Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think all workplaces are toxic?

88 replies

Stripeymum11 · 13/07/2023 09:43

Is there an inherent indignity in working for someone else?

I’ve worked for years now in schools and am starting to think that I’m just never going to be thick-skinned enough to properly thrive in them.

Each time we adults get a new job, we have to familiarise ourselves with the written policies of a place then, regardless of any personal feelings, have to become a representative of that organisation. Fine. That’s just reality, I shove down my core values and give my time in exchange for money.

But it’s the unwritten policies that really upset me. The cultures of bitchy gossip, the male heavy leadership teams that don’t seem to do very much, the brushing (important safeguarding) issues under the carpet, the passive aggressive management, the reactive management styles.

How so people drag themselves through full time work, knowing they have to endure all of this crap for at least 30 more years without becoming just as bad or really depressed?

Is this what attracts people to leadership roles? So they’re not at the mercy of cruel management themselves?

AIBU

OP posts:
Hawkins0001 · 15/07/2023 19:21

I think it's a mix at times, I prefer to try to dance between all the various groups, some times its possible other times others get suspicious of the motives.

Stripeymum11 · 15/07/2023 15:37

ps. I too have worked with some incredibly kind, funny, inspiring and lovely people over the years so I know it’s never all bad.

I have just noticed that I often end up feeling disempowered in the workplace but it probably says as much about my default settings as it does about the workplaces themselves.

OP posts:
Stripeymum11 · 15/07/2023 15:35

Thanks so much for all of your comments.
I bought a great book called, Rising Above a Toxic Workplace which is already helping me puzzle this stuff out.
I know and am aware that I bring my own ‘stuff’ to the table which could play in to my experience in an unfavourable way.
I’ve always been told I’m over- sensitive and have never quite been able to get in the boxing ring and play the game with all its layers of emotional rough and tumble and I’m aware some people are really cut out for that.

Im just going to carry out an experiment where I go on a negativity diet and even the slightest hint of negativity from colleagues I’m just going to consciously tap out of and see how my mental state looks after a term of doing that.
eventually though I imagine I’ll do self employed work.
thanks again for your insights.

OP posts:
Meadowland · 13/07/2023 22:42

YABU. I've worked with some fabulous people in my career, so no, not all workplaces are toxic by any means.

RampantIvy · 13/07/2023 22:18

Is there an inherent indignity in working for someone else?

No. Only if you resent authority.

BLT24 · 13/07/2023 20:48

Not every workplace is toxic. I know this because I worked somewhere for 13 years and apart from one incident with a passive aggressive manager it was a lovely place to work for 12/13 years. However in the last year that I was there the whole place totally changed, they brought in a horrible senior leader and the other senior leaders could not see how vile this person was, and the changes she brought in were very badly managed. It became a horrible toxic workplace, with everyone moaning and complaining and back stabbing. I left. Others left. Everyone I know who still works there hates the place now and all they talk about is how good it used to be. My only regret is not leaving sooner as it severely effected my mental health.

KajsaKavat · 13/07/2023 20:46

I find that places with fewer egos have a way better atmosphere, offices are bad.

aintnothinbutagstring · 13/07/2023 20:44

I can't imagine many schools would brush serious safeguarding issues under the carpet and if they are - then surely there is a whistleblowing procedure if you think things are not being dealt with properly - you can't just sit back and be witness to that type of thing being mismanaged.

5128gap · 13/07/2023 20:40

I've chosen to work in an organisation which reflects my values, where the policies and procedures I have to follow make sense to me as necessary to further the business aims, and which is led by, centres and benefits women. I'm in a leadership role because I think I have skills and experience to offer and I get satisfaction from influencing the direction we take.
My salary is so poor many people on here would think there was a zero missed off.

UsingChangeofName · 13/07/2023 20:18

But it’s the unwritten policies that really upset me. The cultures of bitchy gossip, the male heavy leadership teams that don’t seem to do very much, the brushing (important safeguarding) issues under the carpet, the passive aggressive management, the reactive management styles.

Not something I've experienced in any of the schools I've worked in.
Don't get me wrong, there is SO much wrong with teaching at the moment, and I'd not recommend anyone to start as a teacher now, but I've never worked in any school with a bitchy, gossipy culture. I've never worked anywhere with male heavy Leadership Team, I've never worked anywhere where any Safeguarding issue was brushed under the carpet.

Even if I had, I wouldn't then think "all workplaces are toxic", I'd think that particular workplace was.

Toddlerteaplease · 13/07/2023 20:18

We have a really close knit team and we all work really well together.

ZenNudist · 13/07/2023 20:07

I'd hate to work in a school. There must be some happy ones.

My workplace is great. Really friendly. Everyone gets on. No bitching. We have a laugh. Work hard. I only look at policies when I've got to discipline someone usually or need go help someone.

Babdoc · 13/07/2023 19:24

I’m retired now, but both my DDs work. Their workplaces are lovely, and very supportive. DD1 is autistic, and her work bent over backwards to be helpful, even providing a retreat room for meltdowns, and an autistic support network, which DD helped to run. They paid for private counselling when she had a relapse of her depression. Her colleagues are mostly geeky old men, and she fits right in - they all chat about computer games and Star Trek together!
DD2 works in a senior marketing role in financial services, has always been well mentored, and now manages a team of staff herself. She is kind and conscientious, encouraging talent, and finds it a supportive place to work. The management switched the staff to a four day week with no loss of pay over the summer months, so they can enjoy long weekends.

I feel rather envious, having slogged for 36 years in the bloody NHS, which always treated its exhausted staff like shit and has never been well managed! Retiring medical and nursing staff were all given a £30 Argos voucher by the management in my hospital - I think that’s possibly more insulting than nothing at all!

DonnaHadDee · 13/07/2023 19:24

That toxic element is not something I’ve experienced at an organisational level, having worked in software development for 25 years in large tech companies. However, of course I’ve met some awful people, but that can happen anywhere.

my biggest challenges are constant schedule pressure, crunch mode, competitive peers, crazy hours, always on, but the salary is very good. I’m not sure I’d be good at anything else!

Oblomov23 · 13/07/2023 19:12

Nope. I've worked in nice places, great places. Only 2 were not good, of which one was very toxic. Everyone I know has had one toxic place, but not numerous.

Kazzyhoward · 13/07/2023 19:08

YABU, lots of workplaces are actually pretty nice places to work in with generally nice people to work with.

I've worked in 7 different firms over 40 years and I'd say only one of those would meet your experience as per the opening post, i.e. bitchiness, poor management etc. The other 6 were actually OK places to work and I only left due to career enhancement or relocation.

The one that was poorly managed with lots of bitchiness was, sadly, dominated by women at all levels, i.e. owners, managers, and most of the staff, and was an absolute hell hole to work in, and I decided to leave within the first month of being there as the whole place was toxic, full of cliques, no support from management, etc.

All the others were owned/managed by a mix of both males and females, and were generally nicer places to work, more supportive management, more supportive co-workers, etc.

BritishDesiGirl · 13/07/2023 19:08

Yes, l beliv that they are. Husband currently works in a male oriented workplace where it is rife with toxicity.

SugarRaye · 13/07/2023 19:07

Stripeymum11 · 13/07/2023 18:44

It’s quite hard to do that if you’re a primary school teacher. I’ve thought about becoming a dyslexia assessor/ tutor but I love having a class.
Food for thought anyway!
Thank you 😺

You can set up your own private education business doing coaching, online teaching, etc. Or you can leave education altogether. You're an educated person with good qualifications. You could set up another type of business.
I took voluntary redundancy from teaching and then got worried how I'd support myself! But a colleague who had done all sorts within education, said there were all sorts of streams of income to be earned within the sector.

Don't compromise your core values and your dignity. If you're unhappy, strike out. Its perfectly possible to do some small class teaching within private coaching. Or go down to part time in school and part time private to get the best of both worlds.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/07/2023 19:05

There are schools and there are schools.

I've been in toxic ones where getting through the week is a triumph of needing the bills paid over the desire to tell them to go fuck themselves, walk out the door and never look back. And I've been in ones where actually, despite the stresses, despite the occasional twat needing to be either brought back into line and encouraged to behave like a decent human being or to fuck off, the underlying culture is of caring for each other and supporting everybody to get through the tough times. If people feel valued and supported, the culture is fundamentally positive. The key is to have staff at all levels onboard with the idea of valuing one another. If you don't feel valued, it's harder to have a thicker skin, as everything feels like a direct attack (largely because it probably is - often attack being the first means of defence) - but if you know you are genuinely valued, frayed tempers or frustration/tiredness/overwhelm are much easier to not take so personally and you can support others in the knowledge that they will try and do the same for you.

Valuing somebody isn't just pay, it's also in how they're spoken to, whether they're listened to, whether their abilities or skills are allowed to be developed and respected.

FuppingEll · 13/07/2023 19:05

dikwad · 13/07/2023 10:43

The only place I have is experienced anything like you've written is when I have worked with other women. I now work as office manager in a construction company, I am the only woman in a team of about 50 and I enjoy each and every day without the gossip and bullshit I've experienced with other females previously.

I don't understand posts this post and others like it. Is it self loathing or do you see yourself as being above other women/not like other girls? Do you turn into a gossipy bitch when you are around other women? I just don't get how you can include half of the population in these stereotypes but then exclude yourself from it? Either women are that way, you included or they are not.

Shimmyshimmycocobop · 13/07/2023 18:55

Absolutely not, and have worked for nearly 40 years in predominantly female based professions ( beauty therapy and nursing).
I've had 14 jobs in that time and 2 were what you might call toxic, one certainly was.

I really don't like people blaming women for toxic work places, there are plenty of horrible male workplaces. My ex worked in construction and at times was treated horribly.

I think you've probably been unlucky op.

DinnaeFashYersel · 13/07/2023 18:46

Most places I've worked have been great.

LlynTegid · 13/07/2023 18:46

Not my current experience, but have had this in the past.

Too many people become managers based on technical or specialist knowledge not on ability to manage people, and never given enough time to manage.

Stripeymum11 · 13/07/2023 18:44

SugarRaye · 13/07/2023 18:05

If it's such an indignity working for someone else and so awful burying your core values, go set up your own business. That way you'll have your dignity and core values in tact.

It’s quite hard to do that if you’re a primary school teacher. I’ve thought about becoming a dyslexia assessor/ tutor but I love having a class.
Food for thought anyway!
Thank you 😺

OP posts:
Windercar · 13/07/2023 18:44

I’ve never encountered gossips at work. Yes, workplaces can have issues - you’re not friends - but if you’re working somewhere which is broadly unsupportive then move.

From friends and this forum though it does sound to me like schools suffer more than other places. My workplace is friendly and professional on the whole