Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 14/07/2023 07:52

I am not qualified to talk about trauma.

But they are developmentally different as a cohort even though masses of children are fine. you see more of certain things in more pupils (not all). I sit in lots of school governor meetings and go to trust meetings and hear over and over how particular year groups have more of particular issues depending on how old they were. So year 1 seems to have lots of communication issues compared to previous years 1 and current year R. Again its stats, so obviously im.not saying every year 1 has this issue just maybe 4 kids used to and now its 10. The year 10s are desribed as on average, having friendship issues associated more with year 7s.

Tinybrother · 14/07/2023 07:49

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 14/07/2023 07:39

We’ve seen a massive increase in referrals to child and adolescent mental health services.

@orangeleavesinautumn why do you think that is?

i suspect the OP’s answer will be shit U.K. parents being shit at parenting

Whiskyinajar · 14/07/2023 07:46

"
Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most."

As a teacher I expect you understand that if it's "normal" then the children have no adjustments to make. In the UK it's not "normal" and our children struggled with the change. Particularly those in abusive households for whom school was an escape.

Nomorenonbinary · 14/07/2023 07:45

In eastern Europe, in Africa, in India, in Malaysia, in rural China I have seen communities more restricted than what we would consider "lock down" - but it is just considered normal life, no one is traumatised or feels deprived.

They don't see their extended families or neighbours or friends? Or shopkeepers or bus drivers or teachers or random people in the street?

blackbird77 · 14/07/2023 07:44

Completely agree with you OP. 100%

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 14/07/2023 07:43

Mine were fine, but I homeschooled fulltime - freelancer at the time - we had enough money for everything we needed and we live somewhere with access to lots of outdoor space which I had the time to take them to. They were younger so I could teach them and they weren’t seeking independence etc as teens do

many, many children were not fine.

Can’t believe you’re a teacher.

Anyway, I think I’ll believe statistics over the opinion of one random on MN.

Nuevabegin · 14/07/2023 07:42

@DannyLaRuesBestFrock could be totally wrong but I suspect @orangeleavesinautumn doesn’t have multiple dcs themselves or maybe any kids and is eye rolling at parents hamming this up for dcs as obviously parents love making their dcs anxious…It’s definitely got that vibe about it . Also the fact is teaching kids and being a parent to kids is a totally different experience.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 14/07/2023 07:41

I ran a pop up, community food bank over October half term. I saw a lot of children in poverty in my local area who were going without the social intervention that they would normally get through school.

I see a lot of the incoming reception kids, 4-5 year olds, with food issues, because it was difficult for working parents to feed their children a variety of foods, and work.

I see a lot of emotional regulation issues in the current reception kids, who stayed at home with mum and dad working, or helping an older sibling with their homework.

I see a lot of 7-9 year olds who had enough understanding to feel scared, but not enough understanding to process the issue, so for them Covid became a boogie man.

I see 9-12 year olds who missed out on their first steps of independence and the self esteem that brings, and the last few years of their gentle, primary schooling.

It's ok to admit that the kids had it bad. Living through covid was <10% of my lifespan to date. I had a frame of reference for norm. For our children, it was a sudden change which lasted 50%, 70%, of their life spans. They didn't have the frame of reference or critical thinking skills to self soothe.

NIparty · 14/07/2023 07:40

My eldest was in primary 1 in 2020. It definitely has affected her. Hyper aware of germs, scared of people getting ill, anxious and less socially able than her younger sister who was more shielded from the effects due to her age. My son was born in 2020, could go nowhere and mix with no one. When everything opened up, like most children, caught everything all at once much more severely than if he had been continuously exposed, and has now developed an autoimmune condition. His doctor is convinced it has been triggered by the amount of viruses and strain on his immune systems in a short burst of time, causing is immune system to adapt much much quicker than it's supposed to.

So for my middle child, I agree with your statement. Her life has (as much as anyone can tell) continued on the same directory as it would have without covid. She wasn't hard done by, isolated or traumatised. She was old enough to have had childcare, mum's and tots, soft play etc before lock down, but not old enough to understand what was happening, and not yet in school to have missed any education. My youngest is developing socially ok, but has been impacted health wise. My eldest has very much been impacted. She missed half of both p1 and p2, fundamental years for learning to read and develop social skills. She had a much higher level of understanding of what was happening. She had friends and family to miss (younger 2 didn't have friends yet and hadn't bonded as much with family as eldest due to their age), all matched with me going in to hospital to have a baby, not being allowed any visitors and due to complications being kept in for 10 days without being able to see her, and without her having the support of grandparents and aunts/uncles etc to help distract her etc

LuckOfTheDrawer · 14/07/2023 07:39

The Covid pandemic is scientifically recognised as something that could cause trauma, both at an individual and societal level.

I'm not sure what your anecdata adds to that really.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 14/07/2023 07:39

We’ve seen a massive increase in referrals to child and adolescent mental health services.

@orangeleavesinautumn why do you think that is?

AgathaSpencerGregson · 14/07/2023 07:39

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:46

I did not select them, I just asked the first 30-40 or so classes in front of me after returning from lockdown

Impeccable scientific method here
youre a genius, OP

MrsLentil · 14/07/2023 07:38

However, consistency in maintaining a child’s view of the world and their ability to navigate it contributes massively to resilience.

Yep, I thought this was obvious, but evidently not to some people.

WimbyAce · 14/07/2023 07:37

At the time I thought it was horrific and I was sad for the children as they were missing out on so much. But now I look back and it wasn't so bad and there were actually some positives. I hear people use lockdown baby quite a lot as reasons for this, that and the other. I had one child who had her 1st 2 years of school disrupted and 1 genuine lockdown baby as she was born at the very start of covid and they are both absolutely fine, in fact thriving.

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 07:37

but in many countries there is never extra curricular activities, it's too dangerous to play out and the kids study all evening with poor light as their ticket out of poverty - this is always not due to covid! These poor kids (in both sense of the word) seem to have less issues then our privileged ones

the obvious factor to me there is consistency. Poverty and danger are threats faced by children in many countries, it’s bloody awful and I think that’s almost universally recognised.

However, consistency in maintaining a child’s view of the world and their ability to navigate it contributes massively to resilience. If you took the child you describe out of that country for 18 months and then sent them back how do you think their resilience to navigate their society would fare?

Changeling78 · 14/07/2023 07:36

Considering my DD is still having mental health issues from lockdown, I find it worrying that she may end up with a teacher with views such as yours. Maybe they’ll tell her how good she had it and how bad other countries had it.

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 07:36

LlynTegid · 14/07/2023 07:25

If Mr Johnson had acted promptly in March 2020, then children could have had less lost schooling face to face, as I think some could have resumed in June or maybe early July 2020.

Agree with the OP that the impact was a lot less than in many other places.

How? As we saw, no amount of lockdowns actually stopped it. Every time we came out of a lockdown it came back. No country in the world actually fixed the problem. Even Australia and China (who many posters said we should be following with their even stricter/longer lockdowns). Even if we'd have locked down sooner, we may have come out sooner, but we'd still have been back in again sooner! No early lockdown would have sorted out Delta or whatever the second lockdown was. Every country saw the same thing play out. Yes some had less deaths as they had more restrictions. But none got away with shorter lockdowns with no restrictions.

Maddy70 · 14/07/2023 07:35

I'm a teacher. Some of my students were stuck 24/,7 in abusive homes trying to do their school work on a shared laptop (if they had one at all) and leek up with children who had much better advantages being frightened all day long.

2boysandagirltoo · 14/07/2023 07:34

Everyone will have a different take on this.

I had one child who didn't get to take the GCSEs she'd worked so hard for, another who didn't finish year 6 or start year 7

All 3 kids reacted differently and have all been affected in some way.

Prescottdanni123 · 14/07/2023 07:32

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:46

I did not select them, I just asked the first 30-40 or so classes in front of me after returning from lockdown

Right. Because teenagers are so good at admitting that they are struggling/finding things difficult to an unsympathetic teacher in front of an entire class of their peers. Hmm

MrsLentil · 14/07/2023 07:32

I'm still astonished that long-term isolation and desocialisation of children, for the first time in human history, was not considered a vastly dangerous and unethical experiment

This.

Enko · 14/07/2023 07:32

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:58

some impact, yes, but it really want the terrible trauma and deprivation it keeps being referred to as. It was more an annoyance in inconvenience in general.

We don't actually get to decide what impacts others. Situations affects different people differently. Can I suggest you educate yourself on trauma before you proclaim because others have it worse British children can't be traumatised.

Also you asked students where you are? Let me guess nice middle class area with lots of supportive parents?

My own children were not hugely affected as they had a lovely supportive home. Some of the students in the secondary school I worked in after covid spoke of not knowing if they would get food or trying to do their school work via a small telephone screen.

They were hugely affected.

Different demographic to what my children are. Yet they were affected too.

Again we don't get to decide what others find traumatic.

DannyLaRuesBestFrock · 14/07/2023 07:30

Have you got your own kids OP, or do you just teach other people's and hand them back to their full time carers after a few hours of the day?

How could you possibly know?

Annoyingnamechangerperson · 14/07/2023 07:28

I think YABU you’re saying that some children worldwide have a different standard of education / living and social life to children in the UK and therefore British children weren’t traumatised by having to lead that life for a couple of years.
Could you not counteract your own argument then by saying it would be more traumatising as a UK child to have your complete education and social life changed?
Surely by your comparison the children you’re comparing UK children to had an easier time with lockdown as it was closer to their ‘norm’ and therefore not as traumatic?
I think you’re trying to compare apples to oranges and you can’t.
I think COVID was traumatic for everyone everywhere especially at the start.
No one could escape the daily death count, daily briefings and general scare mongering and yes I would say any person / child in any country would be affected by that as it was constant and everyone was locked down.
Added to that the rates of domestic abuse and child abuse increased during lockdown and the people experiencing this were literally locked down at home Id say there was a lot for children to be traumatised about and now they’re facing their trauma as children who have missed out on two years of social development with their friends.
Added to that there were also children who were already traumatised, struggling with anxiety and mental health difficulties before lockdown who didn’t have access to face to face support during that period who are trying to manage that now as well as it being generally isolating and terrifying for most people.

Nuevabegin · 14/07/2023 07:27

Also saying how swaths of a society like you mentioned in countries like China live like this a lot and are absolutely fine ; how can you make this statement , how do you know? I agree asking a whole class how did they get on is so general , my dcs often will say what the teacher wants them
to say. Do you have dcs? One huge thing I’ve learned being a parent and a teacher is how many dcs are completely different in the classroom vs the home. I cringed so much when I saw posts from teachers saying “now you know what a hard job it is teaching ..” I can easily manage a class of 30 teenagers but I know I’ll find my three teenagers challenging. Do you get what I mean ? You don’t really see the real people in your classroom most of the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread