Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Update- My boyfriends family member paid for everyone’s ice cream, AIBU for being upset that bf didn’t say anything

166 replies

Redrose28 · 12/07/2023 22:48

Hi all, I recently made a post about an outing with my boyfriend, his sister and her boyfriend, where we all got ice creams and the sisters boyfriend paid for everyone except mine.

I bought it up with my boyfriend calmly. He told me that what happened was: I offered to pay for my boyfriend, and the sisters boyfriend offered a few seconds later as he hadn’t heard me. For some reason, my boyfriend thought I wouldn’t want him to pay for me so didn’t suggest paying for me, and instead accepted the sisters boyfriends suggestion of paying. My boyfriend then defended the sisters boyfriend, saying that he didn’t consider it rude towards me, the sisters boyfriend wanted to pay him back for things my boyfriend has done for him.

That’s quite confusing but hope it makes some sense!

So my boyfriend essentially thought the situation was not rude in any way. I can see his point of view, at the same time not feeling that he understands my point of view in any way doesn’t feel great.

Am I being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 13/07/2023 07:38

Jesus, let it go.
Can’t believe you started a second thread about an ice cream situation

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/07/2023 07:34

IncomingTraffic · 13/07/2023 06:17

I’m not sure there are only two types in this thread.

I’m in the ‘two threads about buying ice cream; this is just not the relationship for you’ camp.

I’m not sure I care much about the ethical dilemma here at all. But if someone is this upset about something like this, then I think it’s a sign that the relationship isn’t right for them.

The OP is early 20s. Deciding to end a relationship because you are bothered because your boyfriend leaves you to pay for your own ice cream and then tries to convince you he’s more feminist than you is fine.

I think you could be right. I especially don’t like the I’m more feminist than you explanation. I know it’s only an ice cream but I’d be having my wits about me if I continued this relationship.

Ladybug14 · 13/07/2023 07:29

Your boyfriend can't or won't see your pov and isn't sympathetic or understanding about how you feel

I wouldn't want to date someone like this

You deserve someone who is kinder

I'd get rid

7eleven · 13/07/2023 07:28

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 13/07/2023 07:18

Nah, people who are sad enough to come on sites like this to be pricks deserve it. This is a place where people reach out for advice/help, can't cope with the saddos. They need to fix their loneliness (it's ALWAYS loneliness), not take it out on OP's.

Oh dear. Resorting to personal attacks again.

Lollipopsicle · 13/07/2023 07:22

I can't believe you're still banging on about this OP. It's a bloody ice cream. Get a grip and stop whingeing.

princessconsuelabananahammock91 · 13/07/2023 07:20

You've made two posts about someone not paying for your ice-cream? You've such a tough life.

MissedItByThisMuch · 13/07/2023 07:18

TommyNever · 13/07/2023 06:54

Nah, there are always more than two types of people. 😄

In fact the people who insist there are two types of people tend to be the ones lacking insight and empathy.

I see this ice cream purchase problem as trivial because I'm a mature adult and I realise the people involved in the OP are probably quite young, and still not free of the petty dramas of juvenile rivalry.

A humorous eye-rolling response is the best way to restore cheerful perspective in these situations, as I'm sure the OP will agree when looking back on this stormy teacup a year or two down the track.

😂 Um I’m perfectly well aware there are actually more than two types of people, it’s a rhetorical device. But ok.

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 13/07/2023 07:18

7eleven · 13/07/2023 07:03

It is quite ironic that the people who think the boyfriend/s behaviour was grossly rude are the ones being rude on this thread.

‘fuckers’ ‘thick’ ‘(not) normal’.

Not exactly smashing ways of putting forward your point of view.

Nah, people who are sad enough to come on sites like this to be pricks deserve it. This is a place where people reach out for advice/help, can't cope with the saddos. They need to fix their loneliness (it's ALWAYS loneliness), not take it out on OP's.

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 13/07/2023 07:14

You know, its interesting how we are told to trust our instincts, see red flags for what they are, yet on this thread posters are actively telling OP that her feelings don't matter, it's not a big deal etc. Her gut is telling her something. I mean, I know posters just want someone to take out their own sad lives on, but perhaps they could try and look beyond their need to be arseholes? No? Thought not 😁 some sad bastards around.
OP, he won't have your back. It was weird of his sisters boyfriend to exclude you and the fact he couldn't say, er what about Redrose28? says alot. He wouldn't be for me.

slashlover · 13/07/2023 07:04

"Thanks but no thanks, my girlfriend's buying my ice cream because it'll taste better coming from her.

WTF?

as the other girl's won't be a part of the family in the future so "I'll hold on to my money now and save it for the one he'll actually marry or that I actually like".

This part confuses me. Are you saying that the sister's boyfriend didn't buy the ice cream as OPs BF is planning on dumping her?

OP, what do you mean by defending you? Asking for him to buy an ice cream too? Confronting him on why he didn't buy you one?

7eleven · 13/07/2023 07:03

It is quite ironic that the people who think the boyfriend/s behaviour was grossly rude are the ones being rude on this thread.

‘fuckers’ ‘thick’ ‘(not) normal’.

Not exactly smashing ways of putting forward your point of view.

swimsong · 13/07/2023 07:01

It's kinda flaky but not worth a meltdown.

TommyNever · 13/07/2023 06:54

MissedItByThisMuch · 13/07/2023 06:11

There appear to be two types of people on this thread, and presumably in life, those who think it’s mean, thoughtless and ungenerous to make someone feel bad by excluding them from something (yes, even something as seemingly insignificant as buying ice creams), and those who swan through life thinking only about themselves and seeing only their own perspective however petty, unkind and mean spirited that makes them behave towards others.

@MumGMT why do I need to direct insight and empathy to the others in the group? What “injury” has been done to them? If the sister’s bf couldn’t afford an ice cream for the OP he should have just bought his and his girlfriend’s.

Sure this isn’t an earth-shattering issue as quite a few people have nastily pointed out to OP, but this is a chat site ffs. People are allowed to post about minor things in their life that they’re just a little concerned about.

Nah, there are always more than two types of people. 😄

In fact the people who insist there are two types of people tend to be the ones lacking insight and empathy.

I see this ice cream purchase problem as trivial because I'm a mature adult and I realise the people involved in the OP are probably quite young, and still not free of the petty dramas of juvenile rivalry.

A humorous eye-rolling response is the best way to restore cheerful perspective in these situations, as I'm sure the OP will agree when looking back on this stormy teacup a year or two down the track.

Nagado · 13/07/2023 06:47

I think it was pretty thoughtless of the sister’s BF but I’d let that go on the grounds that young men aren’t always known for their comprehensive thinking. I really don’t think that there was any malice in it. Your BF, however, seems to have shocked you with his lack of consideration for you. And I’m with you on that. I wouldn’t leave my DH out like that and I wouldn’t expect him to do it to me. Him doubling down on his thoughtlessness when you’ve spoken to him just makes him sound like a bit of a twat. Be honest with yourself, is this a one off or a pattern of behaviour? You’re young. Too young to be tying yourself down to anyone who makes you question yourself or lower your bar for how you expect to be treated.

Also, if there’s a next time (which I suspect there might be), I’d post on the Relationships board instead of AIBU. You’ll get some brilliant, if blunt, insights on here, but there are also some right fuckers on here too.

bellac11 · 13/07/2023 06:43

Mrstwiddle · 13/07/2023 00:57

Op, ignore comments about it just being an ice cream. That's not what you're upset about it which is quite obvious to most people.

This does not reflect well on your boyfriend at all, why wouldn't he think that you'd be upset at being left out? any normal person would. He should have offered to pay for you or raised it at the time with the other guy, is he generous with money generally? I'm going to guess not.

Or perhaps any normal person expects that OP has some degree of ability to understand what is a misunderstanding or that her feelings are out of proportion to what happened

Perhaps he is also considering whether to continue the relationship with someone so dramatic?

Beautiful3 · 13/07/2023 06:39

But its just icecream. I wouldn't talk about it anymore and forget it. Unless it keeps happening. Then it would piss me off.

Beautiful3 · 13/07/2023 06:38

Why would he think that, you wouldn't want to have an icecream bought for you. That's kinda worse, he actually thought it better to buy your own. It's worse because they had a discussion about buying icecream, it wasn't an awkward suprise. He just thought yeah he owes me annicecre, my girlfriend can buy her own! I understand that the sisters boyfriend wanted to buy him one, because he owed him one, but you don't leave out one person. Think this update makes it worse.

7eleven · 13/07/2023 06:37

It does sound like an awkward situation, but it’s an extreme response to feel that your boyfriend didn’t ‘defend’ you. Defend you against what?

It is possible for things to be less than ideal and it not be the end of the world. Seems like you’ve gone 0-60 quickly.

Do you find yourself this bothered by pretty trivial things often? It’s odd that the sister’s boyfriend did this, I agree, but if you let things like this bother you this much, you’re going to be upset a lot throughout your life.

Tubs11 · 13/07/2023 06:27

Is it bothering you because he has form for this type of behaviour?

If it's only this one incident and you otherwise feel secure and loved in your relationship then I would let this one incident go.

I totally understand why this is bothering you. You're meant to be a team and on this occasion you weren't, it's nothing to do with feminism and more to do with love and security

MuthaHubbard · 13/07/2023 06:19

LittleMonks11 · 12/07/2023 23:00

It's just one Cornetto

👋todays internet winner 🏆

Bliss1221 · 13/07/2023 06:18

If you wanted someone to buy you an ice cream your boyfriend should have bought his own and for you too.

what kind if guy needs another guy to buy him an ice cream and lets his gf sort herself out lol

seriously,are you all 14?

babysharkdoodoodedoodedoo · 13/07/2023 06:17

You didn’t really need defending? The explanation your boyfriend gave was clear. Was a bit odd of sisters boyfriend but no big deal and not meant maliciously. Let it go.

IncomingTraffic · 13/07/2023 06:17

I’m not sure there are only two types in this thread.

I’m in the ‘two threads about buying ice cream; this is just not the relationship for you’ camp.

I’m not sure I care much about the ethical dilemma here at all. But if someone is this upset about something like this, then I think it’s a sign that the relationship isn’t right for them.

The OP is early 20s. Deciding to end a relationship because you are bothered because your boyfriend leaves you to pay for your own ice cream and then tries to convince you he’s more feminist than you is fine.

MissedItByThisMuch · 13/07/2023 06:11

There appear to be two types of people on this thread, and presumably in life, those who think it’s mean, thoughtless and ungenerous to make someone feel bad by excluding them from something (yes, even something as seemingly insignificant as buying ice creams), and those who swan through life thinking only about themselves and seeing only their own perspective however petty, unkind and mean spirited that makes them behave towards others.

@MumGMT why do I need to direct insight and empathy to the others in the group? What “injury” has been done to them? If the sister’s bf couldn’t afford an ice cream for the OP he should have just bought his and his girlfriend’s.

Sure this isn’t an earth-shattering issue as quite a few people have nastily pointed out to OP, but this is a chat site ffs. People are allowed to post about minor things in their life that they’re just a little concerned about.

Kimchikitchen · 13/07/2023 06:10

LittleMonks11 · 12/07/2023 23:00

It's just one Cornetto

Give it to me