Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
whatkatydid2013 · 14/07/2023 07:27

It seems staggeringly naive to believe such a huge disruption to everyday life along with all the uncertainty in the initial lockdown about how bad covid might be and the uncertainty following it on when restrictions would end won’t have had a fairly significant impact on lots of people’s mental health. I guess as a child if you are relatively introverted, if you live in a decent sized home with some accessible outdoor space, if your family have the money to fund whatever is needed to make schooling remotely work, if you had a SAHP or a furloughed parent who actually got 80% of their usual income and could manage fine on that so they were not stressing out about finances & they were a generally engaged parent, you maybe had a sibling or two of a broadly similar age with similar interests and you were shielded from the don’t kill your granny messaging and they didn’t lose close relatives without being able to see them then it’s reasonable to expect you’d do ok. The more of those that aren’t true the less likely you’d be ok and then you have the kids who have actively abusive or wholly negligent parents, who are young carers, who are SEN etc that have even more to contend with.

I am fully aware we were a lot luckier than other people. Our family and close friends were all ok. No one ended up in hospital with covid or anything else. We have a large house with a small garden, a good income, a friendly neighbourhood where people helped each other out (eg getting food for each other, passing on various toys, games, jigsaws etc to give kids and adults new stuff to do, grandparents who bubbled with us to help in second lockdown, kids close in age with similar interests. We have no SEN needs to contend with and the kids were both at a primary school that was very child focused and did their best to have the kids in and having normal school experiences in so far as was possible. I still think it’s had an impact on them spending weeks on end basically stuck in the house/garden while both their parents were stressed out juggling full time work, full time childcare and trying to keep them getting through the material sent home from school. Whether you loved or hated lockdowns it’s still an adjustment transitioning back to more normal life and some people (& children) will find that harder than others

Florabeebaby · 14/07/2023 07:27

Oh yes yes....isolation, no proper education, no socialising and watching their dad being put in an ambulance hardly breathing. No suffering at all.
Maybe don't generalise as everyones experience was individual.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 14/07/2023 07:26

It's all relative though every single person experienced lock down differently.
I imagine as a child if you had a parent who worked in a hospital you didn't have an easy ride.
We came through unharmed from covid but mentally I think we will be seeing the results of that for years to come.

gogomoto · 14/07/2023 07:26

Very true op. But we do love to moan. And we love to blame shift (see thread yesterday about French children sitting nicely at the table in restaurants, plenty of posters stating all kinds of nonsense when it just comes down to parenting).

In Spain kids didn't leave their houses for weeks, as many more live in apartments to the U.K. that meant not going outside. In france they had a distance cap how far you could go ... but in many countries there is never extra curricular activities, it's too dangerous to play out and the kids study all evening with poor light as their ticket out of poverty - this is always not due to covid! These poor kids (in both sense of the word) seem to have less issues then our privileged ones

WorriedMillie · 14/07/2023 07:26

My DD loved the lockdowns, she was 6, we shielded her from the news and explained what was happening in an age appropriate way, she loved us being at home (incl her grandma), baking and going for walks. We were able to help her with her learning

But, she’s a NT, resilient kid, who’s had a healthy and stable childhood, nice house, etc. She’s bright and wasn’t impacted by her lack of schooling and she was young at the time.

Many, many children don’t have these privileges, for many, school is their safe and reliable place, ther home life is not happy nor safe, for whatever reason. Parents had to go out and be frontline NHS workers, with all of the stress that causes (my friend was separated from her child as child is CEV and friend was a frontline worker, that was very traumatic for the child and mother).

I can begin to imagine the impact on teens. Another friend’s son’s GCSEs were impacted, he struggled without social interaction with peers and became anxious and depressed

I could go on and on…

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 07:25

I don’t think you’ve actually thought this through OP (being generous).

is the UK a lucky country in many, many ways? Absolutely. Is that an invisible shield against trauma? No, it isn’t. Trauma happens on a scale and is relative to the individuals personal experience. It’s not so much about the experience as the consequence. I should think (hope) that as a teacher you understand that.

whatever kind of society a child lives in , upheavals to the operation and function of that society affect children deeply. From the youngest to the eldest, our society suspended all the opportunities we expect our children to partake in and learn how to function within our boundaries. It wasn’t a permanent change and now children are expected to slot back into our expectations after missing crucial lessons on how to do that.

That’s lost now and making that up to an age group who simply aren’t mature enough to rationalise the shift themselves requires support, guidance and patience. Telling them they’re privileged means fuck all to your average school aged child because experience is relative and they don’t have the life experience to draw on to understand the realities of that statement. In many, many ways that’s a good thing and is a symptom of a very good life but it’s really distasteful to paint a whole cohort as precious and dramatic because the society we’ve created as their primary experience of existence doesn’t impart the ability to truly empathise with those in worse situations and then use that as a yardstick to measure their resilience.

LlynTegid · 14/07/2023 07:25

If Mr Johnson had acted promptly in March 2020, then children could have had less lost schooling face to face, as I think some could have resumed in June or maybe early July 2020.

Agree with the OP that the impact was a lot less than in many other places.

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 14/07/2023 07:24

I'm not reading all of your post; as the parent of a child who suffered mental health issues as a result of covid I find it upsetting and dismissive. My dd is clever, fairly privileged, stable family background etc and has a similar group of friends. From speaking to her school mental health support workers 50% of my dcs peers - all girls - suffered with some sort of mental health issue when everything went back to normal. Eating disorders, self harm, social anxiety, ocd, agoraphobia, all during GCSEs, have all be directly attributed to covid experiences. During lockdown they were fine, more than fine, but when everything went back to normal the problems started. Please don't tell me everything was fine because we live in the UK. Unless you have a child who suffered with mental health issues as a result of lockdown you have no idea, and certainly no right to be so dismissive. It wasn't about money, access to education, being in a comfortable home with a bg garden and a good Internet access, it was about access to people - friends, family - and the fear that giving your grandmother or vulnerable friend a hug could kill her.

Shouldbehoovering · 14/07/2023 07:24

They were denied the opportunity to play and interact with other children. No amount of parental love and availability makes up for that and it is something children in under developed countries do get to do in spades. The lack of social and emotional development and impact on mental health (even of very young children) is significant.

Azaeleasinbloom · 14/07/2023 07:24

notavillager · 14/07/2023 00:15

I'm still astonished that long-term isolation and desocialisation of children, for the first time in human history, was not considered a vastly dangerous and unethical experiment

Totally agree. The restrictions that were suddenly forced upon them, the almost total lack of state schooling ( in my area of Scotland anyway), the lack of a coherent plan for their further development - totally wrong.

Op, it’s shocking that children in some other countries are denied education, and the basic human rights that ours are, but we are not aiming at lowest common denominator in nurturing our future adults.

milveycrohn · 14/07/2023 07:23

I suspect it depends mainly on the age of the children, but I personally believe it was totally horrific;
It wasn't only schools that closed, but also the various out of school activities, such as Brownies, Cubs, ballet lessons, junior football clubs, swimming lessons. Those are just an example, but there are loads more.
Then there are play dates - Banned; Also our local park was closed and locked. This may depend on the age of the child of course. An older child (teenager) may already spend a lot of time on social media, and could maybe work much more independently. However, younger children definitely need proper teaching time. Of course I would guess that most parents would try to help and teach as much as they could (all the time, while working from home?). But it is also the social time that is most important.
Many families live in small flats, and with parks closed, were stuck at home most of the day (I even saw some primary aged DC, having to wait in the socially distanced car park, where everyone was queueing to get into the supermarket. In otherwords, shopping was considered a single person activity, and children not expected to go as well).
This may have been better for children if they had siblings to interact with, but what about only children?
Then of course, there were the usual 'rights of passage' events, that children would have missed, such as final day of term or school, school prom, discos, family weddings, graduations, school trips, outings, (remember all museums art galleries, gyms, swimming baths were all closed).
The rule of 6 did not allow for two average sized families to meet up (ie 2 parents with 2 children).
So for some families, where there are siblings, a large garden, and maybe parents who were furloughed rather than working from home, then some parents could have provided an inspirational time for them, but for the majority, this would not be the case.

Nuevabegin · 14/07/2023 07:21

@orangeleavesinautumn how did your dcs get on during lockdown? All my three were absolutely fine but I’m able to understand many were not . Also tbh I didn’t stop going to shops with them or get them to distance or wear masks (unless around older ppl)
I’m also a teacher , I’ve worked in different countries , what countries have you worked in where dcs live in effectively lockdown ? I’m in Ireland the rules of the pandemic lasted much , much longer here and were quite frankly bonkers tbh, two of my dcs missed almost a year and half of school or actually maybe more. It didn’t have any effect on them
whatsoever tbh and we loved spending time in nature and I certainly did not stick to 5km limit in Ireland which was hugely controlling and against people’s civil rights.
Theres a huge knock-on effect of lockdowns which have effected kids- so many children in awful home situations going massively under the radar, even those in ok situations there was a lot of stress, I know a few adults who became very anxious and controlling (“normal” people who have children in their charge), the knock-on effects of loss of income , people not being diagnosed with illnesses as therefore if many of these effected people have children there was huge stress in the house. Can you not see that ? My sister works in paediatrics and saw a big increase of mental health issues with young people and no the parents weren’t all the types to be hamming it up . It’s very dismissive and honestly patronising to say what you say. Were your children ok op?

Tinybrother · 14/07/2023 07:21

Youonlygetonelife19 · 14/07/2023 07:17

I assume you have not been striking of supporting teachers’ strikes as teachers in UK have much better pay and conditions than teachers in many countries.

A good point

i live with a teacher and he has opinions on what impact lockdown has had on children he teaches, as well as other factors like underfunding of schools, parenting, cost of living etc. but he isn’t arrogant enough to rule out any one cause just because he publicly asked a bunch of children if something had negatively affected them and they all said no

Changeling78 · 14/07/2023 07:21

You’ve made a sweeping generalisation, it’s quite concerning that you work with children.
My 14yo dd was so changed by lockdown that she took an overdose and is still having counselling. My 11yo DS couldn’t have given two shits and handled it well. For every 50 children who put their hands up to say they loved being home there are 50 still dealing with the aftermath.

OCaptain · 14/07/2023 07:21

@Saschka

Really interested to know which countries have schools in which primary aged children are routinely not allowed to go outside into the playground, or see classmates, teachers or family, more than once a month. How exactly are they being taught, if they aren’t allowed contact with the teachers or their classmates? How are they fed, is a tray slid into the isolation cell? I’ve also worked in a lot of developing countries, and I have to say I don’t know of any which have schooling systems anything like that.

Actually, as Australia is rather a large country, many children live on isolated properties (particularly in the Outback). They have no classmates to speak of but are either home-schooled or have lessons via the School of the Air. This a a correspondence school that gives lessons via the internet and radio. It's a vital service for kids that otherwise would have to go to boarding school. It isn't that they aren't allowed to see teachers or classmates - they just don't really have any in the conventional sense.

When in my final year of school, I had to move states in Australia and I couldn't find a new school to accept me. I had to do my final year entirely via correspondence - and this was before the internet. I had no friends in my new community, so I spent that year in my room doing my work. I had no final prom, no leaving celebrations, nothing like that. It wasn't the best situation, and I wouldn't recommend it, but my only other choice was repeating a year and I wasn't doing that!

So it does happen, regularly.

MrsLentil · 14/07/2023 07:20

And it was great fun working full-time from home and looking after 3 under 10s. Happy times indeed 😂. Not stressful, oh no!!! And the schools expected hours and hours of tasks completed by very young kids, whose parents were working 8-10 hours.

Those who were furloughed had probably a lovely time on the whole though.

MrsLentil · 14/07/2023 07:19

As a society we were told to CEASE the most human thing of all,

Sux2buthen · 14/07/2023 07:18

Yeah my kids and I had a cracking time in the refuge, loads of us did.

Stupid post

Potsto · 14/07/2023 07:18

I have a 4 year old with a compulsive need to wash and/or sanitise their hands everywhere we go, speech delays, and a fear of other people.

I have a 6 year old who gets overwhelmed with too much "going out" and needs frequent rest days at home - before covid they would be out every day, and cry if we stayed at home. They cried a lot in the early days of lockdown.

They have two parents suffering from both the mental impact of lockdown with two under threes in inappropriate housing, and the physical impact of long COVID.

We did our best to make it as good as possible for them, and they probably mostly didn't hate lockdowns. But it's definitely affected them long term.

It affected everybody.

GregoryFluff · 14/07/2023 07:18

I mean, it depends where you live. I live in one of the poorest towns in England. I'm talking 2nd, 3rd generation unemployment, rampant drug use, domestic violence, terrible housing conditions, alcoholism, social services stretched so thin that standards are in the gutter
One of the teachers at the secondary a 10 minute walk from my house, went on his bike everyday to deliver the kids lunch and believe me, that was so he could get eyes on them and check they were okay
A huge number of kids were locked in with their abusers, and left watching younger siblings whilst their parents drunkenly fought
No more escape to school
I'd argue those poor kids didn't much love it tbh

MrsLentil · 14/07/2023 07:17

There are idiots you parrot that their kids behaviour is poor because of Covid, rather than parenting, excessive screen time, ultra processed for etc.

Your comparison with the 'world's children' is ignorant to say the least but it's MN so it's ok to be ignorant, it makes for lively IABU threads.

One of the key issues was that the sense of normalcy was taken away and replaced with a collective feeling of uncertainty and fear. This collective fear was actively steered by our government through public communications campaigns including on social media and threads and posts on MN.

There was a lack of daily routine and structure and the world seemed unpredictable. Whether it was or wasn't, doesn't matter, that was the collective experience as conjured up by WHO and governments.

Those silly, colourful DIY fabric masks did nothing to prevent Covid but created an edgy sense that things were frightening, we had to be suspicious of our community and wary.

As a society we were told to do the most human thing of all, socialising and interacting with each other. That's very harmful. You mention kids in china living remotely, well that's their normal and they don't live like that as a result of a 'dangerous' (?!) pandemic. They have their normal social structures and it is not an exceptional alarming situation.

You say that we have freedom and privileges. That's sad. Freedom is NOT a privilege, it's a basic right.

Anyway, enjoy your IABU.

And yes YABU.

Youonlygetonelife19 · 14/07/2023 07:17

I assume you have not been striking of supporting teachers’ strikes as teachers in UK have much better pay and conditions than teachers in many countries.

Beezknees · 14/07/2023 07:16

I cannot stand this type of post. It's that patronising "don't complain about anything because someone else has it worse" bullshit.

OP you are talking rubbish, and my child certainly did suffer during lockdown, as did I.

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 07:16

I disagree enormously. Social isolation is detrimental to children. And I think it's stupid to expect them to recognise it the damage themselves.
I have nieces and nephews in Africa and yes they missed out on education, yes they don't have the luxuries my kids have. But they were never isolated. Different experiences, but neither worse than the other.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 14/07/2023 07:15

Other people's suck does not make our suck suck any less.

Swipe left for the next trending thread