Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
AnneElliott23 · 14/07/2023 05:32

What do you teach, inherent privilege and blinkers???

Just look at how many cases are starting to come out, bit by bit, of child and animal abuse during lockdown if you want to understand just how sh*t it was for some kids and families. And they're almost certainly just the tip of the iceberg.

Look up generational trauma too; PTSD, especially complex PTSD, can take decades to show. We don't yet know the full picture of what this is going to do to us as a species, but if you have lived in a country where you have been taught you have relative freedom for generations and those freedoms are suddenly withdrawn and you can be fined by the police for simply going for a walk as happened in Derbyshire and many other places, I would venture to suggest it probably came as a bit of a shock. That's before we get to anything practical like changes in food security.

It really wasn't all banana bread and boxsets for many, but if you've never taught in really poor inner city or rural schools you will only know your reality. I'm guessing it isn't English literature you teach, and I really hope it isn't anything on the social sciences or healthcare side of the curriculum. You may, as you claim, have genuinely taught all over the place, but if that's been as supply, say, whatever you might think, ot takes a long time for some less privileged kids to trust a new teacher, if indeed some of them ever do. They'll be wanting to fit in with the class consensus.

But hey, hurrah for your resilience and amazingly robust research methodology. I can only hope broader life experience is on the way for you.

OhDeniseReally · 14/07/2023 05:06

Your post is a fine example of anecdata OP. Yiu asked kids in a classroom in front of their peers, not sure how truthfully they would answer in front of others in a class. They might be putting a brave face on it. It also depends How you asked them. Also, these are all kids from the same school so you would not have the variety of different demographics, so your research is fundamentally flawed and is likely to produce a skewed result.

Squirrelsnut · 14/07/2023 04:53

It's not a race to the bottom. I've taught for decades and we are definitely seeing the effects of lockdown on younger kids who were in Reception/year 1 in 2020. They are noticeably more needy and less socialised than normal.

stayathomer · 14/07/2023 04:47

Justsaynonow
sleepyscientist

@Justsaynonow so your not okay with taking your chance against a virus which we could already see from china was relatively harmless
How was it relatively harmless before vaccines were made? Did you see the tally of body count in Italy? Ambulances at morgues with dead people queued around blocks?! At the start of this it was right it was treated like Ebola because it was killing people and as someone who got long Covid it was not relatively harmless- I never had health issues before it then had heart/ chest pains from walking a few steps. I object to the idiotic rules they had at times/ in particular when they did figure out how to keep people safe/ and that people followed those times to such an extent that they probably infected people afterwards because they couldn’t think for themselves to take sensible precautions (eg if I had a bug now I’d stay away from people but people said ‘but the rules say!’) and also the big bad blame game when people needed contact/help/human company, but to say all the measures weren’t required is an insult to people who did die or get long term illness out of it (I no longer get chest pains but I know people who are still impacted and have reduced function)

stayathomer · 14/07/2023 04:37

Yanbu in that they didn’t have it difficult compared to certain countries BUT it was a scary time where they were told ‘don’t leave your house or there will be consequences’, stay out of shops, on the radio there were repeated wash your hands and stay home or this virus could kill people you love. They missed out on the usual things teens do. In particular I feel so much for kids just leaving school being made feel like socialising was a criminal activity. And I’m one who had a better lockdown than most. Actually sorry yabu

Justsaynonow · 14/07/2023 04:29

sleepyscientist · 14/07/2023 01:47

@Justsaynonow so your not okay with taking your chance against a virus which we could already see from china was relatively harmless but you were happy to play Russian roulette with peoples mental health? It's all about a risk assessment, if we were dealing with Ebola the measures would have been appropriate to the risk vs a flu like virus in which case they were above and beyond reasonable.

In case you would like to read some research... here's a link

What SARS-CoV-2 Does to the Body (2nd Edition, July 2023)

An Incomplete and Growing Resource

https://www.panaccindex.info/p/what-sars-cov-2-does-to-the-body

Justsaynonow · 14/07/2023 04:23

sleepyscientist · 14/07/2023 01:47

@Justsaynonow so your not okay with taking your chance against a virus which we could already see from china was relatively harmless but you were happy to play Russian roulette with peoples mental health? It's all about a risk assessment, if we were dealing with Ebola the measures would have been appropriate to the risk vs a flu like virus in which case they were above and beyond reasonable.

No one that has studied this disease has ever described it as relatively harmless. (And it's mutating constantly, so delta variants, for instance, can't be compared with omicron related variants.) Not China, where there's currently a surge forecast to cause hundreds of millions of infections. That's why it's classified BSL3. Much higher risk than the flu. Worse consequences. Mental health can be worked on, long term illness/damage, not so much - which, by the way, also impacts mental health. As does covid infection.

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 14/07/2023 04:15

Children in the UK are more isolated than in any of the African countries I’ve worked in where children usually have large extended families and interact with their community in a way that is not the norm here. Can you be specific about where in the world you are talking about OP?

TortolaParadise · 14/07/2023 04:05

HarrietSchulenberg · 13/07/2023 23:57

My teens loved lockdowns. No pressure to do anything and all online with friends. They particularly liked the second lockdown as they had online lessons so more normal structure to their days and more contact with classmates so not just the usual friendship circle. I had to work throughout so we kept to regular routines to some extent, eg regular bedtimes, so they didn't go nocturnal like so many teens I know did.
From my experience it was the ones who threw all routine out of the window that were the ones who struggled the most with the return to normal life.

Can't speak for all but for many front line workers and their children it was business as usual. With added hysteria!

Tptp · 14/07/2023 03:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

MrsMorrisey · 14/07/2023 03:07

You can't expect a child to understand something they've never experienced.
So to say you're privileged, you've got no idea, is right.
But we can't expect them to be grateful when most of there childhood or teenage years were dramatically changed.
Some kids in Melbourne didn't go to school for nearly two years.
You can't say to them "think yourself lucky you don't live in China".

MrsMorrisey · 14/07/2023 03:00

Try being in Australia during lockdown. Sucked!!! YABVVVU

ArcticSkewer · 14/07/2023 02:52

So your claim is that in China, Eastern Europe and other countries you have lived in, children don't leave the house, they only study at home online, don't go to activities with other children and don't meet more than five family members at a time?

Where on earth were you living?

I've lived all over. Noone lived like that. Poorer countries were often the most sociable - kids weren't at home on xboxes, they were out in the streets. I can't believe anyone else believes a word you are saying tbh.

BadLad · 14/07/2023 02:52

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

Here's someone with quite the opposite point of view:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4563246-to-say-that-every-child-and-young-person

This person thinks that every child who survived lockdown should get a medal.

To say that every child and young person… | Mumsnet

That got through the pandemic, followed the rules, stayed indoors for long periods of time, endured isolation, online learning, ping pongs in and out...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4563246-to-say-that-every-child-and-young-person

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/07/2023 02:44

YABU OP. My DC were born 10 years apart. This summer I have become very aware of the gap between DS1 and DS2's experiences at this age.Sad

GrandmasMeatloaf · 14/07/2023 02:42

@orangeleavesinautumn are you a teacher OP? If so, maybe you could convince your colleagues to take a collective pay cut to help the school funding? I am sure that there are teachers in many other cultures who are much worse off than in the UK - or doesn’t it work that way?

this makes me so angry, children were failed during the pandemic. Sweden kept schools open at primary level. The reason for that was the fear that closing the schools would have a disproportionately negative impact on the weakest children in society ( lowest socioeconomic groups, SEN, poor attainment /attendance). I think that is what happened as well herr.

yes, some children had a decent or even good time. This was mainly children whose pRents either could afford a larger house, a garden or even to decamp somewhere on the country side. We live in a flat and our children had a decent time as I spent the time helping them with school, taking them for walks, baking, talking to them. We don’t have that much money but I had the time - what if I had worked at Tesco? Or anywhere else where I needed to work all day for a minimum wage?

What about parents with mental health issues? Abusive parents where school was the only point of contact with other adults? How do you think those children fared?

what about the learning? again, I managed to sort my children out and we bought extra books to cover the curriculum. Luckily I am comfortable with primary school maths, including algebra. And I quite like English and science. How do you think other children fared?

I will not even go there with deaths from Covid. Not the death from the actual illness but the deaths of younger people from cancer which was left untreated. That happened to my SIL, we are still recovering from that. What about children upset about that?

The whole Covid shutdown was a massive social experiment and we caused untold damage to the weakest children in our society. The fact that some children (in nice houses, whose parents had the time to play with them, who’s parents could afford computers ) had a good time does not negate that.

Coyoacan · 14/07/2023 02:32

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:51

But they get hugely more education than most children in the world, and hugely more socialising too, many children the world over get less education and less socialising now than out children did during lockdown.

For example I've worked in schools where children live their whole child hoods in what we would term "lockdown" and it is considered normal life, leaving the premises once a month at most, and then only for a hour or two. Nothing unusual about that.

In eastern Europe, in Africa, in India, in Malaysia, in rural China I have seen communities more restricted than what we would consider "lock down" - but it is just considered normal life, no one is traumatised or feels deprived.

It is just that we are used to such great freedom and privilege.

I find it very hard to believe that children in those countries don't get an education or to socialise.

Madwife123 · 14/07/2023 02:32

Not all children are the same!

My autistic son really really struggled a) with the routine changing with no notice b) being indoors so much during the day c) anxiety about me going to work and catching covid.

GameofStrife · 14/07/2023 02:25

My daughter would have answered positively had you asked her. She certainly wouldn't have told you about trying to kill herself during covid aged just 11.

Canuckduck · 14/07/2023 02:14

My kids liked lockdown for the most part and we had a much much more stringent one than UK. They did minimal work at online school but still did ok, spent tons of time relaxing and then we were able to socialize and play in the backyard all summer.

However lots of their school mates live in overcrowded homes and some had to care for siblings at young ages. We had very limited school participation.

I think older age teenagers really missed out. I’ve heard about quite a few really struggling with anxiety around pressure around exams , beginning post secondary etc.

Hellokittymania · 14/07/2023 02:04

First off, I also have worked in a number of countries, including in Southeast Asia, with vulnerable groups, many of whom really do experience a tough weight of life. I also have a disability, so experience a lot of watch our students had to go through first hand. When I was much younger, I used to think like you and say oh well the UK has some things that are so much better, and this is still true. However, as a lot of people have pointed out, each country does things its own way, and I think you have to look at it from the countries perspective and not compare. Somethings aren’t great in Vietnam, But also, some things are better in Vietnam than in the UK. When you live somewhere, you just have to take it for what it is, the good the bad the difficult and the ugly.

I am visually impaired, and as an adult, the lockdown for me in the UK was an absolute hell. I was completely isolated, I had no family nearby to help me, I couldn’t order my food online because everyone had taken up supermarket an Amazon delivery slots, and trying to get on the vulnerable list at Sainsbury’s was a task in itself. It took months, they kept changing the rules and so people who were class is vulnerable or than not class is vulnerable. The food packages that were delivered to us, and yes it was good that we at least had food packages, but a lot of the food was actually rotten. I received frozen milk, which without realizing it was much more past the date, and after a few days it wasn’t good. Since I was on my own, I didn’t realize this at first. I then lost what little vision I had during that first lockdown, couldn’t find a doctor, so I didn’t see anyone until September, and once I knew I was going to go totally blind, had no support whatsoever. If you ask many parents in the UK who have a child with special needs, I’m sure many of them can give you some really difficult stories of what they went through. Yes, there were nice times, if you can call it that, some things were made slightly easier, but a lot of online learning for children with disabilities was a rather irrelevant. How do you teach a blind child mobility or daily living skills, when touch and handover hand is so important, on an online platform? Many parents didn’t know how to help their children, since they are not specialized teachers, and sometimes, the children themselves did not want their parents to be involved with their learning. You could say that the children in Vietnam who I know we’re at home the entire lockdown, I didn’t go to school at all. Yes, they missed out a lot as well. But so did the children in the UK who lost so much. And to the person in a previous post he replied that they would have isolated anyone who was vulnerable, that wasn’t the other answer. Many of us who are classes “vulnerable“ really did suffer. I am a resilient, strong person, and even while losing my vision and was stuck within a very small studio for months on end, I kept going, I kept smiling and I got through it in one piece. But I know others who weren’t as strong as I was, and who had nobody to help.

boysmuminherts · 14/07/2023 01:53

Well my eldest honestly had a terrible time. No socialising, clubs, sport, school with his friends from March 2020 till returning to school in September. And then again another lockdown in the following Dec/January stuck in his bedroom in the winter. It was awful for a secondary aged child. Yes, he was fed and had access to online education and TV but he was really affected. My primary aged child coped much better.

sleepyscientist · 14/07/2023 01:47

@Justsaynonow so your not okay with taking your chance against a virus which we could already see from china was relatively harmless but you were happy to play Russian roulette with peoples mental health? It's all about a risk assessment, if we were dealing with Ebola the measures would have been appropriate to the risk vs a flu like virus in which case they were above and beyond reasonable.

Justsaynonow · 14/07/2023 01:37

Sorry OP, a bit of a derail here, but I'm still astonished that trying to prevent repeated infection by a rapidly mutating Biosafety level 3 airborne pathogen was so unpopular, and that allowing unfettered spread is not considered a vastly dangerous and unethical experiment. Maybe it's Covid's detrimental impact on the brain that's inhibiting critical thinking and promoting the acceptance of the minimizing/russian roulette approach?

Just wanted to point out that covid is still here, causing long term systemic consequences for many - and not just the elderly. Children. Unborn children. I am not down playing the impact of social isolation, etc., but the potential medical consequences of one infection, let alone multiple, are horrifying and in some cases life long and life limiting. Immune deficiency, neurologic issues, autoimmune disorders, cardiac issues, diabetes, accelerated cancer and dementias...resulting in even more strain on medical and social supports. Repeated infections allow the virus to mutate. The best way to stop the virus is to prevent the spread - mask/good air quality etc.

elliejjtiny · 14/07/2023 01:37

It's all relative. A lot of children didn't know much about what was going on in other countries, they only knew that their lives were awful.

My dc had significantly less of my time/supervision during lockdown because I was trying to get a 5 year old and a 8 year old to do lessons when they would much rather look at hamsters doing an obstacle course on YouTube. My then 12 year old took an overdose of sleeping tablets. I couldn't stand it and cried myself to sleep most nights. Meanwhile my in-laws were going on and on via zoom about the wonderful time they were having.