Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think uk children in general did not have a bad experience during the pandemic

338 replies

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:40

Just read yet another post when inappropriate behaviour in a teen is put down to delayed trauma from covid times.

Having worked as a teacher in many countries, I can tell you that the conditions we called "lock down" are normal life for many of the world's children, and our children are incredibly privileged compared to most.

They didn't really suffer, they just had a slightly less ultra-privileged life for a short time. They were not more isolated and deprived than "normal" they were less isolated and deprived than normal, in a world wide sense - they were just more isolated and deprived than we have come to expect in our wealthy world.

Some may have been afraid, or bereaved, but most were not, and many enjoyed themselves enormously, more children I know preferred lock down to normal school, than preferred normal school to lockdown - and I have asked literally hundreds of children!

Can we stop telling them they are disadvantaged and traumatised now please!

OP posts:
summersausage · 14/07/2023 06:29

phobiaofsocialmedia · 14/07/2023 00:00

You're so wrong. I can't even begin to explain why. Loads of mental health issues as a result of lockdown I know of and have been impacted by.
Just because other places have it worse doesn't mean we should be grateful.
Women in some countries aren't allowed out without a male relative, they can't drive - it's like saying we shouldn't be cross about the gender pay gap because other women in other countries have it worse.

Exactly this. We can't refuse to accept trauma because someone, somewhere has it worse, it's not a competition! It's like saying it's silly to grieve the loss of one parent because some people lost both. Trauma is personal, and relates to how the person feels, not how other people might feel in comparison.

I am aware that life is general is better in the UK than some other countries, and we are lucky to have the benefits system, furlough etc. but there has been a huge spike in mental health problems in children and adults post covid. I worked throughout the pandemic, educating and supporting the most vulnerable groups, some of who still came into the classroom physically for their well being. This was great but I wasn't allowed to see my support network, which was not so great. My mental health suffered and, of course, this had an impact on my child. Yes, some children may have enjoyed learning from home, a slower pace of life but others lost their routine, had parents struggling with their mental health and that has to cause some type of impact/trauma. My SEN child became excessively clingy and avoidant of others, which is only just (literally in the last 3 months) starting to change, damage was done.

mangochops · 14/07/2023 06:29

Lovelydovey · 14/07/2023 06:26

My 11yo DS would tell you that he preferred lockdown as he didn't have to go to school if you asked him. In truth - it has left huge scars on him - he has anxiety and OCD as result of it. He lost three grandparents, now struggles with socialising and is obsessed with death and germs. He doesn't see the link to lockdown - we and his therapist do.

Exactly. As someone who worked in psych, you are being incredibly naive OP to think if a child tells you lockdown was fine, that means they are fine. Staggeringly naive.

TooMiddleClassForMN · 14/07/2023 06:27

I have asked literally hundreds of children

You might want to check the dictionary for the definition of “literally”. Because I say you’re literally lying.

Lovelydovey · 14/07/2023 06:26

My 11yo DS would tell you that he preferred lockdown as he didn't have to go to school if you asked him. In truth - it has left huge scars on him - he has anxiety and OCD as result of it. He lost three grandparents, now struggles with socialising and is obsessed with death and germs. He doesn't see the link to lockdown - we and his therapist do.

mangochops · 14/07/2023 06:25

HereToo · 13/07/2023 23:49

I mean I get what you're saying but it's like telling someone 'There are people starving in Africa' when they don't want to eat their dinner.

What goes on in other countries, doesn't affect them does it?

If they had a bad experience, it was their bad experience to have.

Yep- this. I dont really see the point of this post. You could also argue that ALL British people have it easy compared to those who live in Syria. It may well be true but that doesnt mean there arent lots of people in this country who arent struggling with things like illness, domestic violence, or poverty. Its not really much comfort to people struggling to say well, it could be worse! you could be in Syria is it?

Saschka · 14/07/2023 06:23

Really interested to know which countries have schools in which primary aged children are routinely not allowed to go outside into the playground, or see classmates, teachers or family, more than once a month. How exactly are they being taught, if they aren’t allowed contact with the teachers or their classmates? How are they fed, is a tray slid into the isolation cell? I’ve also worked in a lot of developing countries, and I have to say I don’t know of any which have schooling systems anything like that.

If you mean boarding schools where they are only allowed home once a month, but they mix freely with the other pupils and teachers, that is a bit different isn’t it? Because they are still getting teaching and socialisation.

Many children, mine included, were stuck inside flats with no garden for months at a time, with one parent at work (essential worker) and the other attempting to work from home. DS was a toddler, so while his socialisation and ability to deal with transitions was affected (had noticeably regressed on return to his previous nursery) there was no permanent damage.

Some of my colleagues had primary aged kids, who were not old enough to sit at a laptop and work. Their schooling was disrupted for about two years. If you actually are a teacher, do you not think that missing Reception and Y1 might have an impact on attainment?

Yes, they get more schooling that children enslaved in clothing factories in Bangladesh. But when they sit exams or apply for jobs, they are being compared with previous years of children in the UK, not illiterate children in developing countries.

labamba007 · 14/07/2023 06:23

Have you actually looked into studies on the impact of lockdowns on children's mental health, OP? Or is all this just based off you asking a class?

ZairWazAnOldLady · 14/07/2023 06:22

I think the idea that you can ask a class full of children what it was like and how it impacted them and get an answer of any true value or clarity is SO utterly ridiculous I don’t know where to start.

My children are slightly older and will tell you it was “fine”. What else are they going to say?

Velvian · 14/07/2023 06:20

I think you don't know as much about the UK as you think you do@orangeleavesinautumn .

My DC3 has found it so much harder going to school since lockdown, it has been very hard for some children to get back to 'normal'.

Are you making some assumptions that come from a place of your privilege? Travelling from continent to continent is a luxury that most of us don't have.

I think that you have forgotten the fear of the early days and the empty supermarket shelves. How quickly (a few days) our comfortable lives can come undone.

Where do you think bad behaviour comes from? If it is not from a lack of something what is it from? Is it the kids' fault? Does it matter who is at fault? What is the solution?

How are young people going to start their own lives in years to come? It is already a several times harder than it was for their parents and grandparents and you, OP. Who around them can relate to that?

I'm not really sure what point you are making. If course their lives are more comfortable than many people elsewhere in the world, but their prospects compared to adults around them are greatly diminished.

PaperSheet · 14/07/2023 06:20

I find people always think the age of the kids worst affected are the age of the kids they have/ teach/ know. Everyone is always trying to argue who had it worse. The teens that missed out on GCSE exams and proms. The uni students who missed out on freshman year and the parties. The reception year kids who missed out on social skills.
The fact is it sucked for many people of all ages. And some it didn't. But by telling children and young people they have it the WORST EVER and they're all traumatised isn't helping anyone. It's fine to acknowledge it, but I find it's constantly being drummed into the younger generation just how horrible it was.
In my work I had a 21 year old recently telling me how her generation was so screwed because of covid. How there was no recovery from it and going on about how it was just the worst thing ever and all older generations will never understand and allowances should be made for her generation. (Should add I work in a medical field and I was only making polite chit chat about how her uni course was going). This obsession with being the MOST VICTIMISED EVER in many many aspects of life needs to stop. Plenty of generations had awful things happen. And I think most people acknowledge it was terrible for a lot of people. But at some point people are going to have to stop making excuses for it being the reason for every behaviour going.

110APiccadilly · 14/07/2023 06:20

In which countries are children normally legally forbidden from meeting friends? Because the only circumstances I can think of would be teenage girls in very strict Muslim countries and even then they'd be able to meet friends with the right chaperoning.

Lots of children do have very hard lives, I'm not arguing that. But I can't quite see that that is the same as lockdown.

TheOutlaws · 14/07/2023 06:15

Have you taught in a UK school during the past 2 years OP?

I’ve been teaching for 20 years and the behaviour of a handful of children aged 11-13 is the worst I’ve seen. Colleagues across the country say the same. Our hypothesis is that they’ve missed out in a crucial developmental stage, whereby they internalise rules/routines/social norms - these children behave as if they’ve never entered a classroom. Year 7 (and I’m hearing Y6) are particularly impacted.

In an ironic twist, one parent said to senior leadership recently, ‘He’s fine at home so it’s your problem.’ No, it’s because he spent an extended period locked down in YOUR home that he’s now experiencing horrendous problems in school!

BlueRidgeMountain · 14/07/2023 06:14

Both my kids were in school though it (keyworker). If you asked my oldest in front of the class he’d certainly lie. He was the only one in his year group attending school for weeks, and spent his days lonely, scared and developed OCD as a result. He is still struggling badly with OCD, which morphed from obsession about hand washing, to believing he’ll die if he touches “cursed objects”. He thought he’d die when he got covid - he’s had worse colds- and is now terrified of getting ill.
my youngest is autistic, and actually enjoyed lockdown school- it was quieter, he had two of his best friends there and got way more 1-1 that he ever would normally.
so no, asking a class full of kids will not elicit truthful responses, and even asking them individually probably won’t unless you are prepared to spend the time really delving into their mindset. I’d guess you’re not a psychologist so you aren’t going to get a real answer to your question from the vast majority of kids.

Goingthere · 14/07/2023 06:12

Surely it's all relative? Just because the UK, in general, is more privileged than other parts of the world, does not mean children here cannot, and did not, feel unsafe/traumatised/upset due to their living conditions during the pandemic. Their experience is not invalidated because they live in a country which is considered wealthy.

I do agree that it seems like a convenient excuse for schools but there needs to be a balance between questioning the school and ensuring the children do not feel dismissed because they live in a "privileged society".

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 14/07/2023 06:11

Where is it normal for children not to socialise with other children?

Angelik · 14/07/2023 06:11

MintJulia · 14/07/2023 01:28

My ds was 11 when covid hit. His school switched to teams lessons full time. I was furloughed so I made sure he was in each lesson. We went cycling or walking or had kickabout every lunch hour, and again every evening.

I redecorated the house while he was in lessons. I baked most days or worked in the garden but was there if he needed me.

DS' karate classes moved on-line so twice a week we would clear the sitting room, set up a video link and do an hour's karate.

It was a bit solitary but with video calls to family and on-line Minecraft chat, he did ok.

Lucky you. That wasn't the case for everyone and that you cannot acknowledge that makes you come across as very insensitive.

Angelik · 14/07/2023 06:08

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 23:58

some impact, yes, but it really want the terrible trauma and deprivation it keeps being referred to as. It was more an annoyance in inconvenience in general.

How old were these children you asked? Mine were 10 and 7. My dh is paramedic and I worked full time from home for at least 50 hrs per week. Schooling was practically zero. So on top of being frightened for their dad's welfare they were deeply lonely. I could see the impact on their physical health - they went grey. It was awful. So with respect, your view is a very very very poorly formed. I am genuinely concerned that you are a teacher given your lack of basic intelligence.

BigOldBollocks · 14/07/2023 06:08

Yeah you're right OP. We should lock them all up again. Doesn't do them any harm, after all.

AutieNOT0tie · 14/07/2023 06:04

You ask a very small sample.

A lot of children lost close family members. Went through significant financial trouble. Struggled with enforced isolation.

Some breezed through and actually enjoyed the lack of social pressure.

And everything in between . Generalisations are not usually helpful

southlondoner02 · 14/07/2023 06:00

This doesn't chime with my experience at all. In my local boroughs children's social workers weren't carrying out proper child protection visits (quick chat through a window mainly), at risk children not being seen in schools. We're still seeing the result of this through case reviews. Most of my DD's friends live in flats without gardens, cooped up in small spaces. Some of them have high numbers of siblings and they had no access to computers or other ways to interact with the school. I know a number of children who were bullied attending keyworker school, inadequately supervised and no doubt a lot of the kids worrying about parents working in hospitals and care homes. Most kids I know who were at home have two working parents so little interaction with adults or support with learning during the day

That's not to say that lots of kids weren't having a lovely time but I'm not sure comparing with other countries is particularly helpful. I'm also not sure that most who had a difficult time would tell you, especially as they were expected to 'get on with it' and then expected to behave like it never happened

Confusion101 · 14/07/2023 05:48

Two year groups*

Confusion101 · 14/07/2023 05:48

I think this is a dangerous thread to pull at as it can quickly lead down the "nobody should ever complain about anything ever because there is somebody somewhere in the world having it worse than you are" route.... Yes, other children have it worse, but that doesn't take from the fact that young children in "privileged" societies had a huge change, lived a life they previously had zero experience of, heard nothing but scaremongering for months, went periods of time without seeing loved ones, friends, family.... Don't tell me that doesn't bring some trauma to the table for some.

I am a secondary teacher and the difference in the social skills and academic skills of students coming into us now compared to a few years ago is huge. The biggest challenges we have are with the year two groups that didnt get a proper transition period from primary to secondary due to covid. That can't be a coincidence.

sevenbyseven · 14/07/2023 05:44

For example I've worked in schools where children live their whole child hoods in what we would term "lockdown" and it is considered normal life, leaving the premises once a month at most, and then only for a hour or two. Nothing unusual about that.

In eastern Europe, in Africa, in India, in Malaysia, in rural China I have seen communities more restricted than what we would consider "lock down" - but it is just considered normal life, no one is traumatised or feels deprived.

Do tell us more,.OP, about these multiple places you've been where people live under permanent lockdown conditions. Fascinating.

Whoiscomingtosaveyou · 14/07/2023 05:42

You obviously don’t work in a deprived area OP.
My friend is a deputy head in an inner city school and for many kids school was respite from an awful home life. They had far more safeguarding issues raised during lockdown than any other time.