Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cakes and Treats at Work

494 replies

WhatTheFlipToDo · 14/07/2023 00:19

I have worked at my current work place for about a year. I have been consistently a size 12 in clothes for two decades yet I have put on over a stone in that time and size 14 clothes are getting tight. The only variable between this job and my last one is a permanently well stocked table of ‘treats’. So, biscuits, those little M&S tubs of cake bites, donuts, Rocky bars. You name it.

It is a job where you end up incredibly tired sometimes and I have little will power around chocolate at the best of times but when I'm tired it’s a million times worse. Essentially, I eat far more sweet things now due to this bloody table of junk food. Obviously, as I eat things I replace them but then I just eat them again. I don’t know what to do. I’d like to ask the team to save treats for an actual occasional treat but, simultaneously, if I’m the only one who has no will power, is it fair to request they adapt their behaviour for me?

I feel the views in this article sum up my own well. https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/17/people-should-not-take-cakes-in-to-the-office-suggests-food-watchdog-chief

Am I being unreasonable to want the team to cut back on the treats so I don’t get even fatter or is this my problem to manage? Genuinely contemplating leaving as I just will not be able to manage my weight without a change in workplace culture.

People should not take cake into the office, suggests food watchdog chief | Health | The Guardian

Food Standards Agency chairwoman likened culture to passive smoking, and said offices should be a ‘supportive environment’

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/17/people-should-not-take-cakes-in-to-the-office-suggests-food-watchdog-chief

OP posts:
Sigmama · 14/07/2023 10:03

Which countries are these that don't snack and are thinner?

notanicepersonapparently · 14/07/2023 10:00

Thank you to everyone who took the time to answer my question. As someone whose weight has fluctuated over the years I do find this an interesting subject. I do agree that a little bit of what you fancy does you good but I feel treats are being pushed on us all the time. If someone offers me something they’ve brought in for their birthday or they’ve made themselves and I say no to it I feel awful. It’s like I was saying I don’t give a shit about your birthday and your home baking looks like crap. I don’t know why I feel like this. It’s not logical.

WeWereInParis · 14/07/2023 10:00

I think there needs to be a mindset change on snacking. We can't smoke anywhere near our site, and the Friday drinks beer fridge has gone, but the irresponsible promotion of cake and pizza lunches for staff in sedentary roles remains.

That's not been done out of care for the health of the smokers or drinkers though. Smoking affects those around them (and I imagine they want to discourage regular smoking breaks from work as well), and drinking affects performance.

I'm not saying all the snacking is fine, but I doubt employers will care in the same way.

ManateeFair · 14/07/2023 09:59

Of course YABU. Why should other people stop sharing snacks with one another just because you've put some weight on? It's not their problem.

The snacks are optional, not mandatory. You choose to eat them, and apparently in quantities that cause weight gain. That is your issue, not anyone else's. I've got terrible willpower when it comes to food, but I don't blame anyone else for that and I certainly don't complain when other people put a tub of M&S Brownie Bites on top of a filing cabinet. Nobody else has to modify their social eating habits to suit you.

readbooksdrinktea · 14/07/2023 09:56

I mean, my workplace in the UK was like what you describe. I get it. You're still being very unreasonable to expect your lack of control to be your colleagues' problem.

tttigress · 14/07/2023 09:55

CoffeeCantata · 14/07/2023 09:48

OP, I think you're getting a hard time. Of course it's up to the individual to exert self-control, but as others have said, there's a happy medium. Yes, you probably are being unreasonable to expect to veto snacks for everyone but I think the following 'rules' might help make it easier for everyone in the workplace:

  • treats should be placed/located in a designated area away from the usual kettle and coffee machine - eg a cupboard somewhere you have to make a bit of an effort to go. I know from my experience that it's 'out of sight, out of mind' but if they're right next to the kettle and I'm tired, I'll struggle. Tough luck if they need to go in the fridge - people shouldn't bring in treats that need to be in the fridge!
  • or as a compromise and a nod towards healthier culture, there should be designated occasions when treats are brought in, such as birthdays or celebrations related to the workplace (end of project, promotions etc etc).
  • Whoever brought the treat in should be asked to take the leftovers home at the end of a day or possibly 2, or at least palm them off on someone else to take home.

Please don't suggest I'm a cake-fascist here - I do know I can't make rules. These are just my suggestions for a better work/treat balance which would help everyone to get what they want. We would be sensitive to people struggling with alcohol addiction etc and not leave bottles of booze around for them so, in view of the concerns about obesity, I think it's fair to make indulging in sugary snacks a definite, conscious decision and not put people who might be struggling to to the right thing through torture every day!

Ok, one problem with point 2. Where I work almost every F-ing day is a birthday, retirement, promotion, work celebration etc. etc.

Humidititties · 14/07/2023 09:52

And this is daily.

My suggestion to get a fruit bowl and top it up daily (management would pay for this) was met with disgust lol

Humidititties · 14/07/2023 09:51

I hear you OP, I've worked damn hard this past 2 years to lose weight, my willpower is totally shit if there's something I like put in front of me and due to where I sit in the office, they are in my view all day. Currently on said table are 4 packets of Bourbon biscuits, 2 packs of custard creams, tub of cornflake bites, tub of millionaires shortbread bites, tub of mini rolls, bags of pretzels, Jaffa Cakes. Fair enough eat them, but why can't they keep them on their desks or in their drawers?

I know it's my problem but when you've had eating disorders, binge eating, zero willpower, it's really annoying. I don't think about eating crap until it's right in front of me 😓

LaMaG · 14/07/2023 09:51

OP I agree with you. I worked in a place where it was socially acceptable to bring in treats all the time, anyone with leftovers brought them in, half eaten boxes of chocs after Christmas etc. The people who brought them in did not do so to be generous but to avoid eating them themselves at home and knowing that fools like me would eat them instead. Its all very well saying don't eat them but I would be sitting there constantly craving feeling anxious unable to focus because I could see them and I'd eventually cave. Yes it was my issue but it was unfair. The gambling analogy is accurate IMO. I never said anything but then a new manager brought in a healthy eating policy banning all sugary or fatty items in the office and had a bowl of fresh fruit arrive instead. Everyone said how relieved they were, it was amazing how many people disapproved of the former practice but didn't want to say.

CoffeeCantata · 14/07/2023 09:48

OP, I think you're getting a hard time. Of course it's up to the individual to exert self-control, but as others have said, there's a happy medium. Yes, you probably are being unreasonable to expect to veto snacks for everyone but I think the following 'rules' might help make it easier for everyone in the workplace:

  • treats should be placed/located in a designated area away from the usual kettle and coffee machine - eg a cupboard somewhere you have to make a bit of an effort to go. I know from my experience that it's 'out of sight, out of mind' but if they're right next to the kettle and I'm tired, I'll struggle. Tough luck if they need to go in the fridge - people shouldn't bring in treats that need to be in the fridge!
  • or as a compromise and a nod towards healthier culture, there should be designated occasions when treats are brought in, such as birthdays or celebrations related to the workplace (end of project, promotions etc etc).
  • Whoever brought the treat in should be asked to take the leftovers home at the end of a day or possibly 2, or at least palm them off on someone else to take home.

Please don't suggest I'm a cake-fascist here - I do know I can't make rules. These are just my suggestions for a better work/treat balance which would help everyone to get what they want. We would be sensitive to people struggling with alcohol addiction etc and not leave bottles of booze around for them so, in view of the concerns about obesity, I think it's fair to make indulging in sugary snacks a definite, conscious decision and not put people who might be struggling to to the right thing through torture every day!

Suckingalemon · 14/07/2023 09:45

I'm not a failure thanks. And I won't bugger off because you don't like my opinion.

The snackers who eat themselves into obesity related disease are crippling the NHS, so it is an irresponsible behaviour with effects on society.

Go and comfort eat that.

tttigress · 14/07/2023 09:45

ActDottie · 14/07/2023 09:42

Best thing I did was go vegan as suddenly I couldn’t have any of the office treats and I had an excuse as to why as sometimes people can pressure you to have something as well.

I hate the fact that if you don't want to eat something, there is some hilarious "banter", and you are expected to give a reason why you don't want to eat something.

ActDottie · 14/07/2023 09:42

Best thing I did was go vegan as suddenly I couldn’t have any of the office treats and I had an excuse as to why as sometimes people can pressure you to have something as well.

ThePoshUns · 14/07/2023 09:40

I worked somewhere similar. Just don't eat them.

tttigress · 14/07/2023 09:37

For me the word "treat" implies something that happens not very often, such as less than once a week.

Not every day or every other day!!

LemonsOnTheMelons · 14/07/2023 09:32

Suckingalemon · 14/07/2023 09:23

I think there needs to be a mindset change on snacking. We can't smoke anywhere near our site, and the Friday drinks beer fridge has gone, but the irresponsible promotion of cake and pizza lunches for staff in sedentary roles remains.

I have one line manager with iron willpower who brings in fruit, and is on the receiving end of a lot of banter because of it.

Countries where snacking is not a regular thing are thinner.

Oh bugger off and learn some self control 🙄

You can’t compare drinking and smoking to snacking. Smoking causes cancer and affects everyone around you, drinking affects your faculties and thus your performance at work.

You don’t want snacks? Just don’t eat them. It really is that easy, but if you’re finding it so hard don’t try and punish everyone else around you for your own failings.

SayHi · 14/07/2023 09:24

notanicepersonapparently · 14/07/2023 09:01

Could I ask those who think this is just a matter of willpower whether they are actually faced with this situation themselves? How much food do their coworkers bring in? Is it left on display. If so do they eat some or none? How much sugary snacking do they do and do they manage to maintain a healthy weight?

I work in a SEND school which is physically and mentally challenging and very different to an office environment, so i can’t speak for those who work in offices.

We have sweet treats at least once a week.

I always eat it but I don’t overeat on it because it’s for everyone and not just me.

I always bring in a healthy lunch and eat healthy at home so I can enjoy these treats without the guilt.

I also tend to not sit down after lunch because of my job but if I was in an office job I would try and get some exercise on my lunch break anyway after sitting down all morning.

I find that allowing yourself treats keeps you at a healthy weight.
I always struggled with my weight and it was only when I started eating treats as part of my diet did I lose weight and keep it off.

I also use MyFitnessPal just to keep an eye on my calorie intake and if I do happen to go a bit silly at work then I have a lighter meal in the evening or slightly less calories the next day.

Suckingalemon · 14/07/2023 09:23

I think there needs to be a mindset change on snacking. We can't smoke anywhere near our site, and the Friday drinks beer fridge has gone, but the irresponsible promotion of cake and pizza lunches for staff in sedentary roles remains.

I have one line manager with iron willpower who brings in fruit, and is on the receiving end of a lot of banter because of it.

Countries where snacking is not a regular thing are thinner.

AnotherDayAnotherUsernameForMeAgain · 14/07/2023 09:23

M4J4 · 14/07/2023 09:08

I limit myself to one bite. Just tasting what everyone else is having satisfies the craving to not be the one missing out.

One bite would just open the floodgates for me. My old office used to do cake Friday (each staff member taking a turn to go to various places) and after a few months of this I said thanks for the offer but I’m going to opt out as I like a cake/dessert treat a week and look forward to having it when I socialise. Almost everyone agreed and one lady in particular took the huff that I had ruined her treat. I apologised if she felt that way but I didn’t really love a cake from greggs or a piece of Costco cake and I felt it was ok to opt out.

TimesRwo · 14/07/2023 09:16

notanicepersonapparently · 14/07/2023 09:01

Could I ask those who think this is just a matter of willpower whether they are actually faced with this situation themselves? How much food do their coworkers bring in? Is it left on display. If so do they eat some or none? How much sugary snacking do they do and do they manage to maintain a healthy weight?

Yes! I’ve worked in two different offices where there is always a chocolate tin on display, or those M&S boxes, or brownies / muffins supplied very regularly.

I just didn’t eat them everyday - would limit myself to one a week, every now and then two. If I ate them everyday, my weight would have ballooned but I managed to keep it consistent.

Goldenbear · 14/07/2023 09:12

I work in a big place and there always appears to be sugary treats available for someone's birthday or a cake sale. I don't have any of it but then again I slink back to my office with the coffee, I'm not that bothered.

My DH's office provides a permanent array of 'healthy' snacks so fruit, lentil crisps, healthy flavoured popcorn, flavoured water, protein bars. I believe on Friday there is beer or wine. He likes the snacks as he works long hours and needs to keep going until about 9 after being there since 9am. He said the worst thing is if they order in Chinese takeaway on the late work nights and he does think that is responding for his early 40s 1 stone weight gain. Also, they have bring your national cuisine and one woman from Poland always makes amazing cake but highly fattening!

kyliekoo · 14/07/2023 09:09

YANBU
I'm shocked at the number of people who think it's fine to have a table full of junk at a workplace. It's really not, and our national obesity rate shows this.

Someone mentioned gambling, which is a good comparison: I wouldn't approve of a slot machine in my office (even though I'm not a gambling addict), because I care for the welfare of my colleagues and know it could be a huge temptation for one of them.

Please don't think you're colleagues are as mean and selfish as some of the posters here. If you say that you are really struggling with the "treat table", it would be pretty heartless of them to say, "this is YOUR problem." I'm sure they would be happy to have their snacks at their desk instead. Also, it may well be that may others feel the same as you and are unhappy at the amount of weight they have put on.

I would ask around and see how your colleagues feel about removing it. If you told your manager you are thinking of leaving because of it, I'm sure they would also think seriously about removing it (rather than having to rehire/train another staff member).

M4J4 · 14/07/2023 09:08

M4J4 · 14/07/2023 09:07

I work in an office of 2k people, there are regularly cakes, biscuits, those little supermarket buckets of mini chocolate rolls, flapjacks etc on display.

Often people will cut the cake in their own area and bring it into communal areas to offload share it with others.

I limit myself to one bite. Just tasting what everyone else is having satisfies the craving to not be the one missing out.

LolaSmiles · 14/07/2023 09:08

Could I ask those who think this is just a matter of willpower whether they are actually faced with this situation themselves? How much food do their coworkers bring in? Is it left on display. If so do they eat some or none? How much sugary snacking do they do and do they manage to maintain a healthy weight?
In an old workplace we had a snack box and biscuits out in the break area. We also did bring and share lunches too around once a month.

I don't have treat mindset so there's no morality attached to eating a biscuit or cake. It also means there's no underlying thinking of "it's been a long morning so I deserve a biscuit... It's Jane's birthday so I'll treat myself to some cake. That meeting was rough so I'll just have a chocolate brownie bite as a little pick me up".

If I wanted to have a biscuit with my coffee, I'd have one and feel no guilt. Some weeks I'd have a snack every day, others not at all. I didn't give much thought to it.

5128gap · 14/07/2023 09:08

Not always, but often, this kind of mindless desk eating and need to punctuate your day with treats is a sign of a bored workforce. I know a lot of jobs are dull and routine, but there can sometimes be ways to make your work day more interesting so you don't need to entertain yourself with food. Are you challenged and busy? Do you need to start thinking about a move to somewhere where you might be? Failing that, can you inject non food related punctuation into your day? A walk, a chat, some stretches in the toilets, meetings arranged at cake time?