Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Headteachers should drive to the homes of absent pupils and get them into school

346 replies

Amuseaboosh · 14/07/2023 07:54

Headteachers "have a duty" to drive to the homes of absent pupils and bring them into school, the education secretary has said.

Gillian Keegan said levels of absence in schools were now "a crisis," with recent figures revealing that 125,000 pupils spent more time out of class than in.

I know how very lucky I am to have never had to cope with any of my children not wanting to go to school.
However, I'm not so ignorant that I believe that all the parents dealing with this issue haven't tried absolutely everything to get their child into school. Where is ANY member of teaching staff supposed to find the time to attend to 125,000 pupils in person to get them to come to school?

AIBU in thinking Gillian is out of touch and ignorant? Or can someone see wisdom here that I cannot?

OP posts:
Wheresthebeach · 14/07/2023 10:26

Its absurd to have HT and Deputies doing this. They have so much work to do anyway.

I'm afraid it needs to go back to the system when I was a kid (when the dinosaurs roamed the Earth) and Truant Officers employed to round up the kids and talk to the families. They will be best place to then report issues to SS if it's neglect, or help families where needed.

unicornhair · 14/07/2023 10:23

I think the government need to admit their part in this mess. I know they won’t.

DDs primary did nothing in lockdown, sent out a bunch of sheets from twinkle twice (didn’t want them back) and that was it. They did open for key workers but very few parents worked, and it was only a few TAs in.
Basically they gave permission to be home and do nothing. I’ve met others whose schools were the same.
We have free hours to get small children into the routine of getting into school and learning. Then just totally broke the routine. We talk about learning loss in the summer holidays- how about 6 months.

They then made classrooms unpleasant places with open windows and masks. how are children meant to have a positive reaction to education.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 14/07/2023 10:22

JustanothermagicMonday1

You are right about the underlying causes for absenteeism needing sorting first. I’m not sure I agree with your categorisation but there are multiple within child/family factors.

There are also the wider system factors: schools are now huge - it’s much harder for teachers to build good, trusting relationships with all the kids. Adult to child ratios don’t allow for sufficient oversight. The impact of lockdown. Huge gaps in learning and now teachers are having to adapt what they would usually do. The culture of the school - are the teachers happy and well supported. Is there a culture of kindness and support? Are the teachers resourced enough to individualise teaching to meet different needs?

So many things can influence this issue. But, I agree that we need to first understand the causes and then address them - sending HTs out will not make a difference and is a very costly waste of time.

DandelionBurdockAndGin · 14/07/2023 10:21

Hehasasecretfriend · 14/07/2023 09:09

I'm a teacher of teenagers. One particular student regularly misses my class which is after lunch. I have called his mother and brought it up at the PT meeting. Her response was yes he frequently just wants to watch TV after lunch and moans about going back. She can't do anything about it so can I stand at the school gates and remind him as he's leaving to come back.

The majority of parents do their utmost but there are some (particularly in our area) who love to blame the teachers for everything.

I wouldn't have believed this till I saw a parent in front of me essentially tell primary school staff that her son who'd run off instead of getting in car was their issue as it was school hours now.

There may have been some complex back story but mother wasn't visibly upset seemed bit taken aback that everyone in reception was a bit stunned by her attitude and she made it clear she was going shopping - not rushing to work or looking for the child - around 8 - and she thought informing school staff was enough.

Pronouncements like this embolden few parents that are like this - and rest it doesn't help it's not address why this is happening - either reasons at home or school - and ignores that many schools who do try this anyway with looking at above posts with very mixed success. It offers no help school refusers or their parents who clearly feel very alone and unsupported.

Roselilly36 · 14/07/2023 10:20

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 14/07/2023 08:20

If any head teacher has a magic wand that can usher a 6foot teen into school against their will can I have one too please? Heads are not fairy godmothers!

Exactly, no way on earth would I have been able to get either of my DS’s to school if they refused.

Thankfully I didn’t have that problem, must be very difficult situation to find yourself in.

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 10:19

Howls · 14/07/2023 10:15

I’d hazard a guess that families so chaotic they cannot get children to school have undiagnosed SN as well, and need support, not blame and punishments.

I think this is true, also unchaotic families can become chaotic when a child gets to the point of non attendance.

My child slept in a tent in our living room for weeks and didn't change his clothes. To the outside observer we were chaotic. The reality was we were in survival mode.

hiredandsqueak · 14/07/2023 10:18

Dd was out of school for two years. In our LA if you have an EHCP then you are outside of the remit for educational welfare. I did force the LA to provide tutors and CAMHS signed her off sick. Didn't stop the school trying to force her back into school to protect the attenance figures by calling meetings to discuss reintergration with everyone but CAMHS invited. These only stopped when I invited CAMHS myself to attend.
School did turn up once unannounced, they believed I should be more forceful, I told them that if they didn't make an appointment they wouldn't be gaining entry and sent them away. They never made an appointment or turned up again.
Dd never went back to the school she couldn't attend but went happily to independent specialist that I secured through Tribunal process.

Howls · 14/07/2023 10:15

I’d hazard a guess that families so chaotic they cannot get children to school have undiagnosed SN as well, and need support, not blame and punishments.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 14/07/2023 10:14

Phos · Today 09:46
I’d have thought a HT would be putting themselves at unnecessary risk doing this. Most of these absentee children will be at a certain kind of household where a teacher turning up (probably alone because resource!) will be subject to a torrent of verbal abuse at best.

Having worked with children and families for 30 years, I can tell you clearly and confidently that there is no ‘certain kind of household’. The reasons for absence and school refusal are multi-factorial and complex. Your comment is judgemental, ignorant and stereotyping.

BluNomad · 14/07/2023 10:13

My situation doesn’t involve mh however I had a serious accident & was physically unable to get my dc to school on certain days, I was unable to walk let alone drive or use public transport. The school treated me horrendously about keeping dc off school, despite knowing my circumstances they were unwilling to help in any way & the head teacher kept bleating on about how it affects overall school attendance..I asked him what he suggests to which he told me it’s not his problem or responsibility to solve, maybe if I made more mum friends I wouldn’t have this problem! Appalling man & appalling teacher

JustanothermagicMonday1 · 14/07/2023 10:12

There are different categories of children who don’t attend much:

  1. severe mental health issues and anxiety, especially in teens: this is where underfunding children’s services and NHS in that regard are to blame as well as the situation being even worse post pandemic

  2. chaotic families, usually in poverty: different issues, need social services support - carrot rather than stick. If school is where there is food, play, free after school club provided - that would help

  3. children with undiagnosed SEN, those who should be in special school or those who are not properly supported in main stream - school funding/staffing to blame - ties in with 1

  4. bullied children who are traumatised by school - some actually need therapy

  5. lazy parents on benefits, substance abuse (drugs/alcohol etc) who cannot be arsed to get kids up and dressed. Older kids in that category following in footsteps. Kids learn from their parents.

  6. kids who just get physically ill a lot

Keegan needs to treat the underlying issues first. Treat the cause not the symptoms.

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 10:11

But I read it as directed at chaotic families who struggle to be organised enough to get their kids to school every day for whatever reason, not school refusers.

The problem is that the school can't really tell which applies.

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 10:09

Sirzy · 14/07/2023 09:57

In theory if a student is absent for 15 days in an academic year (don’t need to be consecutive) then the LA is supposed to step in and ensure that they are still receiving some sort of education (hospital school, tutors etc) but in reality that never seems to happen

Yes this should happen.

The duty is on the LA not the school and a complaint needs to be made under s. 19 of the Education Act 1996 if it isn't done. Normally this is ignored and a second tier complaint can be made and then you can take the LA to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman.

At the same time if the child does not have an EHCP you can ask for a needs assessment. The fact that the child is struggling to attend school is enough of a trigger but again the LA may refuse so you may need to appeal.

It might be that the child's needs are better met in a special school or ASD unit. It may be, and was in the case of my child, that they are too traumatised for any formal environment.

IPSEA is a good source of support - www.ipsea.org.uk

(IPSEA) Independent Provider of Special Education Advice

IPSEA offers independent legally based advice, support and training to help get the right education for children and young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).

http://www.ipsea.org.uk

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/07/2023 10:06

Lullibyebye · 14/07/2023 08:04

The primary school I work at has about 3 regular school refusers so the deputy head goes and gets them when they refuse to come in. The deputy is soooo busy and it means there is less support at school when there are extreme behaviour issues but it really means a lot to those families who are struggling to get their children to school so they can get to work.

You have to be joking?

Forcing an EBSA to school makes it worse. My dd self harmed in this position. Do you know what drives EBSA? It’s predominately ND kids in NT schools. Where’s the support for that instead of dragging them in?

My A* ASD Dd in Y 12 has refused to go to school since Easter. She’s in autistic burnout. Can’t cope with all the sensory and social demands. How is forcing her into school going to solve that?

Its a bloody nightmare to deal with, lm so stressed.

NOTANUM · 14/07/2023 10:06

Most Mumsnetters have jumped to the conclusion that this is an attack on parents with school refusers or kids with MH challenges.

But I read it as directed at chaotic families who struggle to be organised enough to get their kids to school every day for whatever reason, not school refusers. These are the very kids who may find school a refuge with routines, friendly adults who may serve as role models and hot meals every day. Doing everything possible to get the kids into school is a good thing.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/07/2023 10:05

tfresh · 14/07/2023 08:47

> Not all parents will have tried everything. Some of them will have tried nothing.

Op being extremely generous in their original post. Benefit sanctions for your kids not going to school seems reasonable to me. Might take a chunk out of the problem

I'm not sure why you would assume benefit sanctions would help. Ignorant comment.

These issues affect children across the whole of society and often in affluent families.

Theft · 14/07/2023 10:02

"However, I'm not so ignorant that I believe that all the parents dealing with this issue haven't tried absolutely everything to get their child into school. "

I don't even understand this sentence, too many double negatives. Do you think parents have tried everything or they haven't???

lifeturnsonadime · 14/07/2023 10:01

CactusDreams · 14/07/2023 09:52

I am so sorry you went through that.

Thank you for sharing your story though, that just triggered a lot of unexpected tears for me (in a good way, I think!) when I read your ending, as it actually gave me hope that my DD will eventually succeed and will recover from what the school environment did to her.

I just read your post and it resonated with me as I think my DS and your DD have had similar experiences.

My son went through periods of psychosis too, he was trying to jump out of windows etc. He would have rather been dead than go to school.

Keep going. Anxiety meds have really worked for DS, sometimes children with autism produce less serotonin naturally than neuro-typical children.

My DS is absolutely fine now, I would never have believe it possible as recently as 18 months ago.

BungleandGeorge · 14/07/2023 10:00

As with most things they really need to butt out and let the professionals work in a solution. And it needs to be a radical solution to increase wellbeing and Sen support. If a loving and committed parent can’t sort the problem I’m afraid a headteacher has little chance.

Catspyjamas17 · 14/07/2023 10:00

I feel a letter coming on, as a parent of once of these children.

RenegadeMrs · 14/07/2023 09:59

This type of stupidity just makes me think 'No one really thinks this. Gillian doesn't really think this, what other bullshit are they trying to hide from us today?'. And then I go round in circles of self doubt about whether I'm overly cynical or not.

Sirzy · 14/07/2023 09:57

Dulra · 14/07/2023 09:54

Is it the job of the school though? I am Irish so possibly a different system but if absences here are over 20 days in a school year they are referred to the Education welfare officers who deal with it.

In theory if a student is absent for 15 days in an academic year (don’t need to be consecutive) then the LA is supposed to step in and ensure that they are still receiving some sort of education (hospital school, tutors etc) but in reality that never seems to happen

Waffle78 · 14/07/2023 09:56

One of our teachers did this when a friend of mine didn't turn up for an exam. She had missed that much school the education authority refused to pay for her to take her exams. Our head of year paid for her to take them. I know back then 93/94 it was £15 for each exam. She is the third out of 5 siblings. So this teacher had been involved with this family for years. She knew the family circumstances. But her and another one of her siblings are the only ones who work full time. She is the only one who owns her own home. She retired when we left I'm sure she would be proud of her if she knew what she's achieved I am.

Emmelina · 14/07/2023 09:56

A teacher dropped by to check up on my autistic daughter, then 8, who had school refused that day.

The teacher got a half committal grunt from my daughter’s position under her desk with her blankets and fairy lights on. They took my word from then about school refusal days and just call part way through the day now to check in!

BibbleandSqwauk · 14/07/2023 09:56

@Jujubes5 and @Gateappreciation it's not about making it fun or not fun, or choosing whether to come to school. It's not a choice the child is making in many cases. My DD was bored rigid at home, hated it, desperately wanted to go in and be in class, be with her friends, but literally couldn't get out the car. School were hopeless, absolutely did not get it and said she was being rude and naughty. Their EOW came out..totally pointless as I knew if would be. Her counselor that I was paying £40 a session for met us at school one morning to try, no luck.
I had no idea how paralyzingly terrifying it is to be in this situation. I work, I was missing work, cutting corners, risking my job. To be fair CAHMS "early help" did contact me but by then I had taken the decision to put her in a private school (which I know is not an option for all and frankly is not really affordable for me but I'll take on debt as she needs it). They allowed her so much more flexibility for a period of time until she healed and is now thriving. I had no idea the depth of EBSA and having to try and persuade school, family and ex that she was ill, not choosing this, was awful. Turning off the WiFi, making being at home a "punishment" is not the answer.