Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cancer is rising exponentially in under 55s?

237 replies

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 07:28

Anecdotes not data, but:

  1. Kidney cancer that’s spread - friend - fit, well, 52, diagnosed after routine check for something else. Spread to other organs, no symptoms
  2. Triathlete colleague, 52 years. Stomach/ bowel cancer, spread. Diagnosed after, a sudden, violent, stomach upset. Stage 4.
  3. Colleague / stage 4 bowel cancer, aged 47, no real symptoms.
Numerous other acquaintances in 50-55 bracket.

Should we have ‘preventative’ MRIs?
To be expected in 50s as old/older?
Does it reflect your experience?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
1dayatatime · 13/07/2023 07:48

I had a very similar conversation yesterday with a GP friend after work in the rise in cancer cases in younger than expected people.

It seems to be more men than women.
Covid lockdowns played a part as people simply didn't get diagnosed as they avoided or were unable to attend a GP surgery.
A third of cancer diagnosis happens in A&E where people go in complaining of a pain etc and then find out it's cancer. Again during lockdown this didn't happen.
Cancers are being spotted earlier.

So currently there is a bit of a catch up on a backlog of cancers that had already been there and in some cases sadly left too late plus improvements in medical care that are spotting other cancers earlier.

Waitingroompurplecup · 13/07/2023 07:46

I know three people from school who died before the age of 30 of cancer. More than I count on my fingers when it comes to relatives of people from school who all lived in the area. Several brain tumors.
My theory is we were in a rural area and the school was surrounded by farmers fields where they were regularly spraying pesticides.
There was also an incinerator down the road. Built in proximity to a school.

hamstersarse · 13/07/2023 07:43

I agree OP

i know multiple people my age (48) who have it / died quickly.

I was talking to my mum (81) about it, and it definitely used to be a rarity when she was my age.

There’s clearly something about our environment that is causing this.

LobsterCrab · 13/07/2023 07:43

This doesn't reflect my experience personally - I have a friend who had breast cancer in her 40s, but otherwise the cancer sufferers I know have been in their 70s / 80s. I'm 49 btw.

Do you think it's related to lifestyle, diet etc? I guess not, as you say that your friends are fit and healthy?

Sapphire387 · 13/07/2023 07:43

I am sorry to hear about your friends but no, I don't think anecdotal evidence is enough to say that cancer rates are rising.

We have a population that lives longer in general, people no longer die so often of things like infections, various other (now) treatable diseases...

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 07:41

Very sorry to hear about your DH.

How overweight do you mean? Nudging obese or just out of healthy zone?

OP posts:
Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 07:39

Good points @languageat30 but those flagged above are paragons of health as per Dame Deborah James, healthy BMI, fit & well.

These are not unhealthy people. Prob small, unrepresentative sample, BUT IME, a dramatic shift/increase in this demographic.

OP posts:
RebelR · 13/07/2023 07:37

I lost DH and 3 other male friends in their 50s to cancer during Covid. I don't think covid was a cause/connection, just it all seemed to come at once, although I do think DH would have got differnet care without covid restrictions.

They were all fairly active in their 40s, but they were all over weight and had smoked a lot in their youth. 3 were regular social drinkers, probably drinking more than guidelines, but not what much of MN would deem excessive and one had been a big drinker until he gave up alcohol all together in his 40s.

Who really knows what it's all about, but to me it's interesting that all these men had very similar lifestyles and mistreated their bodies some extent despite outwardly being quite healthy in middle age.

Cornettoninja · 13/07/2023 07:37

I think preventative MRIs would be a good idea for those who have a significant family history of cancer (this may already be a thing

Not MRI’s but with a strong family history of particular cancers doctors may put you forward for specific screening tests for those particular cancers. I think there’s an argument for starting bowel cancer screening at a much earlier age than 60 (which I think it is now).

Of course that’s all reliant on a functioning healthcare system.

languageat30 · 13/07/2023 07:34

Peverellshire · 13/07/2023 07:28

Anecdotes not data, but:

  1. Kidney cancer that’s spread - friend - fit, well, 52, diagnosed after routine check for something else. Spread to other organs, no symptoms
  2. Triathlete colleague, 52 years. Stomach/ bowel cancer, spread. Diagnosed after, a sudden, violent, stomach upset. Stage 4.
  3. Colleague / stage 4 bowel cancer, aged 47, no real symptoms.
Numerous other acquaintances in 50-55 bracket.

Should we have ‘preventative’ MRIs?
To be expected in 50s as old/older?
Does it reflect your experience?

I think preventative MRIs would be a good idea for those who have a significant family history of cancer (this may already be a thing), but realistically it's not possible to do full body MRIs on the whole population once they reach a certain age.

Cancer rates are increasing, but then again so are survival rates. Our population is so unhealthy in general that it's bound to be part of the cause. There should be a bigger push for people to eat healthily and exercise.

Wildspace · 13/07/2023 07:33

It definitely feels that way but I would expect it’s because we’re hitting that age when this happens. Especially when you consider that 50% of us will have a cancer at some point.

Cornettoninja · 13/07/2023 07:33

I don’t think cancer is rising exponentially although I believe (off the top of my head) that it is rising due to factors like lifestyle and better detection.

Largely though, I think your experience is likely due to the age groups you mix in. 40’s/50’s is when these things become more common amongst peer groups.

On your last point, no I don’t believe that preventative MRI’s would be a good thing and have the potential to cause more harm than good. I do, however, think that regular checkups/annual health checks would be beneficial to all ages but that’s not really a ‘thing’ in this country.

Swipe left for the next trending thread