Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apprenticeship £5.25ph, no free prescription/dental/opticians and no child benefit

86 replies

SamBeckettslastleap · 13/07/2023 15:03

I take it MN will think this is perfectly reasonable but I think it is dreadful that a child on half the minimum wage will have to pay prescription cost/dentist/eyesight.

They also don't get child benefit, or UC/TCs so in low income families will have to pay rent.

How is this fair? Traditionally it is lower income families that go into apprenticeship at 16 .

However if they are home educated (in any form no checks) or go to college and not apprenticeship (some courses are 9 hours a week) they get it all, and could be earning significantly more in PT jobs.

OP posts:
HongKongGarden · 02/10/2023 21:45

Apprentices are often a cost to a business, even before you consider their salary. They’ll often not be producing much, their training costs the firm a lot, and they take up the time of the staff who would otherwise be adding to the profitability, so it’s fair that they don’t also get the same wage as someone who’s not incurring these costs.

Firstinlastout · 02/10/2023 21:44

I don't claim anything at all.I literally take £20 a week off him to cover what I would have got in child benefit_this goes towards my council tax.If I could afford to let him off with it or help him out more I honestly would.

Babyroobs · 02/10/2023 21:41

Firstinlastout · 02/10/2023 21:28

It's not about wanting everything for free.It's more about there's no incentive to work when you don't get any help but you get help if you don't bother.
Even a percentage off ,just a bit of help.
He's got driving lessons to pay for and rent,plus saving up for a car and the rumning of it he also buys his own clothes,toiletries etc so can'tsay he's not got any outgoings.

Let him off paying rent then. If you are on UC there is no non dependent deduction on the parents rent element until a young person turns 21, so it's not like the amount the parents get towards their rent changes.

Firstinlastout · 02/10/2023 21:28

It's not about wanting everything for free.It's more about there's no incentive to work when you don't get any help but you get help if you don't bother.
Even a percentage off ,just a bit of help.
He's got driving lessons to pay for and rent,plus saving up for a car and the rumning of it he also buys his own clothes,toiletries etc so can'tsay he's not got any outgoings.

Babyroobs · 02/10/2023 21:21

It's plenty to live on with low outgoings and the vast majority of young people don't need prescriptions or expansive dental work. A check up is £20 twice a year and some dentists seem to be changing to nine monthly or yearly now. Pre-paid certificate works out to £8 a month. It's hardly going to break the bank. Honestly some people just want everything for free.

Spacecowboys · 02/10/2023 21:16

I don’t think someone on an apprenticeship needs free prescriptions, dental care or opticians. It is £800 per month minimum for apprenticeship roles and as a 16 year old , they won’t have many outgoings.

Firstinlastout · 02/10/2023 21:05

Just hsd the same thing,basic apprentice wage.Sent off the forms along with wage slips,didnt hear anything back so rang them.Apparantly he was over the limit even though its basic wage.What's the point of applying for apprentices when they're just going to get turned down?He can't earn any less than he's on!
It does piss you off when they"re working/college for 40 hours a week and trying to better themselves and get fuck all help.Alot of his friends haven"t bothered with further education or any thing and get more help,makes you wonder why you bother.Anyway he"s just had to cancel his appointments to replace a broken retainer as it costs too much and he can"t afford it.shit times.

Lucyccfc68 · 02/10/2023 20:51

Coleslawclara · 13/07/2023 16:28

All the apprenticeship schemes I’ve come across are a joke. Apprentice office junior, apprentice nursery nurse etc. In the past you’d have at least got minimum wage and worked your way up. Now there’s an excuse to pay you sweet FA for the same work!

There are still an element of crappy apprenticeship programmes on offer, but look around February each year (national apprenticeship week) and you’ll see some fantastic ones. I know because I have spent the last 9 years advertising them. 4 year electrical and mechanical maintenance apprenticeships, which offer a BTEC and HNC and have a start salary of £9.50 ph, with pay rises each year. 5 year quantity surveying and project management apprenticeship, with a starting salary of £22k at 18.

There are also lots of level 2 apprenticeships that I offer for those who are not as academic, but can lead to great careers and they start on £9.50 an hour too.

Look at companies like BT, Mace, Tarmac, PWC, Balfour Beatty and lots of legal organisations.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 02/10/2023 20:51

There is a huge variety in apprenticeships.

our 17 year old has just started one and is on just over £20,000 pa, plus being signed up to a pension scheme. They are doing the pass plus through work which will lower their own own car insurance. So far it’s looking like being a great choice.

XenoBitch · 02/10/2023 20:45

Just looked at what is in my area now. A 15 month long apprentice to be bar staff in a pub. You could not make it up.
Also, a barista in a coffee shop.

XenoBitch · 02/10/2023 20:41

Coleslawclara · 13/07/2023 16:28

All the apprenticeship schemes I’ve come across are a joke. Apprentice office junior, apprentice nursery nurse etc. In the past you’d have at least got minimum wage and worked your way up. Now there’s an excuse to pay you sweet FA for the same work!

Yep, there was an apprenticeship advertised in my town. Full time for a year, and at the end you get a level 2 certificate in food hygiene. The role was basically making tea and serving customers. An absolute joke

ellenc12 · 02/10/2023 20:24

realistically it can be very common!
my son has just turned 17, and started an apprenticeship, needs an eye test and updated prescription every 12 months!!

feenac · 13/07/2023 19:00

Could they join a workplace health scheme? I was an apprentice back in 2005 earning £3.25 per hour. My measly £500 a month was taxed because the threshold was somewhere around £5k at the time. I didn't need prescriptions and the work voucher plus specsavers deals meant my glasses cost £10 but I remember being relieved to have the health scheme when I needed my wisdom tooth pulled out! Saved me £600.

RebelR · 13/07/2023 17:21

LittleOwl153 · 13/07/2023 16:56

UC child element for 2nd child is £237 (£282.50 for 1st /only), plus child benefit of £15.90. (£24 for 1st only) Per week.

For £5.45 × 40hrs child is paid £210. Per week.

From those figures alone I can see why many children of universal credit families are unable to take up apprentiships. Their household would be at least £42 and upto £86 a week worse off, assuming the kid hands over their entire wage and there is no transport/uniforms etc needed. I assume the UC claim will also reduce as the kids income counts?

Surely the benefits are per month (or 4 weeks?) so the "household" is significantly better off if the child does an apprenticeship than stays at school

TiredArse · 13/07/2023 17:09

LittleOwl153 · 13/07/2023 16:56

UC child element for 2nd child is £237 (£282.50 for 1st /only), plus child benefit of £15.90. (£24 for 1st only) Per week.

For £5.45 × 40hrs child is paid £210. Per week.

From those figures alone I can see why many children of universal credit families are unable to take up apprentiships. Their household would be at least £42 and upto £86 a week worse off, assuming the kid hands over their entire wage and there is no transport/uniforms etc needed. I assume the UC claim will also reduce as the kids income counts?

No, the uc is per month.

Overthebow · 13/07/2023 17:07

But surely once the child turns 18 you won’t get child benefit or the child element of UC anyway? So annoying it’s 2 years earlier but it would be coming anyway. So much better for them to be earning £200 a week at 16 and then working their way up to a good job at 18.

ActDottie · 13/07/2023 17:04

I think it’s fair to assume that when you have a child you’ll be financially responsible for them until they’re 18. They’ll be able to make up for the loss in child benefit by paying a notional amount of rent.

LittleOwl153 · 13/07/2023 16:56

UC child element for 2nd child is £237 (£282.50 for 1st /only), plus child benefit of £15.90. (£24 for 1st only) Per week.

For £5.45 × 40hrs child is paid £210. Per week.

From those figures alone I can see why many children of universal credit families are unable to take up apprentiships. Their household would be at least £42 and upto £86 a week worse off, assuming the kid hands over their entire wage and there is no transport/uniforms etc needed. I assume the UC claim will also reduce as the kids income counts?

RebelR · 13/07/2023 16:45

Lots of apprenticeships pay more than minimum wage, just as lots of jobs do.

HighEndGrifters · 13/07/2023 16:42

I have long said that apprenticeships are running the risk of becoming the preserve of the middle classes, our DS (22) (he took a long I know best route to get here 🙄😂is on a decent hourly apprentice wage, out of that he is paying:

Car insurance (needed to get to work, as cheaper than taking the train) £150

Car tax £19.25 (We pay this)

Phone £15 a month (We pay his bill)

Petrol £ 250/300 a month bulk of this is spent on getting to work.

Housekeeping £200 ( I save this for him)

Gym membership (nothing fancy) £25 a month.

Rugby club membership £30 a month (they train twice a week) good for his mental health.

Pension I think is about £100 a month

His AD's prescription £10 a month ( we have paid for a PPC

A meal deal once a week when packed lunch gets boring.

But lets pretend that he was not an only child that we can more than afford to carry, the above come to roughly £850.

If his living conditions were not happy, there is no way he could afford to move out, as just a room without bills around here is minimum £600.

We also pay for MOT and required maintenance.

As I said it is in severe danger of being beyond the reach of many and it makes me angry.

RebelR · 13/07/2023 16:35

Coleslawclara · 13/07/2023 16:28

All the apprenticeship schemes I’ve come across are a joke. Apprentice office junior, apprentice nursery nurse etc. In the past you’d have at least got minimum wage and worked your way up. Now there’s an excuse to pay you sweet FA for the same work!

There was no minimum wage before modern apprenticeships were introduced and minimum wage for under 18s is the same as for apprentices (£5.28, not £5.25, for the sake of accuracy).

SouthCountryGirl · 13/07/2023 16:35

It's not like they have any tax or national insurance to pay?

BoohooWoohoo · 13/07/2023 16:33

Most young people are lucky to be healthy. Do they get free eye test vouchers if they do a computer based job?
My son did an apprenticeship and while the wage is very low it was only for 18 months and he went into a much higher paying job.
Totally agree that not all apprenticeships are equal and some are basically entry level jobs costing the employer half as much.

Needmorelego · 13/07/2023 16:32

If doing a full time apprenticeship (40 hours) they will be earning about £200 a week - 10 times the weekly amount you get for Child Benefit.
If you need extra to cover bills (what you get from UC) then your 16 year olds wages should go towards it. It’s a wage - not pocket money.

Coleslawclara · 13/07/2023 16:28

All the apprenticeship schemes I’ve come across are a joke. Apprentice office junior, apprentice nursery nurse etc. In the past you’d have at least got minimum wage and worked your way up. Now there’s an excuse to pay you sweet FA for the same work!

Swipe left for the next trending thread