Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this fair? SAHM splitting finances for the first time

56 replies

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 21:11

This isn't an argument, I just wanted other people's perspectives or how they do it. Recently taking a step back from working following a number of health complications with DC1.

We've decided that DH will pay off his credit cards with his salary and then the remainder will go into an account that we both have access to. I then pay anything I need to pay off and manage what we spend on holidays, savings, Investments etc

DH generally spends very little on himself, is a big saver etc. His credit card is usually spent on anything for the house or baby or dining out etc. before anyone says why does he get to pay off his credit card first.

YABU : this is not fair. Please provide reasons
YANBU: this is far

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ATeamsvan · 16/07/2023 05:11

So in this plan he has access to any money he wants via the credit card, and also the joint account, but the OP only has access to the money in the joint account? That doesn't sound quite right.
i wouldn't personally like to have no money just for me - dh can't complain about how many shoes I buy and I can't about how much he spends on books, as we have equal spending money.
OP why not get a second credit card for you on the same account, then you can both earn the. cash back?

LaMaG · 16/07/2023 04:56

When I gave up work we probably should have gotten a joint account, but our previous arrangement was DH paid mortgage and I had all household bills so it meant changing accounts with lots of different providers. Just for convenience we calculated how much the outgoings were and arranged a standing order from his account to mine. We also roughly calculated how much casual spending money we had each month and paid about half into my account too as part of this payment. I also got a credit card linked to his credit card account for grocery shopping etc which he clears every month on pay day. When I went back to work a few years ago it was handy to still have an active account that was just for me

AWholeNewWorls · 16/07/2023 02:56

Ok so I spoke to DH and we will have his salary come into an account we can both access.

DH is very honest and open and he said something to me which was unexpected but I would like to share...
We have known each other 3 years and married for 2 years. I am 30 and he is 40. He said he is still adjusting to the fact that suddenly everything he has saved his whole life should be Amine too... He is talking about his savings which total roughly 150k.

OP posts:
Aprilx · 14/07/2023 07:33

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 21:23

Should the salary go into the joint account?

I don’t see why it matters when you have already said he is not selfish over money and it seems like you are not being left short. You seem to be creating an issue over nothing.

We absolutely consider our finances as shared, but we don’t have a joint account, for no other reason than we both had bank accounts when we met and we continue to use them.

Peony654 · 14/07/2023 07:20

Oh and if you have an existing pension, pay into that from the joint account - and get a private pension if you don’t have one. Not fair you miss out on the pension you’d get if you worked

Peony654 · 14/07/2023 07:19

Sounds unnecessarily complicated. His salary should go into a joint account, plus any other income like child benefit. Then pay everything out of that including credit cards. And assuming credit cards are being used sensibly

BarbaraofSeville · 14/07/2023 07:15

DH salary not going into an account you have access to would be a problem if he was taking money for his own savings, overspending or any other reason that would be detrimental to you. It would also be harder to deal with if he died - grim as it is, you have to consider the position you'd be in if he was killed in a car accident or similar. You may not have access to money and have trouble sorting things out in the short term, so would add to the stress at a difficult time.

Which is probably why people are suggesting everything goes into a joint account, then you both get some spending money in a separate account so you have your own personal money - make sure you have enough to buy things like clothes and other personal items, leisure activities, hobbies etc without having to ask. You could also get a second card on DHs credit card, so you can also use this independently to buy for yourself or house/DC.

Definitely put the maximum you're allowed into a pension and also make sure you're claiming CB to keep up with your state pension. If you're not entitled due to your DH earnings, you can opt to not receive the money only the NI credit.

You say you manage savings and investments, so that's good. Ideally these should be split 50/50 to maximise ISA allowances etc and also because it would be fairer and more transparent should you divorce. However unlikely this seems, it's better to consider the 'what ifs' than have to unravel an almighty mess and wonder where all the money has gone should the worst happen (which is what a family member is going through - she has been a trailing spouse for many years to a high earning DH who's now having some sort of mid life crisis, has left her for a younger woman, they're divorcing and he's telling her they don't have any money despite him earning shedloads and previously saying they had plenty).

Also make sure you have good life insurance for both of you. Don't forget that he can only concentrate on his high earning big job because you're doing everything at home/with DC. If something happened to you, he'd probably not be able to manage everything alone.

Catsbreakfast · 14/07/2023 00:19

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 13/07/2023 21:35

Ok… so is the issue here that he gets to basically spend what he wants, and you don’t?

She’s explained it’s spent on family things, not stuff for himself. Paying the card off first is sensible, as otherwise interest accrues.

AWholeNewWorls · 14/07/2023 00:14

Ponderingwindow · 13/07/2023 23:15

If the credit card is just another monthly household expense, then why not just put his salary into the household account and pay the credit card bill along with the other bills? Why the separation?

His rationale is he's just being cautious with paying it off but I will have a chat about doing everything off one account

OP posts:
AWholeNewWorls · 14/07/2023 00:13

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 13/07/2023 22:58

He isn’t. That’s exactly what she said. He doesn’t get into debt on a credit card, he uses it for day to day spending then pays it off in full each month. Often a sensible thing to do as you can build up cashback/points/air miles on a credit card, and also have purchase protection.

It's a cashback one

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 13/07/2023 23:15

If the credit card is just another monthly household expense, then why not just put his salary into the household account and pay the credit card bill along with the other bills? Why the separation?

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 13/07/2023 22:58

Mumtothreegirlies · 13/07/2023 22:54

Why he getting Into debt on a credit card?

He isn’t. That’s exactly what she said. He doesn’t get into debt on a credit card, he uses it for day to day spending then pays it off in full each month. Often a sensible thing to do as you can build up cashback/points/air miles on a credit card, and also have purchase protection.

Mumtothreegirlies · 13/07/2023 22:54

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 21:27

There's no ongoing debt. He uses it for everyday spending instead of debit card

Why he getting Into debt on a credit card?

gogomoto · 13/07/2023 22:34

I now live with dp, the new system is different, he pays for everything joint and I (from my much more modest salary) pay for my car, personal care, clothes and most my daughters expenses (I get maintenance from her dad) though dp always pays for meals out. Works for us, he earns 10x my salary

gogomoto · 13/07/2023 22:30

We had a joint account and joint credit card which was paid off monthly. This works well as long as you have similar spending habits and trust.

I'm no longer married but money was never an issue, in fact I'm still advising exh on financials as he isn't very clued up

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 13/07/2023 22:28

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 22:17

Someone asked what the problem was - I don't have a problem, I just wanted to hear what the perspective was on this.

I only know how my parents spent their money as a couple as an example really.. they didn't have much and they shared a debit card and that was it. DH is a high earner but comes from very humble beginnings so isn't a big spender at all and much prefers to save. Before getting married I probably was a big spender (despite not earning anywhere near similar) but I am older and wiser now hehe

If you’re happy, he’s happy, you both think it’s fair… why do you need anyone else’s perspective?

TeenagersAngst · 13/07/2023 22:23

Do you have access to money? Or is the issue that he controls what is spent on the CC and you only get a say in deciding how to spend what is left over?

TeenagersAngst · 13/07/2023 22:21

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 22:17

Someone asked what the problem was - I don't have a problem, I just wanted to hear what the perspective was on this.

I only know how my parents spent their money as a couple as an example really.. they didn't have much and they shared a debit card and that was it. DH is a high earner but comes from very humble beginnings so isn't a big spender at all and much prefers to save. Before getting married I probably was a big spender (despite not earning anywhere near similar) but I am older and wiser now hehe

Perspective on what though? I'm still baffled!

AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 22:17

Someone asked what the problem was - I don't have a problem, I just wanted to hear what the perspective was on this.

I only know how my parents spent their money as a couple as an example really.. they didn't have much and they shared a debit card and that was it. DH is a high earner but comes from very humble beginnings so isn't a big spender at all and much prefers to save. Before getting married I probably was a big spender (despite not earning anywhere near similar) but I am older and wiser now hehe

OP posts:
AWholeNewWorls · 13/07/2023 22:13

Salary in joint account - message received loud and clear!

OP posts:
PuddlesPityParty · 13/07/2023 22:13

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 13/07/2023 21:35

Ok… so is the issue here that he gets to basically spend what he wants, and you don’t?

She literally says the credit card is used mainly for baby and house stuff so I doubt it.

CherryBlossoms88 · 13/07/2023 22:03

It sounds like the ops husband doesn’t spend extravagantly on his cc and the OP can use it if she wants to. Can you view the credit card statements to see what he’s spent it on?

Personally, if just one person is earning, it would be easier to have it all go into the joint account and you both get equal spends on leisure items. He can then use that money to pay off his credit card for his leisure spends. If he spends joint items like babies nappies for example on the credit card he can use the joint account to pay that part of the cc off.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 13/07/2023 22:01

I'm mostly a sahm. All monies goes into joint account. Anything under around £200 (single item) we buy without discussion. Big items we discuss. 99 percent of spending outside direct debts goes on credit card which is automatically cleared each month.

Not sure I'd be happy with the setup you're proposing.

Chunt · 13/07/2023 22:01

And yes, you need to sort out your pension provision (or something that makes up for the lack of a pension). It's easy to overlook this if you're a SAHM.

Chunt · 13/07/2023 22:00

I have been a SAHM for more than 20 years. When I was married, and before we were married, all income went into one joint account, and everything was paid from this account. We also had joint savings/offset mortgage accounts. But absolutely everything was joint. I spent what I needed to spend and that was that (this also included stuff like going out, buying clothes etc - I wasn't silly and didn't buy Rolexes or that kind of thing). We also had a joint credit card. We made all our big purchases (houses, cars etc) as joint decisions, based on what we had available. It would have been weird not to.

Basically, all income should go into the joint account, and everything should be paid out of that (in my opinion).

Swipe left for the next trending thread