Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher gifts - ungrateful shit!

530 replies

Hufflemuff · 13/07/2023 09:23

More of a rant than a question to be fair!

I was listening to Heart radio this morning and they had a teacher on called "Mc Grammer" (a rapping teacher - cringe) who was discussing teacher gifts and "what not to buy"...

He said one of the worse gifts he ever got from a student was a Rock - because the pupil said "he rocked" (aww) and some Doritos because that was the pupils favourite crisps (bless). He also said mugs were mostly an unwanted present "there's only so many cups of tea you can drink" apparently.

He said in the past he's gotten an Arsenal shirt, Nando's gift sets and gift cards... He said you should get to know the teacher to find out what they like and buy them something personal to them.

AIBU to be totally pissed off by this mans arrogance. It was totally tone deaf during the middle of a cost of living crisis to suggest parents buy gift cards (the minimum of which is usually £10) and other expensive presents in order for it to be considered a worthwhile gift. The fact he poo-pooed that boys rock as "one of the worse" gifts, which admittedly you wouldn't put on your mantel piece but the sentiment was there. He didn't consider that the boys parents might not have the money to buy a 'real' gift but he still wanted to give him something.

Ah!!! I was so very cross. It was the expectation to get something as a certainty and even then, he might not have been satisfied with it.

I have teachers in the family and they are always happy to get anything at all, no matter what it is. I think he was a really bad representation of all those caring teachers and Heart did the profession a real disservice by having him on.

Rant over! Gah!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 13/07/2023 15:53

The rock was a cool gift and he's an obnoxious ingrate for dismissing it.

But I don't blame teachers for not wanting a bunch of cheap tat. Most people like to select their own mugs. Parents are under no obligation to shower professional teachers with gifts. Sit the kid down and have them write a heartfelt letter to the teacher, enclose in a card, job done. No expenditure necessary.

stargirl1701 · 13/07/2023 15:32

@Jumbojade

Any single gift over £30 must be reported on in my LA and then tax paid on it.

Jumbojade · 13/07/2023 15:23

wholivesondrurylane · 13/07/2023 13:41

if that bothers you so much, why don't you become a teacher?

Funny enough, nurses, midwives and doctors are left presents by parents or patients in hospital!

Funnily enough nurses (plus other NHS workers) and carers, are actually very limited in what they are allowed to accept.

In my local health board area, they cannot accept any monetary gifts, and that includes gift vouchers. The ward may be given gifts of biscuits or sweets, but not much else.

The size of some of the vouchers described on here, is a definite no no and if it was found that they accepted a gift like that, they would face a disciplinary!

Allhailkingcharlie · 13/07/2023 15:09

I'm a teacher. Don't give anything. Just say thank you at the end of the year and ask your child to say thank you. I would love that more than anything!!!!

gillybean2 · 13/07/2023 15:09

Last year our local food bank posted pictures of the teachers from one local school dropping in big donation. They’d asked their classes to donate an item for the food bank instead if they wanted to give an end of year gift. I thought that was brilliant and much more useful. Summer holidays can be busy at the foodbank with less donations coming in too. Perhaps more teachers could suggest that if they don’t want more mugs or other ‘tat’.

WeWereInParis · 13/07/2023 15:08

Still remember children being upset and even apologising for not bringing a gift ( as if turning up to a party without a birthday present) I always made it clear gifts weren’t necessary.

I remember being that child. I vividly remember in year 1 sitting round in a circle while everyone gave the teacher their present (I assume the teacher did this as a way to appreciate each gift, so the child saw her open it etc). I was genuinely really nervous as it came closer to my turn, thinking I was going to be in trouble for not having anything. Thankfully by coincidence I was sitting next to the only other child in the class who also hadn't brought one, and in unison we sort of hung our heads and said "we're really sorry, we didn't get you anything". It's one of my earliest memories of school.

IateAllTheGaribaldis · 13/07/2023 15:01

I can't remember who said it but the family who send in donuts and pizza during the last week - thank you for the great idea!

Unfortunately takeaways here often won't deliver to schools but I'm eyeing up a big box of Krispy Kreme donuts to send in with DS on Monday.

I'm also planning on a card / cards and an email to the head.

Would you have him make just the one card to 'all' of his teachers and TA? (two teachers, three TA's - it's a special needs school and they have all changed his life so much, no exaggeration, he's like a different child)

I want to express my gratitude to each of them but cannot for the life of me think of what to write in separate cards and don't just want to write the same thing in several.

JusthereforXmas · 13/07/2023 14:51

I do think some gifts are crap like my oldest first year at school and the pushy mams took it upon themselves to demand we all pay for their 'group' present.

We had no say in it and It was a MASSIVE. It was a finger print tree poster that they made themselves that certainly didnt cost £5pp (which equals £150) for paper and an ink pad. What teach wants a massive poster of smudged kids fingerprints though? there wasn't even anyway to know what kids it was etc...

I learned my lesson and ran away every time I saw those parents coming from then on... If I got cornered I conveniently had forgotten my purse.

I like to buy my own gift for them, I find useful supplies mixed with something for the teacher (like a box of prit sticks for the class and a nice fancy best teacher cookie etc...) goes down well enough, isn't trying too hard (non of the keeping up with the jones one upmanship) and is useful and inoffensive.

I think the rock is adorable (especially if its a cool rock or crystal which are still pretty cheap) and Dorritos thats an inoffensive and practical present. They are the types of presents that I think are best... small or usable but not something they will get 30 replicas of.

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/07/2023 14:50

This is why we do a class first. We give what we can afford and then usually get a voucher for somewhere that can be used in lots of places

And a card where we all say something

StefanosHill · 13/07/2023 14:47

Catlover77 · 13/07/2023 14:44

He is not far wrong though. I have many family members and friends who are teachers and they honestly do not want all the crap gifts. Give nothing or a card.

Not even a voucher?

Catlover77 · 13/07/2023 14:44

He is not far wrong though. I have many family members and friends who are teachers and they honestly do not want all the crap gifts. Give nothing or a card.

carduelis · 13/07/2023 14:43

Irritatedmum · 13/07/2023 13:31

I like to get a token gift because in my opinion teachers are underpaid, overworked and underappreciated. I’m not a teacher, but I hear stories on here about the massive amount of hours and effort that go into looking after our children, there’s no way they’re paid enough for what they do.

So I get a £5 voucher from Costa so they can have a coffee and maybe a little cake, and hope thats ok for them, I worry now after seeing this chat!

Tbh just your acknowledgement of how hard teachers work would be enough of a gift for me if I taught your kids!

WeWereInParis · 13/07/2023 14:39

COL is a factor - but hard to believe when the same parent claiming COL for being a cheapskate is going on quite a nice holiday this summer (case in my daughter's class).

They're probably saying that as an excuse when what they want to say is "I don't want to get the teacher a present". Which shouldn't be an unreasonable position to take.
My mum is a teacher and loves nicely written thank you cards (she teaches gcse and 6th form) and does not expect anyone to be spending money on her. I know class gifts aren't a secondary school thing, but she'd be mortified if she thought people were judging other parents for not contributing to a gift!

stargirl1701 · 13/07/2023 14:38

@Nicknacky

Yes, I post on Teams at October and April that I do not want gifts. It's tricky to word as it immediately establishes you were expecting them.

I also post on Teams requesting a box of tissues and soap from each family if they are able to contribute. I label them and each time we get a box or soap out I thank the child for their contribution to our classroom environment.

Onedownonetogooo · 13/07/2023 14:28

Pkhsvd · 13/07/2023 09:25

That’s awful and fuels my fears about what to get my DCs teacher as I’m worried about giving a rubbish gift but money is also very tight at the moment. The idea of getting to know the teacher to know what they like sounds quite ridiculous really, I barely see my DCs teacher and I can’t rely on a young child to tell me what her teachers interests are.

I’m a teacher and i would be delighted with a box of chocolates , a candle or a bottle of Prosecco ! £5 limit Max .

I would be equally as pleased with a homemade card ! It’s a gesture that makes us feel so grateful for all we do and that’s the whole point . £5 max spend 💕

42isthemeaning · 13/07/2023 14:27

Awful. As a secondary teacher I expect nothing. I'm always touched to receive a card or drawing from a pupil. I vowed never to be like a friend's dm, (now a retired primary school teacher) who used to get tons of gifts, go through them all once home and screw up her face whilst saying, that's rubbish, I'm binning that! Horrible behaviour!

RobertsRadio · 13/07/2023 14:27

A Christmas card was all my kids ever gave to their teachers. I think most teachers would be glad not to be overwhelmed with unwanted tat carefully chosen gifts. Most people are trying to rid their homes of unwanted and unused "stuff", why would teachers be any different.

Twillow · 13/07/2023 14:25

TheChosenTwo · 13/07/2023 09:45

I loved the letter and cards more than anything else. Mugs were added to the burgeoning staffroom collection, I don’t drink tea or coffee and we already have too many mugs at home!
I’m the least sentimental person in the world and quite the minimalist but at the back of my wardrobe is a big box which contains every thank you card and letter I received from students and their parents. I have left that profession now, traded it in for one where pissed off parents aren’t berating me for doing my job, but occasionally when I’m having a wardrobe clear out I look through that box and relive some truly wonderful moments.
Those personal heartfelt words of gratitude are the most thoughtful things a teacher could ever hope to receive.
Save your cash and write a lovely card!

Absolutely agree. Handwritten card/notes from child and/or parent are the best! Nothing else required imo.

Mamansparkles · 13/07/2023 14:24

That's terrible! And makes me really angry. I would LOVE a rock from my pupils and it would have pride of place on my desk (even better if it's painted).

Inertia · 13/07/2023 14:22

I haven’t heard the interview but that made me cringe. Did he genuinely say worst presents, rather than e.g. most unusual or memorable? If so he’s an absolute arse.

It’s been said many times, but cards and messages from the children really are treasured-teachers don’t expect gifts.

The thing I’d most value is something for the classroom- pencils or glue sticks would be perfect, and I love the book idea mentioned above.

HarrietStyles · 13/07/2023 14:17

I was listening this morning open mouthed 🤯 I worked in Childcare for many years and hand on heart the best presents I ever got were hand-made cards with beautiful personal messages inside. I still have some 10/20 years later. I would have adored a child giving me a rock and telling me it was because I rocked. When I was a Nanny I was given cash bonuses, expensive jewellery, designer handbags (sorry not intended as a brag) and although it was lovely and I certainly didn’t complain - the most treasured gifts were beaded jewellery made by the children and the handmade cards. It really is the thought that counts.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 13/07/2023 14:13

I don't buy anything most years, occasionally I'll bake some cupcakes for them to take in.
I have 5 school aged children, I can't afford gift cards or anything lavish (my show off of a sister insisted on buying pandora bracelets for her daughter's teachers 🙄) and I resent when we are asked to all 'donate' a fiver to a big present.

I'm constantly being told it's "only a fiver" by other parents.
To them and their one or two kids, yes, it's not a lot.
To me, that's £25.

MrsR87 · 13/07/2023 14:06

MaggyNoodles · 13/07/2023 13:59

My son overheard his year 1 teacher say her scissors were broken. He used his own pocket money to buy her a new pair as an end of year thank you present.
When he gave her the gift, and told her why he'd bought them, she said all the right things, but when we popped back into the class 15 mins later for his forgotten PE kit she was slagging the scissors off to the TA as a strange and cheap gift.
Ds didn't hear her, but I did. Never bought another gift for anyone in that school again.

That’s horrible! How thoughtful of your son to think of and remember that. This teacher would have loved it.

wholivesondrurylane · 13/07/2023 14:05

Divebar2021 · 13/07/2023 14:01

@wholivesondrurylane

how do you know what people have donated?

because the organiser ask for one or 2 people to check the transactions, so no one can accuse anyone of putting money in their pocket...

That's the one good thing with a set amount, which we haven't got, it stops any possible query.

Divebar2021 · 13/07/2023 14:01

@wholivesondrurylane

how do you know what people have donated?