Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worn out by the mismatch between annual leave & school provision

412 replies

Yellowlegobrick · 13/07/2023 17:05

25 days. Like most people i get 25 days annual leave.

School holidays plus inset days needs 65 days cover.

There are sod all good options to cover it locally. There'll be a football camp 20 mins away for 3 days 9 - 2.30, a forest school doing an odd week 9-3. The bigger camps are massively oversubscribed, don't run for the whole holiday and you sometimes can't get a place.

Aibu to think there needs to be a formalised, centrally managed system to acknowledge the gap and provide better coverage?

Even if DH take all our annual leave separately, we can't cover it all, especially not when we lose at least a couple of days each per year of annual leave covering days the children are ill.

Its a constant annual stress, i find myself filled with dread when the letter comes from school: end of term, finish after lunch at 1.15.... there goes another half day 🙁

OP posts:
EllieQ · 15/07/2023 13:58

unicornhair · 15/07/2023 10:53

i didn’t know term time provision was so bad because I had lots of friends with children and they were doing okay. That’s because their school did wraparound care. There was actual holiday clubs where they lived.
I had no reason to believe provision would be so different across the U.K. especially when there were several options for nursery, you expect it to continue.

This is so true. If your friends/ family have wraparound/ holiday childcare, you just assume that your child’s future school will be the same.

I only started thinking about it in advance of school applications because a colleague with an older child discovered the school in the village she’d recently moved to had very limited wraparound/ holiday care, and had to change her working hours as a result - she told me to check provision and book as early as possible when I was applying for schools for DD.

LovePoppy · 15/07/2023 13:35

Britinme · 13/07/2023 17:23

How old are the children? On my side of the Atlantic, summer camps seem to be a major thing, as school summer holidays run mid-June to beginning of September and most people don't get more than 2-3 weeks vacation from work. They are hideously expensive though.

this is what I’m wondering, are there no summer day camps?

sumner break is 10 weeks long, the kids go to what is basically day care camps all summer

clairea123 · 15/07/2023 13:26

This is interesting as almost every club I’ve used has been in a school.
Our school itself runs holiday club, sports camp is at another local school, etc.
Maybe some schools need the income from renting out the space?

reluctantbrit · 15/07/2023 13:22

@CactusDreams - Parental leave can work but if you have to split every school holiday with 2 other colleagues there is realistically no way additional 2 weeks are allowed or possible without causing resentment and severe disruption.

The same with saying you can WFH, my work specifically forbids WFH when I have a child younger than secondary school age unless it's an emergency for a day or two max and then they actually allow paid emergency leave. I have to confirm I have childcare in place if I want WFH.

Tumbleweed101 · 15/07/2023 13:10

Have you looked at local private nurseries? We offer school holiday provision 7am-6.30pm for children up at age 11 and I think may others offer similar if they do wrap around care.

Sugarfree23 · 15/07/2023 12:59

The one I use is in a school, they have access to the hall, toilets and the playground. A section of the playground will be fenced off as an extension is being built.
And it wouldn't be beyond possible to move it to one of the other schools it picks up from. No way are all schools being worked on solidly for 6 weeks of the holidays.

I really don't see how that cannot be repeated elsewhere. The hardest thing is getting it set up and running in the first place, Which definitely needed council support.

Shinyandnew1 · 15/07/2023 12:34

some suggestions school buildings could be used

As said up thread-this wouldn’t be possible in any primary school I’ve been in due to the maintenance, cleaning and building work that needs to be done to stop them being unsafe during term time. Use church halls, use sports halls, use community centres for childcare-but if people want primary schools in use throughout the summer it’s not going to be long before they are literally falling down.

clairea123 · 15/07/2023 12:21

This is what we did.
you actually should get 5.6 weeks minimum a year to include bank holidays.
my husband’s work shut down over Christmas, so he’d always do that week.
I would volunteer for any weekend work so that I could toil in return to slightly increase my allowance- and take it for things like sports day etc.
i would take 5 weeks off and work over Christmas break. I would try and do this on bank holiday weeks so my allowance went further.
my husband would take 1 of his remaining weeks off.
We would take two weeks off together through the year.
I always had to take any child sickness etc as unpaid but that was better than taking a block of time unpaid.
so we used to be able to cover 8 weeks between us.
I would then do swaps with parents to cover the other weeks- so I’ll have your child 2 days this week if you could have mine days over this week// I took a teaching assistant’s to school in a morning but she then had them a day in the holidays when I needed her to etc.
I also was occasionally allowed to work a week of compressed hours- so worked my hours but in 4 days not 5.
I also used some of the clubs on occasion so I could take half days holidays and not full days.

It was a complete juggle though- and I ended up feeling like my kids were being passed from pillar to post.
School holidays were something to be endured rather than enjoyed- I felt terribly guilty that we weren’t out ‘making memories’ and having great experiences and instead were stressed, grumpy and broke.
You have my complete sympathy. I now have my older dd looking after my ds- and she now moans as she’s not allowed to look for a job or go out with her friends..

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2023 12:02

Sugarfree23 · 15/07/2023 11:46

The situation is possibly made worse by increasing the retirement age. 10 years ago more Grans were around to help out, now they are working to 66 so smaller window of being retired and fit enough to look after grandchildren.

And less inclination because of that smaller window of active retirement.

Sugarfree23 · 15/07/2023 11:46

The situation is possibly made worse by increasing the retirement age. 10 years ago more Grans were around to help out, now they are working to 66 so smaller window of being retired and fit enough to look after grandchildren.

unicornhair · 15/07/2023 10:53

i didn’t know term time provision was so bad because I had lots of friends with children and they were doing okay. That’s because their school did wraparound care. There was actual holiday clubs where they lived.
I had no reason to believe provision would be so different across the U.K. especially when there were several options for nursery, you expect it to continue.

Fizbosshoes · 15/07/2023 10:38

Willyoujust · 15/07/2023 09:46

Schools are there to provide an education for your children. They are not a childcare provision to mind your children while you go to work! Clearly there’s a lot of people out there who did not consider childcare when they made the decision to have children. It amazes me how many people decide to have children and then moan about this!

A baby will need some form of childcare from newborn until around 12 ish (often longer, more specialised childcare if they have disabilities or SEN)
Lots of things can change in 12 years - both personal and financial circumstances and the availability or provision of childcare, and it would be virtually impossible to plan for or mitigate against all situations (including pandemics and recessions)

StormShadow · 15/07/2023 10:34

Most people when they decided to have a baby will plan for maternity and pre-school/daycare costs. I don't think many people realise how poor/expensive/unsuitable out of term provision is. I certainly didn't. They might look at their current location and what primary schools are good but not many people are able to research that far into the future because provisions change.

Yes, exactly.

A couple who are considering TTC now will, if all goes well, have a child who is primary aged until 2035 at the earliest. As fucking if anyone knows what the holiday clubs in their area are going to look like in a dozen years time. There is no amount of considering things that will give you that information. In just the same way as someone who has a 10 year old now would not have been able to predict in 2012 the general gutting of the sector, pandemic and labour shortage with which we are now faced.

JMSA · 15/07/2023 10:24

It's an outdated system. Fine when mums were at home all day. These days not so much.
And I say this as someone who works at a school!

Mutabiliss · 15/07/2023 10:24

cyncope · 14/07/2023 12:39

@Yellowlegobrick sounds like you could do with finding a childminder who can cover things like half day finishes, TD days, strikes and school holidays.

Christ, have you tried to find a childminder recently?! I have one. She's one of only two who picks up from our school. She doesn't work Fridays or school holidays and is quite fearsome about her time off (and fair enough, it's not a job I'd want). Honestly I'm hugely grateful to have got a place with her, childminders are like hen's teeth.

JonSnowedUnder · 15/07/2023 10:22

Willyoujust · 15/07/2023 09:46

Schools are there to provide an education for your children. They are not a childcare provision to mind your children while you go to work! Clearly there’s a lot of people out there who did not consider childcare when they made the decision to have children. It amazes me how many people decide to have children and then moan about this!

I haven't seen anyone suggesting it is the schools responsibility, just some suggestions school buildings could be used.

Most people when they decided to have a baby will plan for maternity and pre-school/daycare costs. I don't think many people realise how poor/expensive/unsuitable out of term provision is. I certainly didn't. They might look at their current location and what primary schools are good but not many people are able to research that far into the future because provisions change.

My primary school (90s) opened in the summer from 9 to 5ish, mainly run by the classroom assistants and local uni students. It cost £1 a day.

We have a big split in our area. Either the clubs are expensive, activity heavy provisions or they are aimed at very low income families. I can imagine it's most difficult for middle earners to either secure a place at the cheaper one (which is often used by parents who don't work) or pay out more than their salary on the other.

StormShadow · 15/07/2023 10:19

It's true, the link between childcare and educational provision has been very blurred. It's the same in the welfare benefits system too. We have a society where school has a significant childcare function, as lockdown demonstrated in multiple ways. Less work gets done when schools are closed, because less labour is available.

This isn't to say that schools should be providing childcare over the holidays. I recognise that buildings maintenance means many couldn't if they wanted to, and also it's not clear where the workforce to do this would come from. But we seem to have come up with systems where we get the worst of all possible worlds, and it's understandable that people are pissed off. School is childcare when UC want you to up your hours, but it's not childcare when it comes to, you know, actual childcare so you can work.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/07/2023 10:14

Schools are there to provide an education for your children. They are not a childcare provision to mind your children while you go to work!

Except the reality is the government clearly think schools have a childcare remit to some degree given the use of schools for childcare over lockdown - when in fact the educational part of their remit took a lower priority. The government also expect parents of school aged children to look for work, and many work patterns extend over school hours.

In any event, I don’t want schools to provide childcare so I can go to work, I’d like childcare to be available so I can go to work. It just doesn’t exist for kids with complex needs.

StormShadow · 15/07/2023 09:54

I feel it's the world of work that's a problem as much as the way holidays are set up.

I'm really glad that point has been raised.

Indigotree · 15/07/2023 09:49

I feel it's the world of work that's a problem as much as the way holidays are set up. The summer holidays were based on grouse shooting season, weren't they? So around the holidays of MPs, not anyone else?

There's far too much time spent at work considering many jobs are unnecessary to society and/or can be done in less time or with jobshares (the four day week is a good start, though not helpful for parents needing to collect children!). Holidays could be spaced out better across the year, although it doesn't make sense to be working indoors long hours in summer.

AIBot · 15/07/2023 09:47

Aibu to think there needs to be a formalised, centrally managed system to acknowledge the gap and provide better coverage?

YANBU - it’s due to misogyny and our society not valuing childhood or family life.

Willyoujust · 15/07/2023 09:46

Schools are there to provide an education for your children. They are not a childcare provision to mind your children while you go to work! Clearly there’s a lot of people out there who did not consider childcare when they made the decision to have children. It amazes me how many people decide to have children and then moan about this!

Sugarfree23 · 15/07/2023 09:42

Shinyandnew1 · 15/07/2023 08:37

Most school heads I know are inches away from a nervous breakdown or retirement-the way they have been treated by the government over the last 3 years is appalling. Being held responsible for sourcing year-round childcare is not their responsibility. They need to educate children in term time and ensure the buildings can be made safe during the holidays so that this can happen.

The afterschool rent the school hall from the council but have nothing really to do with the school.
Other than the odd bit of co-ordination with any other afterschool activities, it's not something that headteacher needs to worry or think about.

Mutabiliss · 15/07/2023 09:04

I haven't RTFT, but just chiming in to say yes, it's ridiculous. There's an expectation that women work (and that's fine, I work almost full time myself and would hate to be a SAHM), but school holidays are still set up the same as when women had to give up work when they had children.

My son's just about to start school and I've been searching for holiday clubs ready for Easter and next summer. School do a different activity every day, which is great but he really won't like some of them, and they don't release what they are until a few weeks before. The only other clubs I can find are either sport-based and very expensive, or start from age 7. It's impossible, and that's with a job I can do from home and enough money to afford clubs. Fuck knows what people on low incomes and inflexible jobs do.

Shinyandnew1 · 15/07/2023 08:37

Sugarfree23 · 14/07/2023 09:51

I'm north of the border so most are still council run.

And the afterschool is a not for profit parent run organisation which the council helped setup 25 years ago. It still needs to balance the books.

Work is going on in the school so kids are being kept away from the area of work. But I hear what you are saying. Certainly more difficult if the school owners have no invested interest in encouraging child care provision.

Most school heads I know are inches away from a nervous breakdown or retirement-the way they have been treated by the government over the last 3 years is appalling. Being held responsible for sourcing year-round childcare is not their responsibility. They need to educate children in term time and ensure the buildings can be made safe during the holidays so that this can happen.