Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my relative would stop harping on about portion sizes

556 replies

Averagesizedsalad · 14/07/2023 22:18

I have a relative who is doing my head in with their repeated "Oh I'm so teeny tiny, oh this is so much food however will i manage" dramas. I need to rant before I explode! Share with me your infuriating virtue signalling teeny tiny stories? Maybe I am just extra cranky because I am HUNGRY everytime I see them because I'm breastfeeding 🤷‍♀️

Said relatives recent examples:

  • When served a totally average sized salad for lunch, lamented "Oh this is so large, however will I have room for dinner later? I shall have to skip dinner, this salad will keep me full until morning" (I WISH I was joking, but alas I am not)
  • Recently cooked a meal of pasta for lunch, in which I could count the number of pasta pieces on one hand. Of course accompanied by "Oh what a large meal, I shan't want dinner later at all!" It equated to about 1 normal sized portion of pasta dish split between 2 people, so fair enough that might be considered a light lunch if you're expecting a big dinner later, but not so much food that you wouldn't need to eat later on!
  • Lamented that after having a normal sized slice of cake at a party that they were "Being sooooo naughty and would need to go on a big diet afterwards". It's a single slice of cake at a birthday party for goodness sake! You're not eating 1/4 of a cake everyday for dessert!

Obligatory: relative doesn't suffer from any health issues that might result in a small appetite blah blah blah. They are just insufferable and enjoy attention.

Thanks for listening to a hungry lactating mother complain after having about 10 curls (pieces? Squirls? What is the correct term here??) of pasta for "Lunch"

OP posts:
JMSA · 15/07/2023 12:48

I am on holiday with a friend at the moment. Yes, I may be piling the food on my plate at the buffet Blush but I'm not sure our holiday is the time or place to tell me ('as a friend') that I need to see a nutritionist about my eating habits.
Yes, I know I overeat and am overweight. I KNOW I need to sort it.
But just for this week, leave me alone! and I won't mention your smoking

Comedycook · 15/07/2023 12:48

NewtonsCradle · 15/07/2023 12:01

No it wasn't that. It was competitive, each woman wanted to be the one who ate the least. They would then try to shame each other with I couldn't manage that!!! The portions were already half according to the recipe so in fact I was serving half a slice, a quarter of a slice, an eighth of a slice etc. It was truly depressing to observe. Thanks for your helpful comment though, really amusing.

I know exactly the type of situation you mean
Its so tedious.

Unfortunately and bizarrely there is a weird thought process amongst many women that food intake is somehow related to morality. As if you are a fundamentally better person if you eat less.

Lottapianos · 15/07/2023 12:48

'I remember ages ago a thread on here where a woman said she found fruit so incredibly sweet, she could only manage a piece every few months'

🤦🏻‍♂️
Haven't seen this but I can well imagine. There are some sad scary views about food on here

Averagesizedsalad · 15/07/2023 12:46

Lol to answer some q -

The relative in question is of an average sized build, neither extremely skinny nor overweight. The pasta dish, they offered to cook for me as they were visiting me + newborn and I thought "oh how lovely for someone to cook me a hot meal while DH is at work"... it was a nice meal, all 2 mouthfuls of it 😭

I wouldn't even mind if it was an occasional thing. I have definitely sometimes gotten portion sizes completely out of whack if I didn't realise how big a recipe would be or how filling it would be, and I will always have a chuckle at my cooking then at the dinner table by saying "Oh sorry for the big portion of rice/whatever, I completely messed it up and didn't realise how much it would make - just eat however much you want!!" If my relative simply said on occasion "Thanks for the meal, it's lovely but I'm not very hungry today so I'll just have a little bit" that would be fine! But it's the going on and on and on. And on and on and on and on for the entire meal that is infuriating

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/07/2023 12:45

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/07/2023 09:54

@CurlewKate , I’m an older (pretty ancient) woman and I’ve never felt ‘conditioned’ to under-eat, or to pretend to, or to feel that I shouldn’t enjoy my food.

DM loved her food and ate a lot (she was a child during the war and experienced rationing so I can understand it). She struggled with her weight practically all her life but I'm eternally grateful for when I read these threads is that she didn't police our food, she didn't involve us in her weight struggles and she never, ever commented on our food intake (apart from the cost of buying food for three eternally hungry teenagers with the metabolisms of a blast furnace).

Natty13 · 15/07/2023 12:44

10HailMarys · 15/07/2023 12:35

If you don’t spend the whole meal banging on about it, you’re golden. Loads of people don’t eat that much. It’s not having a small appetite that’s annoying, it’s making a big humblebragging fuss about it that gets people’s backs up.

In an ideal world this would be the truth bit it's not. I'm often spoken to as if I'm one of these performative under eaters by colleagues and friends of friends/friends of in laws etc. when I literally don't say a thing about portion sizes or reasons for turning down food offered. Ever.

I have a daughter and nieces and am very conscious of not contributing to them having body issues or unhealthy attitudes to portions. It's nobody's business whether I'm turning down a cake because I don't like the flavour, a sandwich because it has too much rocket, a meal because it contains something that will give me a bad tummy, or because I have an event coming up and am following planned meals for a few weeks. It just doesn't matter. I don't want other people to comment on my eating so I don't comment on it myself. However people very often do.

fuchiaknickers · 15/07/2023 12:43

To be honest, I would quite enjoy this opportunity to ramp up the fuss to the next level and give her ridiculously tiny portions.

So wait for her to say her totally normal portion is “enormous!” and apologetically whip out a tupperware and offer to decant some of it, ask her how much she thinks she can eat- this much? A bit less? Keep going?

Silly woman.

I suppose the only caveat is if she has an actual eating disorder in which case better to be kind. But if she’s just being a performative arse, give her the performance she’s asking for!!

DrSbaitso · 15/07/2023 12:40

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 15/07/2023 12:35

People, especially women, know exactly what calories they are eating/what portions they are eating and they should be left to get on with it.

Men don't face this sort of censure, not ever.

I think your posts are, as usual, wanting to say far more, be far more jibing, but you stay just on the side where you won't be called on it. I clock them though and I expect others do too.

Obesogenic society was coined by somebody like you, wanting a stick to bash people with. We have a completely messed up society of which, obesity is a factor. This thread wasn't about that though and we don't need a spokesperson, thanks.

I clock them though and I expect others do too.

Of course. It's a bloody klaxon.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 15/07/2023 12:39

MissTrip82 · 15/07/2023 12:34

My mum does this. Refers to normal portions as ‘huge’, judges people for eating them, talks about overweight people as ‘colossal’.

My sibling died from complications of anorexia.

I am really sorry to hear about your sibling, what an awful bloody disease that is.

I doubt your mum sees any parallel with her behaviour.

I honestly don't understand why people can't just shut up when it comes to what other people are eating. Nothing they could say is going to change it and it's solely for their own benefit/weak egos. They do though, sadly, have agency over their children and can wreak any amount of pain and suffering. All done under the guise of 'caring'.

DrSbaitso · 15/07/2023 12:37

But if you say no thanks people might think you're a bore, depriving yourself, performatively!

"No thank you" is not performative. Here is how my aunt performatively refused a cake at my daughter's second birthday.

Me: "OK, I'm cutting the cake."

Aunt: "Oh none for me, thank you."

Me: "OK. Uncle?"

Aunt: "I mean, we already had so much food already."

Me: "No problem. Uncle, can I offer you some cake?"

Aunt: "There was just so much! All those sandwiches, the vegetables, we already had biscuits too, don't you think that's quite a lot? I couldn't eat any cake after all that.

Me: "Uncle, would you like some birthday cake?"

Aunt: "I just couldn't, it's so much. Did you make it? All that cream, and jam too? It's so much, we already ate..."

Obviously this is the point where I should have slammed the cake in her face. "Not for me, thank you" is fine!

10HailMarys · 15/07/2023 12:36

AngelicInnocent · 15/07/2023 11:47

My MIL was a tiny tiny woman who ate nothing but there was never a performance about it.

If someone asked her, genuinely concerned, she would explain that she was brought up that way and these days, it was just what she was used to.

If someone commented on what she ate in any other manner, she would look at them and say "and it's got what to do with you? Fuck off!".

Always funny from a little old lady.

And heaven help anyone who told a child that food would make them fat etc around her. She would give them hell.

She sounds like an absolute LEGEND 🤣

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 15/07/2023 12:35

RoseAndRose · 15/07/2023 07:50

It's not generational

But it is true that the human body needs fewer calories with age

So older women who don't want to pile it on with the menopause will be consuming less than someone like OP who is a younger breastfeeding woman, who actually needs a few hundred calories above her normal intake

People, especially women, know exactly what calories they are eating/what portions they are eating and they should be left to get on with it.

Men don't face this sort of censure, not ever.

I think your posts are, as usual, wanting to say far more, be far more jibing, but you stay just on the side where you won't be called on it. I clock them though and I expect others do too.

Obesogenic society was coined by somebody like you, wanting a stick to bash people with. We have a completely messed up society of which, obesity is a factor. This thread wasn't about that though and we don't need a spokesperson, thanks.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/07/2023 12:35

FKATondelayo · 15/07/2023 09:02

I used to be taken to lunch a lot by media agencies. In theory very nice, but the 10th time every single woman at the table interrogated the waiters about gluten, no-bread options, carb content, whether the dressing could be served on the side, if they could have a wafer of jackfruit instead of potato fries I realised I'd rather just eat a sandwich and packet of crisps at my desk.

When I was with ex we had a friend whose wife would do this when we were all out at dinner. Still cherish the memory of SIL snapping at her to shut up and order so we could eat.

10HailMarys · 15/07/2023 12:35

mimi912 · 15/07/2023 10:41

After reading this thread I'm worried now that people are calling me performative and a 'dainty' eater. I often struggle to finish portions kindly provided by others!

If you don’t spend the whole meal banging on about it, you’re golden. Loads of people don’t eat that much. It’s not having a small appetite that’s annoying, it’s making a big humblebragging fuss about it that gets people’s backs up.

MissTrip82 · 15/07/2023 12:34

My mum does this. Refers to normal portions as ‘huge’, judges people for eating them, talks about overweight people as ‘colossal’.

My sibling died from complications of anorexia.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 15/07/2023 12:34

Bbq1 · 15/07/2023 11:43

With a doughnut the other half of the ring is literally an extra 2 or 3 bites so why not just eat the thing? I don't usually bother much with cakes in work but i find it really off putting seeing half a doughnut sitting there. I think people who do this would normally consume the entire portion. If eating at home but don't want to be seen as greedy in public. It's nit greedy ti consume a portion size intended for one.

The fact you think it is about greed is really telling. If someone eats half a doughnut it doesn’t mean they are judging you for being greedy for eating a whole one. It just means they….only want half a doughnut.

There are quite a few posts on this thread that have tipped over from being about performative undereating (which I 100% agree is a thing and is both annoying and harmful) to posters just judging other people for eating less than them.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 15/07/2023 12:32

Former mil and sil are like this. Neither are slim either.

N0ëlle · 15/07/2023 12:32

I agree about cheap cakes, they're not hard to resist. Some of them have a slimy texture. You can feel rather than taste the sliminess. But if you say no thanks people might think you're a bore, depriving yourself, performatively!

Like @nancyjoan though, I'm saying this on this thread, in real life I just leave what I don't want, or just smile. I don't get in to conversations about what I'm probably going to end up leaving uneaten on the plate.

Daphnis156 · 15/07/2023 12:29

The young people at my work, far from any performance under-eating, ate all day- from bowls of cereal in the morning, to chocolate, pasties, cakes, biscuits, revolting smelly things in plastic pots, toast; it was never ending.
They were all not fat, and saw nothing odd in the quantities eaten.

They would simply have laughed at your "portion queen" relative, and ignored her.

Blueuggboots · 15/07/2023 12:23

My mum can't eat a piece of cake or a cream cake etc without commenting that she shouldn't eat it....I've asked her to
a. Refuse it
b. Eat it and enjoy it without the comments

When we used to go for dinner, we'd get 1 potato, a small amount of veg and a slice of meat....nope!!!

DrSbaitso · 15/07/2023 12:17

Ratonastick · 15/07/2023 11:58

I have a friend like this. Every meal out is a running commentary about portions and how she won’t need dinner. She used to irritate the arse of me, until I met her mother. Then it all became crystal clear.

Her mother was rake thin, smoked like a chimney and already had bone problems in her 60s (which she was strangely proud of as it proved how delicate she was) but she was vicious about other women’s food intake. Described her own (gorgeous 6ft tall) daughter as “lumpen” and “bovine”. On my friend’s wedding day, she came down in her dress and looked absolutely stunningly beautiful. Her mother’s first words were that it was a shame she hadn’t slimmed down and she didn’t really deserve such a nice dress at her size. I could have wrung her neck as I watched my beautiful friend’s eyes well up.

So now I am far more forgiving. It’s deep down learned behaviour. And I have also noticed that it’s virtually stopped since she stopped visiting her mother so much.

That's unforgivable.

Moredramathanrazzamatazz · 15/07/2023 12:13

Sadly, they have disordered eating. Feel bad for them and otherwise ignore.

BeardyButton · 15/07/2023 12:05

Ratonastick · 15/07/2023 11:58

I have a friend like this. Every meal out is a running commentary about portions and how she won’t need dinner. She used to irritate the arse of me, until I met her mother. Then it all became crystal clear.

Her mother was rake thin, smoked like a chimney and already had bone problems in her 60s (which she was strangely proud of as it proved how delicate she was) but she was vicious about other women’s food intake. Described her own (gorgeous 6ft tall) daughter as “lumpen” and “bovine”. On my friend’s wedding day, she came down in her dress and looked absolutely stunningly beautiful. Her mother’s first words were that it was a shame she hadn’t slimmed down and she didn’t really deserve such a nice dress at her size. I could have wrung her neck as I watched my beautiful friend’s eyes well up.

So now I am far more forgiving. It’s deep down learned behaviour. And I have also noticed that it’s virtually stopped since she stopped visiting her mother so much.

This is disgusting. my mother has said similar, but even she would not do this on a wedding day. How fucking horrible. Why are we women so awful to each other?!

NewtonsCradle · 15/07/2023 12:01

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 15/07/2023 11:11

Or maybe you were just cutting the slices too big?
Ime it can be quite hard to get the person who has made the cake to cut you a small bit when you don’t have much room. Someone says ‘half that size!’ and the slicer cuts a piece that is about 20% smaller so the next person says ‘half that size!ʼ and so it goes on.
If they were actually halving it each time you would be down to a crumb by about the fifth person 😂

No it wasn't that. It was competitive, each woman wanted to be the one who ate the least. They would then try to shame each other with I couldn't manage that!!! The portions were already half according to the recipe so in fact I was serving half a slice, a quarter of a slice, an eighth of a slice etc. It was truly depressing to observe. Thanks for your helpful comment though, really amusing.

Ratonastick · 15/07/2023 11:58

I have a friend like this. Every meal out is a running commentary about portions and how she won’t need dinner. She used to irritate the arse of me, until I met her mother. Then it all became crystal clear.

Her mother was rake thin, smoked like a chimney and already had bone problems in her 60s (which she was strangely proud of as it proved how delicate she was) but she was vicious about other women’s food intake. Described her own (gorgeous 6ft tall) daughter as “lumpen” and “bovine”. On my friend’s wedding day, she came down in her dress and looked absolutely stunningly beautiful. Her mother’s first words were that it was a shame she hadn’t slimmed down and she didn’t really deserve such a nice dress at her size. I could have wrung her neck as I watched my beautiful friend’s eyes well up.

So now I am far more forgiving. It’s deep down learned behaviour. And I have also noticed that it’s virtually stopped since she stopped visiting her mother so much.