Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this was cruel towards their daughter?

90 replies

Iwishthaticouldbelikethecoolkids · 13/07/2023 08:26

It's a work friend who has a 21 year old daughter. The daughter lives with her parents and had her long-term bf to stay over for a couple of nights (LDR)
I think her father wanted them to sleep in different rooms initially, but it would've meant sharing a room with her younger brother.
One night apparently the father heard some 'noise' coming from the floorboards upstairs which led directly to the daughter's bedroom and put two and two together.
Anyway, he was furious and told her mother on the phone about the 'night he'd had'.
He then invited their family friends to go out for a meal but left their daughter and boyfriend at home, they weren't invited. Apparently he was cold with the daughter that day.
Aibu to find this incredibly harsh towards the 21 year old. Sure, nobody really wants to hear that but a quiet word 'Can you make sure you're a bit quieter next time' would have sufficed.
Deliberately leaving her out and telling her Mum about it is just cruel. The girl is 21 so an adult, she should move out if that's how she's treated.

OP posts:
Catspyjamas17 · 13/07/2023 09:37

I agree with you, OP.

ActDottie · 13/07/2023 09:36

At 21 the dad needs to just accept she’s old enough to have a proper relationship now.

Isittimeformynapyet · 13/07/2023 09:34

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 13/07/2023 09:13

If the dad could hear, then presumably so could the younger brother. Perhaps this is the issue. I think loud sex when other people are in the house is disrespectful, particularly when its your parent's home. Punishing her for it is wierd. Coming into work and telling all of his colleagues about it is out of order. Neither father nor daughter are being respectful towards each other here.

There's no mention of "loud sex" in the OP. In fact, from the description, the sound could have been walking about.

I really don't understand why people need to embroider things like this. It's how rumours run rampant.

KangaRooMoo · 13/07/2023 09:32

Yeahhh... so kinda agree with where you are. It's an overreaction to be upset anyway over floorboards and guessing 21 yo daughter is spending the night with her LTB. And the shaming aspect of leaving her out is cruel, I agree with that.

I am just conscious that we don't know the full story though and there may be reasons why this is a huge deal to the Dad. There could be reasons why he's not part of the "sex positive movement" and ultimately it is his house. If daughter knew he didn't want it under his roof, then at 21 she's old enough to have made alternative arrangements.

My Nan was once having her sister and brother in law visit. They were all over 40 with grown up children. She made arrangements for her and her sister to share a room and my grandad and BIL to stay in the other bedroom 🤣🤣 THAT was a bit extreme and my great aunt told her not to be so bloody daft, it was a laughable moment later, but some people really are extremely uncomfortable with sex. It's not necessarily right or a healthy attitude to have but it's their home. So. 🤷

wholivesondrurylane · 13/07/2023 09:16

If she is old enough to have sex, she is old enough not to go with daddy and his friends for a meal out!

Since when is it "cruel" not to bring a 21 year old along? She should be happy, she can have noisy sex while the house is empty.

The OP is just as over-reacting as the dad. Every adult needs to grow up in that story.

Toohotrightnow · 13/07/2023 09:13

Maybe dad left them at home so they could have their ‘alone time’ when he wasn’t in the house and could selectively deny it to himself? Sounds like a good plan

Blinkinbloodyhayfever · 13/07/2023 09:13

If the dad could hear, then presumably so could the younger brother. Perhaps this is the issue. I think loud sex when other people are in the house is disrespectful, particularly when its your parent's home. Punishing her for it is wierd. Coming into work and telling all of his colleagues about it is out of order. Neither father nor daughter are being respectful towards each other here.

Chickenkeev · 13/07/2023 09:13

He sounds like a bit of a gobshite, but you're a bit over invested imo.

MammaTo · 13/07/2023 09:11

This sounds a lot like my dad, I don’t think he’d be as calm as just giving me the silent treatment though - probably would of packed my bags as he was very much “my house my rules” kind of man. If you want to sleep in the same bed you can get your own place.
It ended up with quite frosty living conditions between the 2 of us and I moved out at 24. Obviously a lot harder with COL crisis going on to move out but it was the only way to get some freedom.

keepmovingon · 13/07/2023 09:11

He is an idiot. What does he do when he hears her fart fumigate the house! Sex is a normal part of a healthy life.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 13/07/2023 09:08

Well I imagine they got up to a whole lot more being left at home for the day.

Megifer · 13/07/2023 09:06

She should have flat out denied it - " eeew Dad don't be daft no way would we have sex if theres a chance you could hear"

Then he'd either have to just back off or admit he was listening in.

CalistoNoSolo · 13/07/2023 09:05

Are you the daughter? Otherwise I can't see why you even care. The father is a dinosaur but his house, his rules. The daughter and boyfriend can move in together or stay at a hotel/b&b when he visits. The not being invited out - maybe the father didn't want to have to pay for the boyfriends meal too? Maybe he wanted to talk it over with his friend? It all sounds like a storm in a teacup to me.

Megifer · 13/07/2023 09:04

I can't put my finger on it but there's something weird about this Dad acting like this and id be amazed if all he heard was creaking floorboards id bet he was actually listening. Like hes controlling his daughters sex life literally and emotionally by being difficult. Why? Would make me a bit uncomfortable but I can't explain why.

What does mum say?

Gerrataere · 13/07/2023 09:03

Peacoffee · 13/07/2023 08:42

You’re a bit over invested in this.
He had a rule, separate room, many parents have this. The DD doesn’t have to live at home at 21 but while she does they don’t want her bf staying in her room. That’s fair enough. She choose to break that rule and the consequence of that is missing a lunch out.
Are people getting pent up because this is about sex? If a 16 year old was told to not go on the PlayStation all night and did anyway and then wasn’t treated to lunch the next day would people be outraged?

But she’s not 16, she’s an adult. Telling adults not to have sex with their partners because they’re under their parents roof is a ridiculously archaic stance to take. Being respectful and quiet is not unreasonable but ‘no sex, separate bedrooms’ at 21 is quite frankly the most embarrassing thing about this. It’s a very quick way to lose respect for your parents, not because of their ‘rules’ but because they evidently will always treat you like a child when under their roof.

namechange55465 · 13/07/2023 09:02

DinnaeFashYersel · 13/07/2023 08:28

Sounds like a normal dad reaction to me and cruel is a strong word.

Do you know a lot of dads that don't know how to communicate like adults? I'm going to use a stronger phrase than just cruel: I think huffing about giving someone the silent treatment and not inviting them to places you'd normally invite them, rather than saying what's bothered you, is emotionally abusive.

NotOnYourNellies · 13/07/2023 08:48

I think the dad embarrassed himself more than his daughter
What a dickhead

Nagado · 13/07/2023 08:46

It’s insane to think that two 21 year olds aren’t going to have sex if they’re sleeping in the same bed, so if the father had such a problem with it under his roof (as he has every right to) then he should have refused to let the bf stay over, or insist one of them slept on the sofa.

Also, it’s quite understandable that he doesn’t want to hear them. But surely a quick ‘this is not something your dad wants to listen to’ would have mortified her enough that she made sure it didn’t happen again? His reaction is a little odd.

I’m assuming you work with the mum? What did she think about his reaction?

Isittimeformynapyet · 13/07/2023 08:45

Maybe the Dad wasn't sleeping soundly because he was hyper vigilant and had his bat ears on for any tiny noise emanating from his daughter's room. She wasn't necessarily swinging from the chandelier.

Peacoffee · 13/07/2023 08:42

You’re a bit over invested in this.
He had a rule, separate room, many parents have this. The DD doesn’t have to live at home at 21 but while she does they don’t want her bf staying in her room. That’s fair enough. She choose to break that rule and the consequence of that is missing a lunch out.
Are people getting pent up because this is about sex? If a 16 year old was told to not go on the PlayStation all night and did anyway and then wasn’t treated to lunch the next day would people be outraged?

pictoosh · 13/07/2023 08:42

Yes it's cruel. It's not a 'normal dad reaction' - it's the action of a controller. You don't punish adults for having sex. Weirdo.

TheBeesKnee · 13/07/2023 08:42

So hang on, he heard some creaking floorboards? Bit of an overreaction.

greenspaces4peace · 13/07/2023 08:40

im confused what’s upsetting who?
not being invited could be viewed as allowing her privacy?
youth having sex at home? Surely by 21 a young person knows how their parents will react.
and it’s perfectly reasonable to plan/consider separate bed rooms.
or get a hotel.

Isittimeformynapyet · 13/07/2023 08:39

If the Dad can't bear the thought of his daughter having sex then he probably won't be able to discuss it reasonably. Some Dads would scream and shout, others like the sulky, silent treatment.

He's not emotionally capable of better, sadly.

Poor girl, being shamed like this.

DamaskRosie · 13/07/2023 08:38

Hmmm, well his house his rules, I guess, but to me having the rule at all for a 21yo is a bit strange and excluding her as a punishment is unkind. I think she needs to accept that this is her dad's position and that he means it, and so if she's not happy she should start planning to move out, which is what I would do in her shoes.