Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If a couple say “your presence is our present”…

212 replies

transylvanianfamilies · 14/07/2023 19:20

…and it’s a wedding abroad (only Ireland and one of couple is Irish) after a hen abroad then you still get them a gift or bung them some cash?

DH says no. I think £50 and/or bottle of nice champagne. I couldn’t turn up to a wedding empty handed.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 15/07/2023 23:05

Belltentdreamer · 15/07/2023 21:01

Well let’s agree to disagree. I would never turn up empty handed to somewhere - it’s just not in my nature I guess. If I knew people didn’t drink maybe I’d bring a nice soft drink or 0% beer.
I guess I am part of a a social group that likes a drink and we all are lucky enough that a bottle or bringing a few bits is a purchase we wouldn’t need to think about financially. Plus I enjoy giving my host something nice 🤷‍♀️

I would never turn up empty handed to somewhere - it’s just not in my nature I guess.

Even if the host told you not to?

cloudsintheceiling · 15/07/2023 23:04

I wouldn't give them anything, and if they didn't like it then they shouldn't have said what they said. But that's my literal minded neurodivergence talking.

Moredramathanrazzamatazz · 15/07/2023 23:01

I would never turn up empty handed to somewhere - it’s just not in my nature I guess.

That's because you like performative gift-giving which is for yourself and not for the host or recipient. If you are asked not to do something, try not doing it!

Moredramathanrazzamatazz · 15/07/2023 22:48

*environmental reasons

Moredramathanrazzamatazz · 15/07/2023 22:46

They don't want presents. It's actually rude to get them a present because they have indicated they don't want one.

If you still absolutely must, then make it money or vouchers. Or a charity donation in their name (although not everyone likes this but if you go with something mainstream or something you can tell would suit their interests, they will be polite and not criticise it I am sure).

Do you even know that they drink, and like champagne? Even if they do, everyone gives them a bulky unsolicited gift, how on earth will they get it home?

Last time someone bought me unsolicited champagne, it ended up as a raffle prize at the local school.

They know you'll have spent money to get to Ireland, and many people don't want lots of presents for logistical or environmental presents. If they were amenable to presents they would've said so or indicated that if people really must, there's a list or an account or travel vouchers could be used if received (stating the company).

Belltentdreamer · 15/07/2023 21:01

redskytwonight · 15/07/2023 19:00

Like I say, I must have unusual friends ... I'm not talking about formal dinner parties, I'm just talking about going round to a friend's for a casual dinner. A lot of my friends don't drink, or will be driving. The host (unless they've asked otherwise) provides the drink (no expectation that it will be alcoholic). We roughly split the hosting so it evens out. We did all used to take a bottle but as we never drank them and ended up taking them home again, we stopped the practice.
I think it's more odd that you'd go round to a friend'shouse and always feel obliged to take something.

Well let’s agree to disagree. I would never turn up empty handed to somewhere - it’s just not in my nature I guess. If I knew people didn’t drink maybe I’d bring a nice soft drink or 0% beer.
I guess I am part of a a social group that likes a drink and we all are lucky enough that a bottle or bringing a few bits is a purchase we wouldn’t need to think about financially. Plus I enjoy giving my host something nice 🤷‍♀️

Wheredoistart78 · 15/07/2023 20:48

I got married in Jamaica and didn't want any presents as people were paying to travel.

Summerscoming23 · 15/07/2023 20:42

SoShallINever · 14/07/2023 19:38

Well I never! Are you sure they are actually Irish?
All the Irish weddings I've been to have been at least £200 minimum gift.

This exactly. All irish people will.show up with at least 200 in a card,more depending on the venue.

Useruser0912 · 15/07/2023 20:38

Radyward · 15/07/2023 20:05

What happens is people forgo holidays. My cousin isint going on hols this year as She has 3 weddings to go to. weddings are crazy expensive in Ireland- usually held in Hotel- 3-4 courses- there might be a round of drinks paid by the B and G or parents of B and G for the whole crowd . They are mostly a 2 day affair. ie a bbq or music in the pub the next day. People might stay over in hotel- if its a group of friends you wouldnt really wear the same outfit to multiple weddings. The biggest local wedding I heard of lately was 500 attendees- they dancefloor was packed!!! thats a crazy number for ireland.

This wouldn't help me either as I can't afford holidays 😂 I definitely wouldn't fit in Ireland! It sounds lovely though if you can afford it I would love to attend a wedding like that and have a big social circle lots of parties etc.

Badbudgeter · 15/07/2023 20:36

It means they want cash 💰

Confusion101 · 15/07/2023 20:35

@Radyward that is exactly what I had to do this year. No holiday in place of a lot of weddings. The cards were nearly the cheapest part of each of them! 😂

I agree with someone who said if they expected something, they would not have written this on the invite!

WillyLows · 15/07/2023 20:17

@HawdMeBack

*Yes we did.

I find these replies very weird! I'd be honoured if someone asked me to be such an integral part of their big day. The way folk are going on is as if the people invited are doing the bride and groom a favour! If that's how they feel they should refuse, not begrudging accept. *

There was no expectation for the wedding party to spend ANY money, other than on their holiday. That was their choice. EVERYTHING else was paid for for them. I don't think expecting a card is a big ask.
*
It's not the same as a holiday if someone else chooses where, when and who you go with!

It's not a treat to get something you might never want to wear again or even like!

The level of entitlement is nuts!

On this basis, if I was ever to get married again and someone had done all this for my wedding, absolutely no way would I expect a gift on top.

WillyLows · 15/07/2023 20:15

@HawdMeBack

*Yes we did.

I find these replies very weird! I'd be honoured if someone asked me to be such an integral part of their big day. The way folk are going on is as if the people invited are doing the bride and groom a favour! If that's how they feel they should refuse, not begrudging accept. *

*There was no expectation for the wedding party to spend ANY money, other than on their holiday. That was their choice. EVERYTHING else was paid for for them. I don't think expecting a card is a big ask.
*
It's not the same as a holiday if someone else chooses where, when and who you go with!

It's not a treat to get something you might never want to wear again or even like!

The level of entitlement is nuts!

On this basis, if I was ever to get married again and someone had done all this for my wedding, absolutely no way would I expect a gift on top.

LolaSmiles · 15/07/2023 20:09

Yes most people bring a bottle when they visit a friend for a meal they’ve cooked for them, I mean come on! I wouldn’t turn someone away if they didn’t but genuinely don’t know anyone who world turn up empty handed.
Maybe in your circle and you've all got money to burn in a circle of obligatory wine/chocolates/flowers giving, but many friendships don't work like that.

The way me and my friends work is that we all host each other and everything evens out. An extra £10-20 per social occasion adds up.

I'd rather see my friends than have them either decline because they haven't got the MN-obligatory bottle of wine, or feel awkward and uncomfortable that everyone else is trading obligation wine they don't.
It wouldn't surprise me if some of these obligation bottles of wine go from mumsnetters house to mumsnetters house because nobody wants to risk saying "isn't it silly everyone spending an extra £10/20 each time we meet up to pass some sort of test"

redskytwonight phoenixrosehere your friends sound like mine.

Radyward · 15/07/2023 20:05

What happens is people forgo holidays. My cousin isint going on hols this year as She has 3 weddings to go to. weddings are crazy expensive in Ireland- usually held in Hotel- 3-4 courses- there might be a round of drinks paid by the B and G or parents of B and G for the whole crowd . They are mostly a 2 day affair. ie a bbq or music in the pub the next day. People might stay over in hotel- if its a group of friends you wouldnt really wear the same outfit to multiple weddings. The biggest local wedding I heard of lately was 500 attendees- they dancefloor was packed!!! thats a crazy number for ireland.

Useruser0912 · 15/07/2023 19:23

What happens if your are invited to an Irish wedding and can't afford to gift £200? There is no way I could ever afford to give that as a gift to someone. Even £50 as a gift would be a really expensive to me (luckily I have a small family and not many friends so haven't been to a wedding for years!). I guess I would have to decline the invite in this situation? As someone also mentioned you'd be considered a cheeky fucker to give a £50 gift. £200 is a lot of money to me I can't imagine having to give that to a close friend never mind a colleague etc.

phoenixrosehere · 15/07/2023 19:22

Belltentdreamer · 15/07/2023 18:54

Yes most people bring a bottle when they visit a friend for a meal they’ve cooked for them, I mean come on! I wouldn’t turn someone away if they didn’t but genuinely don’t know anyone who world turn up empty handed.

And many of us don’t nor expect people to. We’ve had friends and family over and never expected them to bring anything with them and have declined when asked.

People usually ask and we decline. Not had anyone bring anything for a meal despite this. Saying that, most people we know drive to us and aren’t going to drink because of it.

redskytwonight · 15/07/2023 19:00

Belltentdreamer · 15/07/2023 18:54

Yes most people bring a bottle when they visit a friend for a meal they’ve cooked for them, I mean come on! I wouldn’t turn someone away if they didn’t but genuinely don’t know anyone who world turn up empty handed.

Like I say, I must have unusual friends ... I'm not talking about formal dinner parties, I'm just talking about going round to a friend's for a casual dinner. A lot of my friends don't drink, or will be driving. The host (unless they've asked otherwise) provides the drink (no expectation that it will be alcoholic). We roughly split the hosting so it evens out. We did all used to take a bottle but as we never drank them and ended up taking them home again, we stopped the practice.
I think it's more odd that you'd go round to a friend'shouse and always feel obliged to take something.

Belltentdreamer · 15/07/2023 18:54

LolaSmiles · 15/07/2023 14:10

Also mentioned on here is when you're invited to dinner and the host says "please don't bring anything". Maybe I have unusual friends but when one of my friends says that, they mean it. It they wanted you to bring a bottle they would equally state this.

Politeness and etiquette should be all about making people feel welcome and at ease. That means making sure your guests understand what is expected of them. Not about forcing them to analyse your communications and try to work out the unwritten subtext.
Totally agree with this. It's about making people feel at ease, or should be. But then sometimes I read things on here and think a lot of posters actively look for situations to prove they're so much better at hosting/being a guest in a bizarre way.

If I invite my friends round, it's because I want to see them. I'd hate for them to feel obligated to bring me a bunch of flowers and chocolate just because I've invited them for lunch. My hospitality is genuine and with no strings attached.

Do people seriously have so much money to burn that they get into an endless cycle of spending money on wine/flowers/chocolate whenever they go to a friend's house?

Yes most people bring a bottle when they visit a friend for a meal they’ve cooked for them, I mean come on! I wouldn’t turn someone away if they didn’t but genuinely don’t know anyone who world turn up empty handed.

HawdMeBack · 15/07/2023 14:44

WillyLows · 15/07/2023 09:49

@HawdMeBack

Did you choose his wedding outfit to fit in with your taste and theme? If so, that doesn't count as a bonus for him.

The amount people are expected to spend because someone else chooses to get married now is absolutely nuts.

Yes we did.

I find these replies very weird! I'd be honoured if someone asked me to be such an integral part of their big day. The way folk are going on is as if the people invited are doing the bride and groom a favour! If that's how they feel they should refuse, not begrudging accept.

There was no expectation for the wedding party to spend ANY money, other than on their holiday. That was their choice. EVERYTHING else was paid for for them. I don't think expecting a card is a big ask.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2023 14:40

Gwenhwyfar · 15/07/2023 08:44

OMG a cheque in 2023 that they have to go into town and find a bank branch still open to put it in their accounts. What a hassle.

I can credit a cheque on my phone.

The charity donation route is the best one.

HawdMeBack · 15/07/2023 14:37

Poned · 15/07/2023 08:24

If you expect guests to spend money on an indulgent hen/stag and wedding abroad, you should not expect gifts off anyone. Especially if you asked for none 🤯

We didn't 'expect' anyone to do anything. They were invited and chose to accept the invitation. There was no obligation. I don't see how attending an event then means you can't/shouldn't write a card?! 'Thanks for including me in your special day', 'congratulations, wishing you every happiness'. Strange!

LolaSmiles · 15/07/2023 14:10

Also mentioned on here is when you're invited to dinner and the host says "please don't bring anything". Maybe I have unusual friends but when one of my friends says that, they mean it. It they wanted you to bring a bottle they would equally state this.

Politeness and etiquette should be all about making people feel welcome and at ease. That means making sure your guests understand what is expected of them. Not about forcing them to analyse your communications and try to work out the unwritten subtext.
Totally agree with this. It's about making people feel at ease, or should be. But then sometimes I read things on here and think a lot of posters actively look for situations to prove they're so much better at hosting/being a guest in a bizarre way.

If I invite my friends round, it's because I want to see them. I'd hate for them to feel obligated to bring me a bunch of flowers and chocolate just because I've invited them for lunch. My hospitality is genuine and with no strings attached.

Do people seriously have so much money to burn that they get into an endless cycle of spending money on wine/flowers/chocolate whenever they go to a friend's house?

Teder · 15/07/2023 12:37

Getoutofherenow · 14/07/2023 22:39

It's not just what the bride and groom expect - it's what the parents of the couple expect too - what they have given to other's kids. Give a small wedding gift and that will stand out and be remembered for years (or at least that's the fear)

I’d have to decline all weddings. Imagine being judged for having the audacity for being low income?!
I’m not talking about multi millionaires turning up empty handed without even a card but average working people who genuinely don’t have the cash.

redskytwonight · 15/07/2023 11:23

I think this thread shows that it's a real shame that some vague notions of "politeness" and the "done thing" mean that friends can't tell friends exactly what they mean and be believed.

We said we didn't want wedding presents. We meant it. Some people gave us cash or vouchers. Some people gave us actual presents which are virtually all still in a box in the loft 20 years later because we genuinely didn't want them, have no use for them, but didn't quite like to throw out something someone had given us as a wedding present.
Other friends have said "we already have everything I need and have no room for anything else in our small flat; if you did feel you really wanted to give us anything we'd be happy to have a contribution to our honeymoon fund or a donation to x charity which is important to us for xyz reason". They still got presents.

Also mentioned on here is when you're invited to dinner and the host says "please don't bring anything". Maybe I have unusual friends but when one of my friends says that, they mean it. It they wanted you to bring a bottle they would equally state this.

Politeness and etiquette should be all about making people feel welcome and at ease. That means making sure your guests understand what is expected of them. Not about forcing them to analyse your communications and try to work out the unwritten subtext.

Swipe left for the next trending thread