Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Whose fault was/is this (if anyone's)?

254 replies

familieseh · 12/07/2023 22:21

Family member 1 (host) has a huge garden and hosts gatherings often over summer.

A BBQ has been pending for a while, involving host's family, extended family and friends and neighbours. The purpose of the BBQ is to celebrate two family member's birthdays that are close together.

When first discussed about two months ago, it proved hard to find a date where both birthday family members were available. Also host had a dilemma as to whether to have it on a Saturday or Sunday-given a lot of people have busy Saturdays over Summer, but people work on Mondays and may not want long drives/booze etc.

One of the birthday family members is in a LDR and only sees their DP some weekends, DP always leaves on a Sunday morning as they work on the Monday-it is difficult for them to get Mondays off at this time of year. Host is very aware of this, but it wasn't discussed specifically while making arrangements.

Last time the DP visited everyone was trying to figure out what weekend would be best and decided on this weekend. This was around a month ago.

In the meantime birthday family member's friend asked if they could spend some time with them the Saturday of this weekend-birthday family member mentioned the BBQ and said they were welcome to come to it (which they knew they would be) and mentioned to host who said yes that's fine but then later on, they said to birthday family member 'You do know It's on the Sunday, not the Saturday?'

Birthday family member hadn't known this and is now upset as their DP cannot be at their birthday gathering with them. Their DP is upset because they were looking forward to coming.

Host has said birthday family member should not have assumed it'd be on the Saturday. They've also given their (valid) reasons why the Sunday would be better, and said they discussed it at length with other family members. It had not been specifically mentioned at any point to birthday family member however, despite these discussions, which has riled them somewhat.

Birthday member accepts that they assumed and shouldn't have but feels that host should have specifically mentioned about it being on a Sunday, and should also have perhaps been mindful that birthday member's DP cannot 'do' Sundays when making the decision.

Other info-host reckons they mentioned the date (not day) to both the DP and birthday member. Neither remember this conversation and also have said that this would have been weeks ago and they mightn't' have been mindful to look up whether this was a Sat or a Sun.

Host is upset as birthday member is disappointed and upset and has said they won't attend for the whole day-they were expecting a nice day with their DP and they often have to attend events alone due to LDR and this was going to be a nice day for them, now It's just 'meh'. They're not especially close to anyone else there other than host, and there's a huge age gap with all guests and them too.

Their DP was meant to be doing some of the cooking to give host a break to speak to their friends-which is a small issue.

So was birthday member wrong to assume and should have asked? Was host wrong to assume birthday member knew the day? Should they have specified and/or thought 'hang on, the DP isn't free on Sundays? Should birthday member have made this clearer? All of the above?😂

This is long but I still feel I haven't included all info...I'll answer anything required though!

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 13/07/2023 16:22

familieseh · 12/07/2023 23:31

@Harrysutton about three hours. I wonder if that's a bugbear too

Wait, the DP's drive home is only three hours?! And they cannot ONCE make an exception and stay all day on a Sunday and drive home in the evening? Not just one time, for their partner's birthday? How much time does a grown adult need to prepare for work the next day? This is the thing I'd be pissed off about if I were you, not the fact that there was some mild confusion over dates.

PowerBMI · 13/07/2023 16:19

familieseh · 13/07/2023 09:12

I'll respond properly later but to answer some questions DP isn't a big drinker, its not that. They won't be flexible about Sundays. They're upset they wanted to spend all day there. The BBQ was arranged with two people's birthdays in mind I have already specified that AL for the DP isn't an option IMO it is very different to those saying 'well my DP/DH works away no big deal I'd go on my own-LDR and not getting much time together and not for events often makes it different to that.The other birthday person wasn't bothered which day it was on Birthday person is close to the host and obviously their DP but not anyone else attending so they've mentioned that they'll feel a bit of a spare part. This was also the case for them last year.

The Dp is a choosing to not be there. So they are upsetting themselves. They could, just be more flexible.

and your Op did it would be difficult to get AL. Not that it wasn’t an option.

ManateeFair · 13/07/2023 16:16

After ploughing through all of this, I've come to the conclusion that everyone involved is unreasonable and you all sound like utterly exhausting people. Why are you all so incapable of just communicating?

Why can't you just make your own birthday arrangements instead of having to rely on someone else to host huge BBQ with the host's friends and neighbours? Why would you want someone else's mates and neighbours at your birthday celebration? Why not just have a BBQ and stop shoehorning birthdays into it?

Just how long-distance is the relationship between birthday guest and their DP if they can't stretch out a Sunday until, say, late afternoon before driving home? Unless it's 12-hour journey or something, can't they just make an exception for their partner's birthday? If DP and I have to be with family on a Sunday, we'd probably leave about 6-7pm and be home at 10-11pm in order to be up for work on Monday.

Anyway. I don't really understand why the pair of you just didn't have a conversation like this:

'I'd like to have a BBQ to celebrate your birthday and X's birthday. How about the weekend of the 29/30th?'
'That would be great - if my birthday's going to be a part of it, though, it would need to be the Saturday because I'd like DP to be there and they can't stay for Sunday.'
'OK - what if the other birthday guest can't do Saturday, though?'
'If it's a problem, just crack on and I'll do something with DP on Saturday for my birthday instead - don't feel you have to host my birthday, though, it can just be for other birthday guest and I can arrange something else for mine.'
'OK, I'll check with other birthday guest and see what works best for most of the other guests and I'll come back and let you know if it's going to be the Saturday or the Sunday.'
'Great - if it's the Saturday DP will help with the cooking, so let me know.'

BadNomad · 13/07/2023 16:15

It's stupid to arrange a birthday gathering for someone without checking if the date suits.

Birthday girl and BF need to grow up. They can do something special together on the Saturday. Her feeling "meh" and him not bothering to visit at all just makes them look petty.

Whitewolf2 · 13/07/2023 16:13

Host should have communicated the date first to the people the party is to celebrate the of birthday to check with them and confirm - before telling all the other family members. Surely the birthday guests are most important and then everyone can make plans accordingly. It would be different if it was just a family bbq.

MCOut · 13/07/2023 16:03

Everyone is ridiculous here.

Host - Made a mistake when planning and didn’t communicate the date properly. These things happen and there was no need to get defensive and shift blame.

Birthday Person - Is being dramatic. What’s done is done, the date can’t be changed so they can just go without the DP if they’re willing to accept the DPs inflexibility.

DP - is perfectly able to attend and should be willing to do so for their partner, as a one off. They don’t need to take annual leave, they can just leave at 6 and be back by 9.

ClaraLane · 13/07/2023 16:02

DP isn’t a very good partner. It’s a 3 hour drive not a 12 hour plane ride. Why are they so rigid about having to leave in the AM? I agree with a PP who said that BBQ host may have purposefully arranged it for the Sunday to create discourse about DP always being so inflexible and making birthday person realise how low they are on said “partner’s” priority list.

CovertImage · 13/07/2023 15:56

It seems like the OP is the ‘birthday person’ based on the quantity of knowledge around that person and their ‘DP’.

Yes and the "DP not BF" response to someone

RobertsRadio · 13/07/2023 15:53

You've said the host asked the long distance DP of the birthday guest if they would help with the cooking, despite the host knowing that the DP always leaves Sunday mornings. When the host asked this and the DP agreed to help, did it not occur to the Host to say "you do know the barbecue is on Sunday, are you able to stay the whole day/did you manage to get Monday off.".

The fact that this didn't prompt the host to check with the DP he was definitely free all day Sunday and he also got the days mixed up for his neighbour's party is making me wonder if this is totally his fault and he just forgot or got confused about the day,

The host should have made sure both of the birthday guests knew exactly which day the barbecue was on, especially as it's so important to the one with the LD DP. Do you think it's possible the host has got some sort of cognitive decline?

JulieHoney · 13/07/2023 15:51

Host is kindly hosting a BBQ for a large group of extended friends and family. Getting an agreed date will have been like herding cats.

Host told birthday1 the weekend and day, told Birthday2 the weekend and the date but didn't specify the day. Host assumed BD2 would know date was a Sunday, BD2 assumed host would plan party for a Saturday. Minor miscommunication on both parts (but I would totally have checked my calendar so sympathise with host)

Birthday2 is sulking because totally inflexible DP - who only has a 3 hour drive - insists on leaving Sunday morning.

Either Birthday2 goes to the BBQ (and presumably sees friends and family) or she stays at home on her own and the BBQ goes on without her. It's a shame, but it's not the host's fault.

Viviennemary · 13/07/2023 15:50

Of course the host should have checked woth the two birthday folk if the date was suitable for them. If there are a lot of people attending there will probably be some who can't make it.

Silvered · 13/07/2023 15:49

It's only a 3 hour drive - what's the big deal? If the BBQ starts early they can spend most of the day there. Leave at 5pm and be home before 9. Sounds like a huge storm in a teacup.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 13/07/2023 15:44

catherinewales · 12/07/2023 22:35

If the host knew they can't do Sundays then the host is in the wrong. If they wanted the DP to do some cooking they should have arranged it for the Saturday. Also if I knew the host, knew I couldn't do Sunday and when they told me a date I'd have presumed it was the Saturday.

This.
And the host could have solved the whole problem at the outset by emailing the Birthday person with the proposed time and date. The birthday person could have checked. But saying don't assume, whilst true, it is not that nice really.

Its become such a drama. Trying to please two birthday people. But really no point organising it for a day that one of them can't do.

saraclara · 13/07/2023 15:40

They won't be flexible about Sundays. They're upset they wanted to spend all day there.

You have a problem with your somewhat pathetic partner, not the relative who's kindly hosted this thing. Yes there's been a communication error, but none of that would matter if your partner wasn't so unneccessarily inflexible. He could have the enjoyable time that he wants, if he wasn't so wussy about a three hour drive afterwards.

saraclara · 13/07/2023 15:37

I've totally changed my mind on this sonce learning that the DP would only have a three hour drive home!

My inlaws lived three hours away from us. We'd visit them for a weekend at least every six weeks, and leave on Sunday evening. Even with little kids! Its's nothing.

When I was still working and my MIL was in a care home, I'd drive there and back in a day every third or fourth Sunday. So a six hour drive and in my 60s!

7eleven · 13/07/2023 15:27

Sorry if I’ve missed this, but can’t it just be moved to the Saturday?

C152 · 13/07/2023 15:19

Well this is just poor initial communication all round. The host should have specifically told the birthday member the day and date and asked whether Sunday was convenient. When the host didn't do this, the birthday member should have asked for clarification when they were first discussing this specific weekend.

However, the host is being very unreasonable to organise this on a Sunday given that:

  • the purpose of the BBQ was to celebrate two birthdays
  • they knew that 1 of the birthday guests has a partner who always leaves on Sunday morning, due to work committments
  • they expected the birthday guest's partner to help with the cooking, despite knowing they wouldn't be able to attend on Sunday
Seeingadistance · 13/07/2023 15:07

SideWonder · 12/07/2023 22:42

In fact, if I were the birthday person my first response would be not to attend the BBQ but spend my birthday day with my partner.

This.

Madamecholetsbonnet · 13/07/2023 15:04

I don’t understand why this is such a big deal.

Birthday person can attend their family BBQ. Their DP might not be able to. So what?

tattygrl · 13/07/2023 15:03

pikkumyy77 · 13/07/2023 15:00

Its so funny that people keep complaining about the birthday person and dp and asserting they “want to be the star” and are “not important “ and “ not the center of things” and that the host is “so generous “ to be “doing this for them.”

Is it generous to give birthday person the gift of a party they can’t enjoy because someone important to them can’t attend? Is it generous to arrange it on a day that is inconvenient to them? Its like throwing a meat party for a vegetarian—if its for me it should include something I like.

This! As if generosity (or rather, doing a lot) in and of itself mitigates everything else. It's very misplaced without ascertaining that all the arrangements are convenient for the recipient of the "generosity".

Begonne · 13/07/2023 15:00

What would birthday member like host to do? Cancel the party? Change to the Saturday even though all the other guests are expecting it on Sunday and may not be able to make it?

Mistakes happen. The choice is to respond with petulance or grace regardless.

Sometimes people handle these conversations badly and try to deflect or apportion blame. The choice is still to respond with petulance or grace.

The strength of a relationship lies in how we treat each other in difficult moments.

pikkumyy77 · 13/07/2023 15:00

Its so funny that people keep complaining about the birthday person and dp and asserting they “want to be the star” and are “not important “ and “ not the center of things” and that the host is “so generous “ to be “doing this for them.”

Is it generous to give birthday person the gift of a party they can’t enjoy because someone important to them can’t attend? Is it generous to arrange it on a day that is inconvenient to them? Its like throwing a meat party for a vegetarian—if its for me it should include something I like.

Twillow · 13/07/2023 14:44

Are you the birthday person? Or the host? Why all this cloak and dagger?

My initial reaction is it's all a bit of a storm in a teacup.
a) If host is being generous etc why hold it against them if the saturday is more suitable for the majority, as I think you said.
b)Why is the DP being so awkward and inflexible? And why can't the birthday person have their own celebrations with the DP on the saturday and still go to the party, don't they like going anywhere on their own or something - though I think you said DP would go for part anyway?

I think the birthday person - sorry if that's you OP - is being a bit of a drama queen about this.

mrsm43s · 13/07/2023 14:42

N27 · 13/07/2023 14:34

It sounds like the debate of saturday v Sunday has been going on since the very beginning so why didn’t birthday put a stop to that straight away and say sorry Sundays don’t work for us

But it was a gathering involving host's family, extended family and friends and neighbours, and there are two birthday guests. Why should the entire party be arranged to the inconvenience to many others to accommodate one birthday guest's partner preference to not be flexible.

The birthday person's partner is:
a) not the star of the show that everything should revolve around,
b) not the only person who will have other commitments and preferences,
and
c) able to come anyway, but is refusing to do so because they don't want to be flexible, hence showing a huge lack of consideration for their partner.

BONKERS.

tattygrl · 13/07/2023 14:37

I find it very bizarre to arrange a party for someone and not absolutely triple check that the date works for that person. That's kind of all there is to it for me. All this back and forth about "you shouldn't have assumed" blah blah, well, if you're going to go to all this trouble, which, yes, is generous, make sure that the person of honour can attend! The host is generous, but ultimately has been careless.