Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my daughter is taking a crazy financial risk?

483 replies

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:42

Unfortunately my daughter has separated from her partner with a 2 year old. She saved to buy the house they both lived in and both paid half the mortgage after they got together. He is not making any claim on the house as it was a short lived relationship which is fortunate in the circumstances. He has however said he wants not part in my granddaughter’s life which has left my daughter deciding to go part time to four days a week which will obviously reduce her income drastically. I know she will be able to claim maintenance but we don’t know what that looks like and I wouldn’t like her to rely on that. Me and DH both think she now needs to move to find somewhere with lesser mortgage payments, daughter is saying 1,100 for a four bed house is a good deal and it would be pointless moving now. She’s never told us her finances before but I am shocked she is now left paying this, surely this is far too much to pay especially as a single parent? Am I unreasonable to encourage her to downsize and get somewhere which much lesser payments? Her current rate is fixed until 2027 but it is portable. I am very worried for her.

OP posts:
ASGIRC · 15/07/2023 19:22

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 17:16

If it weren’t for the economic climate I would agree with staying out of it but it is worrying in the circumstances

But exactly because of the economic climate, moving would be much more expensive.
1100 for a 4 bed is not outrageous. There are box rooms in London shared houses going for more!

How long since youve bought a house OP? cause even 20 years ago when my mom and step dad bought their flat, it cost them 250k, and it is now valued at over 1M. So I think you might just be out of touch with what houses cost and what mortgage payments are like.

StopStartStop · 15/07/2023 19:22

OP, it's natural to worry.
Has your dd never lived alone before? Is this her first time facing running the house without support of a partner? If I managed, she will.
You mustn't try to take over, even if you think you know best. Let her find her own way.

AmITooOldToDoThis · 15/07/2023 19:19

Struggling to work out what the fuff this has to do with you.

Againlosinghope · 15/07/2023 19:11

@daufhtercrusus

In 32k maintenance would be approx £315 a month

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 15/07/2023 19:08

Mind tour own business. She is confident she can do it and has not asked for your help so if you keep interfering you will ruin the relationship. Just be clear that you cannot financially support her if it goes wrong and leave it at that. She is an adult.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 15/07/2023 19:03

It just means she's going from full time to part time 4 days a week

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2023 19:02

Thank you for this thread @daufhtercrusus. It’s great entertainment. I’ll add another mind your own business.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 15/07/2023 18:50

She’s old enough to work out her own finances . She can always get a lodger.

jennyjones198080 · 15/07/2023 18:44

Vynalbob · 15/07/2023 18:25

I would consider asking if she should move but for an extra reason.....who's name is on the house/mortgage.....her and her ex relations could change when maintenance is brought up.
Self protection....but obviously if it's not an issue and she wants to stay it's her decision.

OP should not ask this. The house is in the daughters name - she bought it before the relationship began and he ex isn’t claiming any of it.

Unlike OP, her daughter seems to have her head screwed on

Mummabear89 · 15/07/2023 18:38

The estimated child maintenance calculation for £32,000 considering that he is not going to be having his child and doesn't have other children to support is £73.64 a week or £318.87 a month. If he gets any benefits such as UC then he'll only have to pay a flat rate of £7 a week though.

Vynalbob · 15/07/2023 18:25

I would consider asking if she should move but for an extra reason.....who's name is on the house/mortgage.....her and her ex relations could change when maintenance is brought up.
Self protection....but obviously if it's not an issue and she wants to stay it's her decision.

FarmGirl78 · 15/07/2023 16:14

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:51

I just hope she doesn’t turn to us to help meet the payments. She is saying that figure is reasonable nowadays for the size of the house etc and she wants to hold on to the asset… that’s all fine but at 1,100 a month it doesn’t strike me as realistic! If we had known that was the repayment when she bought the house we would have told her that was too much but sadly we weren’t informed at the time.

You interfering so much is probably the EXACT reason you were never given even the slightest whiff of how much her mortgage is. Its non of your business whatsoever.

I think it's a shame that now we've got to the crux of the matter your main concern that she might approach you for money. She's finding her feet as sole parent to a small child, she's living as the only adult in the house so no-one else to share mental load with, she might be feeling rejected, lonely and shit about her life currently, and now she's got you pushing her too. Leave her be. Perhaps focus on supporting her emotionally and keep your nose out of her financial circumstances. Such a shame your prime concern is how this might affect you.

Ps. £1,100 for 4 bedroomed detached is a great deal in current market.

saraclara · 15/07/2023 14:50

If she’s in a fix until 2027, downsizing right now probably isn’t an option.

Exactly! If she took out a mortgage now on a house two thirds of the price of the one she lives in, her mortgage payments will be higher than she's paying now! If she's on a fixed rate now, she'd be insane to move at this point. Quite apart from the estate agent fees, the stamp duty, the legal fees and the removal costs eating into any monies released by downsizing.

Seriously, it seems as though you don't have a clue about this stuff.

She bought this house before he moved in. Why do you feel any more stressed now than you did when she bought it on her own?

Moredramathanrazzamatazz · 15/07/2023 14:41

If she can afford it for the time being, and given it's not a good time to try to sell, she'll be better off staying put. Less disruptive for her and importantly, the kids. Encourage her to see a financial adviser in due course, well before 2027 but not yet. Assume she has done her sums with respect to maintenance (that may have been agreed - some men do pay the right amount without fuss), pay, and benefits. Just support her the way she is being asked to be supported for now and don't push.

TheSeaDoesntKnowMyName · 15/07/2023 14:05

redskytwonight · 15/07/2023 11:01

My DS is looking for a room to rent. As well as the local paper (which actually doens't exist any more in paper form) my parents suggested he should look at cards up in shop windows. I'm not sure DS even knew what they were talking about.

My dm is convinced she is an employment law expert as she once worked at an employment agency in 1955

Abitofalark · 15/07/2023 13:57

If you are really worried that she won't be able to manage, you could consider offering to have the child for one (or more, if you like) day a week so that she could have the option to stay working five days a week if she wanted and save on nursery fees into the bargain.
But maybe she wouldn't want that option. And maybe it wouldn't suit you either. It's just an idea that might be worth thinking about.

happysoul23 · 15/07/2023 13:29

Gosh rent on my 2 bed house is £1100.
I manage as a single parent, no maintenance and average wage as a nurse and UC too up.
It's tight but I make it work.

StripeyDeckchair · 15/07/2023 13:19

Her finances are non of your business - you need to keep your nose our of them.

£1100 pcm on a mortgage is on the low side
If she moved she'd have to find £20k or more for stamps duty, fees solicitors etc - that would be far better spent on her current mortgage.

It sounds to me that you are out of date on how much everything actually costs and over involved in her life.

Persipan · 15/07/2023 13:07

OP, look at it this way...

  • Moving is expensive - she'd likely be paying out thousands in costs to sell and buy somewhere cheaper
  • If you port your mortgage you'd have to pay early repayment charges on any drop in the loan amount, so that's more thousands.
  • Porting your mortgage generally triggers new affordability checks which she might not pass with childcare costs taken into account. So she might lose her current mortgage rate, which is presumably lower than rates on offer now - meaning moving to a cheaper property could well end in higher mortgage payments anyway

So even assuming she could sell, can you see how this isn't actually a financially sensible plan? She could easily shell out more than a year's worth of mortgage payments in fees and charges, only to end up paying more than she currently is for less house.

I get that monthly payments over £1000 seem high - they are high! It's not like everyone is excited to be paying that much! - but they're normal nowadays, and no amount of wanting them to be lower is going to make it a good idea to bin off a perfectly good house at vast expense just to have the same (or higher) mortgage anyway.

Clarinet1 · 15/07/2023 12:27

Dd sounds like a young woman who has her head screwed on to me.
At the very least there is no need to rush
into a decision to move. As PP have said there is always the option of a lodger although, to
those specifying female, remember that women have boyfriends, brothers, fathers, guys they pick up on a night out that they have never met
before so I’d lay down some clear ground rules.

CloverHilla · 15/07/2023 12:16

LakieLady · 15/07/2023 11:43

Me too!

I can just see the thread title now: "AIBU to think my DM is totally out of touch and is infantilising me?"

You put it much more succinctly than I did 🤣

CloverHilla · 15/07/2023 12:14

I'm so confused by at lot of what you're saying OP.

  1. She is moving from working 5 days a week to 4 days a week - I don't see that as a "drastic reduction" in her income.
  2. She bought the house on her own, so presumably earns enough to get the mortgage for it. She was paying this before her (short term) partner moved in, so can presumably pay it again.
  3. You don't actually know how much she earns, but assume it's not enough. She does know her own finances, and is happy to drop a day working.
  4. You say you'd never take out a mortgage of more than 500 in repayments, but as you have an adult daughter I would imagine your first mortgage was many years ago so you don't actually have a realistic idea of what mortgages are like these days.

I say, best of luck to her!! If you can't help her financially, be there for her emotionally and take your DGD on occasion to grow your bond with her and give your daughter a break.

blueshoes · 15/07/2023 11:58

OP, it sounds like you are out of touch with today's realities and out of your depth and lack the skills or finances to help your dd.

You are only worried for yourself having to bail your dd out. I think your dd has enough to worry about than about than soothing your concerns and explaining to you how her finances work in the present day so you can feel reassured.

I think you need to step out of this.

jennyjones198080 · 15/07/2023 11:46

LakieLady · 15/07/2023 11:43

Me too!

I can just see the thread title now: "AIBU to think my DM is totally out of touch and is infantilising me?"

Yea - the I earn over £Xxk a year and can easily afford my mortgage but my mum is guessing my salary on the internet and random strangers are talking about what benefits I can receive and how many rooms in my house I should rent out to other random strangers.

my mum seems to think I am
financially incompetent!!!

LakieLady · 15/07/2023 11:43

BravoMyDear · 14/07/2023 20:28

God, I would LOVE to hear the daughter’s side of this 🤣

Me too!

I can just see the thread title now: "AIBU to think my DM is totally out of touch and is infantilising me?"

Swipe left for the next trending thread