Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for the most inappropriate unsolicited advice you received from a random person about your child?

207 replies

Adviceagains · 14/07/2023 13:52

I’m feeling sensitive today. Stood in a queue and dd asleep in her pram. Women behind me starts talking to her husband/partner saying that baby looks too hot, how ridiculous she is in a hat indoors in this weather… obviously I could hear. I didn’t say anything. She then taps me on the shoulder and shows me an NHS page on clothing/temperatures for babies and said I might need it. What the fuck? I am a new mum and already stressing over making the right decisions. Am I alone in this? I actually cried when I got in the car.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
takealettermsjones · 19/07/2023 14:15

FussyPud · 16/07/2023 00:21

My middle child was in crisis once. I had him in a safe hold, on the concourse of the local bus station. He and I were as safe as possible in the situation, but in full public view. Most people just went around us, one bloke decided to stand and berate me. He ended his rant with “that child needs a good hiding!” to which I replied “so do you, but I’m a bit busy right now.”

You're my hero!

kannnet96 · 19/07/2023 11:56

I was walking with my sleeping baby in a pram. My phone rang and the conversation went as follows

Hi Mrs k. Calling to confirm your appointment for tomorrow

Me- yes 2.30. Perfect. Thanks for confirming

Goodbye.

A lady walking behind me came up to me tapped me on the shoulder and said
" I hate seeing mothers on their phones rounds babies. They won't be small
Long enjoy it.

  1. baby wad alseep
  2. I was only phone for about fifteen seconds
  3. it was confirming an appointment for said baby
  4. it's none of her business
SadieContrary · 19/07/2023 11:18

Let me be clear, I think the woman could have delivered that message a LOT better and more sensitively BUT if she genuinely was concerned that your baby was overheating then why not tell you. We are all in outrage when we hear about things happening to children and no one spoke out despite suspecting something was wrong.

As plenty of previous commenters have said, sometimes we did things as new Mums because we didn’t know any better.

My faux pas was draping a muslin or light blanket over my DDs pram/buggy to shade her when she was asleep and it was months before someone showed me an article about how it restricts airflow and how much the temp increases in that space. I was horrified… and also embarrassed as well as then stressing about being a terrible Mum.

The fact that you’ve posted here shows that you care and that alone shows that you’re intent on being a good Mum

CommiePinkoSatirist · 16/07/2023 22:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Berklilly · 16/07/2023 22:31

A friend this weekend,

  • Whilst I was putting my 5 weeks in the pram for a 5 min journey: "Does she need a blanket?"
  • Whilst I was putting my jacket on:" You're not going to put a blanket on her?"
  • whilst I was putting the rain cover: "Did you not forget the blanket"
  • whilst unlocking the pushchair: "wait!!! I found the BLAAANNNKEEET!!!!!!!!"

🙃

MumofSpud · 16/07/2023 22:01

I was told not to wear black as my baby would get depressed - I was pregnant !

user1471538283 · 16/07/2023 21:53

Some people always feel the urge to say something!

I had a woman I barely know at work try to tell me how to raise my DS. My DS was doing very well at school and her son was a bit odd. But to hear her you'd think her son was a genius when he was not.

TrustyRusty68 · 16/07/2023 21:43

Every wo(man) & their dog will have advice to give - wanted or not! Just know that you’re doing a great job - smile & wave, smile & wave :-)

ZoeDavoMCR · 16/07/2023 16:28

There’s always someone ready to offer you some sort of bullshit when you have a baby, I nipped in a shop for one item with my 2 year old who was in a foul mood kicking me when I was carrying him and then screaming if I put him down, I had been in the shop for 5 seconds when a woman said ‘he’s tired of walking he’s too young to be expected to walk so far’ he had literally taken 2 steps, I had carried him from the car and just put him down…..I just told her to fuck off and mind her own business

Oysterbabe · 16/07/2023 14:21

I'll admit I was judgy pre children when I saw kids underdressed and shoeless in cold weather. Then I had DD, I haven't been able to keep a coat or shoes on her since she was 6 months old.

MargaretThursday · 16/07/2023 13:34

Plymsoul · 16/07/2023 11:27

@Tinkietot 😂 this reminds me of the time I took my son and his best friend to the cinema when they were about 6 - the woman serving said ‘oh your twins are so beautiful’- I said thanks, they are pretty but they aren’t twins- this one isn’t actually mine… and she wouldn’t have it! It was all ‘are you sure?’ ‘But they look so alike’ ‘they have the same hair’ ‘they must at least be siblings’.

The advice I get most (and get tutted at about most about) is my son not wearing shoes. He is autistic and he hates them. He has them, he takes them off.

I don't wear shoes a lot of the time. At work I'm known so much for it, that when I broke my toe and was wearing sandals, more people commented that I was wearing shoes than that i was limping badly!

Plymsoul · 16/07/2023 11:27

Tinkietot · 14/07/2023 14:16

I argued with an old lady once that my little boy was in fact a boy. Around 8 months at the time and she said what’s her name. I replied he’s a boy. She told me he was far too pretty to be a boy and was I sure on his sex?

I have loads from my mother; they should be sleeping through the night by 3 months, I shouldn’t breastfeed past 3 months and that’s why they don’t sleep, why aren’t they forward facing so they can look out the window in the car, too many snacks and why can’t they have chocolate at 6 months it’s only a little bit….too many to write.

@Tinkietot 😂 this reminds me of the time I took my son and his best friend to the cinema when they were about 6 - the woman serving said ‘oh your twins are so beautiful’- I said thanks, they are pretty but they aren’t twins- this one isn’t actually mine… and she wouldn’t have it! It was all ‘are you sure?’ ‘But they look so alike’ ‘they have the same hair’ ‘they must at least be siblings’.

The advice I get most (and get tutted at about most about) is my son not wearing shoes. He is autistic and he hates them. He has them, he takes them off.

orangeleavesinautumn · 16/07/2023 11:10

Plymsoul · 16/07/2023 11:06

@orangeleavesinautumn I never understand this- how is a pair of stretchy magic gloves going to protect your fingers from the weight of a person slicing over them with ice skates on?

I dont understand it either, tbh, but my brother assures me it makes a difference. How much difference, I dont know, but he has told me of cases where he thinks fingers were saved by what seems to me to by a modicum of protection.

Still, if you have ever seen a cyclist come off their bike, there is a clear demarkation in their cuts and grazes where their clothing ends - I am amazed how much even a teeshirt protects the skin. Different forces though, I agree

Newmumatlast · 16/07/2023 11:07

AlienatedChildGrown · 14/07/2023 16:19

A man came over when I was breastfeeding DS (now 23) in McDonalds in Milan.
He stood over me for ten minutes explaining how I should be carrying around a tiny mattress to lay DS on to feed. Always. His wife stood behind him nodding.

I was having to translate it all to SIL who was also breastfeeding my now hulking huge nephew.

That was the first and last time I breastfed in public for months. I didn’t believe him about the mattress, it certainly wasn’t one of the million Italian things I was “doing all wrong Signora!”. But being a new mother in a cultural soup that wasn’t my own was just too damn stressful.

I think he was 4 before I wasn’t worried about being mistaken for the “the foreign babysitter” and anther round of “Does his mother know you have no idea what you are doing?”

Big fat hug. It sucks that the occasional person has a lot to say about stuff that really isn’t their business. And they get to occupy our thoughts and chip away at our confidence in a way the many thousands who don’t stick their oar in … don’t.

But there really are a teeny tiny minority. All the other people milling around thought you were managing perfectly well. You can tell from their silence. And their vote in your favour STRENUOUSLY outnumbers the PolicePeople On Infant hood Doing It Right Patrol.

The silence though... People should stand up for other people if they hear inappropriate comments. I'm just mad I don't hear them.

Plymsoul · 16/07/2023 11:06

orangeleavesinautumn · 16/07/2023 06:43

its normally compulsory for safety reasons. My brother works in A and E and insists, for everyone in the family. Maybe it was my brother you met!! 😂It may have been unsolicited, but I wouldn't call that "inappropriate" .

It is the difference between losing your fingers and saving them if someone skates over your hand

@orangeleavesinautumn I never understand this- how is a pair of stretchy magic gloves going to protect your fingers from the weight of a person slicing over them with ice skates on?

celticprincess · 16/07/2023 10:36

Some old lady stopped me and told my my baby shouldn’t be sat up in her pram. My baby was 6 months old but looked younger as she was small for her age. BUT she had really bad reflux and could never be laid down flat and was kept up alot of the time. At 6 months she was sitting up unaided out of her pram.

TheBerry · 16/07/2023 10:09

Ott to cry about it but yeah you can’t really give unsolicited advice about other people’s babies unless it’s some kind of emergency.

That said, the NHS does recommend taking hats off babies indoors as they can overheat rapidly if they can’t expel body heat through their head, so the advice was probably actually sound.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 16/07/2023 08:43

Breastfeeding my fifth baby, on the maternity ward
Midwife came in to tell me that I was “doing it wrong” 😂

After her round, I ended up speaking to several women who were on the verge of giving up after the way she spoke them. Helped some of them to relax and get more comfortable, and they decided they were happy to continue with it. And supported another woman in her decision to go onto bottle feeding.

EsmeSusanOgg · 16/07/2023 08:06

A few snippets:

At 4 weeks old: 'Is he good? Is he sleeping through the night?'

By a receptionist at the dentist (note, baby was in pram at time): 'There's a reason teeth come at 6 months, that's when you should stop breastfeeding.' - baby was 4 months old... Breastfed until just over 2.

Many, many random people saying he either needed more/ less layers utterly unbidden. Often with conflicting unasked for opinions on the same day in the same weather...

'SIDs is just scaremongering, all my children were fine and we didn't have that advice in the 80s and 90s,'

'Why are they rear facing still (for a 7 month old)? Aren't they uncomfortable?'

'You should put rice in their milk or they will never sleep,' - about an at the time very much asleep 3 month old.

'I had mine on solids from 10 weeks,'

Oh gosh... There's just millions. And all unsolicited!

Bringmethesleep · 16/07/2023 07:51

My son is visually impaired. Sitting in doctor's waiting room when he was about 9 months old. An elderly man comes over from the other side of the room to look in the pram at him...and then says, "oh...he's a bit boss eyed...what a shame". One of those moment when you are a totally overwhelmed and sleep deprived new mum and you think of all the responses you could have given after the event. It's stuck with me though.

onwardandupwards · 16/07/2023 06:53

A family member told me my ds is autistic, adhd and agoraphobic because I never took him.to the park enough, and when my dd was diagnosed with autism they said I must be doing something wrong in pregnancy to have two "like it". Same family member says they will grow out of it, she knows as she's worked with children for years ( she's a dinner lady 2 lunch times a week)

orangeleavesinautumn · 16/07/2023 06:43

coxesorangepippin · 16/07/2023 02:18

The absolute best was that DD should be wearing gloves at an indoor ice skating arena. Tons of other kids without gloves too. But this old guy picked me out to tell me that?

Unfortunately I didn't tell him to go fuck himself

its normally compulsory for safety reasons. My brother works in A and E and insists, for everyone in the family. Maybe it was my brother you met!! 😂It may have been unsolicited, but I wouldn't call that "inappropriate" .

It is the difference between losing your fingers and saving them if someone skates over your hand

coxesorangepippin · 16/07/2023 02:18

The absolute best was that DD should be wearing gloves at an indoor ice skating arena. Tons of other kids without gloves too. But this old guy picked me out to tell me that?

Unfortunately I didn't tell him to go fuck himself

FussyPud · 16/07/2023 00:21

My middle child was in crisis once. I had him in a safe hold, on the concourse of the local bus station. He and I were as safe as possible in the situation, but in full public view. Most people just went around us, one bloke decided to stand and berate me. He ended his rant with “that child needs a good hiding!” to which I replied “so do you, but I’m a bit busy right now.”

clpsmum · 15/07/2023 23:04

W1CK887 · 15/07/2023 22:51

I have 2 sons who are autistic and non verbal. I was told that my youngest "can speak but is just choosing not to". This was by a tutor who apparently specialises in teaching autistic children.

I've been in a similar situation. An expert told me my son didn't speak because he didn't have any space to speak and the rest of the family didn't give him the opportunity