Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my relative would stop harping on about portion sizes

556 replies

Averagesizedsalad · 14/07/2023 22:18

I have a relative who is doing my head in with their repeated "Oh I'm so teeny tiny, oh this is so much food however will i manage" dramas. I need to rant before I explode! Share with me your infuriating virtue signalling teeny tiny stories? Maybe I am just extra cranky because I am HUNGRY everytime I see them because I'm breastfeeding 🤷‍♀️

Said relatives recent examples:

  • When served a totally average sized salad for lunch, lamented "Oh this is so large, however will I have room for dinner later? I shall have to skip dinner, this salad will keep me full until morning" (I WISH I was joking, but alas I am not)
  • Recently cooked a meal of pasta for lunch, in which I could count the number of pasta pieces on one hand. Of course accompanied by "Oh what a large meal, I shan't want dinner later at all!" It equated to about 1 normal sized portion of pasta dish split between 2 people, so fair enough that might be considered a light lunch if you're expecting a big dinner later, but not so much food that you wouldn't need to eat later on!
  • Lamented that after having a normal sized slice of cake at a party that they were "Being sooooo naughty and would need to go on a big diet afterwards". It's a single slice of cake at a birthday party for goodness sake! You're not eating 1/4 of a cake everyday for dessert!

Obligatory: relative doesn't suffer from any health issues that might result in a small appetite blah blah blah. They are just insufferable and enjoy attention.

Thanks for listening to a hungry lactating mother complain after having about 10 curls (pieces? Squirls? What is the correct term here??) of pasta for "Lunch"

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 18/07/2023 17:03

@DrSbaitso ah yes- met plenty of those !!

MustardChair · 18/07/2023 16:58

No- did not drop kick out. But even DH who is oblivious and also likes to see the best in people commented to me privately that she was 'unbearable'.

They have not been back.

The last night she cooked for us and made a bit of a show about what a great cook she was. First course was corn on the cob cooked inside clingfilm in the microwave. No butter. Main was plain rice with some sauteed mushrooms. It was quite edible, granted, but nothing spectacular.

Silvered · 18/07/2023 16:26

MustardChair · 18/07/2023 15:46

I have a weight-fraud person in my life as well. I have always had weight issues- my parents (despite both being overweight) prescribe a moral virtue to weight as well. I only see them about once a year so I have gotten into a binge-starve cycle to try and lose weight ebfore i see them- then binge like crazy because i had 11 months until I saw them again. (Last time I saw my mother she started laughing and called me a hobbit).

Anyway- the wife of a friend of DH's came to stay and was clearly shocked that i had gone up in weight- 13 stone by then. She looked me up and down and said ' I see I shall have to teach you how to eat properly'. Seriously. (I have actually told this story on here before). The next day they asked for bacon butties for breakfast and she made a huge show of cutting hers in half and handing it back to me saying; 'This is a correct portion size'.

Anyway one night she was busily going on and on and on about how she knew she had to lose weight now as she had now reached the dizzying heights of 8 stone. The woman is 5 ft 7 or more and although on the slimmer side of things was not a waif. There was simply no way she was 8 stone unless the consistency of her flesh was like an aero bar.

Fucking hell. Please tell me you drop-kicked out the front door?

Annaisatwat · 18/07/2023 16:18

MustardChair · 18/07/2023 15:46

I have a weight-fraud person in my life as well. I have always had weight issues- my parents (despite both being overweight) prescribe a moral virtue to weight as well. I only see them about once a year so I have gotten into a binge-starve cycle to try and lose weight ebfore i see them- then binge like crazy because i had 11 months until I saw them again. (Last time I saw my mother she started laughing and called me a hobbit).

Anyway- the wife of a friend of DH's came to stay and was clearly shocked that i had gone up in weight- 13 stone by then. She looked me up and down and said ' I see I shall have to teach you how to eat properly'. Seriously. (I have actually told this story on here before). The next day they asked for bacon butties for breakfast and she made a huge show of cutting hers in half and handing it back to me saying; 'This is a correct portion size'.

Anyway one night she was busily going on and on and on about how she knew she had to lose weight now as she had now reached the dizzying heights of 8 stone. The woman is 5 ft 7 or more and although on the slimmer side of things was not a waif. There was simply no way she was 8 stone unless the consistency of her flesh was like an aero bar.

Fucking hell. I would have taken both sides of her bacon sandwich, put them in the bin and told her to leave.

Honestly, the rudeness of some people is staggering.

horseyhorsey17 · 18/07/2023 16:15

MustardChair · 18/07/2023 15:46

I have a weight-fraud person in my life as well. I have always had weight issues- my parents (despite both being overweight) prescribe a moral virtue to weight as well. I only see them about once a year so I have gotten into a binge-starve cycle to try and lose weight ebfore i see them- then binge like crazy because i had 11 months until I saw them again. (Last time I saw my mother she started laughing and called me a hobbit).

Anyway- the wife of a friend of DH's came to stay and was clearly shocked that i had gone up in weight- 13 stone by then. She looked me up and down and said ' I see I shall have to teach you how to eat properly'. Seriously. (I have actually told this story on here before). The next day they asked for bacon butties for breakfast and she made a huge show of cutting hers in half and handing it back to me saying; 'This is a correct portion size'.

Anyway one night she was busily going on and on and on about how she knew she had to lose weight now as she had now reached the dizzying heights of 8 stone. The woman is 5 ft 7 or more and although on the slimmer side of things was not a waif. There was simply no way she was 8 stone unless the consistency of her flesh was like an aero bar.

Ahhhh I know this scenario only too well! I am 5 foot 7 and have dropped down to 8 stone before (stopped eating due to depression) and looked like a heroin addict. I think that was actually what opened my eyes to the fact that other people around me were lying through their teeth about their own weight. It's so weird how people do this isn't it? What's the point - really?!

MustardChair · 18/07/2023 15:46

horseyhorsey17 · 17/07/2023 16:35

Mine was the same! Once when I was 18 she saw me walking up the drive to our house and came out to say 'oh my god you look massive darling.' I was nine and a half stone and a size 10 - which is more or less what I've always been (I am 5'7). But I've always felt fat. She always said she was only seven and a half stone but she clearly wasn't - and my sister similarly lied about her weight and still does - and the weird thing was that I believed them, it was years before it dawned on me that I was actually slimmer than either of them so unless I had really heavy legs or something, it was unlikely either of them were seven and a half stone.

I have a weight-fraud person in my life as well. I have always had weight issues- my parents (despite both being overweight) prescribe a moral virtue to weight as well. I only see them about once a year so I have gotten into a binge-starve cycle to try and lose weight ebfore i see them- then binge like crazy because i had 11 months until I saw them again. (Last time I saw my mother she started laughing and called me a hobbit).

Anyway- the wife of a friend of DH's came to stay and was clearly shocked that i had gone up in weight- 13 stone by then. She looked me up and down and said ' I see I shall have to teach you how to eat properly'. Seriously. (I have actually told this story on here before). The next day they asked for bacon butties for breakfast and she made a huge show of cutting hers in half and handing it back to me saying; 'This is a correct portion size'.

Anyway one night she was busily going on and on and on about how she knew she had to lose weight now as she had now reached the dizzying heights of 8 stone. The woman is 5 ft 7 or more and although on the slimmer side of things was not a waif. There was simply no way she was 8 stone unless the consistency of her flesh was like an aero bar.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/07/2023 15:02

Theres a jar of Brinjal pickle with a 1986 date on it. There was a tin of something unidentifiable that had been in the cupboard since circa 1970, that got moved to a plate in the fridge when it started to leak... however we did manage to sneak that one out to the bin recently (if caught doing that he WILL get stuff out and put it back in there).

We try to remove such things but if caught there is often a fight - in trying to remove some gone off, fermented, fizzy orange juice, I got caught and the ridiculous old bastard downed the entire bloody pint of it... anyone else would have been ill for days, he was fine (pissed, but fine).

But this refusal to 'waste' anything is also how we know he consumes any outrageous desserts, chocolate etc left at his home (which we do on purpose so he will eat them or he tends to live on beer)... he cannot BEAR to throw anything out, he will eat things he does not like, as well as things that have gone off, in order to avoid throwing them out. Particularly if he thinks someone else might have enjoyed it of course!

AutumnCrow · 18/07/2023 13:31

DrSbaitso · 18/07/2023 12:51

he has things in his fridge from the 1980s

What??

I'm pretty sure I have a jar of chutney in the back of my fridge that's an antique.

DrSbaitso · 18/07/2023 12:51

he has things in his fridge from the 1980s

What??

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/07/2023 12:41

My Dad will make a song and dance at times about how he doesn't eat much doesn't need much, couldn't eat 'that'.... whatever 'that' happens to be. If you offer him some he will profess to NEVER eat such FILTH, its always 'gross' and 'revolting' (meant in the sense it is excessively lavish, rich and sugary)....

But has drawers of chocolate biscuits hidden away (from who, he lives alone!) 'for his blood sugar' (nowt wrong with it that stopping 4 pints, half a bottle of wine and a couple of whiskies each night wouldn't fix)... and if you leave a cake or dessert in his fridge it WILL vanish.

If questioned he will claim he threw it away, but the collection of Gu ramekins is ever growing, and he has things in his fridge from the 1980s, he doesn't throw things away, ever!

He mostly prefers to comment on other peoples food but doesn't do it to me as we leave any time he starts that shit and he dislikes being abandoned more than he enjoys food policing.

SlimPig · 18/07/2023 11:40

This shit pisses me off. Its so tiresome. I had a thread on it once, linked by a PP above.

My DH has lost a bit of weight recently and started this shit a bit, making me feel shamed for wanting to eat a proper amount. Mentioning he eats less than me. He may well do at an actual meal, but then he'll be up and down all night snacking on shit, so doesn't actually eat less than me. I told him to go fuck himself.

TommyNever · 18/07/2023 11:16

Comedycook · 18/07/2023 11:07

I've never known a man to get performative over his portion sizes or another man's, but loads of them will comment on what a woman is eating

True and if a skinny woman eats a lot, they'll say how great it and how they love a woman who they can pig out on the sofa with. She's cool. If the woman is fat and eating a lot, they will see it entirely negatively.

No doubt some men do, but I would never dream of commenting on anyone's portion size. I enjoy my food and am "big-boned" myself, and certainly not going to pass judgment on others, regardless of their sex.

phoenixrosehere · 18/07/2023 11:13

DrSbaitso · 18/07/2023 10:52

I've never known a man to get performative over his portion sizes or another man's, but loads of them will comment on what a woman is eating.

Agree. I have had FIL comment on me eating a takeaway (order of chips and garlic sauce) when we visit them when we have it only when visiting them and I don’t really eat them when at home. Never says anything about DH’s while also tucking into ours and has more than I do. I can’t win tbh.

Comedycook · 18/07/2023 11:07

I've never known a man to get performative over his portion sizes or another man's, but loads of them will comment on what a woman is eating

True and if a skinny woman eats a lot, they'll say how great it and how they love a woman who they can pig out on the sofa with. She's cool. If the woman is fat and eating a lot, they will see it entirely negatively.

DrSbaitso · 18/07/2023 10:52

Crikeyalmighty · 18/07/2023 10:41

I've personally found this performative tiny portions stuff seems very common in middle class/well to do women over 50 (I'm 61) I think some of it may come from comments from our youth , my 'posh' grandmother was a good cook but always did minuscule portions and was always slim I admit- whereas my 'working class' gran used to serve gigantic meals of varying quality and was always offering bags of crisps or biscuits between meals etc - she was always somewhat overweight too but as a kid I liked going there far more!! Can I just say I've yet to meet a bloke of any size- who does this kind of nonsense

I've never known a man to get performative over his portion sizes or another man's, but loads of them will comment on what a woman is eating.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/07/2023 10:41

I've personally found this performative tiny portions stuff seems very common in middle class/well to do women over 50 (I'm 61) I think some of it may come from comments from our youth , my 'posh' grandmother was a good cook but always did minuscule portions and was always slim I admit- whereas my 'working class' gran used to serve gigantic meals of varying quality and was always offering bags of crisps or biscuits between meals etc - she was always somewhat overweight too but as a kid I liked going there far more!! Can I just say I've yet to meet a bloke of any size- who does this kind of nonsense

ZiriForEver · 18/07/2023 10:05

DangerousAlchemy · 18/07/2023 07:34

@ZiriForEver sorry - you go to a restaurant & you'll order HALF A GLASS OF WINE?? 🤣🤣 this did make me laugh!

Sorry to disappoint you, but not in the restaurant.
I was talking about home/meeting with friends/party at work setup. (As was, at least partially, the OP).

I would love if restaurants were happy to accommodate my preference, but the communication about it would be too awkward to try.

funnelfan · 18/07/2023 08:54

My MIL keeps up a constant stream of comments about both her food and everyone else in the table, but only if she’s cooked it. At restaurants she’s fine. In her case it appears she has some form of anxiety around food (is very restricted in what she eats) and cooking for others really stresses her out. So we take her out to eat when we visit her and it’s a win all round.

TommyNever · 18/07/2023 08:51

DangerousAlchemy · 18/07/2023 07:34

@ZiriForEver sorry - you go to a restaurant & you'll order HALF A GLASS OF WINE?? 🤣🤣 this did make me laugh!

Heh. Me, I'll occasionally order half a bottle but only if they're offering half bottles, and only if I'm dining alone. But even then I'd usually be happier with a whole bottle but feel slightly embarrassed with that much wine to myself in public (obviously doesn't bother me at all at home). 😊

Coolmom81 · 18/07/2023 08:27

NancyJoan · 14/07/2023 22:20

My mum does this. I find it dementing. I often don’t eat dinner if I’ve had a ‘proper’ lunch, but I don’t feel the need to tell people about it.

Same! She will also feel the need to point out what she left because “she couldn’t finish it all” knowing that I’ve cleared my plate 🙄 I’m almost certain she wasn’t like this when I was growing up. think it must be an age thing, but glad to know it’s not just mine.

mangochops · 18/07/2023 07:41

Not everyone feels comfortable leaving food on a plate and no-one should have to eat more than they want - especially at home/self catering setup when leftovers which remained in the pan are not wasted

She can eat as little as she wants, thats not the issue here. The issue here is her judgemental running commentary on it which is clearly designed to make others feel uncomfortable about what they are eating. Its rude AF to try to shame others about the amounts they are eating. Literally noone cares if she eats a tiny amount and noone is pressuring her to eat more. It is her who is making this into a big vocal issue, noone else!

DangerousAlchemy · 18/07/2023 07:34

ZiriForEver · 15/07/2023 00:00

Just let the relative decide her portion size, call her over when plating stuff if necessary. No big deal.

Not everyone feels comfortable leaving food on a plate and no-one should have to eat more than they want - especially at home/self catering setup when leftovers which remained in the pan are not wasted.

Especially with the cake, I often want to taste it, and half the standard slice is ideal for that. At my workplace it is totally normal wish, and it is possible , just have a normal knife available.
Similarly, I can ask for half a glass of wine or small taster of other alcohol.

I suppose it helps that I'm not teeny tiny or dieting, or talking about teeny tiny dieting, I generally like food, I don't comment on other's portions and there is no performative intention/aspect in it.

@ZiriForEver sorry - you go to a restaurant & you'll order HALF A GLASS OF WINE?? 🤣🤣 this did make me laugh!

DrSbaitso · 18/07/2023 05:41

GwinGwyn · 17/07/2023 23:25

It’s Monty Python’s four Yorkshiremen… don’t play into it. Either don’t have her around for supper or else just ignore her performance.

" 'Ad to lick road clean wi' tongue..."

"You licked the road? I just inhaled the smell of the wheat at 5am and I was stuffed all day!"

stacyvaron · 18/07/2023 04:14

Try my patented response, "mmm, sucks to be you" and let it go

StrangerYears · 18/07/2023 01:45

I work in an office filled with women like this (bar me and one other).
"Oh I must resist the thing someone has brought in to share. I will be like a house.
"How many calories are in that yoghurt?"
"I'm so naughty, I've taken a grape to eat later'
"when my husband is away, I don't eat as I only eat for his sake"

I never talk about what I am eating, so was taken aback when someone offered me cake and I took a miniscule piece. "Are you dieting?" Nope- I am just not a fan of cake.

Me and my mate call them 'the almond people'. Half an almond and they are full.