Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at my mother changing her mind

35 replies

TuckingFypos · 14/07/2023 17:08

To give some background, my mother was a single parent to me and we struggled financially as I was growing up - she has never been used to having money, so she’s very good at saving / making what she has go as far as it can.

I inherited her thriftiness to an extent, but have never been well-off myself. I’m early 40s and in a long term relationship - we’ve always rented in the South East and have spent the last 12 years saving whatever we can for a house deposit, but still have nowhere near enough to buy, particularly at our age and in the area we live and work.

Mum came into a considerable amount of money a year ago. She very generously offered to gift us a lump sum to add to our deposit, which for the first time gave us a real opportunity to buy a house. We discussed it over a few weeks, as I wanted to make sure she was happy to gift the money - I couldn’t take it from her if she had any reservations, or if she thought she might need it in future. She was insistent that we use the money as, in her words, ‘it’s going to be yours in the end anyway’. She said what she had left would be more than enough to carry her through retirement.

We’ve spent the last year watching the market, getting mortgage in principles, having viewings. With house prices and interest rates rocketing, we decided to cool it for a while - even though the market is as it is, we still thought we could wait until 2024 / 2025 when house prices have fallen.

In the last few weeks, Mum’s now decided that she won’t have enough for her retirement and that she feels uncomfortable giving us the money because she doesn’t know if she’ll need it or not, with the economy being as it is and prices shooting up all over the place.

I know it’s her money, her security and her retirement and I have no right to be upset, but after a wonderful year of opportunities opening, I feel utterly deflated. I’m a very pragmatic person and don’t generally get caught up in dreams, but we’ve been so excited about potentially owning our own house, how we’ll decorate it, having a driveway, having a garden etc etc. I know this was the only chance we’ll get, as we won’t have the opportunity to have that much capital again.

AIBU? I think I am, it feels like I'm being a spoiled child. It also feels like I've had the dream of 15 years dangled like a carrot and then snatched away 😟

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HanSB · 15/07/2023 00:19

The situation has changed, a lot has happened in the past year to make people fearful of their financial circumstances. You decided that it was not a good idea to buy a house right now because of the economy. She has also decided that with all costs rising maybe she cannot afford this gift she intended anymore too. I think it is valid to feel upset because you had already budgeted this in your mind but at the end of the day it was not given a year ago and used for the purpose intended at that time.

Codlingmoths · 15/07/2023 00:03

I hope she’s pretty sympathetic to your disappointment.

Threenow · 14/07/2023 23:48

I agree that neither is wrong here. I can understand you are very disappointed, but can also see your mum's point of view as none of us really know what is going to happen economically. I never expect anything until it actually happens - lessens the disappointment somewhat.

Hazel444 · 14/07/2023 22:56

It's a real shame, but why didn't she give you the money straight away rather than leaving you dangling for a year - do you think she ever really intended to give it to you?

moderndilemma · 14/07/2023 22:23

You must be so disappointed Flowers

I'm sort of on the other side of the discussion. dh and I are retired and had for many years discussed how we could support our dc DURING their lives rather than just leaving them money at the end. After a couple of years of living on our (healthy) retirement income we decided we had enough to maximise the allowable tax-efficient financial gifts (£3k per year each). We know how much difference this would have made to our lives during the difficult and financially stretching years of child raising.

We made a commitment to our dc to do this for 5 years.

Of course we have now been hit with CoL increases and a potential 22% increase in our council tax next year. A holiday we'd booked for next year has increased by £700 each and we've decided to cancel it. Potential house alterations that would give us downstairs accommodation suitable for the very, very long term have risen in price beyond anything that is even possible to consider. And my dh's parents have both moved into a care home (funded through all their life-time savings and the sale of their house). It is eye-wateringly expensive, and we know that there will be no possibility of an inheritance.

In all honesty, if we'd had a crystal ball and known all of this we probably wouldn't have made the commitment that we did. But we did. And we will honour it. We know that our dc are hit more acutely by the CoL increases than we are.

Tourmalines · 14/07/2023 21:41

No, you’re not being unreasonable. Although she never owed it to you , she offered you and convinced you she had enough for her future. To do a complete 180 is a kick in the teeth for you . Not much you can do . Life is full of ups and downs unfortunately.

PrinceHaz · 14/07/2023 19:31

I think the very definite offer followed by the very definite withdrawal of the offer doesn’t put her in a good light but as you know, there’s nothing you can do about it.
It would have better if she’d just given you a smaller lump sum in the first place.

determinedtomakethiswork · 14/07/2023 19:26

I think she's being a bit shortsighted because you could end up moving quite a distance away in order to buy and that isn't going to be to her advantage as she gets older. I can understand that she got overexcited and thought she could dole money out right left and centre, but it was very unfair of her to mention that to you until she was absolutely certain about it. On the other hand if she had given it and later said she regretted it, you would feel really awful.

ssd · 14/07/2023 18:46

Well i think its rotten of her.
I'm sorry op.

stayclosetoyourself · 14/07/2023 18:25

Could you buy together?

WallaceinAnderland · 14/07/2023 18:19

When I bought my first house it didn't have a driveway or a garden. Maybe lower your expectations and try to find a house you can afford within your own means.

TuckingFypos · 14/07/2023 18:01

LovedmyRaleighChopper · 14/07/2023 17:19

I suppose coming into money as a person with none must’ve felt like winning the lottery to her. They always say don’t make big plans immediately, wait a while. Your dithering/extended planning has forced her to do that and sadly for you reality has struck and caution is now the order of her day. Bad luck, it must be intensely disappointing but you already said you didn’t want her to do it if she had doubts. If you are an only child you do stand a chance of ending up with it one day but honestly having a healthy and loving mother is much better than having an inheritance. Try to focus on that.

This is a very good point, thank you. I guess when you suddenly get a lot of money, you want to share with nearest and dearest (and yes, I'm an only child). It was less dithering on my part, but the market forcing me to wait.

Reflecting on all the answers, I know it's for the best. If she'd have needed the money and it was tied up in equity, that would have been far worse.

OP posts:
Jongleterre · 14/07/2023 18:00

Is there the possibility of buying together a house with a granny annexe?

wutheringkites · 14/07/2023 17:56

If she rents then I can understand why she's worried.

I understand your disappointment too op.

For what it's worth, we moved to a different city to buy and it was the best decision we ever made.

Blottingpaperscript · 14/07/2023 17:54

I don't think you are wrong to feel disappointed and rather hurt. Yes things have changed in the wider financial world but your mother really ought to have considered all circumstances before offering to help and getting your hopes up. We had similar happen to us (bought independently in the end) and it was crushingly disappointing, especially as we were left to believe it would happen for a year. I know people have a right to change their minds, but something as big as a house purchase isn't something to make offers of help about unless you are really sure. Nothing you can do OP but you have my sympathies.

Twiglets1 · 14/07/2023 17:50

Your disappointment is normal, absolutely.

TuckingFypos · 14/07/2023 17:47

Thanks everyone, it was less of an AIBU (I know I am and totally understand my mother’s decision), but it was more to vent and get some validation that the disappointment I’m feeling is normal!

@stayclosetoyourself She’s withdrawing the entire amount, and hasn’t offered a smaller one. I certainly don’t want to make her worry more about money than she already is, so I’m not asking for a different amount.

@fluffiphlox I have been 100% independent since the age of 18. I have relied on no-one for handouts, but was given a kind offer from a relative that would hugely benefit me. Appreciate the advice though, thanks 😂

@Champgal yes absolutely, I think I'm just disappointed that she didn't think it through before offering it to me

@CatStankShame I have a deposit. Just not a very big one. Lenders don’t ask for proof until application stage anyway.

@wutheringkites She's paying rent, she doesn't own a house. But all bills are covered by pensions and she has various investments. But I totally understand why she's nervous. Everything's in turmoil.

OP posts:
TempName247 · 14/07/2023 17:47

Can she loan it to you instead?

wutheringkites · 14/07/2023 17:45

If she doesn't have a mortgage and isn't paying rent, surely she is benefiting from the higher interest rates at the moment?

Fiddlerdragon · 14/07/2023 17:34

CatStankShame · 14/07/2023 17:32

How did you get the Mortgage In Principal without proof of at least some deposit?

It’s literally in the op that she has a deposit. Her mother was adding to it. Plus unless things have changed in the last 4 years since I had one, I didn’t need proof of a deposit, just earnings

EvilElsa · 14/07/2023 17:34

That's a shame. I can see both sides and I think she is probably being wise given the way things have being going. I can see why you are really disappointed though. Don't give up. Look at other options and schemes etc.

CatStankShame · 14/07/2023 17:32

How did you get the Mortgage In Principal without proof of at least some deposit?

stayclosetoyourself · 14/07/2023 17:29

As you get older you start to worry about cost of retirement.

Champgal · 14/07/2023 17:27

Im in a very similar position! My mum told me she was going to sell her house to move in with her fiancé and she wanted yo give me my nest egg early to put down deposit and now has decided he will move into the house with her. Its annoying because you wouldn't expect anything, but when someone offers so adamantly to help you out in a huge way and then changes their mind, it is really upsetting. I haven't mentioned this to my mother, im just taking what ever she says with a pinch of salt.

Parky04 · 14/07/2023 17:26

I wouldn't have started to look for houses until the money had been given!