Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Update- My boyfriends family member paid for everyone’s ice cream, AIBU for being upset that bf didn’t say anything

166 replies

Redrose28 · 12/07/2023 22:48

Hi all, I recently made a post about an outing with my boyfriend, his sister and her boyfriend, where we all got ice creams and the sisters boyfriend paid for everyone except mine.

I bought it up with my boyfriend calmly. He told me that what happened was: I offered to pay for my boyfriend, and the sisters boyfriend offered a few seconds later as he hadn’t heard me. For some reason, my boyfriend thought I wouldn’t want him to pay for me so didn’t suggest paying for me, and instead accepted the sisters boyfriends suggestion of paying. My boyfriend then defended the sisters boyfriend, saying that he didn’t consider it rude towards me, the sisters boyfriend wanted to pay him back for things my boyfriend has done for him.

That’s quite confusing but hope it makes some sense!

So my boyfriend essentially thought the situation was not rude in any way. I can see his point of view, at the same time not feeling that he understands my point of view in any way doesn’t feel great.

Am I being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Melony75 · 13/07/2023 06:02

While you were queuing, he should have said to him, I owe you some money and given it to your bf.
To buy icecreams for all bar one is deliberately excluding you and rude.
Your bf should have acknowledged this i.e. "mate, you tight arse, you didn't get Redrose one" and could have appoligised or given you his, shared his or offered to buy you one.

It sounds like all these people don't think beyond themselves and you need to decide if you want to he with someone like this.

standardduck · 13/07/2023 05:58

It sounds like a petty misunderstanding. I would let it go, unless there is something else going on in your relationship.

IsThatHuw · 13/07/2023 05:54

TommyNever · 13/07/2023 05:17

Lord save us. 😱

Here, have this one:

Here here!

JoieDeLivres · 13/07/2023 05:52

LittleMonks11 · 12/07/2023 23:00

It's just one Cornetto

😂😂❤❤❤

BeautifulWar · 13/07/2023 05:41

Wow, your life must be pretty plain sailing if this is what bothers you!

MumGMT · 13/07/2023 05:37

@MissedItByThisMuch

Of course it’s not just an ice cream. Are you really all that stupid? It’s an indicator of an attitude that it’s fine to be selfish and ungenerous, to exclude someone, to not consider the feelings of the person you are supposed to care about.

Are you stupid?
It really doesn't sound that deep.
OP's attitude says more about her than any of the other people involved in the situation, at the very least she seems very sensitive.

If you genuinely think someone buying an ice cream - or anything - for 3 out of 4 people in a group and leaving the other one to get their own is simply about the price of an ice cream you lack imagination, insight and empathy to an astounding degree.

Where's your imagination, insight and empathy for the other people in the group?
Perhaps if you could direct some towards them you might be able to see other perspectives, instead of being fixated on just the one perspective?

Kafkaland · 13/07/2023 05:37

Jesus. If this is the biggest problem in your life you are very lucky!

How petty and irrelevant.

MumGMT · 13/07/2023 05:29

YABU

OP there was nothing to defend or nothing to stick up for you for.
No one did anything bad to you.

IncomingTraffic · 13/07/2023 05:28

The fact you’ve started two threads about this suggests that your boyfriend is simply not the man for you.

You’re young. You can move on and find someone who won’t leave you to buy your own ice cream.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/07/2023 05:28

moonrakerr · 13/07/2023 01:53

I've paid for my partner + 1 other person I owed money to before. 2 of our friends were left to pay for themselves, though if it had been just 1 person left, I might have twigged and offered a "treat for all" if it occurred to me / if that 1 person seemed receptive (some people I know are very independent).

It might not have occurred to me though because I hadn't realised there are this many people (OP and others) who obsess pettily

Do you count pennies like Ebenezer Scrooge is that why you wouldn't pay for the others. What a mean spirited way to conduct your life.

Rewis · 13/07/2023 05:26

Is this a pattern or isolated incidence?

Sunnysunbun · 13/07/2023 05:20

Would it help if I bought you an ice-cream?

TommyNever · 13/07/2023 05:17

Lord save us. 😱

Here, have this one:

Update- My boyfriends family member paid for everyone’s ice cream, AIBU for being upset that bf didn’t say anything
Seddon · 13/07/2023 03:33

You have 2 choices here OP:

Write it off as a misunderstanding, he wasn't thinking straight, etc and move on with your life and enjoy your relationship.

Or

Decide you aren't really happy in the relationship and this is a 'tip of the iceberg' situation, and leave.

Mothership4two · 13/07/2023 03:14

Stupidy Stupidy Stupidy here.

There was a bit of a misunderstanding, slight awkwardness, BF can understand what happened and doesn't seem to think it's that big of a deal probably because it's just one bloody ice cream. Two threads later and a lot of obsessing OP has made her point and he has made his. It is not that important! Trying to twist this into some kind of major character flaw on his part is just silly. Maybe she should LTB?

You see some gut wrenching posts on MN at times but this is not one of them.

Yes at the end of the day it is JUST about an ice cream

Rosietheravisher · 13/07/2023 02:41

It makes sense to me. Listen carefully peoples:

  1. The boyfriend's sister's boyfriend owed the boyfriend so bought the boyfriend an ice cream.
  2. The boyfriend's sister's boyfriend bought his girlfriend an icecream because boyfriend's like to buy their girlfriend's ice cream.
  3. However OP's boyfriend is a feminist and thought that his girlfriend would consider it demeaning for her boyfriend to offer to buy her an ice cream when she is an independent woman with means of her own. 4)Everybody got bought an ice cream except OP.
CrazyArmadilloLady · 13/07/2023 02:40

Why didn’t you just update the existing thread.

YABU for that alone.

aviatorsrus · 13/07/2023 02:39

OP if you really felt that left out you could and should have said something. Why do you need your boyfriend to defend you?
Sometimes people do things without thinking
I didn't read your previous post but sometimes you need to speak up for yourself at the time, which is more important than ruminating about it later

moonrakerr · 13/07/2023 02:36

On a sidenote, I honestly think if the genders were reversed people would be like "get a grip, you can't pay for a single ice cream cone for yourself?" (which fyi I don't think is a valid response either)

moonrakerr · 13/07/2023 02:35

@Oceanus Exclusion is bad yes, but I think buying/paying for things as a group is usually a bit of a messy affair (and even in OP's post some people didn't hear each other). I would chalk it up to accidental/thoughtless exclusion during slightly messy circumstances, and honestly stop obsessing over it.

The sister likely didn't even realise - when people treat me to things, I don't watch them paying like a hawk because it's rude! And the two bfs – again I have paid for specific people due to circumstances, and I have also been the only one to pay my own way (in my 20s, some of my friends were a bit hopeless - always skint) and didn't mind at all.

I can see how getting the bill for only some after a restaurant meal might be exclusionary, but if it's just an ice cream/coffee/etc, it's bound to be a bit of a messy affair. Why obsess?

MmaRra · 13/07/2023 02:33

Let it go!
Frozen?

GreyGoose1980 · 13/07/2023 02:32

MissedItByThisMuch · 13/07/2023 00:42

God this place is unpleasant sometimes. All those people finding this thread unnecessary and tedious apparently found it necessary to open the thread and comment. 🙄

Of course it’s not just an ice cream. Are you really all that stupid? It’s an indicator of an attitude that it’s fine to be selfish and ungenerous, to exclude someone, to not consider the feelings of the person you are supposed to care about.

OP I don’t think his explanation makes it any better. Id think about whether this is a pattern or genuinely a one off and proceed accordingly.

This

Oceanus · 13/07/2023 01:54

Exclusion is bad, no matter what shape it presents itself in. If the whole group had agreed on a free trip to the park in front of the OP but without inviting her wouldn't it would hurt the same?
The boyfriend said nothing, the sister said nothing and, well, the other guy was the catalyst for the whole thing. Would I want to be a part of this family...? Hmmm, well I don't feel much love there. If I were the sister I'd be saying "you buy my DB an ice cream and I'll get hers", if I were the boyfriend I'd have said "Thanks but no thanks, my girlfriend's buying my ice cream because it'll taste better coming from her. Or I'll buy her one instead". Nobody said a word.
One person thought it was fine to only buy for two and two thought it was fine to get theirs for free as the other girl's won't be a part of the family in the future so "I'll hold on to my money now and save it for the one he'll actually marry or that I actually like".
In the grand scheme of things it's insignificant but is this guy/family worth the investment? Because that "investment" could end up being pricier than a cornetto couldn't it? I think that's why the OP's tossing and turning over this.

moonrakerr · 13/07/2023 01:53

I've paid for my partner + 1 other person I owed money to before. 2 of our friends were left to pay for themselves, though if it had been just 1 person left, I might have twigged and offered a "treat for all" if it occurred to me / if that 1 person seemed receptive (some people I know are very independent).

It might not have occurred to me though because I hadn't realised there are this many people (OP and others) who obsess pettily

Mothership4two · 13/07/2023 01:32

⛈☕🍦

To leave one person out is just rude but it is a fairly insignificant event in a lifetime