Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boris Johnson has "forgotten his old phone code" so can't supply the messages

185 replies

cakeorwine · 13/07/2023 19:36

Boris Johnson ‘has forgotten’ passcode for phone wanted by Covid inquiry | Covid inquiry | The Guardian

It's like getting blood out of a stone.
First he was late to supply the messages.
Then he forgets his passcode.

I am sure there are ways to get in to it.

Boris Johnson ‘has forgotten’ passcode for phone wanted by Covid inquiry

Spokesperson says ex-PM wants to hand over WhatsApp messages but experts describe latest development as ‘pretty lame excuse’

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/jul/13/boris-johnson-has-forgotten-passcode-for-phone-wanted-by-covid-inquiry

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
fuchiaknickers · 14/07/2023 11:17

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 09:36

But you're all missing the forest for the trees.

What outcome do you want from this

A) Boris Johnson and co get a red mark in their Permanent Record for saying mean things about people

B) We get an improved pandemic preparedness policy, including recommendations both on the effectiveness of different public health measures, and on formal procedural points such as "in future, xyz type of restriction should require the explicit consent of Parliament"

Why is ALL the reporting on this focused on A. I don't give a shit about Boris Johnson and he's no longer even an MP. I do care a lot about B. That is the substantive part of the inquiry, or should be.

I don’t think he’s bothered about having said mean things about people, doubt he’d give much of a shit about people’s feelings.

I reckon there’s evidence of corruption / further lawbreaking that he doesn’t want to come to light.

Got to be pretty bad to be worth all this embarrassment.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 14/07/2023 10:04

I’m sure the Police can get into it. If this was Joe or Josephine public they soon would do.

Notonthestairs · 14/07/2023 09:54

The Government set the terms and structure.

covid19.public-inquiry.uk/structure-of-the-inquiry/

cakeorwine · 14/07/2023 09:53

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 09:52

Why are we having an inquiry into how the decisions were made

And not an inquiry into whether those decisions were the right ones - i.e. whether we should make similar decisions in future

I don't worry about AI or nuclear war anywhere near as much as I worry about future pandemics. We are getting caught up in stupid Westminster gossip and shitfights instead of considering the real issues.

So we can look at the next time?
Decision making, how they were made, what decisions were made.

Those things are important

OP posts:
Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 09:52

Why are we having an inquiry into how the decisions were made

And not an inquiry into whether those decisions were the right ones - i.e. whether we should make similar decisions in future

I don't worry about AI or nuclear war anywhere near as much as I worry about future pandemics. We are getting caught up in stupid Westminster gossip and shitfights instead of considering the real issues.

Dinopawus · 14/07/2023 09:48

Because to get to B we need to understand what decisions were taken on the basis of what information and why.

And if those discussions were held via WhatsApp the enquiry need to see the chats.

It isn't about beating Boris up - I genuinely want to understand the context.

Notonthestairs · 14/07/2023 09:46

Not missing anything.

The method of communication/discussion is irrelevant.

The messages form part of development of policy and that is property of the Crown.

The Inquiry only interested in how the Government formulated policy.

We won't see anything not relevant to the above.

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 09:36

But you're all missing the forest for the trees.

What outcome do you want from this

A) Boris Johnson and co get a red mark in their Permanent Record for saying mean things about people

B) We get an improved pandemic preparedness policy, including recommendations both on the effectiveness of different public health measures, and on formal procedural points such as "in future, xyz type of restriction should require the explicit consent of Parliament"

Why is ALL the reporting on this focused on A. I don't give a shit about Boris Johnson and he's no longer even an MP. I do care a lot about B. That is the substantive part of the inquiry, or should be.

Dinopawus · 14/07/2023 09:27

Most of us manage to keep our work WhatsApps and our Private ones separately.

If Government discussions were held by WhatsApp they are disclosable.

And while I'm not about to defend Boris Johnson, I accept that difficult decisions had to be made whilst the science was emerging. And I would like to see the context for those decisions.

My DM died during the first week of lockdown. I believe the policy of moving elderly people around hospital wards made it almost inevitable that she would contract the virus. I want to know why the fuck good infection control practice was ignored right at the start of a pandemic. And I want to know what advice the politicians were getting. Because my sense is that the big boys got excited at the thought of building nightingale hospitals and doing things at scale, and ignored what we have known since Florence Nightingale pointed it out to the Eton twits of her day.

savory · 14/07/2023 09:02

fuchiaknickers · 13/07/2023 21:56

Amen.

Covid had only got to do one good thing and it failed that test.

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 08:36

Well, the context of the message would tell us if it was said in a fit of anger OR was part of the conversation in letting infected patients go back to care homes and hence on policy.

Yes, and this should surely be very obvious.

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 08:34

@Middlelanehogger

I don't give a shit if Boris Johnson said "let the bodies pile high" in a fit of stress/anger. That's not my business. The policies he enacted are

Well, the context of the message would tell us if it was said in a fit of anger OR was part of the conversation in letting infected patients go back to care homes and hence on policy.

You might not give a shit, but i do, my partners Nan died as a result of his CH policy.

Aside, i would hope that any person who is PM does not take the time to to open Whatsapp and send their angry thought to another person... BJ was making policy, deciding which "expert" to listen too and hence the policies he enacted.

Don't really know why anyone would not want the inquiry to have all the information and then shift through what is relevant in order to make recommendations etc

Notonthestairs · 14/07/2023 08:33

All communications regarding Government policy (including developing that policy) is considered property of the Crown.

It is doesnt matter what form it is. It doesn't belong to the individual.

Ministers and officials would have been advised this when they entered office.

It's ridiculous to suggest that the method of communicating makes the content personal.

We won't see the messages unless they are pertinent to the Inquiry.

cakeorwine · 14/07/2023 08:25

"Since the invention of meeting minutes people have been having quiet off-the-record conversations in the hallway before the meeting... WhatsApp is just that in digital form

Emails
Team chats
WhatsApp

All digital evidence.

You want an off the record conversation. Have a conversation.

OP posts:
Jigslaw · 14/07/2023 08:25

Too add, MHs WhatsApp messages provided a lot of insiight around policy decisions that hadn't been seen elsewhere, especially around care homes. Hugely hugely valuable.

Notonthestairs · 14/07/2023 08:23

They were conducting discussions regarding policy decisions via Whatsapp.
Thats why we need to see them.

The form of the message is irrelevant. The substance is what matters.

Jigslaw · 14/07/2023 08:21

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 08:19

I agree that this is an important point.

I just don't think we needed MH's WhatsApp messages to know that the science at that time was not pushing social distancing. There were many scientists pushing alternative solutions and approaches that weren't just "lockdown". This information and alternative perspectives was available to the government very early on in the pandemic.

I would much rather the inquiry be an impartial evaluation of the government's specific policies and the impacts that they had 1/2/3 years on (e.g. impacts to education, non-covid health issues etc). So that we can make recommendations on future pandemic responses.

I don't give a shit if Boris Johnson said "let the bodies pile high" in a fit of stress/anger. That's not my business. The policies he enacted are.

But the scientists advising the government were even saying this, Chris whitty for example. Its hugely relevant that they ignored this to save face and were happy to throw them under the bus. Where's the integrity? There's lots to learn from this.

topnoddy · 14/07/2023 08:21

Boris Johnson = LYING TORY TWAT

It's blatantly obvious to anyone that he thinks he's above anything regarding the law

Yellowdays · 14/07/2023 08:20

"Since the invention of meeting minutes people have been having quiet off-the-record conversations in the hallway before the meeting... WhatsApp is just that in digital form.

If you think this isn't the case I assume you're not a senior decision-maker."

This is not correct. Organisational culture does vary..

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 08:19

Jigslaw · 14/07/2023 08:06

But I don't need to see his private conversations during a highly uncertain time to make that decision.

You won't see them though, the inquiry though. If MH hadn't leaked his own messages people would have still thought the science was pushing for people to not see partners, to eek out social distancing etc when in fact it was politicians who didn't want to backtrack and appear they'd made the wrong decision. I think that's a pretty important point to consider for any future pandemics really.

I agree that this is an important point.

I just don't think we needed MH's WhatsApp messages to know that the science at that time was not pushing social distancing. There were many scientists pushing alternative solutions and approaches that weren't just "lockdown". This information and alternative perspectives was available to the government very early on in the pandemic.

I would much rather the inquiry be an impartial evaluation of the government's specific policies and the impacts that they had 1/2/3 years on (e.g. impacts to education, non-covid health issues etc). So that we can make recommendations on future pandemic responses.

I don't give a shit if Boris Johnson said "let the bodies pile high" in a fit of stress/anger. That's not my business. The policies he enacted are.

BitOutOfPractice · 14/07/2023 08:18

While I agree Johnson is a lying toad, do people not realise that the “unlocking” that is done on every high street is not unlocking the phone in this sense?

And can we stop calling him Boris like he’s our mate?

StormShadow · 14/07/2023 08:17

Middlelanehogger · 14/07/2023 07:55

I strongly dislike this new trend of demanding WhatsApp messages of senior politicians.

They should be able to have confidential conversations without fearing they're going to be broadcast for all the world to see.

The results and outputs of the discussions are all that matters.

FWIW I think the govt made quite poor decisions during lockdown but I judge them on the policies they enacted not their internal deliberations.

This is a ridiculous take. If politicians don't want their personal phones being accessed, they need to not use them to conduct the business of government. There was no excuse for people not understanding the relevant rules about scrutiny and data in 2020. Your argument has absolutely nothing to recommend it.

smilesup · 14/07/2023 08:17

Alexandra2001 · 14/07/2023 08:05

Equally strongly disagree.

We are holding a public inquiry into a series events that led to the deaths of over 240k people, many of whom died with no medical treatment & where the state decided family could not be with them.

It will be for the inquiry to decide what is pertinent, not the Govt being investigated, fortunately, the courts also agree.

There were allegations, denied at the time, that Bojo said "let the bodies pile high ..." rather than have another lockdown, if there are messages that back this up, then i think we should all know, also, if Bojo was treating LD and Covid as a bit of joke and was arranging parties to breach LD rules, we should know that too.

Do we need to know that Boris wished one of his children Happy Birthday? no we do not and the judge in charge will ensure personal msg's stay personal, anyone leaking will be held in contempt and that could lead to jail.

I doubt the narcissist even remembers his children's birthdays.

Sirius3030 · 14/07/2023 08:15

He can’t remember how many kids he has got, so it’s quite possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread