Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher gifts - ungrateful shit!

530 replies

Hufflemuff · 13/07/2023 09:23

More of a rant than a question to be fair!

I was listening to Heart radio this morning and they had a teacher on called "Mc Grammer" (a rapping teacher - cringe) who was discussing teacher gifts and "what not to buy"...

He said one of the worse gifts he ever got from a student was a Rock - because the pupil said "he rocked" (aww) and some Doritos because that was the pupils favourite crisps (bless). He also said mugs were mostly an unwanted present "there's only so many cups of tea you can drink" apparently.

He said in the past he's gotten an Arsenal shirt, Nando's gift sets and gift cards... He said you should get to know the teacher to find out what they like and buy them something personal to them.

AIBU to be totally pissed off by this mans arrogance. It was totally tone deaf during the middle of a cost of living crisis to suggest parents buy gift cards (the minimum of which is usually £10) and other expensive presents in order for it to be considered a worthwhile gift. The fact he poo-pooed that boys rock as "one of the worse" gifts, which admittedly you wouldn't put on your mantel piece but the sentiment was there. He didn't consider that the boys parents might not have the money to buy a 'real' gift but he still wanted to give him something.

Ah!!! I was so very cross. It was the expectation to get something as a certainty and even then, he might not have been satisfied with it.

I have teachers in the family and they are always happy to get anything at all, no matter what it is. I think he was a really bad representation of all those caring teachers and Heart did the profession a real disservice by having him on.

Rant over! Gah!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sartre · 13/07/2023 13:27

What an arsehole. Have a few relatives who teach/taught primary children and they’re always over the moon with any cards, gifts or even hand drawn pictures/cards which are actually their favourite things of all. One cousin keeps a huge box in her loft filled with every card and gift she’s ever received. They do get an awful lot of mugs though so I do steer clear of that when buying my DC’s teachers’ gifts!

Mama678 · 13/07/2023 13:27

adviceneeded1990 · 13/07/2023 12:18

Oh god I’d hate that! Firstly, most LAs don’t allow us to accept anything worth anywhere near that amount so it adds extra paper work! Also, it’s never the whole class that contribute, it’s the ‘cool mummy’ WhatsApp group or similar and it makes other parents feel left out and their kids feel crappy that they didn’t get to play a part in the teachers gift and could maybe only afford a rock.

Not everyone in the class contributes but we always write the card from “all of the children”. Tbf everyone on the class whatsapp are very happy that someone else is organising the gift!

Skiggles2018 · 13/07/2023 13:27

Pkhsvd · 13/07/2023 09:25

That’s awful and fuels my fears about what to get my DCs teacher as I’m worried about giving a rubbish gift but money is also very tight at the moment. The idea of getting to know the teacher to know what they like sounds quite ridiculous really, I barely see my DCs teacher and I can’t rely on a young child to tell me what her teachers interests are.

If the teacher is a decent person they will not mind either way - a gift is not expected!
you could get a card and say thank you if you think they’ve been a good teacher this year - no one would hate that.

ManonDe · 13/07/2023 13:24

Back in our richer days we gave a bottle of french champagne to each class subject teacher. Plus a hand made silver bangle to one who really helped DS1 from a local jewllery maker that we had found out she liked.

Simply cannot afford that this year so we gave a bottle of Aldi champagne to 3 teachers only.

Mind you, when we toured a school for open day a few years back we were taken to the teacher staffroom and saw a hand embroidered cushion with the teacher's name and thanks on it. I commented on how lovely it was and the teacher touring said that yes, it was lovely. The named teacher was so grateful, and she was great and what a pity she had retired now for a few years.

So loved the hand embroidered cushion- not enough to take it home.

That made me throw away the idea of anything personalised immediately.

Skiggles2018 · 13/07/2023 13:24

That’s horrible - but I expect they purposely chose someone who would say that! None of the teachers I know expect gifts or moan about handmade or personally chosen gifts by the child!
I have received pictures drawn and one pupil gave me some Poundland tea lights - I get them out every Xmas for the memory! I had a Freddo - it’s the thought and I’ve always had to explain to the class all their gifts are amazing but in don’t expect them as the biggest gift is if they’ve tried their best to make our class amazing!
I always think it’s hard for the ones who can’t give anything who watch it all given.
I once had a written card from a grandmother saying how much her granddaughter loved my lessons - it was gushing and made me cry!

justteanbiscuits · 13/07/2023 13:24

There was the "competitive" Mum who always liked to be seen walking in with a massive gift, giggling and flicking her hair. The year she walked in with a 24 pack of cans of stella (this was her go to for male teachers) to give to the openly Muslim teacher was quite the moment.

Zebedee55 · 13/07/2023 13:23

When my kids were at primary school, in the 70's, no one ever bought the teachers a present.

A card, for any that were really liked, was it.🙂

Liamgallaghersparka · 13/07/2023 13:23

If some kid brought me a rock I'd be over the moon! A gift is a gift, not something the recipient gets to choose!
Many years ago when I was at school we didn't get gifts for teachers, they were lucky if they got a bunch of roses from my dad's garden!

drpet49 · 13/07/2023 13:22

ReaIIyThough · 13/07/2023 09:27

I cant imagine the mountains of stuff teachers are given each year.....where are they supposed to put it all? Loads of wine, chocolates, personalised things that have just an individual child's name....like teachers don't have an extra house to store all this stuff in. I'd rather contribute as a class to a gift card, bigger cash gift if anything.

This. I imagine teachers get so much tat.

SpeckledlyHen · 13/07/2023 13:22

Coolhwip · 13/07/2023 09:25

Difficult to say if YANBU having not heard him, but I’d imagine some parents might welcome the guidance on what not to get.

We never got our teachers gifts in the 90s.

When I was at school (80's/90's) we did not get the teacher gifts. Does anyone know why we do now? I have never really understood the trend if I am honest (will probably get shot down for saying).

CavierBreak · 13/07/2023 13:16

I offered to organise the teachers gift this year. I really like this particular teacher and so do many parents.

So I have my bank details and received amounts from £20 to £5 to nothing. I made it clear no minimum or maximum and no obligation. I'm not sitting there keeping track of 30 parents contributions. One reminder and that was it.

Vouchers purchased for teacher and TAs. Got my child to write card from the class. Job done.

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/07/2023 13:06

I was a secondary teacher and we never expected - nor usually got - gifts. I once got a chocolate orange from a boy when I had a Y7 form for my tutor group and it was clear his Mum had said "Give this to your tutor! Go on, don't come back and tell me you didn't!" because the way he sidled up to the front, trying to do it without the rest of the (all boys) class seeing, was superb, bless him!

I also got a lovely gift from one of my A level students after he got an A grade (no A* grades in those days) and I still have it - it was 1987!

Lemonandlime123 · 13/07/2023 12:56

As a teacher I do not expect to receive gifts at all, please don't feel pressured to do so. A card with a message or a simple thank you is the best gift anyway.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 13/07/2023 12:54

Teacher's gifts are really unnessary en bloc which they seem to be. I hope that stupid man's comments go far and wide and have the desired affect that this mawkish gift-to-landfill, comes to an end.

It's actually disgusting given that so many people are struggling and this twat mouths off about 'thoughtless' gifts. Angry

towriteyoumustlive · 13/07/2023 12:46

I'm a (secondary school) teacher and hate getting "tat" or trinkets or dust gathering stuff. Sorry!

If you're going to buy a gift, get something useful for a classroom that kids can use, a voucher, or something edible or drinkable. Wine! Mmmmm, wine!

What I really like are all the cards and letters I've received thanking me for the effort I've put into teaching. I've kept every one of them. Some have even made me cry. Some have really surprised me e.g. quiet kids that rarely spoke in my lesson but took the time to write a little card saying how much they loved my lessons and enthusiasm and how I made the subject enjoyable.

Some gifts are nice but a card is the best.

wholivesondrurylane · 13/07/2023 12:43

80sMum · 13/07/2023 12:36

Teachers very rarely received gifts when I was at school. In fact I don't remember anyone ever bringing in a gift - and doing so had never occurred to me or my parents.

Both of my children also successfully navigated their way through the education system from age 4 to age 18 without ever having given any of their teachers a gift or card.

Why do people feel the need to give gifts nowadays? I assume it must be the parents who buy them and not the children.

If you absolutely must get a gift, be sure to make it something consumable and not a junk item like a mug or an ornament etc.

Imagine being a teacher and 10 kids in your class buy you a "world's best teacher" mug for Christmas, then another 10 get you a similar one at the end of the summer term, then it happens again the following year and the year after that and so on! What on earth are people supposed to do with all the junk/clutter?

again.. my grand-father did receive gifts when he was a teacher. It's not about "nowadays".

napody · 13/07/2023 12:42

Shinyandnew1 · 13/07/2023 09:28

Sounds like an arse-sadly there are those all over the place and he isn’t representative of most teachers.

The nicest presents I’ve had have been handwritten letters from parents thanking me for teaching their child-they didn’t cost anything but their time and a piece of paper.

This. They must agave searched high and low to find someone like that.... interesting considering potential motivation in the context around teacher strikes- surely not deliberately stirring up ill feeling?!

ididntwanttodoit · 13/07/2023 12:42

He is a complete arse. Anything at all - esp homemade cards- were always appreciated by me and my teaching colleagues. I walkways shared any choices or sweets I was given with the class (I suppose you can't do that any longer, sadly) and choccie biccies went down a treat when left for all staff to share in the staffrroom. "Teacher" mugs never go amiss: we used to ut them in the staffroom for staff and visitors to use. I was totally embarrassed by being given money in the form of vouchers (and actually, I don't think teachers are allowed to accept these any longer in some LEAs)or wine (! much as I needed it by the end of them!).

LaurieFairyCake · 13/07/2023 12:41

When my DH was a deputy head he had a form where he met his form twice a day for the whole five years

They got him one of those giant (hideous) padded cards and every one of them had written a really lovely personal paragraph about him - he literally cried, they cried, and there was a giant group hug 🤗

He said it was his best moment in 20 years of teaching

Honestly I reckon he will want me to put that card in his coffin Grin - we've moved half a dozen times since, card still in his study

pinkhousesarebest · 13/07/2023 12:40

I’m a teacher and still have cards from my students from when I started.Love the ones that are written by the dc themselves and I also appreciate the ones that the parents write.
Chocolates are fab. Hand made buns etc go into the bin I’m afraid after getting a terrible gastro once. Knick knacks and mugs make my heart sink as I have to think of a way to dispose of them . I’m not ungrateful but I have no desire or interest in accumulating more tat.
Best thing ever is a gift card from a group of parents. Second best thing is nothing.

catlover33 · 13/07/2023 12:39

Im in my 20s but I only ever brought my form tutor a little something like a box of Chocolates. I do remember when I did my GCSEs I brought my form tutor and my english teacher a nice pot plant each (they were both female and in there late 50s/60s). My form tutor as a token gift and the english teacher as it was by far my worst subject and she had gone above and beyond and I came away with a very good grade so it was an appreciation gift for her extra help and support.

Verbena17 · 13/07/2023 12:37

He’s another one who shouldn’t teach! You have to wonder what life skills and morals he’s actually giving the poor kiddos he ‘teaches’.

We didn’t buy a single teacher present for any of our kids’ teachers but sometimes they would make them a little home made card and give that. The only time we bought a gift from our family was for the library of our son’s special school. He had been there from when it opened and it made a massive difference in our life and we wanted to give something as a thank you, and so we bought a fun set of books we knew the other younger children would enjoy

Gifts for teachers is so overhyped and is just an accepted thing to do, especially for certain parents who kind of do it for show and one-upmanship. I think schools should ban gifts for staff - cards or a heart felt poem if you feel like, but no gifts.

80sMum · 13/07/2023 12:36

Teachers very rarely received gifts when I was at school. In fact I don't remember anyone ever bringing in a gift - and doing so had never occurred to me or my parents.

Both of my children also successfully navigated their way through the education system from age 4 to age 18 without ever having given any of their teachers a gift or card.

Why do people feel the need to give gifts nowadays? I assume it must be the parents who buy them and not the children.

If you absolutely must get a gift, be sure to make it something consumable and not a junk item like a mug or an ornament etc.

Imagine being a teacher and 10 kids in your class buy you a "world's best teacher" mug for Christmas, then another 10 get you a similar one at the end of the summer term, then it happens again the following year and the year after that and so on! What on earth are people supposed to do with all the junk/clutter?

adviceneeded1990 · 13/07/2023 12:33

TriciaA1991 · 13/07/2023 12:28

To be honest I don't think teachers should expect gifts - they may work hard but it is their job! I try and buy people gifts wgo are volunteers - Brownie and Guide Leaders, the Chair of the PTA - people who are not paid for what they do but work incredibly hard - some have made more differece for my children than people who are paid

As this thread shows, the vast majority of teachers don’t expect gifts.

whoruntheworldgirls · 13/07/2023 12:33

Glad to read about the hand made cards as my daughter has done that for her teacher and TA, sequins, glitter, gems, the lot 😀
I've also bought them nice chocolates (i know they like them) as they have been superstars this year and really sad to leaving them (me and my daughter!)