Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cakes and Treats at Work

494 replies

WhatTheFlipToDo · 14/07/2023 00:19

I have worked at my current work place for about a year. I have been consistently a size 12 in clothes for two decades yet I have put on over a stone in that time and size 14 clothes are getting tight. The only variable between this job and my last one is a permanently well stocked table of ‘treats’. So, biscuits, those little M&S tubs of cake bites, donuts, Rocky bars. You name it.

It is a job where you end up incredibly tired sometimes and I have little will power around chocolate at the best of times but when I'm tired it’s a million times worse. Essentially, I eat far more sweet things now due to this bloody table of junk food. Obviously, as I eat things I replace them but then I just eat them again. I don’t know what to do. I’d like to ask the team to save treats for an actual occasional treat but, simultaneously, if I’m the only one who has no will power, is it fair to request they adapt their behaviour for me?

I feel the views in this article sum up my own well. https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/17/people-should-not-take-cakes-in-to-the-office-suggests-food-watchdog-chief

Am I being unreasonable to want the team to cut back on the treats so I don’t get even fatter or is this my problem to manage? Genuinely contemplating leaving as I just will not be able to manage my weight without a change in workplace culture.

People should not take cake into the office, suggests food watchdog chief | Health | The Guardian

Food Standards Agency chairwoman likened culture to passive smoking, and said offices should be a ‘supportive environment’

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/17/people-should-not-take-cakes-in-to-the-office-suggests-food-watchdog-chief

OP posts:
M4J4 · 16/07/2023 13:41

LimeCheesecake · 16/07/2023 08:46

Another thing that’s been enlightening on this thread is just how many people think it’s perfectly normal not to have chocolate /biscuits /crisps in your house because “obviously” you’d then eat them all, it’s pretty normal to have constant access to sweet/fatty foods but then not eat them. There’s always some sugary stuff at our house, I just don’t always have it.

and this is a problem, if your solution to being tempted by junk food is to just ban it from your life, then that only works as long as you can control what food is made available to you.

if you can’t control your access to junk food, you need to work on controlling your reaction to it.

it’s pretty normal to have constant access to sweet/fatty foods but then not eat them. There’s always some sugary stuff at our house, I just don’t always have it.

Maybe normal for you but not for me.

I hate it when guests give me chocolates because I feel the pressure to eat them before they expire and are wasted.

I am now better at putting the chocolates in the food bank but it’s natural not to want to waste food and therefore avoid having it in your home.

CornishGem1975 · 16/07/2023 13:24

Just as we have made smoking unacceptable in the workplace and wouldn't have a drinks table, I really do think workplaces should regulate and even discourage the random bringing in of so-called treats. It's a stupid expression anyway - it's not a treat if you're having it 5 times a day.

Of course it's not a treat if you're having it 5 times a day, so have it once. Or not at all. If you can't resist the lure of a donut then it's not about the food is it. People can protest all they like but you choose to put something in your mouth, and it IS about self control.

If you can't find that self control or willpower then work on yourself, be that through therapy or whatever, but don't expect other people to have to change because you can't self-regulate.

HereToo · 16/07/2023 13:17

notanicepersonapparently · 16/07/2023 13:00

I completely agree. I just can’t comprehend posters that say it’s just a matter of self control and then admit they are overweight and can’t resist them. Surely you are living proof that it’s not just a simple matter of saying no. And no one is suggesting banning theses foods from the office (as they have done in schools) just don’t put them out on a sharing table in full view.

Eh? They are living proof that it's a matter of saying no.

They're just truthful enough to admit that for whatever reason, they're not saying no.

It's all about learning self-control, not trying to change the world around you because that's out of everyone's control.

notanicepersonapparently · 16/07/2023 13:00

CoffeeCantata · 16/07/2023 10:23

My third post, because I'm failing (my fault, I'm sure!) to get my point across. Shouting 'just say no' isn't the point.

Yes, it's an individual's responsibility to regulate what they eat and say no. My point is that in the current climate (obesity crisis, recent research into the damage done by sugar and other UHP foods etc) workplaces should discourage the 'treat table'. I have no personal axe to grind here - I do say no but I've also experienced what other PPs have said about pressure from sinister 'feeder' colleagues who push, and then get offended or needle you all day when you refuse. Like another PP I've also had several 'nos' ignored and stuff plonked in front of me at my desk. Doesn't make me eat it, but it led to a grunty atmosphere in the office and my point is: why should people have to put up with this stuff? Work can be stressful enough.

Just as we have made smoking unacceptable in the workplace and wouldn't have a drinks table, I really do think workplaces should regulate and even discourage the random bringing in of so-called treats. It's a stupid expression anyway - it's not a treat if you're having it 5 times a day.

As I suggested previously: either limit the occasions dramatically (one day a week at most, and take your rubbish home with you) or put it in a cupboard.

Then no-one's rights and freedoms are being affected.

I completely agree. I just can’t comprehend posters that say it’s just a matter of self control and then admit they are overweight and can’t resist them. Surely you are living proof that it’s not just a simple matter of saying no. And no one is suggesting banning theses foods from the office (as they have done in schools) just don’t put them out on a sharing table in full view.

ReachForTheMars · 16/07/2023 12:43

YABVU you cant delegate personal responsibility. Bring some fruit in or other alternatives.

Fluff3 · 16/07/2023 12:40

Really, you want others to stop eating sugery things just for you. Wow, your not going to be very popular. You just need to get will power and resist them. Its the same in my job, I am nirse and patients leave chocolates, cakes and biscuits for us all the time. Its up to you to resist them, nobody else. Just limit yourself to 2 very small chocs a day, and when you reach that limit stop. You cant expecet everyone else to suffer because of your poor self control.

Barney60 · 16/07/2023 12:32

I have a similar set up at work, also put weight on, so now i take my own treats in there in my handbag in a plastic box with a lid, low fat low sugar or what ever suits you carrot sticks or something else you can munch on, i often do fresh fruit dipped in thin layer of yogurt and frozen. Place in box add freezer bag.

Beezknees · 16/07/2023 12:06

I think it's your problem to deal with and I'm fat myself. I wouldn't ask people at work to stop bringing things in because of my lack of self control.

Sigmama · 16/07/2023 12:04

Limecheesecsje, the cigarette comparison is relevant, no-one needs to watch upf or junk food, it's just as addictive

KajsaKavat · 16/07/2023 12:00

I worked in a place like this and it was incredibly easy to say no thanks

Ginisalwaystheanswer · 16/07/2023 11:02

Wow, some of you people on here are vicious!
Now this reply may be way too sympathetic and reasonable for Mumsnet, but here goes.

Speak to your colleagues. Yes, speak to them! You might not be the only one who feels like this. See if you can agree to it not being a permanent fixture.
Otherwise, is this desk/table near you so you can see it? If so, see if you can move it.
I find ‘out of sight out of mind’ works well.
Again, ask for others’ thoughts on this.

I can sympathise completely, at some times of the year we have this in my office, especially before and after Christmas. And then birthdays. But we’ve all agreed we definitely don’t want it as a regular thing. In fact, there was talk of a fine for anyone who brought in (unwanted at home) treats after Christmas!

As someone else suggested, bring your own snacks and ensure you have plenty to keep you going - fruit, nuts, low calorie cake bars, rice cakes and those low fat crisp type snacks. How about adding these to the treats table too, so you have a healthier alternative?

It really doesn’t have to be ‘this is completely your problem just deal with it’ as others as saying. I find that quite sad.

Good luck and I hope you can get something sorted.

CoffeeCantata · 16/07/2023 10:23

My third post, because I'm failing (my fault, I'm sure!) to get my point across. Shouting 'just say no' isn't the point.

Yes, it's an individual's responsibility to regulate what they eat and say no. My point is that in the current climate (obesity crisis, recent research into the damage done by sugar and other UHP foods etc) workplaces should discourage the 'treat table'. I have no personal axe to grind here - I do say no but I've also experienced what other PPs have said about pressure from sinister 'feeder' colleagues who push, and then get offended or needle you all day when you refuse. Like another PP I've also had several 'nos' ignored and stuff plonked in front of me at my desk. Doesn't make me eat it, but it led to a grunty atmosphere in the office and my point is: why should people have to put up with this stuff? Work can be stressful enough.

Just as we have made smoking unacceptable in the workplace and wouldn't have a drinks table, I really do think workplaces should regulate and even discourage the random bringing in of so-called treats. It's a stupid expression anyway - it's not a treat if you're having it 5 times a day.

As I suggested previously: either limit the occasions dramatically (one day a week at most, and take your rubbish home with you) or put it in a cupboard.

Then no-one's rights and freedoms are being affected.

Mirabai · 16/07/2023 10:05

LimeCheesecake · 16/07/2023 08:46

Another thing that’s been enlightening on this thread is just how many people think it’s perfectly normal not to have chocolate /biscuits /crisps in your house because “obviously” you’d then eat them all, it’s pretty normal to have constant access to sweet/fatty foods but then not eat them. There’s always some sugary stuff at our house, I just don’t always have it.

and this is a problem, if your solution to being tempted by junk food is to just ban it from your life, then that only works as long as you can control what food is made available to you.

if you can’t control your access to junk food, you need to work on controlling your reaction to it.

I think what’s more enlightening is the number of people have chocolate/biscuits/crisps in the house and can’t live without them, regardless of how much they say they eat.

I don’t have chocolate or crisps in the house - not because I might eat them all but because I don’t eat them so there’s no point. Periodically I might buy some chocolate - but it’s as and when, which isn’t often. I have oat biscuits but more for guests.

I don’t think it’s “normal” (although common) to have or need constant access to sweet fatty foods. It has become the new normal with the rise of obesity.

FinallyPeakedNow · 16/07/2023 09:19

There is so much evidence that sugar and processed crap shouldn't even be described as 'food' so yeah I think the smoking analogy is good. It's a drug. People are addicted. Tax it, ban it, make it obvious you shouldn't be eating it or encouraging others to do the same. Bring celebratory raw vegetable treats in to work and see if people get fat on those.

LimeCheesecake · 16/07/2023 09:08

The comparison to smoking doesn’t work - no one needs to smoke. Everyone needs to eat.

Different peoples bodies require different amounts of food, and many people can fit in chocolate and crisps and fried or high fat foods to their diet and still be healthy and not be overweight.

SerenadeOfTheSchoolRun · 16/07/2023 08:49

FinallyPeakedNow · 16/07/2023 08:04

I would do ALL of this. OP YANBU

We did it with cigarettes and I imagine all the same arguments were made against banning advertising, adding health warnings, plain packaging and putting them behind screens in shops, also banning smoking from indoor public places. I know second hand smoke is an extra issue but look at how the numbers of smokers have dropped since all this was done. Obesity is a national health crisis and so much could be done. Even plain packaging and not placing chocolates near the tills would be a big step.

LimeCheesecake · 16/07/2023 08:46

Another thing that’s been enlightening on this thread is just how many people think it’s perfectly normal not to have chocolate /biscuits /crisps in your house because “obviously” you’d then eat them all, it’s pretty normal to have constant access to sweet/fatty foods but then not eat them. There’s always some sugary stuff at our house, I just don’t always have it.

and this is a problem, if your solution to being tempted by junk food is to just ban it from your life, then that only works as long as you can control what food is made available to you.

if you can’t control your access to junk food, you need to work on controlling your reaction to it.

PorePurifyingCucumberSandwich · 16/07/2023 08:10

Op I empathize. I would struggle to resist as well. The only way I can not eat binge eat sugary treats is by going completely abstinent. I haven't had anything with added sugar in about a month or so and it's so much easier than constantly having to make decisions about what is ok to eat when.

FinallyPeakedNow · 16/07/2023 08:05

Also, that bread near the pastries in the supermarket, that can also get in the bin bc it is barely food now it's so full of over processed crap

FinallyPeakedNow · 16/07/2023 08:04

ThatFraggle · 16/07/2023 06:17

While we are at it, we should shut down McDonald's and KFC because walking past them in town is a temptation. And burger king has a drive through on the way home, that goes too.

The pastries are near the bread in the supermarket, so ban those too. And when paying for petrol, there are so many sweets and chocolates. Ban those too. I can see Gregg's from the window. They should paint their sign and windows black.

See how ridiculous you sound, op.

I would do ALL of this. OP YANBU

LolaSmiles · 16/07/2023 07:16

Take a pot of strawberries or something in with you to give you the sweetness you crave. Plan ahead!
I do this and also keep a small amount healthier snacks and herbal teas in my desk drawer.

I agree with PP about the ultra-processed food not being decent food. Because I try to be aware of calories across the week, I've no interest in using up a large chunk of weekly calories on UPF every day. A biscuit some days isn't the end of the world, but ultimately I'm responsible for my food intake. Nobody else.

MeandT · 16/07/2023 06:50

Well I appreciate it won't happen @ThatFraggle, but it would make for a far healthier country if we did!

As @RunBetter points out, none of these are actually food items - they are an engineered mix of flavourings, preservatives, fat emulsifiers & sugar delivering a higher calorie density than any human needs, devoid of any actual nutritional content (vitamins, minerals, polyphenoix flavinoids) and designed by the "food" industry to make us overconsume and to be addictive.

Other than, yeah just carry on & rely on willpower - it's clearly worked a treat for the 30 million or so in the UK who are overweight to the point it's affecting (creating) at least one other health condition for them!

As a practical suggestion @WhatTheFlipToDo you could try putting some cherries/raspberries/melon there as an alternative. Maybe others will want to join you on a healthier choice. But it's more expensive & doesn't give that addictive hit of sugar&fat&salt that doesn't exist in nature & is inherently addictive to humans.

Neither you or I are going to fix either of those national food policy problems here today, so good luck! Flowers

ThatFraggle · 16/07/2023 06:17

While we are at it, we should shut down McDonald's and KFC because walking past them in town is a temptation. And burger king has a drive through on the way home, that goes too.

The pastries are near the bread in the supermarket, so ban those too. And when paying for petrol, there are so many sweets and chocolates. Ban those too. I can see Gregg's from the window. They should paint their sign and windows black.

See how ridiculous you sound, op.

lookingforaholiday · 16/07/2023 06:02

YABU - you can't ask the team the change because of your lack of willpower. We have constant cakes in the office for birthdays or other but rarely have any. Just make sure you have an alternative healthier snack to hand that you can have if you feel tempted

Tekoa · 16/07/2023 05:57

Essentially, I’m just someone who is approaching middle age, putting on a bit of weight, struggling with managing it and wondering if it was ok to suggest changes to one of the sources of that weight gain. Apparently it isn’t and I’ll accept that.

Good luck, OP. I know how hard it is, also approaching middle age.

I also work with a lot of younger people, with very fast metabolisms, who can eat a lot of treats with no weight again at all.

So I think this would be unfair to them if they enjoy the treats.