Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people on here can be a bit naive with regard to ‘the village’?

201 replies

Buildyourvillage · 14/07/2023 11:21

I see it quite a lot on here, that if you need sudden childcare either because of an emergency or last minute change of plans, you should have a village to call on.

I found out I was expecting my (planned!) baby a couple of weeks after the first lockdown was announced, but I was still determined to be as sociable as possible. My own parents died before I turned 30, so I didn’t have them as support, but we had DHs parents although they live about an hour and a half away.

We did the NCT course and we were really lucky as everyone in our group hit it off and I know not everyone does. However, we’re a little widespread geographically and most significantly, out of six of us, four went back to work FT: two straightaway, two initially went back PT but then got different FT jobs.

Toddler classes here are hit and miss at best. We do the activity with the toddlers and I am always friendly and sociable but somehow it’s hard to strike up meaningful conversations beyond ‘how old is she …’

I have seen on another thread that you should be apparently organising childcare swaps with other mums to cover for school holidays and the like and I’m not against that in theory but in practice I do wonder if one persons village is another persons CF. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheOrigRights · 18/07/2023 12:56

AliRud · 18/07/2023 11:58

When we grew up in the 60's and misbehaved anywhere, my parents knew about it before we even got home!!😥

A couple of months ago I was scrolling through our village FB page only to see a Ring doorbell video of my son and his friend. Just walking along the pavement.
The resident thought it looked suspicious.

It was all fine, I know the resident, told her it was my son and asked her to remove the video.

I then prayed they wouldn't start playing knock down ginger or something.

So, the village (if you want to call it that) was keeping an eye on my son that evening.

AliRud · 18/07/2023 11:58

When we grew up in the 60's and misbehaved anywhere, my parents knew about it before we even got home!!😥

Ukrainebaby23 · 18/07/2023 03:40

Buildyourvillage · 14/07/2023 12:48

I do agree with that @redskytwonight , but then again it does depend on where you live.

More often though I do see it pushed on here as in ‘what? You don’t have any friends who could …’ I am trying to say you can do all the right things and make friends but they aren’t always going to be in a position to help.

@TheWayTheLightFalls i do honestly consider myself a friendly person but while I know a lot of people locally I don’t know many who I could ask to help other than in a dire emergency!

I'm hopeless at making friends, always have been. I seem to have managed to gain a few friends over the years but none with similar aged kids and none local to me.
DH seems sociable but still doesn't seem to make friends, guess that's why we are compatible.

Been to loads of groups while on mat leave, enjoyed them but rarely got passed, how old?, has he done xxx yet? I'm quite deaf, and it's been exacerbated by health issues so can barely hear in some places, and whilst I explain, people don't really understand and think I'm being ignorant, so making friends never likely to happen.
We are just winging it if we/lo get sick basically.
I don't think 'the village' is necessarily a geographical concept though, in these days, your village can include video call contacts, ldr etc etc, is just about having other input in your child's life, not just parents.

VenusClapTrap · 17/07/2023 23:03

I love my ‘village’. Everyone mucks in because few of us have parents anywhere nearby, or willing or able to help. So right from preschool days we’ve all helped each other out. Why drive just your own kid to Cubs when you can take three, and then benefit from someone else returning the favour next week? And there’s always someone asking on the class WhatsApp for ‘someone to grab Evie after school because I’m running half an hour late’ Etc. There’s a real sense of all being in this together.

It goes beyond school mums here - there’s a rota for different village groups to run a monthly coffee morning for the older folk, and a ‘good neighbour’ network where people volunteer to do shopping or hospital lifts etc for those who need it.

I think it’s just a very friendly community where people like to help each other out. I suppose not all communities are like this. I do feel lucky.

MogsMa · 17/07/2023 22:04

I found this all kicked in once they started primary school- we knew all the kids and all the parents in the group, everyone was very engaged and took part in things, we were all in an email group (later WhatsApp). It was completely normal for someone to email the class to ask if someone could pick their kid up because they had a doctors appointment, help out with drop off, video them in the concert if their parent couldn’t make it etc etc. Also rotas for lifts to extra-curriculars etc. So not quite holiday childcare but a lot of helping each other out.

purplehair1 · 17/07/2023 21:46

We had quite a good ‘babysitting club’ where a couple of streets around us traded tokens for babysitting. They were metal curtain weights, and we knew all the other families involved and ‘paid’ with these weights and then returned the favour. It worked really well. Wasn’t an emergency childcare facility or that didn’t occur at the time we were there but I’m sure if it had been needed, our neighbours would have stepped up. Really good system.

orangeleavesinautumn · 17/07/2023 21:39

all these mothers on here looking for child care swaps and not able to find any, maybe you could be helping each other if you live near enough

HollyBookBlue · 17/07/2023 21:35

I found my 'village' when DD went into junior school. I became friends with her friends' parents. We saw each other all the time at school pickups, the park etc. The kids started doing the same clubs. If the kids all need to be at the same venue we share lifts, we cover childcare emergencies for each other. School holidays are broken up by the gang of them descending on a different house a few times a week. It's a good feeling to have a community and to know that there's multiple sets of parents looking out for the group.

But I didn't find it for myself when DD was a baby, DD found it for me!

FedUpWithEverything123 · 17/07/2023 21:17

YANBU - DC is 10 and i have tried to make connections with other parents over the years, nothing ever comes of it. We have no family remotely near. Hence we have no village. It is hard and lonely

anon666 · 17/07/2023 20:46

We never had a "village". Two full time jobs and far flung home towns meant we were lucky to have an alternative emergency contact within 400 miles.

Bbq1 · 17/07/2023 18:47

Elephantinasandstorm · 14/07/2023 11:30

The village was not meant as free childcare though but as overal society where child would grow up and learn from various people as well as have the "village" for safety.
Eg. My parents knew they can let us out at young age because if anything happened or we caused trouble "the village" would help or tell us off. We generally walk to school at 6 without adults and someone on MN once had a logical explanation why it not done in UK. Because in many other places even unrelated adults intervene and somewhat watch over kids. While also telling them off!
I got so much telling off from strangers when I was a kid😂

Whereas nowadays most people on MN tell others, "it's none of your business" when the Op is concerned about potential child or elder abuse. That's what changed in society people actually caring about and wanting to look out for others. Very sad.

longestlurkerever · 17/07/2023 09:32

Anycrispsleft · 17/07/2023 07:01

This is the thing - I don't want to work all year and then clock off of my actual job and spend my "holiday" running a bloody childminding business on the side. I would like a bit of a rest!

Well no one "wants to" exactly but if you've got limited annual leave and limited budget then it can be the lesser of evils, especially if kids are kicking off about holiday club or it's a logistical pita to get them there. And tbh sometimes I find I can do a bit of wfh while they're occupying each other, as long as I don't take the piss. Anyway, it's fine if it doesn't suit other people, but I don't get the strength of feeling against other people doing things differently.

SilverDrawer · 17/07/2023 08:41

I used to live somewhere where the situation you describe was what we did. It wasn’t so much being friends with the other parents, but knowing each other because of our children and their activities/school. It was great..

Where I live now is totally different. People have a much more rigid approach to bringing up their children and don't swap childcare like this. I’m glad mine are older!

unicornhair · 17/07/2023 08:36

I’ve never minded doing the bulk of play date/childcare swops. The problem is there are parents who think they don’t have to do any of it and you are left doing 100%. It’s amazing how many women are happy to use other women.

It’s true you do have to meet a lot of people to find people you gel with. The problem is it’s hard to meet that many people sometimes past a certain age, depending on circumstances, so you can tend to latch onto people when you find them.

Indigotree · 17/07/2023 08:15

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 06:13

I also think a lot of the concept of the "village" is based on periods of time when you had lots of young/heathy women not working outside the home. Where I live everyone woh. There are hardly any sahp.

I can think of just 1 parent in my DC class who is not working at all.

The only people in the village i live in who are around the during the day are the very elderly folk. The people in their 60s are often still working or are doing some childcare for their own grandchildren. There's no one with the time to help others with their kids.

Exactly. More people work more hours than is actually needed these days, despite there being technology and knowledge to mean we shouldn't need work so much.

Anycrispsleft · 17/07/2023 07:01

TheOrigRights · 14/07/2023 13:03

YANBU - the childcare swap never really worked for me. How can it when someone has all school holidays off work and you only have regular annual leave? It was always very one way. I didn't want to spend my annual leave looking after other people's children (playdates aside).

This is the thing - I don't want to work all year and then clock off of my actual job and spend my "holiday" running a bloody childminding business on the side. I would like a bit of a rest!

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 06:13

I also think a lot of the concept of the "village" is based on periods of time when you had lots of young/heathy women not working outside the home. Where I live everyone woh. There are hardly any sahp.

I can think of just 1 parent in my DC class who is not working at all.

The only people in the village i live in who are around the during the day are the very elderly folk. The people in their 60s are often still working or are doing some childcare for their own grandchildren. There's no one with the time to help others with their kids.

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 06:01

I tried to barter childcare over the summer and everyone was like “sorry but I’m mostly at work and when I’m off work we’re going away”.

This is me and everyone i know. We are away the only time ive got off this summer and most holidays except Christmas, when i don't want an extra child around.

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 06:00

For example it's absolutely no extra effort for me to pick up an extra kid from school and drop them to an activity that my daughter also does. I don't see it as an onerous favour and other parents drop my kid off if they're going the same way

Thats not really a childcare swap though, people mean having maybe a couple of kids for say, a half or full day in the school holidays while their mum/dad work. Hardly anyone actually wants to do this.

Yellowlegobrick · 17/07/2023 05:57

Yes the childcare swaps thing, you can't actually get a meaningful amount of childcare with this. If im off work its often because we're going away ourselves and the same is true for other families. The only people who around a lot are the sahp and why would they want to have my kids? They don't need me to have theirs.

I also only get 25 days holiday so the last thing i want is to have 2 or 3 extra children on my day off, its really hard work looking after 4 or 5 kids all day.

Catsmere · 17/07/2023 00:12

Diymesss · 14/07/2023 12:00

When my ex-partner and I had relationship counselling, one of his gripes was that I didn't ask other people like his family enough for help when our kids were ill. My reason for not asking for help was that a) they never offered and b) they were both working

The relationship counsellor was an older woman, she told me I was unreasonable and should have been asking others for help when my toddler was ill - even neighbours, as apparently people want to help.

Who all these neighbours were who a) didn't have jobs b) would have had free time to look after a sen toddler with a fever and not worry about getting ill themselves or their children catching it were I'll never know!

Gawd, I'd have hit the roof if the neighbours with small children in years past had asked that of my mother or me.

memoriesofamiga · 16/07/2023 23:38

I was a single parent for years, and built up my circle of friends who were mostly also single parents. We didn't tend to do reciprocal play dates etc as none of us was dating, but we got together for days out so the kids had playmates. It worked well.

But when I moved in with my long term partner, something shifted. I had one friend in particular who started to ask favours as though I was her backup parent, with the expectation that because my partner might be at home (she never asked if he was, he worked FT as did I), that I could leave my own kids for example at midnight to look after her sleeping kids as she needed to go to A&E - I was getting these calls at least once a month. It was getting ridiculous. I backed off and she stopped contacting me. There are pisstakers that ruin it for everyone.

XelaM · 16/07/2023 23:34

In 15 years I have NEVER done childcare swapping or anything like that with another parent. I don't know anyone that actually does do anything like that, people tend to rely on family (many are lucky enough to have family) not other parents.

Me! I do this 🤷‍♀️ But I'm always happy to pick-up/drop-off my kid's friends from school or to mutual activities or to birthday parties when I can and never say "no" to anyone coming over unless we're away. For example it's absolutely no extra effort for me to pick up an extra kid from school and drop them to an activity that my daughter also does. I don't see it as an onerous favour and other parents drop my kid off if they're going the same way. I'm a single working mum (although I wfh a lot) and my family are abroad.

PurpleButterflyWings · 16/07/2023 23:27

Archeron · 16/07/2023 23:12

I tried to barter childcare over the summer and everyone was like “sorry but I’m mostly at work and when I’m off work we’re going away”.

Sounds like these people have been bitten before by cheeky fuckers and people mugging them off, and trying to palm their kids onto them, and like with the parents in MY scenario, never wanted to have their kids over.

Archeron · 16/07/2023 23:12

I tried to barter childcare over the summer and everyone was like “sorry but I’m mostly at work and when I’m off work we’re going away”.