Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you give NikNaks to a 14 month old baby?

262 replies

ColourfulHairbands · 13/07/2023 21:34

Baby already has the odd Wotsit and Quavers but what’s your opinion on NikNaks? This is the orange pack - Nice ‘N’ Spicy flavour btw.

YABU - it’s fine, I’d give it to a 14 month old
YANBU - I wouldn’t give it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
00100001 · 20/07/2023 07:45

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 21:22

Rubbish. They’re 14 months old. It’s not reinforcing any idea of eating for boredom. It’s merely giving them something to do for 5 minutes to avoid a crisis. You’re talking daft.

Sure at some point what you’re saying might be an issue but exactly as you’re saying carrot puffs or wotsits or whatever, a couple is doing no harm whatsoever. BUT whatever you say the carrot puffs are less bad purely because of the salt content. Fact.

it’s not woman on woman anything. That’s cheap and not thought through. Its mumsnet bollocks. But if someone asks a question, other people are going to give their opinion. Also fact.

The salt content is negligible in 3 w otsits FACT. How much extra salt do you imagine there is in 3 entire wotsits? Ther child would be having more salt from their bit of toast with their egg in the morning.

And adding a slightly less negligible amount isn't the issue.

yes it is, women are piling in women for giving their childre n UPF, whilst saying they give their kids UPF too...

You've fallen for the marketing trick that somehow carrot puffs are an acceptable food to give a baby. When they're just utter crap. Let's all accept that and move on.

Rubyupbeat · 19/07/2023 22:25

It won't hurt now and then.

Daisymae55 · 19/07/2023 21:51

I’ve only given my 16 month old baby crisps. She once came over all curious and big eyed as I ate a pack of watsits so I let her have one (to be fair she wasn’t too bothered by it and left me alone after one)

I absolutely wouldn’t give them a full bag, but maybe one as a little taste if they were interested

Seaweasel · 19/07/2023 21:51

Absolutely would not be letting my baby/toddler within arm's reach of any Nik Naks at all, ever, until they are old enough to go out and buy their own. Because they are all MINE. Mwah ha ha.
Enjoy your rice cakes kiddo.

Brieandcamembert · 19/07/2023 21:43

Absolutely would not be feeding my baby crisis. No need at all.

Get a big variety of healthy tastes in them and don't start an early taste for junk.

gogomoto · 19/07/2023 21:31

Probably not regularly but if they grabbed one I wouldn't take it away. I didn't give mine crisps that young tbh, not even rip off baby ones

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 21:30

Doing the least harm, is still
harm.

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 21:30

whatever you say the carrot puffs are less bad purely because of the salt content. Fact

That’s a fairly irrational argument and not really a nutritional fact at all. It’s a bit like saying, the small hole in my window, is better than a big hole. Both mean the window is broken. That would be a fact.

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 21:22

00100001 · 19/07/2023 12:44

But giving food as "something to do" is a terrible idea reinforces and sets the idea that if you're bored, eat food. However, you do whatever you need to do to get through the day.

If you're giving 3 carrot puffs or 3 wotsits as a one off there's very little different between them.... So why the judgment from people suggesting that somehow that pointless piece of puffed corn that contains 0.00001g is soooooo much better than this other pointless piece of puffed corn that contains 0.0001g of salt.

As usual it's other women making other women feel bad for the choices they're making :/

Rubbish. They’re 14 months old. It’s not reinforcing any idea of eating for boredom. It’s merely giving them something to do for 5 minutes to avoid a crisis. You’re talking daft.

Sure at some point what you’re saying might be an issue but exactly as you’re saying carrot puffs or wotsits or whatever, a couple is doing no harm whatsoever. BUT whatever you say the carrot puffs are less bad purely because of the salt content. Fact.

it’s not woman on woman anything. That’s cheap and not thought through. Its mumsnet bollocks. But if someone asks a question, other people are going to give their opinion. Also fact.

KeyWorker · 19/07/2023 19:16

I wouldn’t give them a bag or their own portion but if I was eating them and the baby was interested I might give them one. I’d probably not make a habit of it and would avoid because of the (inevitable orange stain) junk food aspect/salt content rather than due to the strong or spicy flavour.

EmeraldFox · 19/07/2023 19:09

Hugasauras · 19/07/2023 15:50

Baby crisps are bland pointless shite anyway. They don't resemble real food in any way and they cost a fortune into the bargain. Just buy a cheap pack of oatcakes or some rice cakes or something and use those. Saves a fortune and actually has an interesting texture.

Disproportionate levels of handwringing on here, some of it I imagine from people who have spent months feeding their babies UPF in the form of formula - rightly no one suggests that is not a good decision, but one or two Nik Naks is apparently the end of all things.

Formula is needed to keep babies alive if their mother can not breastfeed or access adequate donor milk. There isn't really much alternative. UPFs as solid food are completely unnecessary (except for a small percentage of children with severe eating issues).

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 15:58

jacckandsalllly · 14/07/2023 18:18

Fuck me stop the planet I want to get off.

You're all acting like a few crisps is akin to snorting cocaine.

Funnily enough UPF’s have been shown to make the brain react in the same way. They are addictive as it triggers dopamine.

Now some people use cocaine and never become addicted. Someone people can’t help it. Same with junk food apparently. Sounds crazy, but 40% of overweight adults in this country are struggling with something.

Hugasauras · 19/07/2023 15:50

Baby crisps are bland pointless shite anyway. They don't resemble real food in any way and they cost a fortune into the bargain. Just buy a cheap pack of oatcakes or some rice cakes or something and use those. Saves a fortune and actually has an interesting texture.

Disproportionate levels of handwringing on here, some of it I imagine from people who have spent months feeding their babies UPF in the form of formula - rightly no one suggests that is not a good decision, but one or two Nik Naks is apparently the end of all things.

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 15:47

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 10:42

I’d think most people realise that they’re pointless and offer no nutritional value as such. I think if we were all honest the reason behind giving them is it distracts baby whilst we try to (insert as necessary) eat our dinner/do washing/deal with another child/have a moment when they’re not hanging off us. The thing that is different is whilst one does no good whatsoever, it still doesn’t have added salt or sugars or flavourings so it sure isn’t doing any harm. Not that I’m suggesting a few nik naks or wotsits every now and then is doing harm, but just why? If you can avoid it and as Mum, you can, for now, why do it?

The thing that is different is whilst one does no good whatsoever, it still doesn’t have added salt or sugars or flavourings so it sure isn’t doing any harm

Isn’t doing any harm? You’ve been had! How do you think one chemical hashed up
piece of shit compared to another hashed up processed piece of crap is so different? Honestly, it’s a con. A carrot never has nor never will be puffed, organic or not.

Have a read (or listen) to Processed People. Lots of science and sensible stuff, backed by research and facts. It’s not a fad and really important.

Edible substances are NOT food and they have never had long term studies done on them as you can’t do this on mice, or people.

00100001 · 19/07/2023 12:44

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 10:42

I’d think most people realise that they’re pointless and offer no nutritional value as such. I think if we were all honest the reason behind giving them is it distracts baby whilst we try to (insert as necessary) eat our dinner/do washing/deal with another child/have a moment when they’re not hanging off us. The thing that is different is whilst one does no good whatsoever, it still doesn’t have added salt or sugars or flavourings so it sure isn’t doing any harm. Not that I’m suggesting a few nik naks or wotsits every now and then is doing harm, but just why? If you can avoid it and as Mum, you can, for now, why do it?

But giving food as "something to do" is a terrible idea reinforces and sets the idea that if you're bored, eat food. However, you do whatever you need to do to get through the day.

If you're giving 3 carrot puffs or 3 wotsits as a one off there's very little different between them.... So why the judgment from people suggesting that somehow that pointless piece of puffed corn that contains 0.00001g is soooooo much better than this other pointless piece of puffed corn that contains 0.0001g of salt.

As usual it's other women making other women feel bad for the choices they're making :/

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 10:42

00100001 · 13/07/2023 21:56

The organic carrot ouffs are about food marketed to make it sound like it's good for your baby.... Since when has a over processed piece of corn covered in sunflower oil and carrot powder been such a great food? Honestly can't see the noticeable and nutritional significant difference between giving a baby 3 wotsits or 3 "organic carrot puffs". People are gullible fools.

It's literally a pointless food and serves only to line the pockets of Mr Organix

I’d think most people realise that they’re pointless and offer no nutritional value as such. I think if we were all honest the reason behind giving them is it distracts baby whilst we try to (insert as necessary) eat our dinner/do washing/deal with another child/have a moment when they’re not hanging off us. The thing that is different is whilst one does no good whatsoever, it still doesn’t have added salt or sugars or flavourings so it sure isn’t doing any harm. Not that I’m suggesting a few nik naks or wotsits every now and then is doing harm, but just why? If you can avoid it and as Mum, you can, for now, why do it?

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 09:39

ladyvimes · 16/07/2023 10:09

A whole bag no bit one or two definitely. They’re the best crisps!!

Food is all about moderation. We live in a society of upf’s that aren’t going to go away. It is possible to have a healthy balanced diet and eat a balanced amount of upf’s. Two niknaks will do absolutely zero damage to a baby! My kids eat crisps daily, like probably most kids! We balance it by saying one bag a day either with lunch or as a snack. No problem!

I think the thing there as you’ve said is you give them to kids, not babies. Yeah, one or two won’t hurt but why? What’s the point ?

Lucyh999 · 19/07/2023 09:37

I wouldn’t give any of those to a 14 month old personally. Not because I’m afraid or anything but there are a whole host of really good baby crisps they can suck that don’t have added salt or sugar. Once you start exposing them to those strong sugary or salty flavours, you’re committed and nothing will taste the same so you’re affecting their taste buds and therefore diet in a detrimental way. I also just dont think it’s healthy and I wouldn’t prize that over convenience. You can chop up fruit or veg and put it in little pots or give the baby things. However, if it’s at a party or bbq or something and they have some and it’s not regular then I wouldn’t worry about it.

shivawn · 18/07/2023 17:05

Nik naks have a strong flavour but I wouldn't call them spicy? They won't exactly being burning your kids mouth off. I wouldn't have given my child crisps at that age but he did have much spicier foods no problem.

EmeraldFox · 16/07/2023 10:19

I think people's definitions of 'in moderation' will vary. For me, in moderation would mean UPF crisps at a birthday party or similar, not every day, similar to a can of coke.

ladyvimes · 16/07/2023 10:09

A whole bag no bit one or two definitely. They’re the best crisps!!

Food is all about moderation. We live in a society of upf’s that aren’t going to go away. It is possible to have a healthy balanced diet and eat a balanced amount of upf’s. Two niknaks will do absolutely zero damage to a baby! My kids eat crisps daily, like probably most kids! We balance it by saying one bag a day either with lunch or as a snack. No problem!

EmeraldFox · 16/07/2023 09:58

Caerulea · 16/07/2023 09:55

@EmeraldFox

So it's the method of the manufacturing process that bothers you? Too many things happened to it vs a ready salted alternative? What things? More powder was added in the same format as you have in your own kitchen?

I'm sorry, it's just snobbery. There's zero wrong with the ingredients & how they were put together is irrelevant. I'm a chef & some dishes have MANY steps & processes to complete them, taking issue cos it's done on a large scale is just silly & puritanical.

It's UPF, I don't think ready salted potato crisps are (not pringles) as they are just sliced potato, oil and salt aren't they?

Caerulea · 16/07/2023 09:55

@EmeraldFox

So it's the method of the manufacturing process that bothers you? Too many things happened to it vs a ready salted alternative? What things? More powder was added in the same format as you have in your own kitchen?

I'm sorry, it's just snobbery. There's zero wrong with the ingredients & how they were put together is irrelevant. I'm a chef & some dishes have MANY steps & processes to complete them, taking issue cos it's done on a large scale is just silly & puritanical.

EmeraldFox · 16/07/2023 09:48

Caerulea · 16/07/2023 09:45

And for all the 'ew ingredients' ppl - stop being ridiculous.

Maize, Sunflower Oil (36%), Nice 'N' Spicy Flavour [Sugar, Yeast Extract, Natural Flavourings (contains Barley Malt Vinegar, Barley Malt Extract, Soya Sauce, Wheat Flour), Salt, Dried Onion, Acid: Citric Acid, Curry Powder (Spices, Rice Flour, Salt), Acid: Malic Acid, Spice, Colour: Paprika Extract, Spice Extracts, Garlic Extract].

Yes, I don't think the ingredients aren't as bad as quavers or wotsits as there are no flavour enhancers. Though, it is still a much more highly processed food than a ready salted potato crisp.

Swipe left for the next trending thread