Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the most inappropriate unsolicited advice you received from a random person about your child?

207 replies

Adviceagains · 14/07/2023 13:52

I’m feeling sensitive today. Stood in a queue and dd asleep in her pram. Women behind me starts talking to her husband/partner saying that baby looks too hot, how ridiculous she is in a hat indoors in this weather… obviously I could hear. I didn’t say anything. She then taps me on the shoulder and shows me an NHS page on clothing/temperatures for babies and said I might need it. What the fuck? I am a new mum and already stressing over making the right decisions. Am I alone in this? I actually cried when I got in the car.

OP posts:
justme2022 · 14/07/2023 17:19

pristinequeen · 14/07/2023 16:45

Not necessarily a jab at me personally but it pissed me off. Distant relative commended me at a family bbq, when my first was about 6 months old, for talking to my daughter because apparently mums my age (I was very early 20s at the time) don't do anything but sit on their phones or plonk the kids in front of the tv. It's always the ones who haven't had an actual baby for 20 years that love to berate young mums, yet all the young mums I know are doing a brilliant job

My aunt, who admittedly was well into her second bottle of wine at the time told me that I was doing an ok job (cheers, I guess) but most new mothers had "no fucking idea what they were doing and shouldn't be allowed to have kids" unlike her who apparently knew exactly how to be a parent the second hers arrived.

OlympicProcrastinator · 14/07/2023 17:19

Hayfeverseasonalready · 14/07/2023 15:17

When discussing my non verbal child: "Have you tried talking to him?"

Umm.... yeah.... I guess I'm kookie that way 🙄

Im sorry this made me laugh so much. Not at your distress but the stupidity of the comment.

I Imagine you just being like, “oh my god! No! I never considered talking to him. I didn’t know you were meant to speak to your child! Thanks Kevin”

ManateeFair · 14/07/2023 17:18

I haven't got any kids but my mum often reminisces about a neighbour of ours who was very prone to dishing out unsolicited advice about all sorts of things. She once told my mum, when I was about six, that our rabbits shouldn't be allowed to hop around freely in my company because it was 'well-known' that rabbits can kill children by jumping up and kicking them in the throat.

Another woman on the estate where we lived also told my mum, with complete seriousness and genuine concern, that she should go back to the hospital and make sure they had given her the right baby to bring home because I don't look anything like my older siblings and 'sometimes they do get swapped over'. Now, admittedly I do look very different to both my siblings, but that's literally just because they look like my mum and I look like my dad?!

GertrudeJekyllRose · 14/07/2023 17:18

I still get unsolicited advice about my son who has special needs and he's an adult now. It's upsetting every single time.

karmakameleon · 14/07/2023 17:17

I’ve had loads (two disabled children attract unwanted advice) but my favourite was the woman who stopped me to tell me I was TUBE FEEDING my three month old baby ALL WRONG. I mean seriously, I have a three month old baby with more medical equipment than the local NICU so you can probably guess that my life is a bit difficult at the moment. And you know absolutely FUCK ALL about tube feeding but you feel compelled to stop me in the street and criticise. Luckily I was on my way to hospital with him and a doctor overheard and told her she could fuck off.

GertrudeJekyllRose · 14/07/2023 17:16

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 14/07/2023 14:28

I used to be overweight (not morbidly obese but clearly an unhealthy weight. And I definitely knew it).

I had had a difficult day, hadn’t eaten all day and decided to buy some sort of cheese pastry thingy on the station before taking the train home.

So I was standing on the escalator, sort of self-conscious about eating something like that in public but also too tired and hungry to wait until home… when this middle aged man tapped me on the shoulder, told me that I simply had to “eat vegetables, no sugar, no bread” and that “everything will be okay”.

no, it did not improve my day. Not at all…

I rushed into M&S to pick up a last minute birthday cake for my son's birthday party. A woman came up to me and told me to put the cake back on the shelf or I'd get fatter! When I ignored her she grabbed the cake out of my basket and put it back on the shelf. I had to call security who escorted her out of the store.

Runki · 14/07/2023 17:14

Hello and I am very sorry you had to put up with this interfering know-all! I hope you feel a bit better now and please know that you are doing a fantastic job!

I have forgotten a lot of the unwanted advice I used to get, but I remember feeling highly irritated that once I had had babies, random strangers began to treat me like an child and thought that because I was in public with a baby, I seemed to be wearing a sandwich board that said, "Please advise me". I remember one woman saying I should never rock a baby as I was "making a rod for my own back". I was waiting in a queue with my first in his pram and was pushing the pram to and fro as I knew it helped him get off to sleep. I couldn't believe it. On another occasion, a friend insisted on letting my baby sleep for three hours one afternoon as she was enjoying holding him...I kept saying please, he's been sleeping for too long, he'll be awake all night....she knew better of course and kept telling me I was being silly. Of course, he was awake until 4 am. I remember sitting with my first in a cafe and a woman at the next table leaned over and said, "Oh you poor thing, do you only have the one child?" I was heavily pregnant with my second at the time and when I stood up to leave and she noticed, and said, "Oh", and looked away, embarrassed. Some people are such opinionated idiots!!!

My two were close in age and I had them in a double buggy for a while. People used to feel it was their place to comment in the street. "Ooh. You've got your hands full" was a particular favourite. And once from a random old man, "The one at the front's awake. The one at the back is asleep". Ah thanks, that's so helpful! My favourite was when I was pushing my first home in his pram, having been to the shops leading up to Christmas. It was 5 pm and dark. A man came out of a pub and shouted out, "It's disgusting taking a baby out this late at night! That baby should be in bed!"

Everyone has an opinion, it seems. But YOU are the best person for the job and you are doing a marvellous job. Don't let the bastards grind you down.

Mygrandadwasmywingman · 14/07/2023 17:06

Newborn dd (i was a first time mum and 19 years old)

'If she cries,just slap her to shut her up'

'Don't pick her up and cuddle her!you'll spoil her'

'Drop a tot of whiskey into her bottle to make her sleep'

'Don't drink diet coke/water/tea/juice while pregnant-just drink coffee' (can't stand coffee)

'Get proper boots for her feet or they wont grow properly and she'll never learn to walk' (she was 3 days old)

'Don't use pampers-you HAVE to use Terry towelling-and wash them by hand-the machine is cheating'

'She needs a happy meal' (she was 6 weeks old)

'Get her weaned!' (She was 5 weeks old)

Don't breadtfeed-youll be useless at it and won't have enough milk' (fed her for 3 months)

'Leave her outside the front of the house,in her pram,in a heatwave,with no shade and unsupervised' (was was a few days old)

Everything I did-'ohhhhh,your making a rod for your own back there!'

'You don't need a car seat-just shove her on your lap'

'A chocolate button won't hurt'-at 2 weeks old

All gems from my own mother

How I survived her parenting,I do not know

DidyouNO · 14/07/2023 17:00

I had a woman grab my baby's feet because she 'knew they were cold'. He was in a sling with socks and bootees on under my coat. She quite literally shoved her hand up my coat to find his feet.
That was weird. I find it laughable to be honest but I have 4 kiddos so I'm probably immune now 😂

PoshHorseyBird · 14/07/2023 16:57

You'll always get nosy busybodies. Maybe for future ones try something along the lines of this. After whatever comment they've made look at them with a really puzzled expression. Then say "I'm so sorry I must have had a total brain fart there! Remind me..at what point did I ask for your opinion/advice?" They will obviously say "well you didn't " at which point you say "no...I didn't did I..." then blank them 😁

mondaytosunday · 14/07/2023 16:54

I was told numerous times my baby was cold and needed more clothes. He was happy, giggling and waving his arms about but no - they knew my baby better. This same baby who grew to be a child who wore shorts all year and when walking to school in the snow and me insisting on a jacket had stripped down to his polo top by the time we got there.
'I think I know my baby's needs better than you thank you' is what you need to say.

Ilovenicnacs · 14/07/2023 16:53

Someone shouted at me to get out of the road with my buggy as I'll get my baby killed. I was crossing the road and there were no cars.

That's the only one that really annoyed me. I smile and ignore for everything else.

Spendonsend · 14/07/2023 16:49

One of my sons was dashing about in a slighly inappropriate way in a supermarket. (None of us are perfect all the time)

A man in all seriousness suggest that in his day kids had less food and had less energy as a result and i should not give him lunch anymore to calm him down.

pristinequeen · 14/07/2023 16:45

Not necessarily a jab at me personally but it pissed me off. Distant relative commended me at a family bbq, when my first was about 6 months old, for talking to my daughter because apparently mums my age (I was very early 20s at the time) don't do anything but sit on their phones or plonk the kids in front of the tv. It's always the ones who haven't had an actual baby for 20 years that love to berate young mums, yet all the young mums I know are doing a brilliant job

Daftasabroom · 14/07/2023 16:44

nasanas · 14/07/2023 16:28

My father telling me I needed to give my 8 year old (autistic and nowhere near ready to go out alone) DS some 'freedom' - he will never learn how to be normal of you don't let him out to play.

I am still to form a reply and it was over 10 years ago 🤦🏻‍♀️

Also a wee mention for my Nanna who cut the broccoli article mentioned upthread out of the Daily Mail so she could give it to me and help cure DS!

DS is a grown adult now and oddly; he is still autistic. Although tbf I didn't let him play out alone at 8 and he would not eat broccoli so maybe they were onto something 🤣

Autistic DS's favorite food was broccoli 🥦 (trees), he's still autistic.

Reugny · 14/07/2023 16:42

PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/07/2023 16:26

Random woman in supermarket around 9 yelrs ago .aaah he needs socks on poor love,don't you you need socks on don't you? To 5 month old ds.

No he doesn't its red hot outside and we've come in here for the aircon thanks

Random woman has clearly missed the baby pulls the socks off and throws them out of the pram/buggie stage. 🙄

MrsSamR · 14/07/2023 16:39

NoNoNadaNo · 14/07/2023 15:14

Hahaha haha this is brilliant. What did you say?

I was just so shocked and blindsided and it was my first baby so I kind of mumbled I hope so and scurried off! It's always after the event when you get home that you think of the good responses in those scenarios isn't it?!

Lwrenagain · 14/07/2023 16:37

nasanas · 14/07/2023 16:28

My father telling me I needed to give my 8 year old (autistic and nowhere near ready to go out alone) DS some 'freedom' - he will never learn how to be normal of you don't let him out to play.

I am still to form a reply and it was over 10 years ago 🤦🏻‍♀️

Also a wee mention for my Nanna who cut the broccoli article mentioned upthread out of the Daily Mail so she could give it to me and help cure DS!

DS is a grown adult now and oddly; he is still autistic. Although tbf I didn't let him play out alone at 8 and he would not eat broccoli so maybe they were onto something 🤣

Our nanas and that fecking article!!! They were convinced it would work 😂😂
Really annoys me that I like brocoli, even now!

blahblahlandgoogoodoll · 14/07/2023 16:36

I was on my phone on the postnatal ward and some woman who had just arrived into the bay announced loudly that she couldn't believe some women were more interested in making phone calls than holding their baby.

Baby was in NICU and I had left while they sorted out new feeding tubes etc. I was calling the unit to see if they were done so I could go back. I couldn't walk as if they weren't done there were not seats outside and I'd had an emergency c section a few hours earlier.

I honestly could have lynched her! I made sure I was really loud on the phone & then when the midwife came I announced loudly that I was leaving to go to NICU to see my baby as the procedure was finished could they fetch me my pain tablets now.

She looked embarrassed and avoided my gaze. I hope she learnt not to be so fucking judgemental!

Also someone else who said 'why can't they just look at their baby' when I was scrolling on my phone.... baby was asleep 🙄

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 14/07/2023 16:31

Just to clarify, 3 to 6 years! Not 3 to 6 everyday!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 14/07/2023 16:30

3rd DD had both a stammer and other speech difficulties. She was also tall for her age so looked older.
I paid for speech therapy and did it daily with her faithfully from 3 til 6. At the end of it, she had overcome the stammer and could be understood. I stuck to never drawing attention to it.
I had "you should talk directly to her more"
"Do stammers run in the family"
"Have you thought about taking her to a doctor"
And finally "I told you she would grow out it"
She is now 15. Looking back I really wish I had just said "oh do fuck off" to every one of them.

nasanas · 14/07/2023 16:28

My father telling me I needed to give my 8 year old (autistic and nowhere near ready to go out alone) DS some 'freedom' - he will never learn how to be normal of you don't let him out to play.

I am still to form a reply and it was over 10 years ago 🤦🏻‍♀️

Also a wee mention for my Nanna who cut the broccoli article mentioned upthread out of the Daily Mail so she could give it to me and help cure DS!

DS is a grown adult now and oddly; he is still autistic. Although tbf I didn't let him play out alone at 8 and he would not eat broccoli so maybe they were onto something 🤣

AlienatedChildGrown · 14/07/2023 16:26

LadyWiddiothethird · 14/07/2023 16:21

Lived in Italy when my children were little,the local prostitutes were always telling me off about various things to do with clothing.I used to try and avoid them,was difficult as my friend lived next door to a house that was a brothel.Provided hours of fun for us as we sat in her lounge watching it all.

Oh god fucking “colpo d’aria” was the bane of my existence. 🤣

PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/07/2023 16:26

Random woman in supermarket around 9 yelrs ago .aaah he needs socks on poor love,don't you you need socks on don't you? To 5 month old ds.

No he doesn't its red hot outside and we've come in here for the aircon thanks

Conkersinautumn · 14/07/2023 16:25

Just now on MN, rather than managing my own childcare I should apparently be letting my kids go home with randoms from school, just so I'm not impeding their social development 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread