Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my daughter is taking a crazy financial risk?

483 replies

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 16:42

Unfortunately my daughter has separated from her partner with a 2 year old. She saved to buy the house they both lived in and both paid half the mortgage after they got together. He is not making any claim on the house as it was a short lived relationship which is fortunate in the circumstances. He has however said he wants not part in my granddaughter’s life which has left my daughter deciding to go part time to four days a week which will obviously reduce her income drastically. I know she will be able to claim maintenance but we don’t know what that looks like and I wouldn’t like her to rely on that. Me and DH both think she now needs to move to find somewhere with lesser mortgage payments, daughter is saying 1,100 for a four bed house is a good deal and it would be pointless moving now. She’s never told us her finances before but I am shocked she is now left paying this, surely this is far too much to pay especially as a single parent? Am I unreasonable to encourage her to downsize and get somewhere which much lesser payments? Her current rate is fixed until 2027 but it is portable. I am very worried for her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
evian76 · 24/07/2023 11:29

You do not sound hugely supportive. It sounds as if your daughter is extremely capable! I would realign your approach to think about how you can positively support your daughter and your grandchild. Fine that you can’t help at all financially but time is money, if she pays for childcare, could you provide one or two days of childcare to offset her costs? It would be lovely for your grandchild too at a time of transition. My advice would be to see your daughter as the successful woman she is and step up to support her in a positive way.

Tiqtaq · 17/07/2023 16:57

Kindly OP, this is your daughter's decision. Leave it to her.

If she asks you for money in the future address that at the time. Don't be worrying now as it is simply not your place and will damage your relationship with your daughter. It's OK to tell her now that whilst you would like to be in a position to help her financially in the future should she need it, you will be unable to afford it and that she should take this into consideration when making her decisions.

Then respect and support her decisions.

Helen483 · 17/07/2023 16:11

Yes, yabu. Going from 5 days to 4 is not a drastic reduction in her income. If she is a basic rate taxpayer then she will save all the tax she would have paid on it. If she falls below the threshold to claim UC, then it might not make much difference at all. And, as others have said, her child care costs will reduce.

More of a worry is that her partner was paying half and has now stopped, but she should get child support from him (and maybe is already?).
She hasn't asked you for financial support - if and when she does is the time to have this conversation with her. Until then you should MYOB about her finances and concentrate on giving her emotional and practical support.

OhMerseyMe · 17/07/2023 15:13

Even if the dad doesn’t want any part of his daughter’s life (what a terrible, horrid person!) isn’t he still responsible for monthly child support?

$1,100 sounds very reasonable to me, at least where I live, so she will likely not find anything for less/much less than that. Given it’s a four bedroom house, she could ask a friend to move in if finances looked bleak. Sorry she is in this situation but probably for the best since her ex seems like a real piece of 💩!

jennyjones198080 · 17/07/2023 12:16

GeraltsBathtub · 17/07/2023 12:06

Did you buy it in 2000?

People on this thread are forgetting g about deposits! I have a large home but not a huge mortgage. I bought it two years ago but had a substantial amount of equity for a deposit.

the mortgage repayment will depend on the individual and their circumstances

Xenia · 17/07/2023 12:12

I would work full time if I were she and I would stay i n the house. The most important things she needs to do are (a) today do a Land registry search which costs £3 to check legal ownership of teh hosue and see if her partner has tried to register any kind of rights over the house (b) check if they had any written arrangements about house ownership as he might later claim , despite not being married, some kind of equitable interest. Then (c) get a solicitor to draw up a short settlement agreement between them about the house so he does not claim rights to it later.

Her partner should pay CMS rates or they may j ust agree between them he will pay 50% of childcare costs but they should certainly try to get this all agreed idealy in writing and with at least some input from a solicitor.

1100 is not a vast sum so I expect she will be able to afford that mortgage. That is the rent my son gets (before he pays income tax on it) on his 2 bed house he lets out (he lives at home with me) on a small terraced place just outside the M25.

GeraltsBathtub · 17/07/2023 12:06

DixonD · 17/07/2023 12:01

Really? Mine is a 5 bed and is the same payment. I live in a really nice, popular area in the south.

Did you buy it in 2000?

DixonD · 17/07/2023 12:01

Herewego81 · 14/07/2023 16:58

A 4 bed in my part of the uk for £1100 a month would either be derelict or the steal or the century

Really? Mine is a 5 bed and is the same payment. I live in a really nice, popular area in the south.

girlladywoman · 17/07/2023 11:53

£1100 for a 4 bedroom house is SO unbelievably cheap.

Brexiteermorons · 17/07/2023 09:41

She is an adult and it’s her business, not yours

Nodeepdiving · 16/07/2023 22:55

OP last replied more than 48 hours and 10 pages of replies back everyone... Just in case anyone hadn't noticed we're shouting amongst ourselves now 😅

clarehhh · 16/07/2023 21:30

Sounds a very reasonable price. Renting a tiny flat near me is a lot more than that. Huge costs involved in moving.

pristinequeen · 16/07/2023 20:33

CatStankShame · 14/07/2023 16:53

If we had known that was the repayment when she bought the house we would have told her that was too much but sadly we weren’t informed at the time

Why do you think you were entitled to know this, or could have say on whether she proceded?

This. You sound like my mum. She's a big grown woman keep out of it, you don't own your daughter just because you birthed her

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 16/07/2023 20:15

I think we've all explained about modern house prices now. If OP is still reading, she must have got it.

What we haven't covered is the cost of childcare. Does the OP understand the financial difference that one day less a week of nursery can make?

And has she thought about why her daughter might think it's especially important that her two-year-old has another full day with mum a week, after this child has been abandoned by her father?

Lemonyfuckit · 16/07/2023 18:26

You seem to consider downsizing is the right thing to do based on the fact you wouldn't consider paying more than £500 a month. I don't know when you bought your current house but have you been living under a rock for the past 10 years? I also don't know where abouts in the country this is but frankly you can pay more than her mortgage payments to rent one bedroom in a shared house these days, and if you think you can get much for 500 per month in mortgage repayments that must be a tiny tiny mortgage with a ginormous deposit, which frankly given house prices versus wages these days the vast majority of people can't afford.
Sorry OP but your tone has really irked me coming from a generation presumably where house prices were just so much more affordable for perfectly average salaries.

Sandinmyknickers · 16/07/2023 17:55

daufhtercrusus · 14/07/2023 17:16

If it weren’t for the economic climate I would agree with staying out of it but it is worrying in the circumstances

But seemingly your solution is that she takes a much bigger financial risk of trying to sell and buy in the current climate, securing a much smaller mortgage but with much higher interest rates so will likely not make as much impact on her current monthly outgoings which probably is based on a mortgage she fixed when rates were lower, and also pay out all the legal costs, moving costs and stamp duty! That sounds like terrible financial advice!!

Stompythedinosaur · 16/07/2023 17:16

It is precisely none of your business!

She's an adult. It's her life. She hasn't asked you to contribute.

Spidey66 · 16/07/2023 16:53

SpeckledlyHen · 14/07/2023 16:46

I don't understand the bit about deciding to go part time to four days a week which will reduce her income. If she is part time now and going to go to four days a week surely that will raise her income?

I read it as going from ft to pt ie 5 days a week to 4.

sassyclassyandsmartassy · 16/07/2023 16:48

£1,100 is normal. I earn similar and could afford to keep my house in the situation described. I wouldn’t be able to save alongside, but I could do it if I cut back on thing and planned. At 32k his maintenance payments will be around £325 a month if he doesn’t want anything to do with child. Equally she could extend her mortgage to being payments down if necessary. I do think YABU to question your daughters choices like this. If you have concerns raise them with your daughter, sit down, talk about it. I think if she can keep the house she would be wise rather than have th costs of moving.

DirectionToPerfection · 16/07/2023 12:52

AlwaysFrazzled88 · 16/07/2023 11:07

You don't even know me. 🤣 Good luck with the heating bill and the cleaning!

Well seeing as she bought the house on her own I'm sure she's well aware of what the maintenance entails.

I imagine there will be less cleaning required now the partner is out of the picture.

Not sure what your issue is. Jealousy possibly.

CactusMama2023 · 16/07/2023 11:51

We rented in south Cambridge (late 20s at the time) before buying cheaper elsewhere and we were paying £1200 a month rent for a 2 bed small semi detached house , that was about 4 years ago. So 1100 mortgage a month for a 4 bed house sounds really reasonable actually and great that she is paying off a mortgage rather than renting and paying into someone else’s pocket like a landlord! Also she has an asset and if meets someone else in the future I’m sure the costs will be shared once again xx

sweepleall · 16/07/2023 11:35

There is a lot of variety in four bedroom houses.

Big difference between a four double bedroom 2 reception room type place and a four bed townhouse with very limited storage and living space

RunBetter · 16/07/2023 11:27

MRex · 16/07/2023 10:53

it may well be a reality - no, vanishingly unlikely, that's just you wishing bad luck on someone.

2027 will be here in exactly 3.5 years. At that point DD age 5 will be in year 1 having had a year at 15 hours free childcare, a year at 30 hours free childcare and a whole year in school; plus the £96 per month child benefit. That's without any income assessed benefits at all. The possibly £40k will have increased, and might have been more than £40k to start with. The mortgage term could easily have be extended with payment holidays to get through the next couple of years if needed. There has been no reason given to think the house has to be sold, and no reason to think this would be financially sensible.

Exactly this.

In 3.5 years she could significantly increase her salary, depending on her industry (my salary has increased from 40k to 70k in that timeframe, and that’s very average for the sector), or meet a new partner and want to live together.

Anything could happen in 3.5 years!

jennyjones198080 · 16/07/2023 11:15

AlwaysFrazzled88 · 16/07/2023 11:09

Not really. Just an observation. Why pay for loads of rooms you don't use? Yet it would be viewed differently if your elderly grandmother was in a three bed council house by herself...

Working from home - space - a lovely large garden? Lots of people want larger homes and can afford to pay for them. Why not?

I love love love my house. I can have guests and parties when I want - I have a generous sized home office for when I work from home - two good sized guest rooms and a large dressing room. I use the space - and love it.

jennyjones198080 · 16/07/2023 11:10

AlwaysFrazzled88 · 16/07/2023 11:07

You don't even know me. 🤣 Good luck with the heating bill and the cleaning!

Out of interest how many bedrooms do you have? And why does a four bed bother you so much!

I moved from a three bed to a five bed and haven’t noticed a significant increase in cleaning or heating costs!

in fact cleaning is easier because everything. Is more organisated and tidy - more storage!