Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH is going to find out about my CC debt isn’t he.

505 replies

Blueskyfordays · 14/07/2023 19:38

PLEASE, PLEASE not a pile on.

I have £4K of CC debt, tbh I have no idea how I’ve even accumulated it over the years but here we are. Minimum payments are £150 a month, I pay off £200-£250 a month but it has a fairly high interest rate (about £80 a month interest charges) husband doesn’t know, we have separate bank accounts with my wages going into mine and his going into his. I just transfer him money for mortgage and bills.

I have never been on our mortgage, mainly because DH can easily afford the mortgage himself and this house was his before we married. We married a couple of years ago.

Mortgage now up for renewal, he said a couple of months ago he wanted to put me on the mortgage. I didn’t say anything, hoping he’d forget/ change his mind.

This morning, the new provider that he’s gone to a quote for rang him and he said he wanted to put his wife on the mortgage too and I had to give some details, name, DOB, job title, current salary etc.

Between us we earn £98k and we would be looking to take out a mortgage of £240,000.

The man on the phone thanked him for the details and said someone will be in touch.

Will they ask/ tell him about the debt? 😭😭 I know people will say I should have told him/ should tell him but I pay it every month, I’ve never missed a payment, it comes out of my wage and if I was spending £200 a month on clothes and shoes (I don’t!) I wouldn’t tell him, so long as I could afford it.

I was just hoping to get it all paid off in the next 2-3 years with him being none the wiser 😞

OP posts:
lilymani · 16/07/2023 17:49

@JenWillsiam I do agree that everyone lies for a reason (even cheaters, murderers, etc), and sometimes it's legitimate self-protection and survival. But sometimes it's not really necessary for self-protection and survival, and we would benefit so much more from an honest way of life – only our monkey brain and "learned" beliefs won't let us see that.

When I finally "came clean" to loved ones about something, I was surprised to learn their love was far more unconditional than I thought. On hindsight, before that, I really blew up their potential judginess and projected negative traits in my head. I tend to be an anxious person and have a childhood backstory, but that's nothing to do with them.

feenac · 16/07/2023 17:44

My DH was more financially secure when we met. He had a mortgage and lived payday to payday but had never had a credit card or overdraft when we met. I earned less but always saved and spent less than he did. Eventually, lifestyle creep caught up with me and I was putting little bits on a 0% credit card. It had built up to £5k by the time he took me by surprise and suggested a joint mortgage and joint account, after 5 years of living together. I immediately paid 3k using my savings but had to confess to the credit card debt. He was surprisingly understanding and cleared the rest. It turned out my savings habit had rubbed off on him and he had been putting away most of his subsequent pay rises. All you can do is be honest with him.

lilymani · 16/07/2023 17:44

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2023 17:29

He knew the wedding dress wasn’t coming from joint funds. Where did he think it came from? The fairies brought it in the night?

Huh? She's only a woman, so therefore she must have no money at all? Her only options are night fairies or a man clothing her from head to toe out of his own pocket? What century are we in again?

She earns a good wage, she had a 10k inheritance from her parents... Based on his knowledge of these things, maybe she just struggled to say to him "actually I spent all my inheritance on clearing 10k debt, and I still have more debt, so I need you to pay for my dress".

Or maybe she thought that the dress that caught her eye cost more than he'd like (which I know you're going to twist this into him being a monster again lol), so bought it on credit. Tbh it sounds a tiny bit like she deals with differences by avoidance/deceit/lies of omission (not a reflection of character most definitely, but not a healthy way of learnt behaviour).

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 16/07/2023 17:42

Doesn't the fact that they were getting married and she had to put her own wedding dress on a credit card sound alarms to you? It does to me. I think it's sad that she had to resort to that.

I have never, ever heard of anyone other than the bride or bride's parents paying for the wedding dress. Is it a thing now that the groom contributes to the cost?

I agree venue, meal, photographer etc should all be shared expenses, but the choice of wedding dress is such a personal thing. Does the groom also go along to help choose it?

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 17:42

🤷‍♀️

JenWillsiam · 16/07/2023 17:40

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 17:37

And that fair enough. But the fact is you do think everyone lies for a reason and you do think it's his ffault.

No that isn’t what it means.

redskytwonight · 16/07/2023 17:37

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2023 17:29

He knew the wedding dress wasn’t coming from joint funds. Where did he think it came from? The fairies brought it in the night?

We also don't know who paid for the rest of the wedding costs. If that was DH it would probably have been quite reasonable for her to pay for the dress.
And wedding dresses can cost as much or as little as you like. OP knew she was putting it on a credit card -she could have chosen to spend less.

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 17:37

JenWillsiam · 16/07/2023 17:31

I don’t agree. You can keep saying stuff but my position won’t change.

And that fair enough. But the fact is you do think everyone lies for a reason and you do think it's his ffault.

JenWillsiam · 16/07/2023 17:31

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 15:37

I agree with this. Her husband sounds very controlling and she seems afraid of him, financially at least. No, it's not right to hide something like this from your spouse. But I do understand why she did it. What is apparent is she doesn't feel she can confide in her own husband because of his rigid judgemental beliefs. And it's sad that she cannot confide in him.

Exactly this.

JenWillsiam · 16/07/2023 17:31

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 15:30

You are. You're blaming him. I know hes not a "victim" in that sense but it is victim blaming.

I don’t agree. You can keep saying stuff but my position won’t change.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 16/07/2023 17:30

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2023 17:29

He knew the wedding dress wasn’t coming from joint funds. Where did he think it came from? The fairies brought it in the night?

There are ways to pay for things other than credit card?

Own money, savings, parents paid for it, etc, etc, etc.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2023 17:29

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 17:26

No, because he had no idea of her /their finances.

He knew the wedding dress wasn’t coming from joint funds. Where did he think it came from? The fairies brought it in the night?

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 17:26

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 17:22

I was going to mention this but changed my mind. But I'll say it now. Doesn't the fact that they were getting married and she had to put her own wedding dress on a credit card sound alarms to you? It does to me. I think it's sad that she had to resort to that.

No, because he had no idea of her /their finances.

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 17:22

lilymani · 16/07/2023 17:05

I don't think he talks about how much he hates debt all the time. He's probably mentioned it a few times and that has fed into OP's anxiety.

I don't see a financially controlling man having no idea about how OP's personal finances work + paying the majority of the bills and mortgage.

It's also getting to the level of comedy to insinuate he's made up the mortgage renewal @BathroomOnTheRight. OP has clearly made a huge effort to keep her debt from him from Day 1, even before the wedding — and ON the wedding day, she was wearing a dress she'd got into further debt for! Safe to say she probably refused to be added to the mortgage and was happy to sign those forms.

Yes husband could just be that much of a MONSTER that she had to lie to him from day 1 — but I think the reality may be that OP may have "learned" from childhood that Love is Conditional. You have to be your partner's perfect mirror, otherwise he won't love you. Flaws will result in immediate rejection and abandonment (classic catastrophising). Even now, the only thing she has taken away from this thread is how to cover up further with a 0%.

My birth family and DH used to be quite judgey about a certain thing. Don't think they realised they were being judgey, disparaging remarks about this thing is a common thing to say in society. They'd only said it a few times but enough times for me to get paranoid. When one day I confessed I'd done / was related to this thing though, their reactions were 100% supportive though initially upset I'd not told them. People are different when abstract things relate to those they love.

I was going to mention this but changed my mind. But I'll say it now. Doesn't the fact that they were getting married and she had to put her own wedding dress on a credit card sound alarms to you? It does to me. I think it's sad that she had to resort to that.

LovelyIssues · 16/07/2023 17:14

Op it's sad to think he'll kick you out because of this. He is your husband, be honest with him. Yes debt isn't great but it could be a lot more! Just be honest so he can help you.

lilymani · 16/07/2023 17:05

I don't think he talks about how much he hates debt all the time. He's probably mentioned it a few times and that has fed into OP's anxiety.

I don't see a financially controlling man having no idea about how OP's personal finances work + paying the majority of the bills and mortgage.

It's also getting to the level of comedy to insinuate he's made up the mortgage renewal @BathroomOnTheRight. OP has clearly made a huge effort to keep her debt from him from Day 1, even before the wedding — and ON the wedding day, she was wearing a dress she'd got into further debt for! Safe to say she probably refused to be added to the mortgage and was happy to sign those forms.

Yes husband could just be that much of a MONSTER that she had to lie to him from day 1 — but I think the reality may be that OP may have "learned" from childhood that Love is Conditional. You have to be your partner's perfect mirror, otherwise he won't love you. Flaws will result in immediate rejection and abandonment (classic catastrophising). Even now, the only thing she has taken away from this thread is how to cover up further with a 0%.

My birth family and DH used to be quite judgey about a certain thing. Don't think they realised they were being judgey, disparaging remarks about this thing is a common thing to say in society. They'd only said it a few times but enough times for me to get paranoid. When one day I confessed I'd done / was related to this thing though, their reactions were 100% supportive though initially upset I'd not told them. People are different when abstract things relate to those they love.

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 17:03

Perplexed0 · 16/07/2023 16:46

BathroomOnTheRight · Today 16:28 I appreciate you trying empathise with the OP and others who find themselves in a similar position. It’s the deceit more than the actual debt I think people can’t get past. Agreed debt and how to pay it off - fine. Deceit in any form - bad. Trust is just too fundamental to a marriage and treating trust with complacency is likely a massive factor in divorce rates. Mismatched approaches to finances another big factor in divorce rates no doubt because money management is too important a foundation.

Thank you, and I do understand where you and others are coming from too. You're right, deceit in a marriage is never good.

Perplexed0 · 16/07/2023 16:46

BathroomOnTheRight · Today 16:28 I appreciate you trying empathise with the OP and others who find themselves in a similar position. It’s the deceit more than the actual debt I think people can’t get past. Agreed debt and how to pay it off - fine. Deceit in any form - bad. Trust is just too fundamental to a marriage and treating trust with complacency is likely a massive factor in divorce rates. Mismatched approaches to finances another big factor in divorce rates no doubt because money management is too important a foundation.

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 16:28

Perplexed0 · 16/07/2023 16:08

The man hating is strong on this thread. Poor DH - if only he knew about this thread and how people perceived him as being abusive for being a responsible adult with finances. Lots of projecting going on! To all those responding who are with the version of the DH they are projecting about on here - LTBs and stop projecting. IMO partners who hide their debt are immature and very dishonest - there is no need for any dishonesty in a marriage. It is child-like behaviour.

Spoken like someone who has never been in OP's situation. There is being responsible and sensible with money, yes. But there is also such a thing as taking it too far, to the extent that the OP can't even talk to her own husband. Being sensible and mature with money is a good thing. I don't deny that, neither I think would OP or anyone else. But her husband seems to come from privilege and doesn't even understand how 'people can get in to debt'. Many poor people are in debt. Some have to resort to things such as Higher Purchase. Unfortunately.

But regardless of the rights or wrongs of OP keeping this from him? His attitude is a bit extreme, even the OP says he's financially controlling. I feel some are not getting the nuance here, and are going straight for OP is wrong, no matter what. And the DH is good for being 'financially responsible'. But there is financially responsible, and taking it so far that they have a fear of any debt to the extent OP feels she has to lie. There is no nuance taken into consideration here. It's all OP = bad because she kept this from him. No much understand of why.

BadNomad · 16/07/2023 16:17

He's hardly abusive and controlling when he's trying to put her name on the house and not forcing her to hand over all her money. It's the OP who seems to lack control - £4k debt with nothing to show for it nor any awareness of how she's spent it nor the sense to keep on top of it by transferring it to keep it on 0% interest. What a waste of money.

If he is controlling, he's pretty shit at it.

Diddlyumptious · 16/07/2023 16:09

I hope you find the courage to tell your DH. I wonder why he hates debt so much. If he was in debt previously hopefully he'll have more understanding towards you. Good luck.

Perplexed0 · 16/07/2023 16:08

The man hating is strong on this thread. Poor DH - if only he knew about this thread and how people perceived him as being abusive for being a responsible adult with finances. Lots of projecting going on! To all those responding who are with the version of the DH they are projecting about on here - LTBs and stop projecting. IMO partners who hide their debt are immature and very dishonest - there is no need for any dishonesty in a marriage. It is child-like behaviour.

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 16:04

The fact of the matter is, she is afraid of him financially and doesn't feel able to confide in him. That's what stands out.

WildUnchartedWaters · 16/07/2023 16:00

redskytwonight · 16/07/2023 15:49

Their child is 1.
They have been married for 2 years.

Last time the mortgage was up for renewal would have been before marriage or child. OP doesn't say how long they've been together, but it's quite likely that this was at a comparatively early stage of the relationship, when not giving an unmarried partner a claim in an asset that you have been paying into for many years before you met, would be absolutely normal.

But do carry on with the trying to prove the man in the wrong, that I know is normal on these threads.

This @

BathroomOnTheRight · 16/07/2023 15:58

xsquared · 16/07/2023 15:53

Did you read the sentence before and after the one you quoted? Here it is:

He said the only reason he’s putting me on the mortgage is if he dies, they can’t just kick me out of the house. The last time it was up for renewal I had to sign a form to state I had no claim over the house. He didn’t want me to have to sign another one of those.

He doesn't want her or their child to be homeless and doesn't want her to say that she has no claim. The opposite of what you were trying to insinuate.

Honestly, I really hate this term, but it is the op who has committed "financial infidelity" yet one or two posters are trying to make out it is the husband who is being abusive. Hating debt and being careful with money doesn't make him controlling and abusive.

But he was complete fine leaving her homeless and possibly their child, before. Only now, he's changed his mind. We don't know how often the mortgage 'renewal' comes up. I've never heard of such a thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread