Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 14/07/2023 10:31

Incidentally FB has just reminded me - it's the anniversary today of the day they took the padlocks off the playgrounds around here. I can still remember the absolute joy as the rumour spread and more and more kids showed up onto the park that day.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 10:30

Also loads demanding lockdown knowing they had keyworker places.

Basically other dc stay home

Load of bollocks

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 10:26

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 10:16

The issue is though, as we discovered, there wasn't really a way to deal with it. It just needed to run its course and wait for vaccines to (hopefully) work. Each time we came out of lockdown cases rose, deaths rose and people freaked out.
If we'd have gone pretty much back to normal in June/July 2020 and stayed that way with no further restrictions the backlash would have been huge! You only had to look on here and the praise australia and new zealand got for having hard core lock downs that went on for months! Everyone would have been screaming about the death numbers and how many children were made orphans and lost grandparents.
It's all well and good looking back and everyone saying what they SHOULD have done. But in the grips of it most people thought very differently.

Not everyone was demanding this but the voices got quashed in the barrage

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:24

The initial dialogue was about the lockdown being to essentially buy time - give the NHS time to pivot and prepare (which actually, it did pretty impressively - it's just struggled to reverse direction and remember what it was originally doing like someone who's gone into the kitchen to fetch something and has no idea what the hell they've gone in there for)... but then somewhere along the line we got sucked into this idea that if we just did a few more weeks... the virus would go away.... if we just added in a few more restrictions... we could get the numbers down a little bit further.

Yeah, there was definitely that shift. Obviously people will have different views on whether it was right to prioritise getting the numbers down (clearly the people who thought we could make it go away are just wrong). But it shouldn't be a surprise that some people changed their views when the narrative changed.

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 10:24

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:19

There would have been staggeringly few orphans though. Grandparents perhaps. But parents of children were not, in most cases, at any significant risk.
At the end of the day it's up to the government and scientists to weight up risk/cost, not the general public. And IMO they massively let us down.

Oh I agree there would have been very few orphans. But back in 2020 that was one of the things people kept posting about. Everyone on here seemed to know someone who had died leaving young children. Same as everyone knew a healthy 19 year old marathon runner who had died.
The media terrified everyone into thinking they were going to die. I think it was too extreme. And I don't think the endless lockdowns were needed either. But the fact is if they'd chosen not to lock down in later waves, the backlash from the public would still have been mental. Even though the government are shit, they couldn't win this. Whatever way they went they'd have been critised.
If we'd not had the second lockdown and deaths were high, people would be on here now saying about how many lives could have been saved if they had.

CoffeeWithCheese · 14/07/2023 10:23

I pulled my kids out a few days before schools closed. Not for fear of the virus to be fair - but because DD2 in particular was not coping well with the atmosphere of terror and restrictions being put in place around her school. She's autistic, but her needs for consistency and change to be managed got thrown out of the window and she was not coping well with that - it was clear what was coming by that point, so I took her out a few days earlier to buy us a smoother transition into the shit that was to come.

Starlightstarbright2 · 14/07/2023 10:23

What a narrow minded view …

yes some children thoroughly enjoyed it but that doesn’t mean they didn’t have struggles adapting back into the world .

the huge increase in mh needs you think is co incidental.

i was a c/ minder during lockdowns young children couldn’t socialise go to groups parks - we did some online classes but missed out on a lot .
we visited one child for there birthday but stood behind a wall at the end of there front garden - this is not how preschoolers learn to integrate .

my own Ds who has Asd/adhd did struggle massively- he missed out on so much - didn’t go on school trips through the whole school , didn’t do work experience, the third lockdown he went into school as a vulnerable child as he wasn’t coping .

children with adhd are generally 2.7 years behind in emotional maturity - been isolated will not of helped any of his maturity.

what you fail to realise is it wasn’t a few weeks break there was constant uncertainty- indeed the third lockdown was announced at 8pm kids went to school one day and not the next.

This is a time in history that will be discussed in history lessons in years to come because it affected many people including children - I still occasionally see in my job people who are struggling to leave the house. They are generally older people but these people are still struggling to visit relatives - grandchildren .

whether they were traumatised by it is not the same question as were they impacted

Saschka · 14/07/2023 10:23

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:19

There would have been staggeringly few orphans though. Grandparents perhaps. But parents of children were not, in most cases, at any significant risk.
At the end of the day it's up to the government and scientists to weight up risk/cost, not the general public. And IMO they massively let us down.

I cannot count the number of fit black men in their early 50s I admitted, in multi organ failure, in April 2020. About 50% died. I also lost 10% of my dialysis unit patients, many of whom had children in their teens.

It just isn’t correct to say “there wouldn’t have been many orphans”. I can think of several off the top of my head, and that was with restrictions.

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:21

carduelis · 14/07/2023 10:17

I think a lot of parents probably rationally knew it was no safer (because whatever measures you take, 30 kids in one room are going to spread an airborne virus) but felt it had to stop somewhere. So while it may not have felt worth the risk of sending kids back in late June or July, when the academic year was winding down anyway, it felt like a risk worth taking in September. I’m sure there’s a name for this phenomenon - it’s why if you’re ill on a Friday you’re far more likely to take the day off than you are if you’re ill on a Monday!

But completely agree that locking down earlier would never have affected case-fatality rates and may well have had no effect on case rates in June (someone must have modelled the latter though?).

Yeah could be that. It's an interesting way of looking at it. People maybe trying to park the issue for a bit.

CoffeeWithCheese · 14/07/2023 10:21

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 09:52

This is the thing. At the time the vast majority of people (on here anyway) supported a lockdown. People were demanding it weeks before it happened. People were pulling their children out of school early.
So they got what they wanted. But now the vast majority of people are complaining it was a bad thing and it's ruined a whole generation of young people.

At the start though it's worth remembering - we were mis-sold a lockdown as a couple of weeks to flatten the curve and kick it down the road. The initial dialogue was about the lockdown being to essentially buy time - give the NHS time to pivot and prepare (which actually, it did pretty impressively - it's just struggled to reverse direction and remember what it was originally doing like someone who's gone into the kitchen to fetch something and has no idea what the hell they've gone in there for)... but then somewhere along the line we got sucked into this idea that if we just did a few more weeks... the virus would go away.... if we just added in a few more restrictions... we could get the numbers down a little bit further.

Once we'd locked down and the self-appointed arbiters of crisp eating on a bench had got their taste of power and route to bully the shit out of everyone else for the next couple of years - no one was ever going to have the courage to say, right, that's it, we're as ready as we ever be and we're going to have to ride the curve now.

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:19

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 10:16

The issue is though, as we discovered, there wasn't really a way to deal with it. It just needed to run its course and wait for vaccines to (hopefully) work. Each time we came out of lockdown cases rose, deaths rose and people freaked out.
If we'd have gone pretty much back to normal in June/July 2020 and stayed that way with no further restrictions the backlash would have been huge! You only had to look on here and the praise australia and new zealand got for having hard core lock downs that went on for months! Everyone would have been screaming about the death numbers and how many children were made orphans and lost grandparents.
It's all well and good looking back and everyone saying what they SHOULD have done. But in the grips of it most people thought very differently.

There would have been staggeringly few orphans though. Grandparents perhaps. But parents of children were not, in most cases, at any significant risk.
At the end of the day it's up to the government and scientists to weight up risk/cost, not the general public. And IMO they massively let us down.

carduelis · 14/07/2023 10:17

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:07

Mmm, I don't think that can be presumed, tbh.

Agree though there were definitely parents who didn't want to send their kids back in June. Lots seemed to have the idea that September was going to be safer, which struck me as odd at the time.

I think a lot of parents probably rationally knew it was no safer (because whatever measures you take, 30 kids in one room are going to spread an airborne virus) but felt it had to stop somewhere. So while it may not have felt worth the risk of sending kids back in late June or July, when the academic year was winding down anyway, it felt like a risk worth taking in September. I’m sure there’s a name for this phenomenon - it’s why if you’re ill on a Friday you’re far more likely to take the day off than you are if you’re ill on a Monday!

But completely agree that locking down earlier would never have affected case-fatality rates and may well have had no effect on case rates in June (someone must have modelled the latter though?).

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 10:16

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:03

It's one thing to support a short lockdown while we work out what we're dealing with.
Years of restrictions is entirely different.

The issue is though, as we discovered, there wasn't really a way to deal with it. It just needed to run its course and wait for vaccines to (hopefully) work. Each time we came out of lockdown cases rose, deaths rose and people freaked out.
If we'd have gone pretty much back to normal in June/July 2020 and stayed that way with no further restrictions the backlash would have been huge! You only had to look on here and the praise australia and new zealand got for having hard core lock downs that went on for months! Everyone would have been screaming about the death numbers and how many children were made orphans and lost grandparents.
It's all well and good looking back and everyone saying what they SHOULD have done. But in the grips of it most people thought very differently.

CoffeeWithCheese · 14/07/2023 10:16

I see the effects of Long Covid include a total lack of empathy, compassion and the development of being a completely psychopathic uncaring douchebag now.

DD2 became fucking terrified of anything floating in the air (she still partially is now). She lost most of her language for a good while, and academically she's still not fully back in terms of parity with her peers with where she was back then. From probably the most "optimal" home background going in terms of a skill set to be able to support her - but she was badly affected... some kids are. The response to that on here was a bunch of fucking bitches telling parents of kids who were really legitimately struggling to "learn some resilience."

Rise in eating disorders - documented
Massive decline in levels of school readiness reported by teachers who work with the cohort - documented
Decline in mental health among kids - documented
Incredibly increase in the percentage of children arriving at school with speech and language needs - documented (and SALT services cannot bloody cope - not to mention there's a massive recruitment problem with that profession as well)

If I could be bothered I'd pull out the exact statistics and references from my dissertation - but the OP just wants to bash kids and push the lockdown minimisation agenda and won't bother listening. But I heard time and time again that, even among the kids who had an "easy" run of it - that there was still a "distrust" for want of a better phrase, that their daily lives and normal were now going to stay the same and that the plans they had for things like camps, residential, parties etc could be made with some relative degree of confidence that they would go ahead.

Not to mention the long term impact in terms of access to early help services which should have been there to support families before hitting crisis points - but where the services were suspended and on firefighting mode for so long that crisis WAS reached needing much more indepth support and intervention, and the fact that waiting lists are still absolutely completely and totally fucking out of control now. Or the fact that transitions for individuals with SEND between paeds and adult services happened in such a chaotic manner that things are now going to shit rapidly for them because of Covid firefighting and service disruption. I've also worked with autistic kids who were fascinated by WW2 military history - for whom the months at home with an internet connection, parents trying to juggle home learning and their own jobs and less supervision than would be ideal as a result, meant that they had months at home on the Internet to google up "Nazis" - you can imagine where internet algorithms can potentially lead that to.

As a society we have a moral obligation to do what we can to mitigate the long term impact that this all had on the kids who put a huge percentage of their lives (because when you're 7 a year off and on is a huge chunk of the time you've been on the planet - less so when you're 47) on hold to keep others safe - and that begins by identifying what damage WAS caused so we can begin to unpick it - and not by minimising it, dismissing them as snowflakes and giving them even MORE shit.

I think what lockdowns have taught us, SHOULD teach us are two huge lessons:

  1. you cannot, however much you bang a saucepan on your front doorstep on an evening, put society on pause without their being consequences.
  2. politicians take the piss and don't follow the rules they put in place.
Saschka · 14/07/2023 10:10

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 09:52

This is the thing. At the time the vast majority of people (on here anyway) supported a lockdown. People were demanding it weeks before it happened. People were pulling their children out of school early.
So they got what they wanted. But now the vast majority of people are complaining it was a bad thing and it's ruined a whole generation of young people.

I think lockdown was better than mass deaths and the collapse of the health service (which, certainly in my hospital, was very close by end of April - we literally ran out of ventilators, CVVH fluid, had increased our ICU bed capacity fivefold).

That doesn’t mean lockdown was a desirable thing, just the least worst of two very bad options.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/07/2023 10:09

redfacebigdisgrace · 14/07/2023 00:17

I am a teacher and am pretty flabbergasted at your first and subsequent posts. You seem really lacking in insight. I’m not sure I believe you’re a teacher to be honest. Even in my privileged independent school many children struggled and we have seen knock on effects in so many ways. Not to
mention my own kids.

As if asking a room of children in front of their peers will elicit truthful responses…. 🤷‍♀️

This.

It's deeply worrying that a teacher has no critical thinking skills.

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:07

carduelis · 14/07/2023 10:04

No, I was just saying that presumably the decision not to open schools was not due to the case rates at the time but due to the case-fatality rate (which was, of course, no lower in the autumn, when as you say seasonal viruses were starting up). But I suspect a lot of parents felt (not necessarily rationally) that things were safer in the autumn than they were in June?

I wonder whether the decision was partly to give schools time over the summer holidays with no children in to work out safety protocols and so on - all that tape that had to be put down to mark one-way systems and 2 metre distances, different arrangements for lunch had to be worked out, how to make equipment safe in practical subjects (I remember disinfecting our safety goggles after every lesson in science)…

Mmm, I don't think that can be presumed, tbh.

Agree though there were definitely parents who didn't want to send their kids back in June. Lots seemed to have the idea that September was going to be safer, which struck me as odd at the time.

Tinybrother · 14/07/2023 10:05

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 09:52

This is the thing. At the time the vast majority of people (on here anyway) supported a lockdown. People were demanding it weeks before it happened. People were pulling their children out of school early.
So they got what they wanted. But now the vast majority of people are complaining it was a bad thing and it's ruined a whole generation of young people.

It might not be the same people, of course, have you tracked usernames or something? Also people can change their minds as time goes on. What people were thinking in March 2020 may have been different to what they were thinking a couple of months or years later.

carduelis · 14/07/2023 10:04

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 09:34

But cases were always going to increase when kids went back to school, and we knew there'd be a deadlier second wave once restrictions were loosened anyway. Chris Whitty told the government that in March 2020, they knew before locking down. So at a time when rates were very low, the government made the choice to push the inevitable back until autumn, closer to the start of winter flu season. With that in mind, it's still not clear what difference an earlier lockdown would've made to schooling in June 2020. I didn't think anyone was arguing that case fatality rates would've been lowered by going earlier, were they?

No, I was just saying that presumably the decision not to open schools was not due to the case rates at the time but due to the case-fatality rate (which was, of course, no lower in the autumn, when as you say seasonal viruses were starting up). But I suspect a lot of parents felt (not necessarily rationally) that things were safer in the autumn than they were in June?

I wonder whether the decision was partly to give schools time over the summer holidays with no children in to work out safety protocols and so on - all that tape that had to be put down to mark one-way systems and 2 metre distances, different arrangements for lunch had to be worked out, how to make equipment safe in practical subjects (I remember disinfecting our safety goggles after every lesson in science)…

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:04

bookworm14 · 14/07/2023 09:57

Our children were forced to sacrifice a lot in order to protect older generations and meanwhile, adults were breaking the rules and politicians having cheese and wine parties/affairs. The least people could do is show children a bit of respect after that and not diminish their experiences, and actual research which shows direct correlations between covid and negative impacts on children.

Absolutely spot on.

Tbf some of us adults were breaking rules because of the welfare of our children, but otherwise completely agree. The OP is a troll, but people having the discussion aren't.

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:03

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 09:52

This is the thing. At the time the vast majority of people (on here anyway) supported a lockdown. People were demanding it weeks before it happened. People were pulling their children out of school early.
So they got what they wanted. But now the vast majority of people are complaining it was a bad thing and it's ruined a whole generation of young people.

It's one thing to support a short lockdown while we work out what we're dealing with.
Years of restrictions is entirely different.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 09:58

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 09:52

This is the thing. At the time the vast majority of people (on here anyway) supported a lockdown. People were demanding it weeks before it happened. People were pulling their children out of school early.
So they got what they wanted. But now the vast majority of people are complaining it was a bad thing and it's ruined a whole generation of young people.

Yeh there was loads of support, actually further than that posters demanding it and going postal on those who said hang on there might be damage to dc

IsThatHuw · 14/07/2023 09:58

bookworm14 · 14/07/2023 09:57

Our children were forced to sacrifice a lot in order to protect older generations and meanwhile, adults were breaking the rules and politicians having cheese and wine parties/affairs. The least people could do is show children a bit of respect after that and not diminish their experiences, and actual research which shows direct correlations between covid and negative impacts on children.

Absolutely spot on.

Second that.

Sugarfree23 · 14/07/2023 09:58

I was a supporter of the first one when we did not know what we were dealing with.
But that doesn't mean all of it was logical or sensible. Far to many inconsistencies that it just became a big social experiment at the cost of businesses and people's MH.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/07/2023 09:58

That's why its important we learn from Lockdown instead of pretending it had no effect. It was seen as necessary back then. No one knew what effect it would have. Now we know, and it can inform decision making in future pandemic situations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread