Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There should be more partial-private options in health and education

186 replies

Middlelanehogger · 12/07/2023 21:28

People often say that for social mobility reasons we should abolish private schools or private hospitals as it's unfair that there's "one system for the rich, one for the poor".

However I think this thinking is backward. We should encourage more gradual step-ups that enable people to slowly inject more of their own personal money into the system as they move up the income ladder and become able to do so.

For example, currently I have the choice to go to my underfunded, busy NHS GP, or a completely private GP and pay the full costs. Likewise I could send my kids to state school or go completely private.

Great if you can afford the "completely private" option.

But there isn't an intermediate option. In Australia for example, you get a govt rebate of say $30 for every GP appt. This covers a basic GP, or you could apply it towards a more expensive GP with a nicer waiting room or late operating hours etc that costs say $50 (i.e. you only pay the $20 difference, vs $0 in the free option).

In the UK you either pay £0 or £50. There's no £20 option.

In the Australian system, the health system overall gets an extra $20 that wasn't there before (from the extra top-up), and more people are able to access the nicer services (because more people can afford $20 than $50).

There's a similar argument to be made for private education. Why can you not "move" your state school funding to a private school to offset the costs? It would allow a smoother mixing along income levels instead of the harsh cutoff/separation we have today.

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 13/07/2023 18:49

I think they're saying that the poorest in society don't need their lives or health to be any worse than they are currently
That is what I'm saying.

The current system already has a lot of options for parents topping up with things they can fund (eg catchment areas, private music lessons, enrichment opportunities, paying for sports coaching, private tutors).

There's also already the option for paying for independent schools, which whilst are out of many of our budgets, some aren't any more expensive per month than childcare for under 2s depending on school and area.

Any system that's deliberately designed to create an underclass and ensure generations are trapped in poverty as public services are shredded isn't a system I'd want.

Yellowlegobrick · 13/07/2023 18:48

No because you end up with a tiered system where those who can afford to pay get a decent fit for purpose service, and the poor get something crap but have no choice.

Wealthier people tend to have more power to make change, and their desire to improve public services benefits poorer people who have no choice.

Also we need wealthier people paying into a public system that subsidises people too poor to fund their own. If people start going privately they tend to start wanting lower taxes and the whole point of taxation to redistribute wealth/benefit is gone.

Mythoughtextract · 13/07/2023 17:50

More options for op but fewer options for most people. Also means your money is going on slightly better health care rather than something you are really interested in.

Augend23 · 13/07/2023 17:43

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 17:34

@LolaSmiles are you saying we shouldn't have any steps at all in case some people fall down the ladder?

I think they're saying that the poorest in society don't need their lives or health to be any worse than they are currently.

It's not a poor child's fault that they are brought up in deprivation, and if they are unable to access decent healthcare you end up with a really unhealthy bottom chunk of the population. The poor health of the population when we needed to conscript them for WWs 1 and 2 was what resulted in minimum housing standards coming in (WW1) and in the NHS (WW2).

Obviously that's a big oversimplification but I 100% think we shouldn't be making healthcare any worse for the worst off in society.

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 17:34

@LolaSmiles are you saying we shouldn't have any steps at all in case some people fall down the ladder?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 13/07/2023 16:46

From a social mobility perspective, it gives people more options to move up the ladder. Social mobility usually doesn't happen in leaps - it happens in steps, over time
But social mobility doesn't just mean there's steps up, though that's how we often think of it.

Just like you can have marginal gains and marginal losses, in your system there's steps up and steps down.

Over time the steps down add up and the children/families who already are feeling the effects of 10+ years of austerity, intergenerational poverty, intergenerational poor education outcomes etc are likely to find themselves even more limited as the quality of education declines. The next generation of parents with lower outcomes are even less able to get good jobs, even less likely to promote literacy at home and then there's a whole class of society who are basically groomed to be at the bottom as an underclass. This underclass are therefore likely to have fewer options, less money, less influence, are more likely to be in precarious employment, more likely to have long term health conditions, destined to be trapped in poor quality housing, and don't have the means to challenge their situation or fight for basic rights and so on.

I might be deeply deeply cynical but it concerns me because there's some people in power who would probably salivate at the idea of keeping a proportion of the country in poverty, desperate, with limited options and no choice to accept terrible working conditions.

Middlelanehogger · 13/07/2023 15:43

I agree it would widen the gap between the absolute highest and lowest levels of service.

However, for the average person, this is irrelevant from a social mobility perspective. What matters is how many jumps up the ladder are actually available to you personally.

Let's say today there are two levels of service. On a scale of 1-10, 10 being best. Today you have the option of getting "level 3" service for free, or "level 8" service for ££££.

A govt voucher system opens up the possibility of people getting levels 4-7 service for £-£££.

Yes, it also offers the ability for super-premium services to offer up to level 10 service. And there's the chance that without pressure from normal middle-income people, standards for the absolute poorest who are less able to advocate for themselves will drop to level 1 service. So the range is now 1-10 instead of 3-8.

But now it's the full range from 1-10 and not just "3" or "8".

From a social mobility perspective, it gives people more options to move up the ladder. Social mobility usually doesn't happen in leaps - it happens in steps, over time.

It's worth noting that for schools, people already try to get "level 4-7" service by buying houses in catchments for good/outstanding state schools. People will always try to get better service if they can. Why should we not acknowledge this instead of ideologically sticking to some theoretical idea of absolute equality that doesn't exist in the real world?

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 13/07/2023 14:35

Other countries do do this and it can be a way to get more money into a system

I haven’t thought about it much but on the face of it could be a good way to go

I prefer it to withdrawing people from private - as for education plans - in a bid to get support

cloudsintheceiling · 13/07/2023 14:27

Completely agree with everyone saying it would widen inequality for many reasons.

Also, "choice" only really works in areas with enough people to make that an option. My large, rural, county has 5 secondary schools (all state). If my kids didn't go to the nearest, the next nearest is about 40 minutes drive (longer on public transport) away. There aren't enough people here to make running multiple schools viable.

angstridden2 · 13/07/2023 12:37

I had a ‘cardiac incident’ in one of the poorer EU countries.An ambulance arrived after about 10 minutes, the ED was immaculate and pretty empty. The staff spoke English, the procedure they diagnosed as being needed was done within 48 hours. All I had to show was my EHIC card.I only paid 10Euros for a tv at my bedside which arrived within 30 mins.The receptionist even called a cab for my accompanying relative. I was so glad to get sick
there and not need my local understaffed and frankly crappy hospital.

if they can do it, why can’t we?

Phineyj · 13/07/2023 12:09

@Watchagotch72 that's really interesting; thanks for typing all that out.

Just goes to show another world is possible.

I had to take my daughter to a GP in France last summer. The service was good and we were able to get a speedy appointment even though as holidaymakers we weren't registered.

Part of the cost should have been covered by EHIC. Finding out how to claim back in the UK was very complicated but I managed it. I finally got a reply on 4th July THIS year (so it took 11 months) telling me how to obtain the small amount due.

I don't think UK health services would be able to handle any form of joint responsibility for paying. It's been "free" for too long.

Watchagotch72 · 13/07/2023 12:08

@BodegaSushi There are different levels of ‘private’ providers here. Lowest are ‘conventionné’ which means they charge what the govt will reimburse. Most GPS, physios, nurses - all the day to day services - are this level, so there’s nothing left to pay. Beyond that, there are two levels where the providers can charge more than the govt up to set limits, then there is ‘outside the convention’ - the latter providers charging whatever they want. so you always know in advance where your provider has positioned themselves and how much you are likely to be reimbursed. In 15 years and two kids, I’ve never had to resort to the top level, and we have always used private providers rather than public hospitals for treatment. I gave birth to DS2 in a private hospital. stayed there for 5 nights (was a bit of a long process) and all I paid for in the end was €20 per night for my private room - the govt and the mutuelle picked up the tab for everything else.

The thing is, if every provider went ‘outside’ ie charged top dollar, they would very quickly run out of clients as they would exclude all the middle-income earners like me, who can afford to pay a reasonable amount but not outrageous, non-reimbursed prices. As it is they can make a very nice living by focusing on this group - and take the pressure off the public system.

BodegaSushi · 13/07/2023 11:47

Am I just being cynical, or would private practices just up their prices to make any top up from the govt negligible?

I know it works in other countries but we have a real culture of greed here it seems.

Watchagotch72 · 13/07/2023 10:55

Just adding to clarify that our mutuelle is €200 for the whole family (2 adults, 2 children) - not individual.

Watchagotch72 · 13/07/2023 10:54

We have a partial private / public healthcare service in France and I think it's great. Those of us that can afford to pay a bit more for healthcare have reasonable options to do so, which relieves the pressure on the public services.It's not all or nothing - NHS or hugely expensive private providers.

DH and I are not wealthy (teachers). We are in the French healthcare system, so have all the rights and benefits that every French taxpayer does. We also pay a mutuelle through our work - not insurance as such, more a top up system that bridges the gap btw what the health providers charge and the government will reimburse. This costs about €200 per month, taken straight from our salaries.

DS broke his arm really badly last year. Because we have a good mutuelle and because there's a great private clinic / hospital round the corner from us with a walk-in trauma clinic open all day, we went there instead of the public hospital A&E. No queues, seen straight away. Long story short, it couldn't be reset and after 3 x-rays and several attempts to reset, the ortho dr sent us away with a next day appointment with a private ortho surgeon. DS had surgery, then wound care from a nurse coming to the house for 3 weeks, then 12 weeks of physio plus rdvs with the surgeon. The care he received was absolutely faultless. No queues. All rdvs made at our convenience.

So what did this cost? Some examples.

X-rays at the trauma clinic.
Clinic charges €52
Govt reinburses €19,52
Mutuelle reimburses €32,48
I pay €0,00

Surgery - 2 hours surgery, top level surgeon, private hospital, private room.
Surgeon charges €598,50
Govt reimburses €148,50
Mutuelle reimburses €148,50
I pay €301,50

Anaesthetist - GA during operation, including pre-op rdv with anaesthetist
Anaesthetist charges €201,22
Govt reimburses €61,22
Mutuelle reimburses €61,22
I pay €78,78

RDV with surgeon
Surgeon charges €65
Govt reimburses €16,10
Mutuelle reimburses €29,90
I pay €19,00

Private physio - 12 weeks, 2 rdv per week.
Physio charges €16,13 per rdv
Govt reimburses €9,58
Mutuelle reimburses €6,45
I pay €0

So yes, we had to pay out for the care. But the prices of private healthcare here are nothing compared to similar services provided privately in the US or the UK. The quality of care was so good, and because we are able to access it at a reasonable (to us) cost, it took us completely out of the public system. We're still paying all our taxes etc, so are still paying into the system and it's there for anyone that needs to use it.

Another important point: mutuelles are not like private health insurance in the UK/US - no such thing as pre-existing conditions (everything is covered).

Another point: because the govt funds this partial private / public system, it means that private providers are able to create facilities - clinics, hospitals, practices etc - throughout the city. I live city centre and I am surrounded by private physios, nurses, doctors, gynaecologists, dermatologists, opthamologists etc. Yes there are shortages, but I can still find them and make rdv at my convenience really easily. Pretty much every part of our city has private clinics and hospitals that supplement the bigger public hospitals.

bobblyjob · 13/07/2023 09:39

MintJulia · 13/07/2023 09:16

We could improve the service provided by the nhs by changing people's expectations, and making them take more responsibility for basic care.

60% of people in a&e don't need to be there.

Weekend drunks and brawlers should be handled by city centre drunk tanks.

60%? How do you come to that figure? If GPs were entirely available on same day then some people would go there yes. Or if there was easy access then some chronic problems would be better controlled and present less. The answer is not that people are silly. It’s that GP is underfunded and underavailable.
And having worked in a city with a “drunk tank” there are still plenty of people that need to come to ED. But they aren’t the ones causing the issue to be honest.

bobblyjob · 13/07/2023 09:37

That’s not really how it works in Australia though. If a GP charges you nothing, that money comes out of their wages. It makes no difference to the government
And in education yes you can go private (fancy) religious (cheap but less fancy) or public. The government heavily subsidise private so it’s not great for the country at all

MintJulia · 13/07/2023 09:16

We could improve the service provided by the nhs by changing people's expectations, and making them take more responsibility for basic care.

60% of people in a&e don't need to be there.

Weekend drunks and brawlers should be handled by city centre drunk tanks.

Maireas · 13/07/2023 07:29

MasterGland · 13/07/2023 07:21

I think whenever you have state subsidies into the private sector, a price adjustment take place in the system to account for it. See: the car scrappage scheme in the last recession, stamp duty holidays after COVID, eat out to help out etc.

The additional money is just subsumed into the profit margin as state funding is not impacted by the usual supply-demand dynamic.

Absolutely this.

MasterGland · 13/07/2023 07:21

I think whenever you have state subsidies into the private sector, a price adjustment take place in the system to account for it. See: the car scrappage scheme in the last recession, stamp duty holidays after COVID, eat out to help out etc.

The additional money is just subsumed into the profit margin as state funding is not impacted by the usual supply-demand dynamic.

Do88byisfree · 13/07/2023 07:09

In Australia I paid $99.50 for a GP appointment this week (2 week wait as non urgent) I only get $41 back from the government. But have to pay the full amount and the refund comes back 24-48 hours later.
No GPs in my area offer bilk billing (fully funded) to new patients.
I can afford it -- but I wonder what happens to the patients who can't.

LolaSmiles · 13/07/2023 07:06

This seems like a recipe to entrench an underclass who have to make do with the absolute minimum service level, or more likely, minimum service level with limited staff and availability.

Mummadeze · 13/07/2023 07:05

I really don’t agree, the completely free options would become worse and the class divide would get wider.

RosaGallica · 13/07/2023 07:04

Eliminating inequality is completely impossible due to human nature, but keeping a harsh separation between "the rich" and "the poors" also isn't the answer. It just keeps "the rich" even more in their bubble.

I have no idea what the situation in Australia is as I’ve never been, not being rich enough: but in the U.K. environment that is a total cop-out. It is not acceptable that some of us work hard all our lives to end up with nothing because all of our money goes to fund idle rich landlords and their even more idle feckless families. For the scale of inequality in the U.K. you can look at https://equalitytrust.org.uk/scale-economic-inequality-uk or remember that poverty kills people in the U.K.

The Scale of Economic Inequality in the UK | The Equality Trust

The UK has the 7th most unequal incomes of 30 countries in the developed world, but is about average in terms of wealth inequality. While the top fifth have nearly 50% of the country's income and 60% of the country's wealth, the bottom fifth have only...

https://equalitytrust.org.uk/scale-economic-inequality-uk

itsallnewnow · 13/07/2023 07:02

That doesn't exist for health Weve dabbled in and out. We use the Livi health app we found through Boots, I paid for a private GP appt before my honeymoon as I thought I needed antibiotics. I agree it's probably the only realistic option