Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH suddenly wants kids

693 replies

GeorgiaHunt · 15/07/2023 07:32

We've been together for 15 years, we are 50 and 40 now.

Very early on we discussed whether we wanted children, we were both very on the fence and neither of us ever made it a priority. We did agree that if one of us really wanted to try, then we would.

We are very lucky, very in love still and we've travelled lots, live in a great house, life is full of hobbies and friends. Financially secure, I had a large inheritance which meant I could give up work but I volunteer 5 days week over two roles I find very rewarding. DH choses to work 4 days a week but doesn't need to, loves his job. Very little stress in our lives.

He turned 50 last month and has said he'd really like us to try for a family. I admit I was really shocked, as I'd thought this question had passed us by with our ages - and in all honesty, I think he's too old.

The increased risks of the baby not being healthy/NT worry me, as well as his energy levels. He's an exceptionally young 50, very fit, but age does catch up with us all! 60 seems so old to have a 10 year old child.

And with my age that brings risks too, and the likelihood of not even being able to get pregnant is obviously high. I'm worried if we started down this path, it would just bring sadness and stress. I definitely wouldn't consider IVF.

How would you react? Looking for any advice!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TrudyProud · 15/07/2023 12:20

Gettingbysomehow · 15/07/2023 11:16

It is not a decision to make because someone thinks they might like to have kids after all. Why at this late stage? Are you prepared to have NO life of your own for the next 18 years. I had mine at 21 and that was the end of my carefree youth.
I didn't have a life of my own again until I was in my 40s.
Are you prepared for anything such as a seriously disabled child who will need care for the rest of their life.
Would you have two given you will both be very old when your child is 40. Who will they have when you are gone?

Personally I'd say 21 is too young.
My mum had me at 22 and Though we are close now I do think she resented giving up her youth so young.

If guaranteed a healthy baby I'd definitely pick becoming a mum at 40 over 21! At 21 I was in final year of university, spent my 20s travelling and climbing the career ladder. Met my husband at 31, married at 34, gave birth to our healthy DD at 35 and now due our 2nd DC at 37.

Having kids young is statistically financially harder which adds inordinate amounts of stress... probably links to why so many who do are knackared by 35. Just an opinion- not shaming anyone for their decisions.

snowgirl1 · 15/07/2023 12:19

I think the trouble with having children - at any age tbh - is that it's such a gamble. You don't know how you'll cope with the sleepless nights or whether you'll have a child that doesn't sleep through for years or will start sleeping through quite early.

DH & I had a lovely life - lots of sporting activities, lots of travel, lots of evenings out. I'd never felt the urge to have children. At 39, DH said he thought we're regret it if we didn't try. I had DD at 40. We're very fortunate that she was a pretty easy child - I love being a mum; DD has brought us so much joy in so many ways - I haven't ever regretted having her. I do think one the reasons we've found it so enjoyable is that both DH & I work 5 days a week and DD went to nursery. I know nursery is an anathema to some people - but for us part-time work wasn't an option and DD being at nursery meant we weren't ground down by tantrums and constantly changing nappies. If you go from doing your own thing 5 days a week/volunteering to being a full-time mum, you might find it quite wearing. Good luck in making a decision which is right for you.

Sparkleshine21 · 15/07/2023 12:18

I think consider fostering or adopting an older child? I agree, Im 32 with one child and I wouldn’t have any more over 35, I can’t imagine dealing with the sleepless nights when they are young at the age of 50, it was hard enough at 25!

Rushhomeroad · 15/07/2023 12:17

A friend of mine was talked into having a baby in similar circumstances. The husband left before the child reached one and has had a lovely single life style since. My friend has her daughter 100% of the time, and the child was diagnosed autistic early on. The child is 16 now and doing well, but the additional needs have been hard to fight for and not what my friend anticipated when convinced having a baby together would complete their family.

GeorgiaHunt · 15/07/2023 12:12

I wasn't expecting so many replies, thank you to everyone taking the time to post - I've taken it all in and finding myself nodding away in agreement to all your points, on both sides.

I'm delighted being an older parent has given so many lots of joy, and I have huge sympathy for those parents who have more to struggle with in terms of additional needs/widowed/abandoned.

To answer a few questions - I'm as sure as I can be that DH wouldn't want to leave the marriage, we've always been so close, it's a lovely relationship full of laughter and mutual support. He's such a kind, loving husband (don't know what I've done to deserve him!).

I do think it's FOMO/his age and not a genuine, well thought-out decision on his part; once we talk later, he'll hopefully see that the lifestyle change is so enormous that it's just not worth the risk of turning our lives upside down.

I have considered fostering, for a number of years it's been in the very back of my mind. We have a few spare bedrooms, perhaps restbite fostering might be a consideration. I will chat to DH and report back!

Again, thank you for the replies. I didn't know if my knee-jerk reaction to say no was unfair, considering what we agree when we met. But I do feel that agreement has long expired...

OP posts:
StillWantingADog · 15/07/2023 12:12

I don’t think it’s too old IF you both want it but it doesn’t sound like you do

i know plenty of people who’ve had their final child in the 40s, not the first admittedly. FIL had DH when he was 50, they had a great relationship until he died aged 85, dh has never wishes he was younger, he definitely did wish he was healthier though, which doesn’t sound like an issue here

lilacsinbloom · 15/07/2023 12:11

BestZebbie · 15/07/2023 11:22

Do you think he might be expecting you to say No, and that will give him the excuse he feels he needs to go and have an affair with a baby-hungry 30yr old?

This was my thought. He's writing himself a get out of jail free card to go and reproduce with someone younger. 50 is prime age for trading in and having a second round of kids with a new partner, or in his case, the first.

Boomboom22 · 15/07/2023 12:08

50 for men is ok, certainly better than 20 to 30. 40 is ok for either.

MandUs · 15/07/2023 12:08

I'd be worried it just took him this long to realise he wanted to have children (not uncommon at all for men) and he'll leave to be with a younger woman to start a family with. With his financial security there'd be plenty of women in their mid 30s to want this.

You need to have some honest discussions with him about what you both want.

SophieHope7 · 15/07/2023 12:07

If you would be the primary caregiver for your child you'd need to be prepared to give up everything you do for a season. It can be very rewarding being a parent but also incredibly tough. As my DH says.... Children absolutely ruin your life but you wouldn't want it any other way.

Jammything8 · 15/07/2023 12:06

Pinana · 15/07/2023 11:44

Wow, some seriously judgy responses here!

I did vote YANBU because I think you should both really want it if you're going to go for it, and you really don't sound like your heart is in it.

However 40 and 50 are in no way too old to have a child! We were 36 (me) and 51 (him) when we had our first, and 42 and 57 when we had our second. We had many fertility issues and feel nothing but grateful to have our children. We are both fit and healthy, and pretty relaxed, and I think we do a decent job of parenting. My husband runs and cycles every day, and probably has far less chance of dropping dead tomorrow than a morbidly obese 40yo...

I can appreciate life doesn't always go to plan and it was the case for you. This isn't OPs case though at all. How can you not realise that 51 and 57 is old to be starting your parenting journey? For me it's not even an argument it doesn't mean you are rubbish parents no, it is old and I just see it as something that isn't even arguing about.

SophieHope7 · 15/07/2023 12:05

Badbudgeter · 15/07/2023 07:35

Do you know anyone whose children you could borrow for a weekend? Nieces/ nephews / godchildren. You might well find the practical reality of children puts him off.

This is such good advice

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 12:05

CecilyP · 15/07/2023 09:02

Natural conception at this age is very risky and I wouldn't do it.
I had a baby at 24 years old and found it hard, just exhausting and relentless and felt like i had no time for myself.

There are increased risks but it’s not very risky. Having children is exhausting and relentless at any age. (The only possible exception is very young mums who get a lot of help from their families.)

But OP doesn’t really seem onboard with the idea, which would make it even harder.

Glad it's not just me. Just had someone amazed I found it hard looking after a baby and toddler! 😕

Lifeomars · 15/07/2023 12:04

your life sounds wonderful, the sort of life I can only dream of having. Having a child is a massive change, I don't even have the language to convey how much it changes everything and not all those changes are enjoyable. I used to liken my experience of motherhood to having had a nuclear war break out in my life such was the upheaval, the exhaustion and the impact on every facet of my existence from the physical to the financial. I was in my twenties so had time and energy to bounce back but I would say I didn't start to feel like my old self for around two years. Of course everyone is different but at this stage what positive changes do you think a baby then the long years of child rearing would add to what sounds like a lovely, full and interesting life. As others have said could you look into fostering, I know a couple who are unable to have children and who foster and they are wonderful at it and it makes such a difference to existing children.

SunRainStorm · 15/07/2023 12:01

In your shoes I would look at fostering.

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 12:01

DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/07/2023 11:55

I found it hard at 33 and 36.

Really?

Why was that?

Most of my friends had their 2nd or 3rd in their mid 30s and didn't find it hard at all.

Erm..I'm pleased for them. I found it hard work looking after a baby and toddler. Many people do. Glad you found it a piece of cake though!

Jammything8 · 15/07/2023 11:57

It all rides on you OP. Do you want a baby? I agree your DH is a bit old and you do sound life you both have a lovely life!

I'd be a bit annoyed that he didn't have this change of heart a good 5 years sooner. It is a bit odd.... but I always knew I wanted to be a mum and now I'm content with 1 DC.

TrudyProud · 15/07/2023 11:56

CecilyP · 15/07/2023 09:02

Natural conception at this age is very risky and I wouldn't do it.
I had a baby at 24 years old and found it hard, just exhausting and relentless and felt like i had no time for myself.

There are increased risks but it’s not very risky. Having children is exhausting and relentless at any age. (The only possible exception is very young mums who get a lot of help from their families.)

But OP doesn’t really seem onboard with the idea, which would make it even harder.

Or for parents with financial means who can pay for support live in nannies etc,

It takes a village (at any age) to raise a child and you can get that village in many ways

DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/07/2023 11:55

I found it hard at 33 and 36.

Really?

Why was that?

Most of my friends had their 2nd or 3rd in their mid 30s and didn't find it hard at all.

garlictwist · 15/07/2023 11:54

It would be a no from me. You're approaching too old and he definitely is. Perhaps he is feeling that he is not fulfilling a paternal/nurturing role in this life. Could you consider fostering (admittedly not an easy thing to do) or could be volunteer with children, doing something like scouts? I don't have children (through choice) but I do have a need to have involvement with children which I get through seeing my nieces.

GrapeHyacinth · 15/07/2023 11:54

It sounds like life is going well and is easy and he feels like he needs a new challenge/enrichment. I'm 52 and would find it hard having a baby now I think. I found it hard at 33 and 36.

TrudyProud · 15/07/2023 11:54

Oceanus · 15/07/2023 08:55

Interesting how people who having yet reached their 40s think that once you hit 40 it all goes downhill! IMHO people usually feel "their age" because they have a difficult life, as in a tough job with lots of stress, then they go home and have to babysit the DH and take care of the house alone, and often deal with several kids alone. Women cook, clean, ferry the kids around, etc, they do it all most of it.
Given you have such a stress free life I honestly don't think having a baby would mean your lifestyle changes massively. You have the money and you have the time, the issue is whether you want it. Do you want a baby? You have to want it, if you do, start trying now, if you don't, it's not the end of the world either, tell you DP and enjoy your life as it is. Not having a child doesn't make you less of a Woman. Having children doesn't define you, you are your own person.

Couldn't have said this better myself

DeliciouslyDecadent · 15/07/2023 11:53

Reading your posts, it comes over as if you'd be doing this for your H, not yourself.

I've already posted that your ages are not the real issue (and of course you have the means to pay for extra screening, privately, if you wanted that) while acknowledging the slightly higher risks.

But you've been with this man since you were 25, inherited money so that was never a reason to postpone being a parent, and you've never felt the urge to be a mum.

If it's something only he wants, it's his equivalent of the biological clock ticking.

Truthfully, I don't see this is a problem that is going to be sorted by anon posters on a forum!

You are getting all kinds of responses from NO to GO FOR IT.

Are any of those replies helping?

You need to dig deep into your own feelings and discuss it with your H.

TrudyProud · 15/07/2023 11:52

@babbscrabbs I agree with you

@GeorgiaHunt for these sorts of threads if you are going to ask for advice about having first children later than average speak to women who are actually going through it!
It's ridiculous getting advice from someone who had kids at 25- of course they are tired in their 30s.... news flash: kids are tiring!

I had my first at 35 and my 2nd will arrive when I'm 37. Yes I'm more tired now but that's because I'm working FT chasing a toddler. When I had my first mn would say "can't imagine having a newborn at 35 etc".
But I had easy conception, easy pregnancy , easy birth, easy 1st year- helped by having a stable marriage with a husband who practices 50:50 parenting, a great high paying career and savings so money isn't a worry. So easy that deciding to go for 2under2 doesn't phase us.

If you and your husband want a baby you have a better set up than a majority of the population. You're financially stable, can afford to stay at home with your family, you are well travelled and presumably would continue to share this with your children. You just need to know it's a big change from only focusing on your relationship to factoring in a baby 💯 dependent on you both.

Fact is fertility is personal. Plenty of 20somethings on mn sad they haven't conceived after years of trying then there's me (and lots of others) who's gotten pregnant the first time we tried on both occasions.
20somethings with babies with chromosomal diseases and me (and lots of us) of advanced maternal age with healthy babies. You don't know which you'll be .
Good luck with your decision.

SleepQuest33 · 15/07/2023 11:52

He needs to realise that it is a bit of a gamble. You may have the easiest child with both of you healthy and energetic well into old age. You may have a child with additional needs. As the mother with a son who has SN I can tell you it is extremely hard and your life will never be the same again, even after they reach adulthood.

on the other hand, children need attention and time and it sounds like you could have that in buckets load by just reducing your volunteering and work and you could give a child a great life.

is he prepared for whatever might come?