Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH suddenly wants kids

693 replies

GeorgiaHunt · 15/07/2023 07:32

We've been together for 15 years, we are 50 and 40 now.

Very early on we discussed whether we wanted children, we were both very on the fence and neither of us ever made it a priority. We did agree that if one of us really wanted to try, then we would.

We are very lucky, very in love still and we've travelled lots, live in a great house, life is full of hobbies and friends. Financially secure, I had a large inheritance which meant I could give up work but I volunteer 5 days week over two roles I find very rewarding. DH choses to work 4 days a week but doesn't need to, loves his job. Very little stress in our lives.

He turned 50 last month and has said he'd really like us to try for a family. I admit I was really shocked, as I'd thought this question had passed us by with our ages - and in all honesty, I think he's too old.

The increased risks of the baby not being healthy/NT worry me, as well as his energy levels. He's an exceptionally young 50, very fit, but age does catch up with us all! 60 seems so old to have a 10 year old child.

And with my age that brings risks too, and the likelihood of not even being able to get pregnant is obviously high. I'm worried if we started down this path, it would just bring sadness and stress. I definitely wouldn't consider IVF.

How would you react? Looking for any advice!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
KimberleyClark · 15/07/2023 15:44

I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare.

Do you think they’d tell you if they did? It’s still a massively taboo thing to talk about IRL.

Abouttimemum · 15/07/2023 15:44

I was 39 when I quite suddenly changed my
mind about children after 20 years of saying I didn’t want them. The difference is DH was only 42. It’s been nothing but amazing for us having DS. We’re knackered but that’s mainly because we both have to work! There’s loads of older parents in my circle, including men over 50 with babies.

Cucucucu · 15/07/2023 15:37

KimberleyClark · 15/07/2023 15:33

I think this is awful advice. Leaving herself open to getting pregnant when she is pretty sure she doesn’t want a baby would be reprehensible.

That’s not what I took from her post , I read she is scared of not getting pregnant and of the disappointment . If that is the case she will regret it a lot more if she never tried

KimberleyClark · 15/07/2023 15:33

Cucucucu · 15/07/2023 12:30

If the health issues are the main worry then don’t be put off more than 30% of babies are born to mums over 40 years old . I have my baby just days before turning 40 , a good friend just had a baby at 44 ( no ivf ) .
Why don’t you come off birth control and see what happens without much pressure

I think this is awful advice. Leaving herself open to getting pregnant when she is pretty sure she doesn’t want a baby would be reprehensible.

mydogisthebest · 15/07/2023 15:32

MrsSlocombesCat · 15/07/2023 13:41

Boris Johnson has just had a child (not himself obviously) and he’s 59. He’s got 3 small children. I did comment on Twitter that Carrie was trying to kill him, lol. I would not want small children and I am the same age as him. However I do frequently have my grandchildren to stay over and I love that. There are younger people having kids who will die before you due to illness or accidents. There are younger people than you having kids with SEN. Lots of women have babies in their forties. My Nan did, and interestingly and sadly my mother died only eight months after her, so although I had an uncle only five years older than me we both lost our mothers in the same year. I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare. I think you should think about it, at least. The joy of giving birth is incomparable to anything else. I remember looking at my firstborn and examining his ears, fingers, toes etc and thinking ‘I made this’ and feeling so overwhelmed with love. All the pitfalls along the way were worth it. My youngest has autism and I adore him, I have never had to cope with empty nest syndrome. Just ask yourself if you don’t have a child, will you feel the same as your husband in ten years time?

It certainly is not rare for parents, particularly women, to regret having children. Do you not read any of the threads on here where there are so many posts expressing regret.

So many of my friends say although they love their children, if they could go back in time they would not have any. These are woman with grandchildren and even great grandchildren but the worry, stress and hassle just never seems to end.

Also so many of my friends with children are divorced (some more than once) and say their marriages started to go wrong when they had a baby.

My childfree friends and family are all happily married with the longest marriage being 50 years and the shortest 28 (all first marriages).

Lavenderflower · 15/07/2023 15:26

I think this very much depends on you - Historically women have given birth from their teens to well in to their forties. Its only due to contraception why this doesn't happen as much.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/07/2023 15:21

I don't think either of you are being unreasonable.

I don't think you should feel under any pressure to have kids if you don't want them. It sounds like you're happy with your life as it is right now.

The real question is, will it be a dealbreaker for him if you say no? And if so, how would you feel about that?

blacknredsweeties · 15/07/2023 15:17

@mrsneate But most parents can't / don't want to go on holiday leaving their 12 year old home.

KimberleyClark · 15/07/2023 15:14

MonsterCalling · 15/07/2023 10:59

I wouldn’t take Jordan Peterson’s advice on whether to have curry sauce or mushy peas in the chippy, let alone whether or not I should have children.

Neither would I he’s a wanker.

Kitty12345678 · 15/07/2023 15:07

If it’s not something you want then don’t feel pressured too. I would have some very serious conversations about it before deciding what’s best for you both.

If you do really want to try then It would be worth getting a fertility check before, as you might find fertility issues or none at all that might impact your decision. It could be difficult naturally, then IVF might be an option to give a better chance at selecting the best embryo. Still the risk of miscarriage with your own eggs, its as much as 50% chance. But woman still have babies in there 40s. Some use egg donors, so that can really help your chances of a healthy baby.

Men don’t always have sperm issues even at 50, .My uncle had 2 kids in his early 50s with his wife who was in her late thirties. She miscarried with their first. But then went on to naturally have two healthy girls now 8 and 6. He can easily keep up with them and isn’t super fit either.

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 15/07/2023 15:05

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:15

I doubt this experience of the men doing fuck-all will be just women with men in their 50s. Most men of all ages CBA to do much when it comes to the babies/children/housework. Some women will deny it, but it's true. Most men are bone idle when it comes to housework/home admin/childcare.

Actually, many of the experiences centred around the men’s health issues, tiredness, fitness and capability of being an active parent past age 55.

It wasn’t just them being “bone idle”.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:38

CecilyP · 15/07/2023 14:24

Yes, could be any age. My friend who became a dad at 50 was very hands on. He and his wife both worked part time without using paid childcare.

For OP she needs to absolutely want a child and she may well be doing the lions share. I wonder if it’s come up now because you’ve both had big birthdays and it would be now or never.

Yeah this. ^ As many posters have said though, it looks like the OP doesn't want a baby at all.

Batalax · 15/07/2023 14:37

I think 40 is fine if you actively want a child. Not so much if you aren’t totally up for it.
If the op was going to compromise and have one for dh, then that should have been when they were younger and the whole thing likely to be easier. I definitely think the agreement has expired. She’s too old to change her life totally for the sake of dh.

CecilyP · 15/07/2023 14:24

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:15

I doubt this experience of the men doing fuck-all will be just women with men in their 50s. Most men of all ages CBA to do much when it comes to the babies/children/housework. Some women will deny it, but it's true. Most men are bone idle when it comes to housework/home admin/childcare.

Yes, could be any age. My friend who became a dad at 50 was very hands on. He and his wife both worked part time without using paid childcare.

For OP she needs to absolutely want a child and she may well be doing the lions share. I wonder if it’s come up now because you’ve both had big birthdays and it would be now or never.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:24

BeachBlondey · 15/07/2023 13:14

Just be aware, that parenting doesn't stop when they reach 18. They need help moving to Uni (physical help moving several times over their degree), emotional support and financial help until they are way in to their 20's. Mine are now 26 and 24, and it's only recently that I have been able to stop supporting them financially.

Your DH is 50 now, would most likely be 52 by the time baby is born. That would make him 70 when they went to Uni. He'd be 73 by the time they finish Uni (bare minimum 3 year degree). My Mum died at 72 (for context).

Certainly don't do it "for him", because whatever he says now, you will end up doing a minimum 80% of the child rearing. Men just never do as much as women. My H didn't do one night feed ever, despite me begging.

Exactly! Imagine doing all the toddler/child/secondary school/teenager stuff, and then having to do all the years at uni too. It's hard work and stressful putting kids through uni, and costs money. Imagine having to do this in your 70s?! Fuck that.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:15

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 15/07/2023 13:05

There was an interesting thread yesterday where many women shared the honest reality about having babies/young children with men in their 50s.
If you go ahead, be ready to do most the child rearing yourself:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4849101-i-feel-like-i-was-tricked-into-marriage-and-now-im-trapped?page=1

I doubt this experience of the men doing fuck-all will be just women with men in their 50s. Most men of all ages CBA to do much when it comes to the babies/children/housework. Some women will deny it, but it's true. Most men are bone idle when it comes to housework/home admin/childcare.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 15/07/2023 14:10

Cucucucu · 15/07/2023 12:35

Was a condescending person !! 30% of births are to women above 40 . Not everyone has children in their 20 s . The op and her husband clearly are stable financially and have lots of free time . So who are you judge if he would o be a good dad or not

@cucucucu

30% of births are to women over 40?

Absolute rubbish.

You can't just make things up to suit your argument you know

Katy4321 · 15/07/2023 13:56

You seem very happy and fulfilled in your current life which is wonderful. And definitely not something to change lightly.
I became pregnant at 44 (my partner was 37) and was a bit of a shock. I was hugely worried about the genetic risks, getting attached to the pregnancy then losing it and the loss of our freedom (we like to travel etc and visit friends).
I talked to various counselling services and midwifes who were very reassuring. Saying how many people over 40 have little or no problems and as I had no underlying health factors probably is all would ve okay. I guess what I'm trying to say it is more likely than not going be okay, although of course risks are higher then 20 or 30 something. But there are also positives of stable relationship and financial security. I took a nipt blood test at 10 weeks , that looked at fetal dna for the most likely serious genetic conditions, so I could potentially make an early decision not to go further.

We now have a beautiful healthy 2yo and we feel very very lucky. It is very tiring at times, different and some freedom has gone, but we are travelling again and seeing things in a new way. I would not risk doing it again as now I'm that much older. I did also love my life before and feel if things hadn't worked out, I'd be very happy continuing my child free life.

I wish you the best with whatever path you choose to take.

BigButtons · 15/07/2023 13:48

MrsSlocombesCat · 15/07/2023 13:41

Boris Johnson has just had a child (not himself obviously) and he’s 59. He’s got 3 small children. I did comment on Twitter that Carrie was trying to kill him, lol. I would not want small children and I am the same age as him. However I do frequently have my grandchildren to stay over and I love that. There are younger people having kids who will die before you due to illness or accidents. There are younger people than you having kids with SEN. Lots of women have babies in their forties. My Nan did, and interestingly and sadly my mother died only eight months after her, so although I had an uncle only five years older than me we both lost our mothers in the same year. I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare. I think you should think about it, at least. The joy of giving birth is incomparable to anything else. I remember looking at my firstborn and examining his ears, fingers, toes etc and thinking ‘I made this’ and feeling so overwhelmed with love. All the pitfalls along the way were worth it. My youngest has autism and I adore him, I have never had to cope with empty nest syndrome. Just ask yourself if you don’t have a child, will you feel the same as your husband in ten years time?

I doubt Boris Johnson’s lifestyle is much impacted by having all the millions of children he has. Not the best comparison to make.
it’s the women who have to gestate and do the bulk of the grunt work . The OP should be very sure about what she wants. She will be far more impacted by having a child than her DH will.

HumanBurrito · 15/07/2023 13:45

We had ours at that age and it has been brilliant but we both knew we wanted them.

HappyJunkie · 15/07/2023 13:44

I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare.

yup, not rare at all

Lentilweaver · 15/07/2023 13:43

I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare.

I have had many moments when I have regretted it. And many on MN do. We just don't talk about it IRL.

HappyJunkie · 15/07/2023 13:42

no bloody way! I say that as a mother of 3, kids are not all they are cracked up to be, I am envious of your life, do not wreck it😀

MrsSlocombesCat · 15/07/2023 13:41

Boris Johnson has just had a child (not himself obviously) and he’s 59. He’s got 3 small children. I did comment on Twitter that Carrie was trying to kill him, lol. I would not want small children and I am the same age as him. However I do frequently have my grandchildren to stay over and I love that. There are younger people having kids who will die before you due to illness or accidents. There are younger people than you having kids with SEN. Lots of women have babies in their forties. My Nan did, and interestingly and sadly my mother died only eight months after her, so although I had an uncle only five years older than me we both lost our mothers in the same year. I don’t know anyone who has regretted having a child personally, although I am sure there are parents who have but I think it’s rare. I think you should think about it, at least. The joy of giving birth is incomparable to anything else. I remember looking at my firstborn and examining his ears, fingers, toes etc and thinking ‘I made this’ and feeling so overwhelmed with love. All the pitfalls along the way were worth it. My youngest has autism and I adore him, I have never had to cope with empty nest syndrome. Just ask yourself if you don’t have a child, will you feel the same as your husband in ten years time?

jennyjones198080 · 15/07/2023 13:31

Fostering has been suggested here by a couple of posters. Just to highlight -
fostering isn’t like borrowing your friends children for a lovely weekend.

you are taking in what are often traumatised, abused, high needs children. It takes a huge amount of skill, patience, love, understanding to care for these children. A friend at school’s mum decided to do this - rich housewife wanted to give back. They stopped after one weekend - very troubled teen boy was laced with them on a Friday night/. Poor kid had been in an awful situation and was angry and scared. They couldn’t cope at all.

foster caters are amazing people and I would never discourage anyone from considering it - but it’s not a solution for someone who wants kids but can’t have them. You need to really want to help these children - need to be prepared to see your home turned upside down, drop plans at a moments notice, have the emotional capacity to listen to awful tales of neglect and abuse and try to bring some stability and love into a child’s life.

it is immensely rewarding - but not
for everyone.