Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take DS4 to a funeral?

59 replies

mumtorn · 14/07/2023 09:00

My elderly aunt has died and her funeral is next week. It is important to me that I go.

I cannot get childcare for DS, is it inappropriate to take him?

He has had quite a few questions surrounding death recently and is quite worried about the fact everyone dies one day.

Should I sit this one out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pottedpalm · 15/07/2023 07:54

Take him; four is old enough to sit quietly for that long. No device and headphones though. Sit at the back and go out if necessary.
At our Catholic church very young children quickly become accustomed to being quiet for an hour at Mass. They usually have books/colouring, a doll
or quiet toy and a few sweets and with hymns and a lot of getting up and down they cope and it is a regular event

booksandbrooks · 15/07/2023 06:47

I don't think its disrespectful to use devices for a small child in this instance - it's a good compromise. Maybe don't set hm up from the start and if it's too much get them out quickly and discreetly.

I took my toddler to to one and my dad just slipped out with her when they were noisy.
I was pregnant with a toddler and many people said what a nice reminder of life going on and such.

MerelyPlaying · 15/07/2023 00:13

Take him. Funerals are for everyone, and death is part of life. Sit near the back and be prepared to slip out if he gets noisy. Absolutely fine to take a tablet, phone or toy to keep him occupied and quiet. The close family will be seated at the front, facing forward and listening to the vicar/celebrant, they're not going to be turning round to see what you're up to. They'll be delighted afterwards to see you there and to know that you cared enough to come.

I'm a funeral celebrant and I'm used to seeing children at funerals, as long as they're not noisy I don't care if they play, sit on the floor, pull faces or do whatever, I'm the only person facing that way who sees them. I've even had mothers breastfeeding during a service. Life goes on.

UsingChangeofName · 15/07/2023 00:00

I wouldn't (didn't, when my dc were that age).

I've been to a lot of funerals, over the decades, to funerals of people I've know from different things I've belonged to, so loads of funerals where I might not know the family well, as well, obviously as my own family funerals, and I so rarely see any dc at funerals, other than teens, that I am always surprised on MN at how many people would take them. I know we are all different, hence me mentioning the number of funerals I've been to at different venues and with a plethora of different families, and the fact it is astonishingly rare to see small dc at any of them.

nocoolnamesleft · 14/07/2023 23:44

In my extended family, children always go to funerals. Because they are family occasions.

Mummyof287 · 14/07/2023 23:39

I wouldn't....not because he shouldn't be exposed to the concept of death in an age appropriate way, but because I think the environment is too much for a 4yo.My DD was 4.5 when her grandad (my father) died.She didn't have a really close relationship with him though, and the funeral was a sombre and heavily religious affair, so we sent her to school (she was asked her opinion too and agreed she wanted to go to school) then took her to the graveside burial the next day instead for closure.She is a livewire and would likely have got bored and difficult, and the way I was feeling I wouldn't have coped well with managing her challenging behaviour/ supporting her emotionally whilst falling to pieces myself. Some people probably thought it strange she wasn't there (DH came and I took 3wk old DD2 as she was so tiny) but whilst I second guessed my decision abit after, I know it was probably the right one in that situation.It's different if its someone they are very close to.

transformandriseup · 14/07/2023 22:57

Our DD4 often plays up when we are out but recently went to her first funeral and sat through the service without noice. We did bring the tablet but didn't need it as DD was in awe of what was going on around her. If she had been noisy we would have just waited outside but in our family children usual attend funerals so she was always going to come.

Twelveisthebestnumber · 14/07/2023 22:46

It also all depends on the mood of the funeral. Whilst obviously many are incredibly somber and sad occasions not all are. My beloved Dad's funeral was literally a celebration of a life well lived. I planned it as such. People were requested to wear summery, happy clothes. We had the happiest church service with applause, clapping and so much laughter. Afterwards we had a huge garden party at my Mum's house with a pig roast and everyone got smashed while remembering my amazing and wonderful Dad. Your son would have been most welcome, even on a silly day. But then I guess our family have always been a bit weird!! If it's not this sort of funeral, then as a church goer, I would say if you are concerned then tuck yourselves in behind a pillar or settled comfortably behind a pew, take the headphones and device and pop them on if needed. I certainly wouldn't care and would find it respectful that somebody cared enough to come and make sure the service wasn't interrupted.

useless1000 · 14/07/2023 22:35

Take him, sit at the back for easy escape- dole out raisins one at a time

Adropofink · 14/07/2023 17:29

I would take him, it’s important to you that you go and the atmosphere and other people will impact on how he behaves in my experience. You can always take him out for a few minutes if he starts to struggle. Go and pay your respects and explain to him what to expect and how to behave beforehand.

SirVixofVixHall · 14/07/2023 17:29

ScarlettSunset · 14/07/2023 09:03

I've always taken my child to funerals. They are part of life and I find it strange that children are often excluded from them.

Same here, I have taken my children to quite a few funerals. Dd was almost two at her first one (her great grandmother). In my experience older people at funerals love to see babies and fuss over them afterwards at the funeral tea.

neilyoungismyhero · 14/07/2023 17:29

I took my little boy to his great grandma's funeral. He was about 2 and a half- he didn't know what was going on I don't think and he was very good. It was a small ceremony.

Cuwins · 14/07/2023 17:28

MRex · 14/07/2023 09:04

Ask your great aunt's closest family, some people dislike children going to funerals. It's ok for your son to have questions, and to keep having questions, death is part of life and something we all need to learn to accept at some point.

This is the key to me. How do her closest family feel about it?

londonrach · 14/07/2023 17:26

Ask the person who organised the funeral what they what but I certainly be happy to take a 4 year old. I wouldn't take a baby or toddler but past 3 is sensible..and host ok with it...yes. death is part of life. I'm very sorry for your loss. X

mondaytosunday · 14/07/2023 17:20

My kids were 3 and 5 for my dads funeral and were fine. I did not take them to the lunch after as they would have been bored.

SoShallINever · 14/07/2023 17:16

I think the people saying that a device and headphones are disrespectful aren't regular Church goers.
You do what works for you OP and no one will judge. I go to both Catholic and high Anglican services and there's always kids looking at an ipad or watching peppa pig on a parents phone.

QueenOfWeeds · 14/07/2023 17:08

Not exactly what you asked, but can I suggest that you let the nursery know so that they can be ready if he has questions for them?

Sorry for your loss.

LlynTegid · 14/07/2023 17:05

Sorry for your loss.

I think go with your son, ensure he knows there is some reward for being quiet during the service, which may help.

sillysmiles · 14/07/2023 16:55

@Reddog1
My great aunts and uncles would not have approved of children at funerals, although I would add that they were all born around 1915 so were the generation above your late relative and her widower/siblings.

I find the differences in attitudes to funerals and customs between England and Ireland fascinating. Do you know why it would have not been approved of?

Toooldtocareanymore · 14/07/2023 16:40

This is your aunt, these people are your family and they will understand, you want to be there and this is what it takes, I disagree with those that say you cant bring a device or a bag with some quiet toy -a book a snack in it, its not being disrespectful he is 4 , no one who matters will care, you're hardly going to sit front and center , if he isn't behaving take a few mins outside. When my child was this age her grandmother often brought her to funerals, if she was minding her, she was well able to understand her grandmothers instructions to behave and shed get an ice cream after.

Reddog1 · 14/07/2023 16:39

What do her immediate family, particularly the oldest ones, think? My great aunts and uncles would not have approved of children at funerals, although I would add that they were all born around 1915 so were the generation above your late relative and her widower/siblings. My parents’ generation (wartime born, so probably your great aunt’s age) were more relaxed but I still think that crayons and gadgets would have been a no-no.

Yet, in Irish families it’s always been the norm to include youngsters.

There’s no ”right” answer. If you’re unsure, ask a family member who’s likely to be honest.

condolences.

CopperSeahorses · 14/07/2023 16:29

Sit near the back and slip out if you need to? Three under 3s came to DH's funeral, you wouldn't have known they were there, for some reason they all sat beautifully with their adults and barely made a sound.

CrystalPalaceAlice · 14/07/2023 16:26

A 4 year old recently attended a funeral that I was at. I was a bit surprised to begin with but when another family member never turned up as they had no one to look after their kids I didn’t get why they couldn’t just bring them. I’d take him, at least you will get a chance to go.

fridaynight1 · 14/07/2023 16:22

Sorry for your loss.

My children went to funerals. They were fine, I think children instinctively know when to be quiet - even little ones. Talking about it years later they have all said they were glad they had the chance to say goodbye.

I think you should go. During the service you could sit at the back and make a quiet exit if they do become unsettled. And afterwards at the wake - I think most people will be relieved that the service is over. I don't know your family but if anything like mine, having a child in the room will probably be a welcome distraction.

landoflostcontent · 14/07/2023 16:06

I do think children should attend funerals, this might sound calculating but it is another rite of passage for them to learn and probably better when the deceased is not a very close relative. I cannot imagine having to cope with ones first funeral when it is a parent, partner or sibling. Having said that 4 years old is an age when they become aware of (and can obsess about) death. So really I have been no help at all but on balance I would take him

Swipe left for the next trending thread