, indicates they wouldn’t be good for the horse.

I think I’d probably be too big as well!

WiddlinDiddlin · 15/07/2023 14:58

Another far too heavy to ride any horse these days - no, you're not fat shaming.

Your horses weight limit is x, their weight is y+ so not suitable for your horse.

I don't think it is unacceptable to put your horses weight limit on a loan advert at all though, I have seen it done, particularly where people are looking for parent/child loans/shares.

Jackie246 · 15/07/2023 14:57

You definitely didn't make the wrong call not letting them on your horse, and I say that as a heavier person who rides a sturdy native to make sure I'm well within their weight carrying limit! There's nothing worse at shows than seeing oversized adults (not necessarily fat!) on small show ponies warming them up for children. There is stringent advice about this for a reason!

Swipe left for the next trending thread