Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my daughter is taking a crazy financial risk?

483 replies

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:42

Unfortunately my daughter has separated from her partner with a 2 year old. She saved to buy the house they both lived in and both paid half the mortgage after they got together. He is not making any claim on the house as it was a short lived relationship which is fortunate in the circumstances. He has however said he wants not part in my granddaughter’s life which has left my daughter deciding to go part time to four days a week which will obviously reduce her income drastically. I know she will be able to claim maintenance but we don’t know what that looks like and I wouldn’t like her to rely on that. Me and DH both think she now needs to move to find somewhere with lesser mortgage payments, daughter is saying 1,100 for a four bed house is a good deal and it would be pointless moving now. She’s never told us her finances before but I am shocked she is now left paying this, surely this is far too much to pay especially as a single parent? Am I unreasonable to encourage her to downsize and get somewhere which much lesser payments? Her current rate is fixed until 2027 but it is portable. I am very worried for her.

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 16/07/2023 00:37

It's not easy to get a smaller mortgage in the current climate. She would likely end up paying a similar amount for a smaller property.

Grrrrdarling · 16/07/2023 00:26

Sakura7 · 16/07/2023 00:14

@Grrrrdarling

She already got the mortgage on her own and has been managing to pay it up to now. She clearly has a decent job.

Her repayments are affordable (or else the bank wouldn't have given her approval) and she's got a fixed rate until 2027.

How do you think giving up this house is going to save her money? Do you think solicitors, estate agents, movers, etc, come cheap?

None of it is cheap & no it wouldn’t but having a smaller mortgage could be more affordable in the long run.
If I could edit my original comment I would but I can’t.
Basically OP’s D’s home will not be counted as an asset when they calculate her UC claim, if she needs to make one. I was lead to believe otherwise from previous enquiries, before UC became a thing & from a friends experience of having to sell her property before she could claim UC!
I believe she can still claim the childcare element of UC without anything else, if her wage is over the threshold for basic support, but childcare isn’t something I have needed to claim so I only know it is paid in arrears & you have to cover the payment upfront each month yourself from friends who qualify for that help.

Sakura7 · 16/07/2023 00:14

@Grrrrdarling

She already got the mortgage on her own and has been managing to pay it up to now. She clearly has a decent job.

Her repayments are affordable (or else the bank wouldn't have given her approval) and she's got a fixed rate until 2027.

How do you think giving up this house is going to save her money? Do you think solicitors, estate agents, movers, etc, come cheap?

Grrrrdarling · 16/07/2023 00:13

DirectionToPerfection · 15/07/2023 23:39

@Grrrrdarling

Say what now?

This 'poor woman' was able to get the mortgage on her own and clearly has a good job. She doesn't need to rely on benefits and nobody can make her sell, what a ridiculous comment.

Just found information to the contrary of what I though benefits counted as assets when doing calculations for UC but sadly you can’t edit comments on here.

OP’s D may need to rely on benefits but it is upto OP’s D if she applies. She would be mad not to though because at the end of the day she, like the majority of us, pays into a system that should be available to us all when we need it.
Very few claiming benefits are doing so without contributing to that pot before they need to claim from it.

OP’s daughter’s home will NOT be counted as an asset when calculating her UC claim BUT she won’t be able to claim the housing element of UC to cover the mortgage. She will however be able to apply for an SMI loan (support for mortgage interest) from the DWP but interest is charged on that & it has to be paid back when the house is sold or passed to someone else.
As she can’t claim the housing element she will also be able to earn more each month, £631, before UC take 55p out of each £1 she earns over that amount.

FYI I actually have a friend who was forced to sell her home by UC before she could claim!
The house was her retirement pot as she planned to sell it once she retired & live off the profits.
I now know this was false information but she sold her house 2yrs ago now so I don’t know what comeback she could bring to the DWP’s doorstep for their forcing her to sell when her house wasn’t even countable towards her assets for the purpose of calculating her UC entitlement.
She used the profit from her home sale to buy a small 1bed flat, that will do her into & out of old age, so she now has no mortgage BUT she has had to live off the leftover cash from sale of her old house before she could claim UC.
She had to leave work due to ill health & despite trying to find work nothing is suitable with her illness & galloping old age is taking it’s toll.

I’ve passed link & info to OP in another comment so hopefully she can put her mind to rest & trust her DD knows what she is doing.
I am assuming her daughter has done her maths & knows she can keep the house because it would be madness to try & hold onto it if she couldn’t afford it long term.
Hard to let go of something if you really love it but it is just bricks & mortar. As long as OP’s DD & her child are happy, healthy & managing financially that is what matters.

pollymere · 16/07/2023 00:12

Around here £1000 a month would probably rent you a one bed flat. She is probably far better off in her house and can rent out rooms. It sounds like she has a decent enough wage to pay a mortgage and support a house anyway.

MumGMT · 15/07/2023 23:51

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:56

@Yfory yes exactly, we are worried she is not considering the running costs etc alone. Our energy bill last November was 300. I doubt it will be cheaper this year.

Why are you infantilizing her?
She saved to get the mortgage, she is obviously aware of the cost of bills etc.

To go back to your thread title.

AIBU To think my daughter is taking a crazy financial risk?

It's not like she's trying to take on the mortgage now, she already has it.

Grrrrdarling · 15/07/2023 23:47

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:42

Unfortunately my daughter has separated from her partner with a 2 year old. She saved to buy the house they both lived in and both paid half the mortgage after they got together. He is not making any claim on the house as it was a short lived relationship which is fortunate in the circumstances. He has however said he wants not part in my granddaughter’s life which has left my daughter deciding to go part time to four days a week which will obviously reduce her income drastically. I know she will be able to claim maintenance but we don’t know what that looks like and I wouldn’t like her to rely on that. Me and DH both think she now needs to move to find somewhere with lesser mortgage payments, daughter is saying 1,100 for a four bed house is a good deal and it would be pointless moving now. She’s never told us her finances before but I am shocked she is now left paying this, surely this is far too much to pay especially as a single parent? Am I unreasonable to encourage her to downsize and get somewhere which much lesser payments? Her current rate is fixed until 2027 but it is portable. I am very worried for her.

Without housing element the basic UC your daughter can claim will be about £638 a month & as she won’t be able to claim the housing element, it doesn’t cover mortgage payments, she can earn £631 a month before anything so taken off her UC. She can also claim for Childcare but that claim depends on what childcare she needs & she will have to cover those costs upfront each month as childcare element is paid in arrears.
She can apply for what is called SMI (Support for mortgage interest) but that is a loan from the DWP, interest is changed on it, & although it doesn’t have to be paid back immediately it will have to be paid back if the house is sold or passed to anyone else.
For UC it seems as though the house will jut be counted as capital though so having her own home will not be taken into account when calculating assets; which is good news. I always thought assets were all counted so learnt something new myself although I’ll never own my own home so it is irrelevant information for me.
What your daughter needs to do is make sure she can cover all her necessities & work out if keeping a 4 bed house with just 2 of them in it is worth it right now.
Hard to let go especially as it is her home BUT it is just bricks & mortar.
Be there for her, as much as you can, & hope everything works out for her ❤
Info can be found here…https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/universal-credit/on-universal-credit/check-how-much-universal-credit-youll-get/

Check how much Universal Credit you'll get

Work out how much Universal Credit you’ll get each month, including which elements you’re entitled to and how your income and savings affect your payment.

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/universal-credit/on-universal-credit/check-how-much-universal-credit-youll-get/

DirectionToPerfection · 15/07/2023 23:39

@Grrrrdarling

Say what now?

This 'poor woman' was able to get the mortgage on her own and clearly has a good job. She doesn't need to rely on benefits and nobody can make her sell, what a ridiculous comment.

Grrrrdarling · 15/07/2023 23:22

Herewego81 · 14/07/2023 16:51

She will be getting a lot in benefits op

see for yourself on the benefit calculators

She won’t get a lot in benefits at all as she will get nothing towards the house due to it being her own!
To be honest they will probably make her sell the house because it is a financial asset meaning benefits see it as she has ‘money’ above the £6000 you can have in assets/savings, before benefits are effected.
Basic benefits with housing element amounts to not much over £1200 a month so in that situation she would literally have £100 to live on after paying the mortgage but she won’t get the housing element as she has a mortgage & housing element will not pay for a mortgage🙁
Back in the day you could have the interest on your mortgage, or some of it, covered by housing benefit so you didn’t lose your home but no more. Now you have to take out a loan from benefits for help with mortgage but that has to be somehow paid back 😬
Sad fact is this poor woman is going to have to either work more hours, which will also limit what benefit support she can receive, to cover mortgage & outgoings or downsize. Downsizing sooner rather than later will save her £££ in the long run.

Inkyblue123 · 15/07/2023 23:05

As long as she’s not asking g you for money it’s not your business.

RunBetter · 15/07/2023 23:01

mellicauli · 15/07/2023 21:44

If she ported the mortgage all the Terms & Conditions of the contract are moved with it. So she would be paying the same monthly amount until 2027 to live in a 2 bedroom flat rather than a 4 bedroom house. What's the point in that?

And she'd also have all the costs associated with moving to pay for too (average cost £12,000, so another full year's mortgage but paid up front rather in monthly installments).

Her best bet is to wait until her current deal is up in 2027 and then review if she wants to downsize then.

If she's struggling at any point she can:-

  1. go interest only for a bit
  2. get a lodger in
  3. extend the term of the mortgage
  4. go back up to 5 days a week
  5. sell the house at that point
  6. go for a promotion or get a new job that pays more money or start a side hustle
  7. she can rent out the house and rent somewhere cheaper

Lots of options.

Maybe if you can't help her financially as you'd like to, maybe you could help her with childcare?

I was going to make a similar point about porting your mortgage. My understanding of porting is you’re simply moving your current mortgage to a new property. You can’t reduce the size of the loan without being charged early repayment fees, which could be substantial (my outstanding mortgage is £400k, fixed to 2027, and the ERC is about £40k.)

I think the net result would be you’d free up some cash (the difference between the sale price of your current property and the cost of the new one), but this may well be offset by stamp duty, legal fees, estimate agent fees etc, and the actual monthly mortgage would remain at £1,100.

Aside from this - is it possible your daughter isn’t actually taking a pay but at all but has negotiated a compressed hours arrangement with her employer, whereby she works an extra couple of hours each evening when DD is asleep and can take every [Friday] off?

She might also have reason to believe things could improve soon, either a promotion might be on the horizon or the free childcare hours kicking in.

I agree with others here though - it’s not really anything to do with you unless she asks for advice. My parents have no idea what I earn or what my monthly mortgage is.

CelestiaNoctis · 15/07/2023 22:50

She'll get universal credit top ups as a single household? And go through CMS to get maintenence. And will get more free hours of childcare. And also she could take on a WFH job on the side. It could work out and I'd wait and see how it goes. Single mums are usually pretty epic and resilient.

ActDottie · 15/07/2023 22:32

Just let her get on with it and trust her. Tbh you seem pretty overbearing.

Devora13 · 15/07/2023 22:03

I wonder why you don't trust her to manage her finances? Does she have a record for getting into financial difficulty, or is she usually sensible with money?

Gettingfleeced · 15/07/2023 21:59

£1100/mo for 4 bedrooms is a great deal! She has options too for using the house as an another income stream, eg. Renting out a bedroom as an office space/beautician room/physiotherapy massage space etc. Or could take in lodgers, or rent out the garage/carpark space if she is near a town/train station or somewhere where parking options are limited.

I think she sounds quite savvy.

Maybe ask her what her plans are for the house and gently suggest some options for her to consider.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 15/07/2023 21:55

Dibblydoodahdah · 15/07/2023 21:41

So wish OP would come back on this thread and tell us (1) when she bought her house; (2) how much she paid for it; (3) how much her monthly mortgage payments were and (4) how much she earned.

I would like to get the full picture of the OP’s finances to understand why she thinks her daughter is taking crazy financial risks.

There is no way OP is coming back. She's probably namechanged now!

jennyjones198080 · 15/07/2023 21:51

CrazyLadie · 15/07/2023 21:46

No way she is only earning £40k per annum and gettinga mortgage with that kind of repayment, a mortgage lender would not approve that

They would.

CrazyLadie · 15/07/2023 21:46

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:55

@NewmummyJ we are not sure, we think around 40,000.

No way she is only earning £40k per annum and gettinga mortgage with that kind of repayment, a mortgage lender would not approve that

mellicauli · 15/07/2023 21:44

If she ported the mortgage all the Terms & Conditions of the contract are moved with it. So she would be paying the same monthly amount until 2027 to live in a 2 bedroom flat rather than a 4 bedroom house. What's the point in that?

And she'd also have all the costs associated with moving to pay for too (average cost £12,000, so another full year's mortgage but paid up front rather in monthly installments).

Her best bet is to wait until her current deal is up in 2027 and then review if she wants to downsize then.

If she's struggling at any point she can:-

  1. go interest only for a bit
  2. get a lodger in
  3. extend the term of the mortgage
  4. go back up to 5 days a week
  5. sell the house at that point
  6. go for a promotion or get a new job that pays more money or start a side hustle
  7. she can rent out the house and rent somewhere cheaper

Lots of options.

Maybe if you can't help her financially as you'd like to, maybe you could help her with childcare?

CrazyLadie · 15/07/2023 21:43

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:51

I just hope she doesn’t turn to us to help meet the payments. She is saying that figure is reasonable nowadays for the size of the house etc and she wants to hold on to the asset… that’s all fine but at 1,100 a month it doesn’t strike me as realistic! If we had known that was the repayment when she bought the house we would have told her that was too much but sadly we weren’t informed at the time.

I'm a single parent and bought a house last year, it's approximately the same and your daughter got more house for her buck than I did. If she relapses she can't afford it long term she will make changes when required. She is a big girl and you have to leave her to live her life her way

Dibblydoodahdah · 15/07/2023 21:41

So wish OP would come back on this thread and tell us (1) when she bought her house; (2) how much she paid for it; (3) how much her monthly mortgage payments were and (4) how much she earned.

I would like to get the full picture of the OP’s finances to understand why she thinks her daughter is taking crazy financial risks.

Keeper11 · 15/07/2023 21:27

Your daughter has a fixed rate mortgage of £1100, until 2027.
if she was to downsize she would have to get another mortgage and now rates have escalated, it is quite likely her payments would not be much less for a much cheaper house.
in 2027 your granddaughter will be at school, so no childcare costs. I think your daughter is being very sensible, and I think you are offering poor advice.
You do not know the whole financial position, you do not mention any career progression plans she may have, you don’t really know how much she earns, or what other job related benefits she may have. You don’t know how much maintenance she may receive, or what state benefits she may be entitled to.
So coming from a standpoint of pretty much total ignorance of the situation, you are advising your daughter to sell her home!
YABU and I hope your daughter ignores your advice.

saraclara · 15/07/2023 21:11

Downsizing is rarely the answer that people think it is.

I've been looking at downsizing in order to help my kids with their own houses. But it was soon evident that unless I was going to down size majorly, at great cost to my qiuality of life, I wasn't going to free any significant amount at all.

I have a (not big) four bedroom (all doubles) house with two receptions, a reasonable sized kitchen and a down stairs cloakroom. Next door is a three bedroomed (one a bit of a box room) house, one lounge/diner, a much smaller kitchen and no downstairs toilet. Both houses detached and with the same sized gardens.

I worked out that after expenses, if I sold my house and bought next door, I would actually lose money, not gain it. I was astonished. There was far less differenc in our house values than I imagined.

Rachpen · 15/07/2023 21:08

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 17:01

I think we are just shocked at the repayments. DH and I would never have contemplated more than 500 a month so we were surprised to learn it was over a thousand.

Of course not, you were able to buy a house when the costs were lower and in any case your earnings and financial decision making is totally irrelevant. You admitted you don’t know what she earns and clearly the bank thought she could afford it otherwise they wouldn’t have granted the mortgage. Keep your nose out. She’s an adult. Frankly- I agree with her that it would be stupid to lose the asset and drop a load of cash on solicitors and taxes. I would welcome my mother asking if I was sure it was affordable but if she pryed into my finances I’d tell her it was private. You then have the opportunity to say you are concerned and you won’t be able to help if she needs it so she is aware of your position. In any case if you are correct and her salary is 40k she will take home around 2600 per month. 1100 doesn’t seem out of the question especially if her childcare free hours kick in and she gets maintenance. with the savings of £550 per month when he was contributing directly then maybe she’s built up a bit of contingency.

Psychonabike · 15/07/2023 21:04

@daufhtercrusus

I get that you are concerned but you are at risk of giving your daughter some seriously terrible advice right now.

  1. Moving house is often unexpectedly expensive in itself so the majority of people would be better off making adjustments in their finances and mortgage type, unless there is going to be big change in monthly mortgage cost.
  2. You seem to be out of touch with the cost of housing as a proportion of income these days, comparing your past mortgage with her current figure.
  3. Her child is 2...childcare costs/changing working hours likely to be short-term. Perhaps she has a short term plan to get through this stage before increasing her hours again in a couple of years?
  4. Short term options include short mortgage holidays or going interest only for a while...both might be better in the long term than moving.
  5. You have no idea what she earns. You are guessing 40k but perhaps this guess is as out of touch as your idea of a typical mortgage?

I think if you stop giving alarmist, out of touch and non-fact based "advice" you might find that she is more willing to have a constructive conversation with you about how she actually plans to adjust to her new circumstances. But if you find that she's still evasive and unwilling to discuss detail it might not be that she is hiding a problem; it might be that you are so out of touch she has dismissed the value of engaging in discussion with you about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread