Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
AllHopeandRainbows · 14/07/2023 12:49

I don’t really think it’s your place to say who did and didn’t suffer. Clearly many children did or there wouldn’t be people saying it. Maybe just mind your own and be thankful of your own privilege that you were one of the unaffected ones.

CoffeeWithCheese · 14/07/2023 12:49

ZairWazAnOldLady · 14/07/2023 12:23

If you were the parent of anyone with LD you were told early on that people with LD wouldn’t get a ventilator if they needed it. I’m guessing that everyone who loves a disabled person hasn’t really come back from that.

I work in LD services and we are still seeing the impact it had on some of our service users now. Some amazing, absolutely fucking life enhancingly epic projects closed, never to reopen. Lots of incredibly good carers left their posts from how awfully they were treated and it's left staffing in a sector that struggles at the best of times in a mess - with high turnover, agency staff, staff that are shuffled around and don't know the people they're working with - the subsequent knock on of behaviours escalating when they could be de-escalated, information not being passed on as staff turnover went through the roof, overmedication as a result of challenging behaviour - and I'm still working through referrals for people who are too out of routine and out of ability to cope with things they previously loved and so no longer leave their home.

Dealing with more OCD type behaviour, people who coped with the loss of everything that they planned their lives around (for lots of our client base they NEED that structure and routine to map their whole understanding of lives around) being stripped away by self-harm - and people who hit the point where they would have begun to appear on our radar during Covid fire-fighting time - now only hitting our radar when the shit really has hit the fan. Not to mention carer stress and placement breakdowns.

I'd say about 40% of my caseload is still supporting carers and families with issues as a consequence of the lockdowns and how people with LD responded and were treated.

Still have homes going into "outbreak" measures and basically locking down with residents confined to rooms as well. Some of the care homes I visit were mandating masks until last month - for people with significant communication impairments that loss of visual information to support communication for that prolonged length of time is bloody huge!

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 12:41

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 12:33

Was it two years damage? I suppose the length of time varies on what repercussions you attribute to what but I would say things had largely calmed down by mid 2021, certainly social restrictions were largely lifted by July 2021. ‘The Fear’ approach largely dissipated due to vaccinations which obviously impacted public perceptions. Granted, ‘softer’ measures weren’t dropped for some months after.

spontaneous reaction and media propaganda are too tangled to attribute a specific campaign to public response. It’s a bit chicken and egg. The government is there to represent the people not tell them how they want to be represented.

I’m not comfortable with the notion that any conversation should have been ‘stopped’ personally. People responded to an event that had never happened in our lifetimes before on a global scale. To think you could tell people to just stop it seems wildly unforgiving of basic human emotions and perception. Ultimately I don’t think it would have worked because on the whole, that’s just not how people work.

People will defend their reaction understandably, and whilst you can’t stop it I think many were ridiculous on here.

I get they don’t want to acknowledge that though and won’t see it. Annoying as that is I could see the manipulation then and now.

Instead I’ll go with questioning what prompted that behaviour which was the daily fear campaign.

That was highly questionable and top down. Without it we’d be closer to now, Covid circulating but no one getting upset or abusive over it. Or a few idk I avoid the board.

It was a policy decision to whip up fear over the virus but largely ignore the damage from lockdown. The public just reacted to that.

Again not the earliest days. But ongoing.

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 12:33

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 12:04

‘Earliest days’ as you say - no problem.

If that had not been prolonged by the overall campaign I’d be totally fine with that.

If it had stopped the conversations would have been very different. Covid is still around now but since dropped from fear approach society moves on too.

No issue with earliest days being different to two years damage.

Was it two years damage? I suppose the length of time varies on what repercussions you attribute to what but I would say things had largely calmed down by mid 2021, certainly social restrictions were largely lifted by July 2021. ‘The Fear’ approach largely dissipated due to vaccinations which obviously impacted public perceptions. Granted, ‘softer’ measures weren’t dropped for some months after.

spontaneous reaction and media propaganda are too tangled to attribute a specific campaign to public response. It’s a bit chicken and egg. The government is there to represent the people not tell them how they want to be represented.

I’m not comfortable with the notion that any conversation should have been ‘stopped’ personally. People responded to an event that had never happened in our lifetimes before on a global scale. To think you could tell people to just stop it seems wildly unforgiving of basic human emotions and perception. Ultimately I don’t think it would have worked because on the whole, that’s just not how people work.

Icannoteven · 14/07/2023 12:32

Yabu. If parents were not key workers, then children and parents were completely isolated, for months at a time.

One day, without warning, they were told that they were no longer allowed to see friends or wider family. Their routines were completely disrupted. They had no chance to socialise (younger kids had no way to speak to their friends). Outdoor activity was super restricted during the first lock down to one hour a day.

Many kids were stuck at home with parent who were trying to do full time jobs and homeschool. I know my own household was a stress nightmare at this time. A house full of people 23/7. The noise, the mess, the conflicting demands. Things were shouty, things were messy, it was insane.

Families were without their usual support networks. We got no break and no help and were parenting harder than ever, trying to be teacher, parent (and employee) and be the only form of social and emotional support for our children.

My kids didn’t get to see their grandparents for about 18 months as we live in different parts of the country that had different restrictions at different times.

The lack of health services available during Covid has really done a number on children and their parents (and therefore how well they can look after their children too).

Add to this the general fear that children must have felt knowing that we were in a pandemic?

And this is just my experience. I can’t imagine what it was like for people with new norms. Or kids doing their A levels or starting university.

I think kids have been completely fucked over by covid.

elliejjtiny · 14/07/2023 12:29

@ZairWazAnOldLady my son has LD and I still struggle with the fact that he could be denied treatment like that. Also that I wasn't allowed to see my 12 year old when he was in hospital after an overdose while Boris Johnson was having parties.

wendyjoy · 14/07/2023 12:27

My Grandsons are home educated so didn't know any different.
But my eldest was 15 and caught covid bad.. he reverted back to being a toddler ..his Mum had to bath him.. feed him.. dress him.
He lost 3 stone in weight and now suffers long covid ..where he has bouts of AFRID and depression.
Traumatised is not a big enough word.

MargaretThursday · 14/07/2023 12:23

Ds still refers to it as being the best year of school he had. I think it also made his ASD/ADHD diagnosis easier-I'd heard stories of how it could easily be 2 years. It took time to get started, but we had both diagnosis surprisingly quickly and easily. I'd referred him in March 2020. On-line consultations suited him much better than taking him somewhere he didn't know.
Not sure it did his academics much good, but I only realised when he was back at school full time how much mental effort just being at school is for him. he was a different child through lockdown-in a good way.

However it did effect dd2's mental health quite badly. Not actually the lockdown, but the constant media reports of how badly lockdown was effecting children's mental health. Part of her mental health issues mean that she's very suggestable, so the more she was told it was bad for her, the worse she got, even though she really quite enjoyed the time off school and especially missing her GCSEs.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 14/07/2023 12:23

If you were the parent of anyone with LD you were told early on that people with LD wouldn’t get a ventilator if they needed it. I’m guessing that everyone who loves a disabled person hasn’t really come back from that.

ThreeImaginaryBoys · 14/07/2023 12:13

I have no idea where you teach, OP, but we are the impact of Covid on the kids in my school every day.

Communication and language skills, social and emotional skills, and even their physical development have been affected.

I suggest you do a bit more research. Look at things like the 'toxic trio'. Look at the mental health reports for young people. Don't base it on a few people you had a chat with.

twelly · 14/07/2023 12:09

I think it does vary massively, there are those who say that the covid lockdown was not an issues and in some ways improved their teenagers experience but there are other for whom the whole experience has proved to be awful with long term damage occurring. I have seen teenagers who have really suffered during the pandemic - isolation, totally useless online lessons - dreadful educational experience in between the lockdowns bringing out the worst in the teaching profession, but I know that is not everyone's experience. I think it varies and we need to acknowledge this, there will be some young people who take years to recover from the experience and others who simply take longer to mature as they catch up on the missed experience.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 12:04

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:58

I don’t dispute that fear was a tool utilised by the government during Covid but I have to presume that you either don’t know or have forgotten the earliest days of Covid when the creation of that fear was a very societal led phenomenon. This was soon backed up by real life experience, again not led by government or even media.

There was never going to be a scenario where ‘without that’ existed I’m afraid.

‘Earliest days’ as you say - no problem.

If that had not been prolonged by the overall campaign I’d be totally fine with that.

If it had stopped the conversations would have been very different. Covid is still around now but since dropped from fear approach society moves on too.

No issue with earliest days being different to two years damage.

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 12:04

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 11:48

But the public and the government all knew full well when flu season starts. The government also knew that a deadlier second wave was unavoidable, though I don't know to what extent the public had copped on to that.

True but a lot of Covid management consisted of ‘suck it and see’. How could it be any other way for a completely new virus? The government was aware of the flu season of course, but it also had to balance that against real life and lockdowns being untenable.

Tests are an established way of controlling outbreaks of disease, it wasn’t unreasonable for those in charge to think the same might apply in the case of Covid. (What was unreasonable was that lanky streak of piss Rees-Moggs standing up in parliament essentially telling parents to shut up when the government completely failed to provide enough testing capability because they couldn’t have possibly known there would be an increase in demand come the return to schools 🙄)

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:58

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 11:46

Ha what an excuse. Not really. It is part of living at a time when a Covid fear campaign is in full swing though.

Without that people wouldn’t have done it so I’d do away with the campaign.

I don’t dispute that fear was a tool utilised by the government during Covid but I have to presume that you either don’t know or have forgotten the earliest days of Covid when the creation of that fear was a very societal led phenomenon. This was soon backed up by real life experience, again not led by government or even media.

There was never going to be a scenario where ‘without that’ existed I’m afraid.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/07/2023 11:48

And yes I did my very best to fit in as much homeschooling as humanly possible but homeschooling doesn’t really work for some children!

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 11:48

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:28

By September there were clearer guidelines around isolations/testing. There was a layer of management that didn’t exist/wasn’t accessible to the general public early on in the pandemic.

But the public and the government all knew full well when flu season starts. The government also knew that a deadlier second wave was unavoidable, though I don't know to what extent the public had copped on to that.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/07/2023 11:47

What a horrible post!

My DS was in yr 1 when Covid hit, and they were just beginning to pick up in some ADHD indicators.

Because of COVID it’s taken until yr 4 to get any kind of diagnosis and still no EHCP in sight. Also didn’t get the support he should have got over the Covid heads because he wasn’t in school - and not considered vulnerable until well into the 2021 lockdown because it was early stages of identifying the Adhd.

He was stuck at home with me (single parent) working full time in a high pressure, public sector job which couldn’t be furloughed but wasn’t counted as “key”.

He’s very bright but has been stuck well behind his peers as a result and is only now beginning to make up ground. All of this would not have happened if he’d been in school.

StefanosHill · 14/07/2023 11:46

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:43

It’s an unmeasurable question though isn’t it? Proof of what didn’t happen is impossible.

I don’t think the intention was ever a blanket ‘save lives’ policy and have said before that if Covid killed (when it’s going to) quickly then it wouldn’t have been half as much of a problem or for so long. But it didn’t/doesn’t. It requires weeks of intensive medical support in a small but significant percentage of the population.

The point was always that the increased pressure on health systems and resources was the danger. We did see the result of ignoring that in some countries - Brazil and India are the ones that spring to my mind. Ultimately if you’re faced with that the options are to cross your fingers or adjust your behaviour. Which is all well and good to leave up to the individual to decide except in the case of a contagion those decisions do directly impact others choices.

Not everyone was demanding this but the voices got quashed in the barrage

@StefanosHill well that’s part and parcel of living in a society isn’t it?

Ha what an excuse. Not really. It is part of living at a time when a Covid fear campaign is in full swing though.

Without that people wouldn’t have done it so I’d do away with the campaign.

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:43

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:33

As I said, risk vs cost.
Of course in a pandemic there would be loss of life. We tried to prevent it and have been left with a mental health crisis, a failing health service and economic disaster. And it's still unclear how many lives were even saved. Was it really worth it?

It’s an unmeasurable question though isn’t it? Proof of what didn’t happen is impossible.

I don’t think the intention was ever a blanket ‘save lives’ policy and have said before that if Covid killed (when it’s going to) quickly then it wouldn’t have been half as much of a problem or for so long. But it didn’t/doesn’t. It requires weeks of intensive medical support in a small but significant percentage of the population.

The point was always that the increased pressure on health systems and resources was the danger. We did see the result of ignoring that in some countries - Brazil and India are the ones that spring to my mind. Ultimately if you’re faced with that the options are to cross your fingers or adjust your behaviour. Which is all well and good to leave up to the individual to decide except in the case of a contagion those decisions do directly impact others choices.

Not everyone was demanding this but the voices got quashed in the barrage

@StefanosHill well that’s part and parcel of living in a society isn’t it?

OsirisservesAnubis · 14/07/2023 11:34

My kids had a fantastic time in lockdown, as did most of their peers. However I appreciate they are young (lower primary at the time) and we are fortunate that we have a nice house and good garden.

I certainly don't think because my kids had a wonderful time that all kids did. But ones I know of certainly did (of all ages) but I attribute that to the fact that the majority of people I know well enough to discuss it with are in a similar socio-economic place as us.

Cornettoninja · 14/07/2023 11:28

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 10:07

Mmm, I don't think that can be presumed, tbh.

Agree though there were definitely parents who didn't want to send their kids back in June. Lots seemed to have the idea that September was going to be safer, which struck me as odd at the time.

By September there were clearer guidelines around isolations/testing. There was a layer of management that didn’t exist/wasn’t accessible to the general public early on in the pandemic.

Hankunamatata · 14/07/2023 10:41

Funny op I was saying to a friend, I wonder how covid will be recorded in history books. As a family we came out unscathed as key worker our lives carried on much as normal with going to work and school, we didnt know anyone who died or was seriously ill. For us covid wasn't really a huge issue but there will be the other end of spectrum where families lost loved ones or left with debilitating conditions

Anniejameslastcallanniejames · 14/07/2023 10:36

Some children would have been at home in domestic violence situations all day everyday, some parents may have lost jobs and were struggling to feed children, some children has no access to laptops or wifi to be able to online school. Some children may have been grieving lost loved ones. Try not to be so small minded

Oliotya · 14/07/2023 10:33

Saschka · 14/07/2023 10:23

I cannot count the number of fit black men in their early 50s I admitted, in multi organ failure, in April 2020. About 50% died. I also lost 10% of my dialysis unit patients, many of whom had children in their teens.

It just isn’t correct to say “there wouldn’t have been many orphans”. I can think of several off the top of my head, and that was with restrictions.

As I said, risk vs cost.
Of course in a pandemic there would be loss of life. We tried to prevent it and have been left with a mental health crisis, a failing health service and economic disaster. And it's still unclear how many lives were even saved. Was it really worth it?

ZairWazAnOldLady · 14/07/2023 10:33

It’s simply not true that “not that many parents of children died”.