Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Headteachers should drive to the homes of absent pupils and get them into school

346 replies

Amuseaboosh · 14/07/2023 07:54

Headteachers "have a duty" to drive to the homes of absent pupils and bring them into school, the education secretary has said.

Gillian Keegan said levels of absence in schools were now "a crisis," with recent figures revealing that 125,000 pupils spent more time out of class than in.

I know how very lucky I am to have never had to cope with any of my children not wanting to go to school.
However, I'm not so ignorant that I believe that all the parents dealing with this issue haven't tried absolutely everything to get their child into school. Where is ANY member of teaching staff supposed to find the time to attend to 125,000 pupils in person to get them to come to school?

AIBU in thinking Gillian is out of touch and ignorant? Or can someone see wisdom here that I cannot?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 14/07/2023 09:55

megletthesecond · 14/07/2023 08:15

DD is on 70%. Her head would need body armour and a hotline to CAMHS / police to get her in on days she refuses.

If the government want to help then fund schools and CAMHS properly.

Quite!

Friend's son hasn't been to school for nearly 6 years.

He's been waiting for a CAMHS assessment for 6.5 years. Finally got a date for September, having been moved up a tier after a massive intervention by a very supportive GP.

Anonymouseposter · 14/07/2023 09:54

most of these absentee children will be in a certain kind of household Well that shows how little you know. Much more complicated than that.

Dulra · 14/07/2023 09:54

Is it the job of the school though? I am Irish so possibly a different system but if absences here are over 20 days in a school year they are referred to the Education welfare officers who deal with it.

Sirzy · 14/07/2023 09:53

Perhaps if parents didn’t have to fight so long fighting for diagnosis and support for children then less would struggle with school attendance.

perhaps if schools had proper funding to support pupils with the right measures for the individuals there would be less issues.

if EHCPs where proper written and the support in them provided there would be less issues.

if we had more alternative provisions available there would be less issues

if schools listened to the families instead of judging there would be less issues.

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 09:52

Most of these absentee children will be at a certain kind of household where a teacher turning up (probably alone because resource!) will be subject to a torrent of verbal abuse at best.

Good grief have you not read the posts on this thread?

Many many households with school refusing children are not like this at all.

Stop being so ignorant.

CactusDreams · 14/07/2023 09:52

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 09:03

The education secretary needs to be looking at why schools are such a traumatising place for many children to be.

Over testing in primary schools has a lot to answer for and can make intelligent children with SEN feel stupid. Add to that over crowded class rooms and poor behaviour management which makes children feel sensory overload. Children don't have the same access to sport, music and imaginative play because of funding cuts. Children who struggle educationally are kept in at break time to 'catch up' rather than being allowed to play.

I have experience of school refusal. My son, when he was 10 at the time, tried to kill himself because school was such a terrifying prospect. A teacher coming over wouldn't have solved that it would have made it worse.

Fast forward 7 years of learning in a suitable environment, (our home), an autism and dyslexia diagnosis and medication for anxiety, and he has just very successfully finished year 12 in a mainstream 6th form and has done so well he is applying to Oxford University.

There are so many assumptions about school refusal. It destroys lives. Most school refusal is entirely down to failures to identify SEN and lack of specialist provision.

I am so sorry you went through that.

Thank you for sharing your story though, that just triggered a lot of unexpected tears for me (in a good way, I think!) when I read your ending, as it actually gave me hope that my DD will eventually succeed and will recover from what the school environment did to her.

afterdropshock · 14/07/2023 09:51

This already happens in many schools.

Hibiscrubbed · 14/07/2023 09:51

There isn’t a thing she says that’s of value. She’s a blind Tory stooge who does as she’s told.

Howls · 14/07/2023 09:49

I’d have thought a HT would be putting themselves at unnecessary risk doing this. Most of these absentee children will be at a certain kind of household where a teacher turning up (probably alone because resource!) will be subject to a torrent of verbal abuse at best.

What a judgemental and ignorant comment!
“Certain type of household”? ODFOD.

Willmafrockfit · 14/07/2023 09:48

that might take all day!

wonderinglywondering · 14/07/2023 09:48

interesting how they’re all of a sudden keen on kids being in school after stopping them for 2 years for lockdowns.

Lockdown caused my daughter to develop severe separation anxiety, and she struggles going into school now. You reap what you sow. They don’t have a leg to stand on after party gate.

Headteachers have more than enough to deal with without this. And they could try improving mental health assistance for both adults and kids, which would help to solve the problem but they’re all pretending the lockdowns had no effect so they won’t bother.

Phos · 14/07/2023 09:46

I’d have thought a HT would be putting themselves at unnecessary risk doing this. Most of these absentee children will be at a certain kind of household where a teacher turning up (probably alone because resource!) will be subject to a torrent of verbal abuse at best.

That said there needs to be mechanisms for checking up on kids who haven’t turned up for safeguarding reasons. Especially at primary. I worked at a school where there was a rapid escalation route to the police following an incident where a child was found alone with the bodies of their parents who had ODd at night.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 14/07/2023 09:46

This is the classic mistake of jumping to solution (an unworkable and likely ineffective, costly and inefficient solution) without first understanding ‘why’. Why has absence increased?

I work with children and young people in a professional capacity and have for 30 years, and the answer to that question is complex.

The reasons why absence starts to increase and what then maintains and exacerbates it are multiple and complex and involve all layers of the system; within child factors, parent factors, family system factors, teacher factors, school factors and wider societal factors.

OneInEight · 14/07/2023 09:46

Oh good. The headteacher can get kicked instead of the parent. Of course then the pupil will be excluded & be off school anyway. Bit pointless really.

CactusDreams · 14/07/2023 09:45

I had a ”school refuser” and used to force her into the car in the mornings and peel her off me, while she was still crying, to make her go in with a staff member.

School said “

Academically capable, just anxious/she is trying to control you/be firm/she is fine when you are gone etc”

She then had a sudden and severe mental breakdown. At 8 years old. I didn’t think we were going to come back from it and she seemed to have psychosis at points. She couldn’t go to school.

School - their attitude towards me was disgusting. More advice that I needed to be firm, “she has to come in”. Muttering about unauthorised attendance.

Luckily DD was fast tracked to CAMHS and they did NOT agree with the “force her in” approach. There is lots of evidence that this causes trauma and makes school fear and avoidance worse.

DD recovered when out of school. She was then diagnosed with autism and some specific learning difficulties, and eventually things started to make sense.

In that early period, I had no support from school as they were so so focused on attendance and just didn’t want to see or believed what DD was going through and what was happening for us as a family. Luckily we were able to pay for professional support and some legal advice, and they backed right down, eventually.

Lots of families do not have that though. And a LOT of autistic DC are out of school. I’ve met so many families with such similar stories, having to fight school and local authorities to get suitable and safe education for their DC, while unable to work as their DC aren’t in education.

The last things these families need is more blame !

The thought of a headteacher coming to our home, to DD’s safe space to tell her to come to school, I can only imagine that impact that would have had 😔

WestwardHo1 · 14/07/2023 09:44

This government shut schools for months and gave the impression that in person schooling didn't matter. And now they appear to be astonished by the entirely predictable results.

As if Headteachers don't have enough to do.

Howls · 14/07/2023 09:42

*School accused us

Howls · 14/07/2023 09:41

Ds school refused for months. School acceded is of not trying, the EWO literally hissed at us in a meeting to “just get him in”. At the time we couldn’t get near him. If we entered his room he attacked us.
School threatened to fine us, take us to court etc.
Not once did they stop and try to meet his needs.

Education has become a farce. More children than ever are having mental health crises. Schools/the government keep piling the pressure on to already stressed out children. I support teacher strikes, but if teachers decided to strike to change the system for the benefit of the children’s well-being I’d be there on the picket line handing out cakes and tea!

More and more people are home educating. If the HE groups on FB are anything to go by, more teachers are home educating because they don’t want their children learning in that environment.

In contrast my youngest is in a school with does their utmost to meet his needs and make sure he’s comfortable in school - sensory issues with school clothes? Wear tracksuit bottoms. Can’t cope with all the lessons? Do your work with the pastoral care team. DS’s attendance is 90% so not amazing, but it feels miraculous, and is all down to school’s willingness to make every reasonable adjustment they possibly can. Older DS’s school didn’t acknowledge his disability at all and set him up to fail.

Children do well if they can.

ZittiEBuoni · 14/07/2023 09:39

When I was doing my PGCE I work shadowed an Education Welfare Officer for a week. This was their job. Don't they exist any more? Has Keegan not heard of these people?

Anaemiafog · 14/07/2023 09:39

DD has CHD and was often ill. She still maintained an attendance of over 90%. One morning I forgot to call in and they turned up just as we were leaving for school around 10.30am. She'd had a heart stress test at the hospital so had to come home to change.

AlisonDonut · 14/07/2023 09:34

Hows about making school a pleasant and interesting place to be in, where girls aren't risking being rapor sexually harassed in the toilets, and kids aren't being lied to, and behaviour management is rewarded not punished and the teachers are given the tools to actually teach facts not fiction?

It's a start Gillian. I wouldn't be going to school to be confronted with that shitshow either.

BramblyHedge · 14/07/2023 09:33

People here and in media who say parents should face benefits sanctions of their kids don't go to school...that is displaying quite a bit of prejudice. My son is only partially attending due to mental health/ASD reasons. We are two professional working parents, reasonable incomes and he is in a state grammar school. His school has enough absent children that it was with having a coffee and information morning for the parents. It isn't just the 'poor kids' who are absent. This can happen to anyone, no matter their background or privilege. I'd never in a million years have thought we were the type of family to have a son who was long term absent from school but we are and it has made me question my own prejudices. To anyone who hasn't been in this situation, don't be too sure about 'what you would do' - sometimes there is actually nothing which works.

ExtraOnions · 14/07/2023 09:30

Then fund CAMHS properly
Then fund SENCO & Pastoral Care properly
and Bring back Vocational Pathways to high schools

If you have every lived with a teenager with Emotional Based School Avoidance (school refuser is such a horrible term) … the thought that a teacher could turn up and your children were suddenly compliant, is hilarious

Comedycook · 14/07/2023 09:29

The government has such a fucking cheek. Closing the schools to our children for months on end...then expecting kids in this country to retain their enthusiasm for education and have zero anxiety around it. Makes me sick. My ds was an incredibly enthusiastic year seven when covid hit. Endless disruption, isolation, masks in classrooms...my ds never got his enthusiasm back. He used to love school. I'm lucky that he willingly goes in every day but he hates it.

Oh and before anyone has a go at me, I have no problems with teachers...they are absolute heroes, but I will never forgive the government for what they did to the kids in this country.

Qilin · 14/07/2023 09:28

Many schools already do this, where appropriate.
Not all persistent absence needs that approach - schools often have information to help support them in knowing when it may be a useful intervention and when it won't help. Other measures can be put in place to help if that's the case.

School staff turning up can and does work for some cases, in other situations it can make matters worse.

I work in primary these days so it's very different to secondary and the approaches will also be different.

School staff DO usually care about the education and welfare of their pupils. School attendance figures, day to day, are irrelevant to most teaching staff, ime, it's the reason behind those absences that we care about,