Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd grumpy at me but I think her lack of communication is to blame.

142 replies

BarbiewhupsSindy · 14/07/2023 01:38

Dd2 and I joined DD1 for long awaited fantastic concert tonight.

Let's say DD2 and I live in Bristol (she's 19 on a gap year, lives at home). DD1 let's say lives in Birmingham - 25, lived there since she finished University, very settled in her own flat, good job, just returns home occasionally for the odd night.

We liaised tonight at a music concert in Oxford.

I drove DD2 up there, DD1 hopped on the train and met us there, we had lovely supper and concert, finished the concert and went to say our goodbyes, when DD1 dropped the bombshell that she'd decided to come home with us for the night, and she'd WFH (our home) and then catch the train back tomorrow evening.

Well all good, and dandy, except I didn't have space for her in the car 😭.

She didn't want to get the late train back as it would involve an hour wait and then a 15 minute walk at approx 1am through the city, or an uber.

So I arranged for a late check in at a hotel in Oxford for her because I felt guilty that I couldn't accommodate her wishes.

She went off in a snit muttering about wanting to spend time with her younger siblings and pets, see her childhood friend, and I've prevented that by not being able to get her back to Bristol.

She has form for holding a grudge, so I'm wondering how long this wobbly will last.

YABU you should have anticipated her prodigal return.

YANBU she should have communicated with you that she'd be returned to Bristol after the concert.

😬

OP posts:
BarbiewhupsSindy · 14/07/2023 10:22

Willmafrockfit · 14/07/2023 06:39

what a shame she didnt say in advance

That's exactly it! So simple. But I guess when you're so familiar with someone, you know you're welcome, there's no need.

She probably thought "oh what a nice surprise for mom, she'll be chuffed" without thinking of the logistics.🥲

OP posts:
BarbiewhupsSindy · 14/07/2023 10:20

StinkyWizzleteets · 14/07/2023 04:00

Aww I really feel for your daughter. You all had a good time together and she felt close
to you all and realised how much she was missing you all by being so far away and wanted to hang out with you all a while. 25 may be an adult bit we all revert to children with out parents and you told one child
she couldn’t come to your home because
you could t fit her in the car. Unless
you’d surprised her with a tiny 2 seater sporty number she didn’t know you owned, I can’t see how it was so impossible.

it was kind of you to offer a hotel room but I get the feeling it was more about the sense
of family and belonging for her than just not wanting to go home. The rejection she’ll be feeling right now will be quite immense

No it wasn't a spur of the moment familial sentiment that made her decide to head home, she'd already planned to come back a couple of days before. She just hasn't communicated it, I guess as she knows she's always welcome, so why tell us would have been her thought process.

OP posts:
MasterBeth · 14/07/2023 10:20

If she knows you have a two-seater car, she's at fault for not asking you to bring the bigger one if she was expecting to come home with you. Obviously.

BarbiewhupsSindy · 14/07/2023 10:17

Hullo sorry for not replying till now, was an exhausting day yesterday and I've just finished school run etc.

Yes I was in our 2 seater 😂 no way could she have crammed in.

We've had a 2 seater for a couple of years now, and DH and I plan together as to who needs the bigger car and who can cope with the more limited car on a individual journey basis.

Last night I only had to account for one other person (or do I thought) so it made sense for me to take the smaller car.

DD1 knows the situation but I guess as she's away from the daily logistical decisions she didn't plot the transport arrangements into her thinking.

She's arranged on Tuesday to meet childhood friend this evening for a drink, but didn't tell me, otherwise obviously I would have driven the larger car.

The answer other points

She still has her room here left as she likes it, made up so she can pop home very welcomed any time.

She had brought a few items for overnight with her in her laptop bag, which she always has with her. Nothing unusual about her having a bag big enough for overnight with her she carries her laptop everywhere she goes so she can work/surf on trains etc.

She can work from anywhere, secure vpn stuff like that I don't even know, she works in tech, she's got it sorted.

She does sometimes get overwhelmed when plans get scuppered so I think she just over reacted when she realised her vision of the night wasn't as predicted.

Couldn't have had a nice drink after the show and waited for the train as it was 11pm and nowhere really for that.

I'm not sure if I've missed anything. Happy to answer any further points.

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 14/07/2023 10:14

I’m assuming she can’t just log on to her ‘job’ from any random computer that may be floating around at her mum’s house?

Lots of workplaces use systems that can be accessed remotely on any computer that's connected to the internet. You just log on and connect to your employer's network online. My employer provides laptops, but we can also log in from other computers if we need to.

ManateeFair · 14/07/2023 10:05

I mean, she should have told you she wanted to stay over if it was that important to her.

However, unless your car is a two-seater (which I assume it isn't, or DD1 would already have known that there wouldn't be a seat for a second passenger) what on earth have you got in there that you couldn't shift over to clear a space on the back seat?

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/07/2023 10:01

anythinginapinch · 14/07/2023 10:00

Yabu. You excluded dd2 from family life. Yes prior notice would have helped.

Yes it would have allowed the DD to come home. But since she didn't mention it, what was OP actually meant to do?!

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/07/2023 10:00

MyTruthIsOut · 14/07/2023 09:43

Not really relevant but I can’t imagine just deciding at the last minute to go and stay at someone else’s house for the night unless I knew I had a tooth brush and some clean underwear in my handbag 😂

And how was she planning on WFH at her
mum’s house?! Surely all her work laptop, files, books or whatever would be at her own home? I’m assuming she can’t just log on to her ‘job’ from any random computer that may be floating around at her mum’s house?

It all sounds odd.

But I still really, really want to know why she couldn’t fit in the car 😂

I wondered about the laptop too!

anythinginapinch · 14/07/2023 10:00

Yabu. You excluded dd2 from family life. Yes prior notice would have helped.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 14/07/2023 09:58

MyTruthIsOut · 14/07/2023 09:43

Not really relevant but I can’t imagine just deciding at the last minute to go and stay at someone else’s house for the night unless I knew I had a tooth brush and some clean underwear in my handbag 😂

And how was she planning on WFH at her
mum’s house?! Surely all her work laptop, files, books or whatever would be at her own home? I’m assuming she can’t just log on to her ‘job’ from any random computer that may be floating around at her mum’s house?

It all sounds odd.

But I still really, really want to know why she couldn’t fit in the car 😂

As long as she has her phone my dd can use any computer to work from home. She doesn't need work specific software . However she does need to let me know in advance otherwise I need the same computer.

My dc are always welcome but it's courtesy to let people know in advance if only to get food in etc

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/07/2023 09:54

I think the car must've been stuffed full of things. Rather than it being a 2 seater.

Anyway it'll be a lesson learned for the daughter to communicate properly in the future

W1h · 14/07/2023 09:51

Taking you not being able to fit her in the car at face value, though I too am curious...
I'd have offered to give her a lift from the station after I'd dropped off other daughter so she didn't need to walk/uber at 1am. But no, you're not being at all unreasonable.

Although she may have thought it would be a nice surprise for you, so up until the point she refused to get a train and had a flounce I don't really think she was being unreasonable either. (Unless of course you actually could have fit her in the car but you were just making a petty point about communication in which case you're the unreasonable one)

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/07/2023 09:51

I guess kids always think their parents house is theirs and there's always space for them I til they get their own house and get married themselves.

She should have communicated it better 100% but I feel for her because it must've been such a letdown being told she wouldn't fit!

NoSquirrels · 14/07/2023 09:51

Hugasauras · 14/07/2023 06:49

It sounds a bit weird, could you really not have made space for her? Presumably if you have a two-seater she wouldn't have expected a seat, so I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that when two people are coming in a standard car there will be space. But SIBU to be annoyed about it and not have a back-up plan and suck it up and get the late train.

Obviously this. What a weird situation. At 25, meeting my mum & sister who were driving, I’d have assumed I could get a lift back with them too, in their regular sized car. If it turned out my mum had - unbeknownst to me - recently swapped her car for a Smart car, I wouldn’t have expected my mum to pay for a hotel, nor would I have accepted. Weird all round.

Humidititties · 14/07/2023 09:45

Yeah depends on the car really, 2 seater then obviously YWNBU but anything else then I'm sure stuff could be moved, held on laps etc. to accommodate her

MyTruthIsOut · 14/07/2023 09:43

Not really relevant but I can’t imagine just deciding at the last minute to go and stay at someone else’s house for the night unless I knew I had a tooth brush and some clean underwear in my handbag 😂

And how was she planning on WFH at her
mum’s house?! Surely all her work laptop, files, books or whatever would be at her own home? I’m assuming she can’t just log on to her ‘job’ from any random computer that may be floating around at her mum’s house?

It all sounds odd.

But I still really, really want to know why she couldn’t fit in the car 😂

Scienceadvisory · 14/07/2023 09:42

Twyford · 14/07/2023 09:38

Why was it a 'bombshell' that she fancied coming back to her home and see the rest of her family.

Communicating that decision late at night on the night you expect to be accommodated is a bit of a bombshell, isn't it? How does she necessarily know that a bed is available or that there will be facilities for her to WFH the following day?

Maybe because she knows her family? I know that there is always a bed for me in my parents home. 1. Because they have told me and 2. Because I've seen it.
Not all parents disown their adult kids as soon as they move out.

Twyford · 14/07/2023 09:38

Why was it a 'bombshell' that she fancied coming back to her home and see the rest of her family.

Communicating that decision late at night on the night you expect to be accommodated is a bit of a bombshell, isn't it? How does she necessarily know that a bed is available or that there will be facilities for her to WFH the following day?

Bellaboo01 · 14/07/2023 09:35

BarbiewhupsSindy · 14/07/2023 01:38

Dd2 and I joined DD1 for long awaited fantastic concert tonight.

Let's say DD2 and I live in Bristol (she's 19 on a gap year, lives at home). DD1 let's say lives in Birmingham - 25, lived there since she finished University, very settled in her own flat, good job, just returns home occasionally for the odd night.

We liaised tonight at a music concert in Oxford.

I drove DD2 up there, DD1 hopped on the train and met us there, we had lovely supper and concert, finished the concert and went to say our goodbyes, when DD1 dropped the bombshell that she'd decided to come home with us for the night, and she'd WFH (our home) and then catch the train back tomorrow evening.

Well all good, and dandy, except I didn't have space for her in the car 😭.

She didn't want to get the late train back as it would involve an hour wait and then a 15 minute walk at approx 1am through the city, or an uber.

So I arranged for a late check in at a hotel in Oxford for her because I felt guilty that I couldn't accommodate her wishes.

She went off in a snit muttering about wanting to spend time with her younger siblings and pets, see her childhood friend, and I've prevented that by not being able to get her back to Bristol.

She has form for holding a grudge, so I'm wondering how long this wobbly will last.

YABU you should have anticipated her prodigal return.

YANBU she should have communicated with you that she'd be returned to Bristol after the concert.

😬

Why was it a 'bombshell' that she fancied coming back to her home and see the rest of her family.

Is your car a two-seater? If this is the case then i am sure she knew this and realised you can't fit 3 people into a 2 seater? If not, what was preventing you being able to fit her into your car?

LobsterCrab · 14/07/2023 09:30

I can't vote until OP explains why there wasn't room in the car. If you drive a 2-seater surely DD1 would know this?

Twyford · 14/07/2023 09:26

LemonsOnTheMelons · 14/07/2023 02:32

I think it’s reasonable to expect your parents to give you a lift back to your childhood home without notice tbh. You’re her parents, not randomers.

Why on Earth couldn’t you have fit her in the car?

Why? Why even assume your parents have a bed for you if you don't give them any notice? Once you leave home, people are entitled to arrange their own lives on the assumption that you'll behave like a normally sensible and considerate human being.

Lobelia123 · 14/07/2023 09:05

She sounds like a right madam - behaving like the most important person in the room, demanding you all dance around her, and now giving you the silent treatment/sulks as punicshment for not being able to foresee her wishes and plans with zero notice....and then you not only pander to her and put her up in a hotel, but sit here mizzing on about whether she'll hold a grudge?? You are the architect of your own misery. Give her a sharp reality check and tell her to take responsibility for herself, stop being a diva and making things unpleasant for her sister. And stop letting her treat you like dirt!

Honeychickpea · 14/07/2023 09:03

25 may be an adult bit we all revert to children with out parents
We don't all do that. Some of us grow out of expecting our parents to be at our beck and call when we are adults.

MorrisZapp · 14/07/2023 08:48

Fascinated by the travel arrangements. Please come back OP.

Heurgh · 14/07/2023 08:45

We have a family car and my reminder of my youth MX5 which I drive in the summer, whenever I can. July is classic 'get the impractical car out while it's not raining' season.

Swipe left for the next trending thread