Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cancer is rising exponentially in under 55s?

237 replies

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 07:28

Anecdotes not data, but:

  1. Kidney cancer that’s spread - friend - fit, well, 52, diagnosed after routine check for something else. Spread to other organs, no symptoms
  2. Triathlete colleague, 52 years. Stomach/ bowel cancer, spread. Diagnosed after, a sudden, violent, stomach upset. Stage 4.
  3. Colleague / stage 4 bowel cancer, aged 47, no real symptoms.
Numerous other acquaintances in 50-55 bracket.

Should we have ‘preventative’ MRIs?
To be expected in 50s as old/older?
Does it reflect your experience?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
TheoTheopolis23 · 13/07/2023 11:15

hamstersarse · 13/07/2023 08:04

@Waitingroompurplecup

i fully agree that pesticides have been a silent killer. And I think it’s been known too long and nothing done about it.

Roundup has only recently been banned….a proven carcinogen which people innocently buy in B&Q. God only knows what farmers have been using

I could be wrong but I don't think it's been banned in the UK, just the EU.
It's being considered for another 5 years on the UK, I think.

Readmorebooks · 13/07/2023 11:09

Cancer wasn't rare in people's mother's generations. I've been a doctor for decades and have seen plenty of cancer in younger people over the decades. However, people died more quickly, often without clear confirmed diagnoses as scans were less effective (or non existent. MRIs did not exist in normal hospitals when I started and CT scanners were new) and there was a lot more shame / privacy associated with it.
We are seeing more bowel cancer younger and I'm not that surprised given how little fruit and vegetables so many of our young patients eat. There's a clear link between bowel cancer and diet - although obviously there are always exceptions and plenty of people get it all have great diets as well.
We are seeing a generalised increase but it's certainly not exponential. The majority is still in the elderly. I work in a deprived area so still see plenty of heart disease and COPD killing people but much less than I used to - people have to die of something and it's much more likely nowadays that that will be cancer, just because we're better at curing other things.
But cancer itself has a much higher survival than it used to (most types. There are still really bad ones to get.)
Apart from bowel cancer, I don't think we're seeing a significant increase in most cancers in younger people. I think it's more that people feel more invulnerable than they used to and there's more of a shock value when they're diagnosed.

LobsterCrab · 13/07/2023 11:09

CamCola · 13/07/2023 11:00

I heard a few years ago that if you survive your 50s then you normally go on to live much longer.
50s are the death decade. You either get through them or you don’t.

I don't think this is borne out by the statistics. The chance of dying rises with age. It's higher in your 60s than in your 50s.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1125118/death-rate-united-kingdom-uk-by-age/

UK death rate by age 2021 | Statista

In 2021, the age-specific death rate for males aged 90 or over was 231.6 per one thousand population, and 209.9 for females.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1125118/death-rate-united-kingdom-uk-by-age

CamCola · 13/07/2023 11:00

I heard a few years ago that if you survive your 50s then you normally go on to live much longer.
50s are the death decade. You either get through them or you don’t.

Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 10:55

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 10:40

Fish, which is cleanest and best?

Virtually all of it unless processed into something like fish fingers. Fish are caught from the wild, we don’t rear them for slaughter on a diet of pesticide grass and antibiotics. We eat a portion of salmon every week, meat twice a week (one chicken then usually mince), and 4 veggie days.

orangeleavesinautumn · 13/07/2023 10:52

Tryingmuchharder · 13/07/2023 09:01

@Peverellshire

On MN 'exponentially' is overused.

You use 3 examples to back up your claims.

Data as others have shared don't back up your claims and since testing is much more advanced that it used to be in the past then one would expect more cases.

Context is everything

I agree about the use of the word exponentially - people don't seem to understand what it means. Absolutely not is cancer in this age group rising "exponentially".

The question the OP is asking is "is cancer in this age range rising?".

And the answer to that is probably not, but when the statistics for this time become available, ie, probably next year, then we will have a definite answer, but there is no evidence of it given on this thread.

StellaJohanna · 13/07/2023 10:48

Yes. I've known my neighbour for many years. We were talking about this. He is sort of semi-retired part-time GP but is now working much more as there is a severe shortage where I live. He has noticed a "cancer explosion" of aggressive cancers particularly among younger people in the last 2 years - young, fit and under 50

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 10:40

Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 10:11

Regarding our diets, the ‘what’s for dinner’ threads give a good indication as to the problem. People listing their menus for the week and every single meal centres on meat, usually red meat. Also a lot of sauces and rich ingredients. People don’t want to eat simply and cleanly now, they see it as their right to eat rich meals every evening and balk if you suggest it’s fine to just have scrambled egg on toast, or jacket potato. The public also seem to have gone off fish, which is a shame as it’s very good for you if eaten correctly and a great alternative to red meat.

Fish, which is cleanest and best?

OP posts:
echt · 13/07/2023 10:20

To think cancer is rising exponentially in under 55s?
This is about data, and very specific in its application to significant numbers.

Anecdotes not data, but
This is stuff you know about three people.

So not of any relevance in terms of health care.

Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 10:15

Oh and house cleaning. It’s not enough just to hoover/dust/tidy any more- everyone nukes the shit out of everything with Zoflora and pumps the house full of chemical air fresheners. Hot soapy water is perfectly fine to clean everything bar the toilet, we don’t need to antibac every surface.

Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 10:11

Regarding our diets, the ‘what’s for dinner’ threads give a good indication as to the problem. People listing their menus for the week and every single meal centres on meat, usually red meat. Also a lot of sauces and rich ingredients. People don’t want to eat simply and cleanly now, they see it as their right to eat rich meals every evening and balk if you suggest it’s fine to just have scrambled egg on toast, or jacket potato. The public also seem to have gone off fish, which is a shame as it’s very good for you if eaten correctly and a great alternative to red meat.

sHREDDIES19 · 13/07/2023 09:57

I think the number one contributory factor in increasing cases of cancers is our diets. Processed food is so pervasive in our diets, did I hear that in the UK around 50% of all of our kids food comes from processed sources? This means additives, preservatives, emulsifiers etc, ingredients that our bodies don't know what to do with. It's literally changing our cell structures. We all need to try and get back to basics and start questioning the ingredients list, make more from scratch, eat more simply. Hard I know when everything that is bad for us is so readily available and in lots of cases, quite cheap.

Fixyourself · 13/07/2023 09:44

People need to start taking responsibility for themselves instead of over stretching the Nhs.
Processed meat is a huge carcinogen- we eat so much of it now.
The rise in cancer rates is directly linked to the food people are eating.

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 09:43

Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 09:33

Very low obesity levels in adults (3%)?

Makes sense, and someone said, upthread, there may be a danger from being even nudging into an overweight category. Low dairy too? Dairy not terribly good for us and prob most of us have too much?

OP posts:
Sweetashunni · 13/07/2023 09:33

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 08:26

Japan

There seems to be evidence that cancer rates amongst the middle aged are ‘up’.

Articles say this is NOT happening in Japan.

So if this is correct, what can we learn from the Japanese?

Very low obesity levels in adults (3%)?

Catspyjamas17 · 13/07/2023 09:33

Jigslaw · 13/07/2023 08:58

That's because its a bit of a myth that leading an 'unhealthy' lifestyle is the main cause of cancer. It raises some risk factors and can lessen the chances of treatment being successful, but sadly looking after your body doesn't make you immune.

This has been the trend for a fair amount of years and researchers still can't confidently conclude why. I think there's been interesting points made on this thread, as many are gastro related I suspect food on a societal level has a fair amount of importance. I say on societal level because even if an individual eats a balanced diet the prevelance of chemicals and additives etc are present in so much most people are likely to ingest at least some.

No indeed. I think constant stress is accepted as a big factor though in helping provide the environment for cancerous cells to grow.

Catspyjamas17 · 13/07/2023 09:29

I don't think it is rising exponentially. For me, I am now in my late 40s and aware of several people of my age or younger having cancer, because I am in that age group where it does become a risk. I'm also aware of people having other health scares- heart - my cousin has already had a bypass op in his 50s, DH could have died of sepsis from peritonitis in 2019 age 48 had we not acted quickly, a couple of friends have had gallstones/gall bladder removed. Several friends have had gynaelogical issues/hysterectomy. I've been fast tracked three times, one for cervical cancer (minor pre-cancerous cell changes that were lasered), one for ovarian cancer (it was endometriosis and a large endometrial cyst on my ovary) and more recently for cancer of the oesophagus (it was a hiatus hernia and oesophagitis) and I'm 47, the first scare was when I was in my mid 30s.

It's a bit like noticing white cars when you own a white car. Cancer is bloody shit though. I'm glad I was seen so quickly each time. Also our bodies don't last for ever and used to regularly wear out in our 40s or earlier in ancient times, so we need to try and look after them.

PinkPlantCase · 13/07/2023 09:21

Annual MRIs will probably do more harm than good. When you MRI people you find all sorts of weird things (not cancer) that aren’t actually causing them any harm or impacting their life. I think it would lead to unnecessary treatments.

I really don’t underestimate the impact of UPFs, my DM is in her 50s she thinks she eats well by replacing foods with low fat, low sugar, highly processed alternatives.

And plastics, bloody plastic.

Interesting point from PP too about anal sex becoming more mainstream and HPV. I think we’d know though if anal sex increases incidents of bowel cancer because there’d be a higher rate in gay men.

Either way people my age in their late 20s and younger were vaccinated against HPV so I’m looking forward to seeing a reduction in HPV related cancers.

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 09:21

Tryingmuchharder · 13/07/2023 09:01

@Peverellshire

On MN 'exponentially' is overused.

You use 3 examples to back up your claims.

Data as others have shared don't back up your claims and since testing is much more advanced that it used to be in the past then one would expect more cases.

Context is everything

I agree. I said as per examples, anecdotes not data, just feel for all concerned and it has all been a bit of a shock/sudden. Useful replies and more to read. In the future it will be all about prevention and not cure.

OP posts:
Irequireausername · 13/07/2023 09:16

Take flame retardants for instance, the UK has the strictest laws on having them in everything. You can buy the same product from the UK and the EU and the UK one will have flame retardants and the EU one won't.

Then it leeches into the water supply and inevitably our food.

MsPrism · 13/07/2023 09:08

I believe that there are blood tests that are currently being trialled for cancer detection- if successful will be much easier to access than scans (I would have thought?)

Tryingmuchharder · 13/07/2023 09:01

@Peverellshire

On MN 'exponentially' is overused.

You use 3 examples to back up your claims.

Data as others have shared don't back up your claims and since testing is much more advanced that it used to be in the past then one would expect more cases.

Context is everything

Jigslaw · 13/07/2023 08:58

Greenbirdgreengrass · 13/07/2023 08:42

Oh and all the people I know who died from cancer were active, healthy weight, good diets.

That's because its a bit of a myth that leading an 'unhealthy' lifestyle is the main cause of cancer. It raises some risk factors and can lessen the chances of treatment being successful, but sadly looking after your body doesn't make you immune.

This has been the trend for a fair amount of years and researchers still can't confidently conclude why. I think there's been interesting points made on this thread, as many are gastro related I suspect food on a societal level has a fair amount of importance. I say on societal level because even if an individual eats a balanced diet the prevelance of chemicals and additives etc are present in so much most people are likely to ingest at least some.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 13/07/2023 08:50

MySoCalledWife · 13/07/2023 08:01

This is sad but normal

Late 40s/fifties is when this stuff happens

It's known as "sniper alley", if you make it through your fifties, you have a good chance to live to old age

But 50s is where a LOT of shit happens 😞

Honestly it can be a bit of a shocker

I agree,it's seems that way although I've lost 3 close friends to cancer before 50 and now have another with terminal and another just finished treatment. I have a lot of friends so the chances are higher I suppose but I really do feel om constantly dodging a bullet.

RoseBucket · 13/07/2023 08:50

Excuse my typos, on phone + dyslexic = guess what I’m saying 😬